The formation of ultrafine grained steel microstructures through thermomechanical processing.

The formation of ultrafine grained steels is an area of intense research around the World. There are a number of methods to produce grain sizes of approximately 1 µm, ranging from extreme thermal and deformation cycles to more typical thermomechanical processes. This paper reviews the status of the production of ultrafine grained steels through relatively simple thermomechanical processing. It is shown that this requires deformation within the Ae3 to Ar3 temperature range for a given alloy. The formation of ultrafine ferrite involves a dynamic transformation of a significant volume fraction of the austenite to ferrite. This dynamic strain induced transformation arises from the introduction of additional intragranular nucleation sites. It is possible that the deformation also hinders the growth or coarsening of the ferrite and may also lead to dynamic recrystallization of the ferrite. The most likely commercial exploitation of ultrafine ferrite would appear to rely on the formation of a critical volume fraction of dynamic strain induced ferrite followed by controlled cooling to ensure this is maintained to room temperature and to also form other secondary phases, such as martensite, bainite and/or retained austenite to improve the formability.

Grain refinement in steels through thermomechanical processing

The development of ultrafine grained microstructures in steels has received considerable attention in recent times. In many cases the aim is to produce high strength structural steels with minimal alloying. It is well established that for an equiaxed ferrite with a uniform dispersion of second phase, both the strength and toughness will be markedly improved if the grain size can be reduced to 1-2 μm, from the typical range of 5-10 μm. Means of achieving this through dynamic strain induced transformation are examined here, following a brief overview of some of the key issues encountered when attempting to refine the austenite in existing mill configurations. A number of deformation microstructure maps are developed to aid the discussion.

Development of ultrafine grained steels through thermomechanical processing

The formation of ultrafine ferrite by strain induced transformation is assessed using rolling and hot torsion experiments. These experiments are used to examine the impact of thermomechanical processing conditions and steel chemistry on strain induced austenite to ferrite transformation and the formation of ultrafine ferrite. The critical strain for dynamic strain induced transformation increased with increasing carbon equivalence, deformation temperature and austenite grain size. The deformation structure in the austenite grains changes with the thermomechanical processing conditions. Drawing on these results and the current literature, the important factors for the production of ultrafine ferrite are described and a mechanism is proposed.

The formation of ultrafine ferrite in low C steels through thermomechanical processing

Ultrafine ferrite can be formed in steels through relatively simple thermomechanical processes. The ferrite nucleates intragranularly within the austenite grain on deformation features, which are favoured by heavy shear and large effective strains. It is also possible to produce ultrafine microstructures under multipass deformation conditions, although these may be due to dynamic recovery rather than strain induced transformation.

Formation of ultra-fine ferrite in hot rolled strip: potential mechanisms for grain refinement

A novel single-pass hot strip rolling process has been developed in which ultra-fine (<2 μm) ferrite grains form at the surface of hot rolled strip in two low carbon steels with average austenite grain sizes above 200 μm. Two experiments were performed on strip that had been re-heated to 1250°C for 300 s and air-cooled to the rolling temperatures. The first involved hot rolling a sample of 0.09 wt.%C–1.68Mn–0.22Si–0.27Mo steel (steel A) at 800°C, which was just above the Ar3 of this sample, while the second involved hot rolling a sample of 0.11C–1.68Mn–0.22Si steel (steel B) at 675°C, which is just below the Ar3 temperature of the sample. After air cooling, the surface regions of strip of both steel A and B consisted of ultra-fine ferrite grains which had formed within the large austenite grains, while the central regions consisted of a bainitic microstructure. In the case of steel B, a network of allotriomorphic ferrite delineated the prior-austenite grain boundaries throughout the strip cross-section. Based on results from optical microscopy and scanning/transmission electron microscopy, as well as bulk X-ray texture analysis and microtextural analysis using Electron Back-Scattered Diffraction (EBSD), it is shown that the ultra-fine ferrite most likely forms by a process of rapid intragranular nucleation during, or immediately after, deformation. This process of inducing intragranular nucleation of ferrite by deformation is referred to as strain-induced transformation.

The effect of multiple deformations on the formation of ultrafine grained steels

A C-Mn-Nb-Ti steel was deformed by hot torsion to study ultrafine ferrite formation through dynamic strain-induced transformation (DSIT) in conjunction with air cooling. A systematic study was carried out first to evaluate the effect of deformation temperature and prior austenite grain size on the critical strain for ultrafine ferrite formation (ε C,UFF) through single-pass deformation. Then, multiple deformations in the nonrecrystallization region were used to study the effect of thermomechanical parameters (i.e., strain, deformation temperature, etc.) on ε C,UFF. The multiple deformations in the nonrecrystallization region significantly reduced ε C,UFF, although the total equivalent strain for a given thermomechanical condition was higher than that required in single-pass deformation. The current study on a Ni-30Fe austenitic model alloy revealed that laminar microband structures were the key intragranular defects in the austenite for nucleation of ferrite during the hot torsion test. The microbands were refined and overall misorientation angle distribution increased with a decrease in the deformation temperature for a given thermomechanical processing condition. For nonisothermal multipass deformation, there was some contribution to the formation of high-angle microband boundaries from strains at higher temperature, although the strains were not completely additive.

The production of ultrafine ferrite during hot torsion testing of a 0.11 Wt Pct C steel

Ultrafine ferrite grain sizes were produced in a 0.11C-1.6Mn-0.2Si steel by torsion testing isothermally at 675 °C after air cooling from 1250 °C. The ferrite was observed to form intragranularly beyond a von Mises equivalent tensile strain of approximately 0.7 to 0.8 and the number fraction of intragranular ferrite grains continued to increase as the strain level increased. Ferrite nucleated to form parallel and closely spaced linear arrays or “rafts” of many discrete ultrafine ferrite grains. It is shown that ferrite nucleates during deformation on defects developed within the austenite parallel to the macroscopic shear direction (i.e., dynamic strain-induced transformation). A model austenitic Ni-30Fe alloy was used to study the substructure developed in the austenite under similar test conditions as that used to induce intragranular ferrite in the steel. It is shown that the most prevalent features developed during testing are microbands. It is proposed that high-energy jogged regions surrounding intersecting microbands provide potential sites for ferrite nucleation at lower strains, while at higher strains, the walls of the microbands may also act as nucleation sites.

Grain refinement through controlled thermomechanical processing

The major challenge for thermomechanical processing is to extend grain refinement towards lower average grain sizes. However, there is also a need to provide a better understanding of the mechanisms through which the refinement processes proceed. Many recent proposals for advanced thermomechanical processing rely on the dynamic strain induced transformation (DSIT), and the dynamic recrystallisation of austenite as the main refinement mechanisms. These mechanisms are still not fully understood and their clarification can be expected to lead to even greater levels of refinement. The current review examines the roles of ferrite recrystallisation , DSIT and initial austenite grain size. It is shown that although the ferrite recrystallisation mechanism in DSIT has certain similarities with the well known continuous dynamic recrystallisation (CDRX), it is significantly affected by the transformed ferrite grain size. Also, reducing the initial austenite grain size increases the recrystallisation rate in the strain dependent as well as strain independent regions. These results show that the traditional concept of metadynamic recrystallisation is insufficient to explain the changes in grain size following deformation. An alternative explanation is presented.

A descriptive model for the formation of ultrafine grained steels

This paper presents a descriptive model to explain the mechanisms involved in the development of ultrafine grained structure in steels through dynamic strain induced transformation. The model considers the microstructural evolution during and after deformation as well as the role of different process variables. A key factor is the competition between nucleation and growth, where it is shown that many potential nuclei can be lost under certain conditions leading to a mixed or coarser grain size.

A study of the strengthening mechanism in the thermomechanically processed TRIP/TWIP steel

The strengthening mechanism responsible for the unique combination of ultimate tensile strength and elongation in a multiphase Fe-0.2C-1.5Mn-1.2Si-0.3Mo-0.6Al-0.02Nb (wt%) steel was studied. The microstructures with different volume fraction of polygonal fenite, bainite and retained austenite were simulated by controlled thermomechanical processing. The interupted tensile test was used to study the bainitic ferrite, retained austenite and polygonal ferrite behavior as a function of plastic strain. X-ray analysis was used to characterize the volume fraction and carbon content of retained austenite. TEM and heat-tinting were utilized to analyze the effect of bainitic fenite morphology on the strain induced transformation of retained austenite and retained austenite twinning as a function of strain in the bulk material. The study has shown that the austenite twinning mechanism is more preferable than the transformation induced plasticity mechanism during the early stages of deformation for a microstructure containing I5% polygonal ferrite, while the transformation induced plasticity effect is the main mechanism in when there is 50% of polygonal ferrite in the microstructure. The baillitic fenite morphology affects the deformation mode of retained austenite during straining. The polygonal fenite behavior during straining depends on dislocation substructure tonned due to the deformation and the additional mobile dislocations caused by the TRIP effect. TRIP and TWIP effects depend not only on the chemical and mechanical stability of retained austenite, but also on the interaction of the phases during straining.

Microstructure and mechanical properties of thermomechanically processed TRIP steel

The strengthening mechanism responsible for the unique combination of ultimate tensile strength and elongation in a multiphase Fe-0.2C-1.5Mn-1.2Si-0.3Mo-0.6Al-0.02Nb (wt%) steel was studied. The microstructures with different volume fractions of polygonal ferrite, bainite and retained austenite were simulated by controlled thermomechanical processing. The interrupted tensile test was used to study the bainitic ferrite, retained austenite and polygonal ferrite behaviour as a function of plastic strain. X-ray analysis was used to characterise the volume fraction and carbon content of retained austenite. Transmission electron microscopy was utilised to analyse the effect of bainitic ferrite morphology on the strain induced transformation of retained austenite and retained austenite twinning as a function of strain in the bulk material. The study has shown that the austenite twinning mechanism is more preferable than the transformation induced plasticity (TRIP) mechanism during the early stages of deformation for a microstructure containing 15% polygonal ferrite, while the transformation induced plasticity effect is the main mechanism when there is 50% of polygonal ferrite in the microstructure. The bainitic ferrite morphology affects the deformation mode of retained austenite during straining. The polygonal ferrite behaviour during straining depends on dislocation substructure formed due to the deformation and the additional mobile dislocations caused by the TRIP effect. Operation of TRIP or twinning mechanisms depends not only on the chemical and mechanical stability of retained austenite, but also on the interaction of the phases during straining.

Characterization of microstructures and tensile properties of TRIP-aided steels with different matrix microstructure

Three different heat treatment processes have been proposed as a fundamental method to produce three kinds of TRIP-aided steels with polygonal ferritic matrix (F-TRIP), bainitic matrix (B-TRIP) and martensitic matrix (M-TRIP) in a newly designed low alloy carbon steel. By means of dilatometry study and detailed characterization, the relationships among transformation, microstructure and the resulting mechanical behavior were compared and analyzed for the three cases. The work hardening of the samples was evaluated by calculating the instantaneous n value as a function of strain. The M-TRIP sample exhibits the highest strength with the highest work hardening rate at low strains and subsequent rapid descending at high strains. In contrast, the B-TRIP sample has relatively high continuously constant work hardening behavior over strain levels greater than 0.067. The difference in work hardening behavior corresponds directly to the rate of the retained austenite-martensitic transformation during straining, which can be attributed to the carbon content, the morphology of the retained austenite and the matrix microstructure in the respective TRIP-aided samples. © 2014 Elsevier B.V.

The use of Fe-30% Ni and Fe-30% Ni-Nb alloys as model systems for studying the microstructural evolution during the hot deformation of austenite

The development of physically-based models of microstructural evolution during thermomechanical processing of metallic materials requires knowledge of the internal state variable data, such as microstructure, texture, and dislocation substructure characteristics, over a range of processing conditions. This is a particular problem for steels, where transformation of the austenite to a variety of transformation products eradicates the hot deformed microstructure. This article reports on a model Fe-30wt% Ni-based alloy, which retains a stable austenitic structure at room temperature, and has, therefore, been used to model the development of austenite microstructure during hot deformation of conventional low carbon-manganese steels. It also provides an excellent model alloy system for microalloy additions. Evolution of the microstructure and crystallographic texture was characterized in detail using optical microscopy, X-ray diffraction (XRD), SEM, EBSD, and TEM. The dislocation substructure has been quantified as a function of crystallographic texture component for a variety of deformation conditions for the Fe-30% Ni-based alloy. An extension to this study, as the use of a microalloyed Fe-30% Ni-Nb alloy in which the strain induced precipitation mechanism was studied directly. The work has shown that precipitation can occur at a much finer scale and higher number density than hitherto considered, but that pipe diffusion leads to rapid coarsening. The implications of this for model development are discussed.

Effect of thermomechanical processing on the microstructure and retained austenite stability during in situ tensile testing using synchrotron X-Ray diffraction of NbMoAl TRIP steel

In this work we compare and contrast the stability of retained austenite during tensile testing of Nb-Mo-Al transformation-induced plasticity steel subjected to different thermomechanical processing schedules. The obtained microstructures were characterised using optical metallography, transmission electron microscopy and X-ray diffraction. The transformation of retained austenite to martensite under tensile loading was observed by in-situ high energy X-ray diffraction at 1ID / APS. It has been shown that the variations in the microstructure of the steel, such as volume fractions of present phases, their morphology and dimensions, play a critical role in the strain-induced transition of retained austenite to martensite.

Enhanced mechanical response of an ultrafine grained Ti-6Al-4V alloy produced through warm symmetric and asymmetric rolling

An equiaxed ultrafine-grained (UFG) microstructure was successfully produced in a Ti-6Al-4V alloy with an average grain size of 110-230. nm through symmetric and asymmetric warm rolling of a martensitic starting microstructure. The UFG material displayed a combination of ultrahigh strength and ductility at room temperature. Compared with the conventional symmetric rolling, the asymmetric rolling process led to a more pronounced effect of microstructure refinement and a higher tensile ductility. The optimum mechanical response was obtained though the asymmetric rolling at 70% reduction, offering an ultimate tensile strength of 1365. MPa and a total elongation of ~23%. Apart from the magnitude of grain refinement, the inclination of basal texture component from the normal towards the rolling direction during asymmetric rolling and possible strain induced β to martensite transformation may concurrently contribute to a remarkable tensile strength-ductility balance.