Knowledge Building in Landscape Architecture

The objective of this study was to develop an internet-based seminar framework applicable for landscape architecture education. This process was accompanied by various aims. The basic expectation was to keep the main characteristics of landscape architecture education also in the online format. On top of that, four further objectives were anticipated: (1) training of competences for virtual team work, (2) fostering intercultural competence, (3) creation of equal opportunities for education through internet-based open access and (4) synergy effects and learning processes across institutional boundaries. This work started with the hypothesis that these four expected advantages would compensate for additional organisational efforts caused by the online delivery of the seminars and thus lead to a sustainable integration of this new learning mode into landscape architecture curricula. This rationale was followed by a presentation of four areas of knowledge to which the seminar development was directly related (1) landscape architecture as a subject and its pedagogy, (2) general learning theories, (3) developments in the ICT sector and (4) wider societal driving forces such as global citizenship and the increase of open educational resources. The research design took the shape of a pedagogical action research cycle. This approach was constructive: The author herself is teaching international landscape architecture students so that the model could directly be applied in practice. Seven online seminars were implemented in the period from 2008 to 2013 and this experience represents the core of this study. The seminars were conducted with varying themes while its pedagogy, organisation and the technological tools remained widely identical. The research design is further based on three levels of observation: (1) the seminar design on the basis of theory and methods from the learning sciences, in particular educational constructivism, (2) the seminar evaluation and (3) the evaluation of the seminars’ long term impact. The seminar model itself basically consists of four elements: (1) the taxonomy of learning objectives, (2) ICT tools and their application and pedagogy, (3) process models and (4) the case study framework. The seminar framework was followed by the presentation of the evaluation findings. The major findings of this study can be summed up as follows: Implementing online seminars across educational and national boundaries was possible both in term of organisation and technology. In particular, a high level of cultural diversity among the seminar participants has definitively been achieved. However, there were also obvious obstacles. These were primarily competing study commitments and incompatible schedules among the students attending from different academic programmes, partly even in different time zones. Both factors had negative impact on the individual and working group performances. With respect to the technical framework it can be concluded that the majority of the participants were able to use the tools either directly without any problem or after overcoming some smaller problems. Also the seminar wiki was intensively used for completing the seminar assignments. However, too less truly collaborative text production was observed which could be improved by changing the requirements for the collaborative task. Two different process models have been applied for guiding the collaboration of the small groups and both were in general successful. However, it needs to be said that even if the students were able to follow the collaborative task and to co-construct and compare case studies, most of them were not able to synthesize the knowledge they had compiled. This means that the area of consideration often remained on the level of the case and further reflections, generalisations and critique were largely missing. This shows that the seminar model needs to find better ways for triggering knowledge building and critical reflection. It was also suggested to have a more differentiated group building strategy in future seminars. A comparison of pre- and post seminar concept maps showed that an increase of factual and conceptual knowledge on the individual level was widely recognizable. Also the evaluation of the case studies (the major seminar output) revealed that the students have undergone developments of both the factual and the conceptual knowledge domain. Also their self-assessment with respect to individual learning development showed that the highest consensus was achieved in the field of subject-specific knowledge. The participants were much more doubtful with regard to the progress of generic competences such as analysis, communication and organisation. However, 50% of the participants confirmed that they perceived individual development on all competence areas the survey had asked for. Have the additional four targets been met? Concerning the competences for working in a virtual team it can be concluded that the vast majority was able to use the internet-based tools and to work with them in a target-oriented way. However, there were obvious differences regarding the intensity and activity of participation, both because of external and personal factors. A very positive aspect is the achievement of a high cultural diversity supporting the participants’ intercultural competence. Learning from group members was obviously a success factor for the working groups. Regarding the possibilities for better accessibility of educational opportunities it became clear that a significant number of participants were not able to go abroad during their studies because of financial or personal reasons. They confirmed that the online seminar was to some extent a compensation for not having been abroad for studying. Inter-institutional learning and synergy was achieved in so far that many teachers from different countries contributed with individual lectures. However, those teachers hardly ever followed more than one session. Therefore, the learning effect remained largely within the seminar learning group. Looking back at the research design it can be said that the pedagogical action research cycle was an appropriate and valuable approach allowing for strong interaction between theory and practice. However, some more external evaluation from peers in particular regarding the participants’ products would have been valuable.

Cultivating the City: Infrastructures of abundance in urban Brazil

Urban agriculture, if it is to become integrated into the city, needs landscape architectural thinking in order to be woven into the larger urban fabric. Thinking at the scale of ecosystems running through a city creates a framework for spatial change; thinking in assemblages of stakeholders and actors creates a framework for social investment and development. These overlapping frameworks are informed and perhaps even defined by the emergent field of landscape democracy. Cultivating the City is a prospective design project seeking to embody landscape democratic principles. The intention is to reclaim the meaning of landscape as the relationship between people and place, both shaping each other. The design in question is a proposed network of urban agriculture typologies in Porto Alegre, Brazil. These hypothetical designs, emphasizing agroforestry with native species, serve as a basis for dialogue between potential stakeholders and as catalysts for future projects. This landscape architecture project sets out to be a mediator in processes of spatial evolution in order to envision just and sustainable urban landscapes.

Prognosemethode für das Schutzgut ‚Landschaft’ im Rahmen der Strategischen Umweltprüfung

Im Mittelpunkt der Dissertation stehen das Schutzgut ‚Landschaft’ sowie ‚Prognosemethoden in der Umweltprüfung’. Mit beiden Themenbereichen verbinden sich bereits heute ungelöste methodische Probleme, die mit der Umsetzung der Richtlinie zur Strategischen Umweltprüfung (SUP) zusätzlich komplexer und deren Lösung mithin anspruchsvoller werden. Dies hängt einerseits damit zusammen, dass eine gesetzeskonforme Gleichbehandlung aller Schutzgüter zunehmend eingefordert wird und gerade das Schutzgut ‚Landschaft’ in einer SUP methodisch besondere Aufmerksamkeit verlangt. Zum anderen führt die gängige planungsmethodische Diskussion allein nicht zu geeigneten Antworten auf o.g. Fragen, und es bedarf der Prüfung verschiedener Methodenbausteine, auch aus anderen Wissensgebieten, um – über ein eindimensionales Landschaftsverständnis einerseits und die bisher bekannten linearen Wirkungsprognosen andererseits hinaus gehend – mehrfach verknüpfte Prognoseschritte zur Anwendung in der SUP zu entwickeln, in denen das Schutzgut ‚Landschaft’ modellhaft für Bewertungsschritte nachvollziehbar abgebildet wird. Hierbei müssen entscheidungsrelevante Prognosezeiträume ebenso beachtet werden, wie in diesen Zeiträumen möglicherweise auftretende sekundäre, kumulative, synergetische, positive und negative Auswirkungen der zu beurteilenden Planung. Dieser Ziel- und Aufgabenstellung entsprechend erfolgt die theoretische Herangehensweise der Arbeit von zwei Seiten: 1. Die Funktionen und Stellung von Prognosen innerhalb der SUP wird erläutert (Kap. 2), und es wird der Frage nachgegangen, welche Anforderungen an Prognosemethoden zu stellen sind (Kap. 2.4) und welche Prognosemethoden in der SUP Verwendung finden bzw. finden können (Kap. 3). Der Schwerpunkt wird dabei auf die Anwendung der Szenariotechnik gelegt. 2. Es wird dargestellt wie Landschaft für Aufgaben der Landschaftsplanung und Umweltprüfung bisher üblicherweise erfasst und analysiert wird, um in Prognoseschritten handhabbar behandelt zu werden (Kap. 4). Beide Zugänge werden sodann zusammengeführt (Kap. 5), um am Beispiel einer Hochwasserschutzkonzeption im Rahmen der SUP Landschaftliche Prognosen zu erarbeiten. Die Prognose setzt methodisch mit der Beschreibung des zu verwendenden Landschaftsmodells und der Klärung des Modellzwecks ein. Bezugsbasis ist die Beschreibung des Charakters einzelner logisch hergeleiteter Landschaftseinheiten bzw. Landschaftsräume, die typisiert werden. Die Prognose selber unterscheidet zwischen der Abschätzung zu erwartender Landschaftsveränderungen im Sinne der ‚Status-quo-Prognose’ (einschließlich der Entwicklung von drei Szenarien möglicher Zukunftslandschaften bis 2030) und der Wirkungsabschätzungen verschiedener Maßnahmen bzw. Planungsalternativen und zwar zunächst raumunabhängig, und dann raumkonkret. Besondere Bedeutung bei den Wirkungsabschätzungen erhält die klare Trennung von Sach- und Wertebene, eine angemessene Visualisierung und die Dokumentation von Informationslücken und Unsicherheiten bei der Prognose. Diskutiert wird u.a. (Kap. 6) · die Bildung und Abgrenzung landschaftlicher Einheiten und Typen in Bezug zu der Aufgabe, landschaftliche Eigenart zu definieren und planerisch handhabbar und anwendbar zu bestimmen, · die Bedeutung angemessener Visualisierung zur Unterstützung von Beteiligungsverfahren und · die Bestimmung des so genannten ‚Raumwiderstandes’. Beigefügt sind zwei Karten des gesamten Bearbeitungsgebietes: Karte 1 „Landschaftstypen“, Karte 2 „Maßnahmentypen des Hochwasserschutzes mit möglichen Synergieeffekten für die Landschaft“.

Drainage, salt leaching and physico-chemical properties of irrigated man-made terrace soils in a mountain oasis of northern Oman

Little is known about the sustainability of irrigated oasis agriculture in northern Oman. The objective of this study therefore was to examine which factors allowed agricultural productivity to be apparently maintained during the two millenia of a mountain oasis’ existence. Soil moisture and physico-chemical properties were measured in a typical flood-irrigated field sown to alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.). Particle size, organic (C_org) and inorganic carbon content, pH and electrical conductivity (EC)of the soil profile were analyzed at 0.15, 0.45 and 1.00 m. Saturated hydraulic conductivity and the soil’s apparent bulk density and water potential were determined from undisturbed samples at 0.05, 0.25 and 0.60 m. During irrigation cycles of 6–9 days, volumetric water contents ranged from 30% to 13%. A tracer experiment with potassium bromide revealed that 52–56% of the irrigation water was stored in the upper 0.4 m of the soil. The rest of the water moved further down the profile, thus providing the necessary drainage to avoid the build-up of toxic salt concentrations. Due to differences in pore size, plant-available water in the topsoil amounted to 18.7% compared to 13% and 13.5% at 0.25- and 0.60-m depth, respectively. The aggregate structure in the upper 1.0 m of the profile is likely preserved by concentrations of calcium carbonate (CaCO3) from 379 to 434 mg kg^-1 and C_org from 157 to 368 mg kg^-1 soil. The data indicate that the sustainability of this irrigated landuse system is due to high water quality with low sodium but high CaCO3 concentration, the elaborate terrace structure and water management which allows adequate drainage.

Clay pot irrigation for tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill) production in the north east semiarid region of Ethiopia

Water shortage is one of the major constraints for production of horticultural crops in arid and semiarid regions. A field experiment was conducted to determine irrigation water and fertilizer use efficiency, growth and yield of tomato under clay pot irrigation at the experimental site of Sekota Dryland Agricultural Research Center, Lalibela, Ethiopia in 2009/10. The experiment comprised of five treatments including furrow irrigated control and clay pot irrigation with different plant population and fertilization methods, which were arranged in Randomized Complete Block Design with three replications. The highest total and marketable fruit yields were obtained from clay pot irrigation combined with application of nitrogen fertilizer with irrigation water irrespective of difference in plant population. The clay pot irrigation had seasonal water use of up to 143.71 mm, which resulted in significantly higher water use efficiency (33.62 kg m^-3) as compared to the furrow irrigation, which had a seasonal water use of 485.50 mm, and a water use efficiency of 6.67 kg m^-3. Application of nitrogen fertilizer with irrigation water in clay pots improved fertilizer use efficiency of tomato by up to 52% than band application with furrow or clay pot irrigation. Thus, clay pot irrigation with 33,333 plants ha^-1 and nitrogen fertilizer application with irrigation water in clay pots was the best method for increasing the yield of tomato while economizing the use of water and nitrogen fertilizer in a semiarid environment.

Water for Food: Feeding what?

Key Findings: “Water for food” is not necessarily synonymous with “water for food security. Countries with similar geological conditions face very different geopolitical realities; national water policies and agricultural motivations reflect this. Water policies and research should seek to understand “water for food” and its connections with economics, the environment, and securities more broadly

Caimanes and the Water - Infinite Legal Struggles about a Finite Good

This report is intended to shed more light on the ongoing water struggle in Caimanes, a small urban area in the central northern area of Chile, neighbouring Latin America’s biggest tailings dam. Undoubtedly, the water in Caimanes is running out and the conflict between the opponents of the dam and its owner, a multinational copper enterprise, is getting more and more attention by the national and also international media. In the discussion a judgment of the Chilean Supreme Court from last October plays a central role, because it is said to have granted the people from Caimanes their right to water. After a short introduction with some details about Camaines and the tailings from the dam El Mauro, the key points of this judgment shall be outlined. The final part of the report is dedicated to various institutional problems of the Chilean resources law and policy that can become virulent for the water supply and the environmental well-being of many other urban areas in the industrialized north of Chile.