Separation mechanisms in nanofiltration and retention changes of organic compounds

Orgaanisten yhdisteiden negatiivinen retentio nanosuodatuksessa on ilmiö, jota eiole kovin paljon tutkittu. Negatiivisen retentioon vaikuttavat syyt tai tekijäteivät ole kovin hyvin tiedossa. Erotusmenetelmänä negatiivinen retentio voi olla käyttökelpoinen tietyissä sovelluksissa. Työn kirjallisuusosa käsittelee nanosuodatuksen erotusmekanismeja ja retentioon vaikuttavia tekijöitä. Myös joitakin malleja on esitetty. Nanosuodatus on monimutkainen prosessi, josta ei voida löytää vain yhtä erotusmekanismia tai retentioon vaikuttavaa tekijää. Prosessit ovat kokonaisuuksia, joissa erottumiseen vaikuttavat syöttöliuoksen, erotettavan komponentin ja kalvon ominaisuudet, ja niiden väliset vuorovaikutukset. Työn kokeellisessa osassa koottiin mahdollisimman paljon esimerkkejä, joissa monosakkaridien negatiivinen retentio ilmenee. Muita orgaanisia ja epäorgaanisia yhdisteitä käytettiin 'häiriöyhdisteinä' syöttöliuoksessa monosakkaridien kanssa. Kokeet suoritettiin kahdella laboratoriomittakaavan suodatuslaitteella käyttäen kahta kaupallista nanosuodatuskalvoa. Negatiivinen retentio ilmeni useissa tapauksissa. Permeaattivuon ja 'häiriöyhdisteiden' pitoisuuksien havaittiin vaikuttavan voimakkaasti negatiivisen retention ilmenemiseen.

Recovery of Hemicelluloses from Wood Hydrolysates by Membrane Filtration

Hemicelluloses are among the most important natural resources that contain polysaccharides. In this study the separation and purification of hemicelluloses from water extraction liquors containing wood hemicelluloses, lignin compounds and monosaccharide by using membrane filtration was investigated. The isolation of the hemicelluloses from the wood hydrolysates was performed in two steps: concentration of high molar mass hemicelluloses by ultrafiltration and separation of low molar mass hemicelluloses from monomeric sugars using tight ultrafiltration membranes. The purification of the retained hemicelluloses was performed by diafiltration. During the filtration experiments, the permeate flux through ultrafiltration and tight ultrafiltration membranes was relatively high. The fouling ability of the used membranes was relatively low. In our experiments, the retention of hemicelluloses using two filtration steps was almost complete. The separation of monosaccharides from hemicelluloses was relatively high and the purification of hemicelluloses by diafiltration was highly efficient. The separation of lignin from hemicelluloses was partially achieved. Diafiltration showed potential to purify retained hemicelluloses from lignin and other organics. The best separation of lignin from hemicelluloses in the first filtration step was obtained using the UC005 membrane. The GE-5 and ETNA01PP membranes showed potential to purify and separate lignin from hemicelluloses. However, the feed solution of the second filtration stages (from different ultrafiltration membranes) affected the permeate flux and the separation of various extracted compounds from hemicelluloses. The GE-5 and ETNA01PP membranes gave the efficient purification of the hemicelluloses when using diafiltration. Separation of degraded xylan from glucomannan (primary spruce hemicelluloses) was also possible using membrane filtration. The best separation was achieved using the GE-5 membrane. The retention of glucomannan was three times higher than xylan retention.

Episodes in carbohydrate chemistry : from β-linked mannosides to glycoconjugates

Carbohydrates are one of the most abundant classes of biomolecules on earth. In the initial stages of research on carbohydrates much effort was focused on investigation and determination of the structural aspects and complex nature of individual monosaccharides. Later on, development of protective group strategies and methods for oligosaccharide synthesis became the main topics of research. Today, the methodologies developed early on are being utilized in the production of carbohydrates for biological screening events. This multidisciplinary approach has generated the new discipline of glycobiology which focuses on research related to the appearance and biological significance of carbohydrates. In more detail, studies in glycobiology have revealed the essential roles of carbohydrates in cell-cell interactions, biological recognition events, protein folding, cell growth and tumor cell metastasis. As a result of these studies, carbohydrate derived diagnostic and therapeutic agents are likely to be of growing interest in the future. In this doctoral thesis, a journey through the fundamentals of carbohydrate synthesis is presented. The research conducted on this journey was neither limited to the study of any particular phenomena nor to the addressing of a single synthetic challenge. Instead, the focus was deliberately shifted from time to time in order to broaden the scope of the thesis, to continue the learning process and to explore new areas of carbohydrate research. Throughout the work, several previously reported synthetic protocols, especially procedures related to glycosylation reactions and protective group manipulations, were evaluated, modified and utilized or rejected. The synthetic molecules targeted within this thesis were either required for biological evaluations or utilized to study phenomena occuring in larger molecules. In addition, much effort was invested in the complete structural characterization of the synthesized compounds by a combination of NMR spectroscopic techniques and spectral simulations with the PERCH-software. This thesis provides the basics of working with carbohydrate chemistry. In more detail, synthetic strategies and experimental procedures for many different reactions and guidelines for the NMR-spectroscopic characterization of oligosaccharides and glycoconjugates are provided. Therefore, the thesis should prove valuable to researchers starting their own journeys in the ever expanding field of carbohydrate chemistry.

Membraanin modifiointi happo- ja alkoholikäsittelyillä

Tässä diplomityössä tutkittiin alkoholilla ja orgaanisella hapolla tehtävien esikäsittelyiden vaikutusta nanosuodatuskalvon ominaisuuksiin. Työn tarkoituksena oli parantaa nanosuodatuskalvon fraktiointiominaisuuksia sekä kasvattaa monosakkaridien suotautuvuutta. Tarkasteluissa käytetty membraani oli GE Osmonicsin valmistamaa Desal-5 DL nanosuodatuskalvoa, jota modifioitiin erilaisilla maitohappo- ja isopropanoliesikäsittelyillä. Suodatukset tehtiin kahdella erilaisella laboratoriomittakaavan levysuotimella käyttäen malliaineina väkevää sokeriliuosta sekä laimeampaa sokeri-suola-liuosta. Happo- ja alkoholiesikäsiteltyjen kalvojen vuo- ja retentioarvoja verrattiin referensseinä käytettyjen vesiliotettujen kalvojen vastaaviin arvoihin. Puhtaat esikäsitellyt kalvot analysoitiin myös tarkemmin kalvoissa tapahtuneiden muutosten ymmärtämiseksi. Suodatusten ja analyysitulosten perusteella sekä alkoholi- että happoesikäsittelyt paransivat nanosuodatuskalvon ominaisuuksia parantaen sokerivuota, heikentämättä kuitenkaan kalvon fraktiointikykyä eri moolimassan omaavien sokereiden suhteen. Hapolla saavutettiin hieman alkoholikäsittelyä suotuisammat muutokset, mutta molemmilla käsittelyillä haluttujen komponenttien retentio monesti jopa parani referenssikalvoon verrattuna. Havaitut muutokset kalvoissa olivat pääosin fysikaalisia, mutta erityisesti happokäsittely muutti kalvon rakennetta myös kemiallisesti. Molemmat käsittelyt lisäsivät myös tarkasteltavan membraanin hydrofiilisuutta.

Application of capillary electrophoretic methods for determining carbohydrates and aliphatic carboxylic acids formed during wood processing

Knowledge of the behaviour of cellulose, hemicelluloses, and lignin during wood and pulp processing is essential for understanding and controlling the processes. Determination of monosaccharide composition gives information about the structural polysaccharide composition of wood material and helps when determining the quality of fibrous products. In addition, monitoring of the acidic degradation products gives information of the extent of degradation of lignin and polysaccharides. This work describes two capillary electrophoretic methods developed for the analysis of monosaccharides and for the determination of aliphatic carboxylic acids from alkaline oxidation solutions of lignin and wood. Capillary electrophoresis (CE), in its many variants is an alternative separation technique to chromatographic methods. In capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) the fused silica capillary is filled with an electrolyte solution. An applied voltage generates a field across the capillary. The movement of the ions under electric field is based on the charge and hydrodynamic radius of ions. Carbohydrates contain hydroxyl groups that are ionised only in strongly alkaline conditions. After ionisation, the structures are suitable for electrophoretic analysis and identification through either indirect UV detection or electrochemical detection. The current work presents a new capillary zone electrophoretic method, relying on in-capillary reaction and direct UV detection at the wavelength of 270 nm. The method has been used for the simultaneous separation of neutral carbohydrates, including mono- and disaccharides and sugar alcohols. The in-capillary reaction produces negatively charged and UV-absorbing compounds. The optimised method was applied to real samples. The methodology is fast since no other sample preparation, except dilution, is required. A new method for aliphatic carboxylic acids in highly alkaline process liquids was developed. The goal was to develop a method for the simultaneous analysis of the dicarboxylic acids, hydroxy acids and volatile acids that are oxidation and degradation products of lignin and wood polysaccharides. The CZE method was applied to three process cases. First, the fate of lignin under alkaline oxidation conditions was monitored by determining the level of carboxylic acids from process solutions. In the second application, the degradation of spruce wood using alkaline and catalysed alkaline oxidation were compared by determining carboxylic acids from the process solutions. In addition, the effectiveness of membrane filtration and preparative liquid chromatography in the enrichment of hydroxy acids from black liquor was evaluated, by analysing the effluents with capillary electrophoresis.

Lignoselluloosapohjaisten väkevähappohydrolysaattien jatkuvatoiminen kromatografinen fraktiointi

Työssä tutkittiin lignoselluloosapohjaisten väkevähappohydrolysaattien (monosakkaridit, rikki- ja etikkahppo) jatkuvatoimista kromatografista fraktiointia käyttäen Japan Organo SMB -prosessia. Adsorbenttinä toimi happomuotoinen (H+) vahva kationinvaihtohartsi. Panostoimista fraktiointia käytettiin vertailukohtana. Jatkuvatoimisen prosessin optimoinnilla saavutettiin monosakkaridien suurimmaksi tuottavuudeksi 283 mol/(m3 h) (panosprosessille 145 mol/(m3 h). JO-prosessilla saavutettiin korkeat rikki- ja etikkahapon saannot: 97,3 % ja 93,5 %. Monosakkaridisaanto jäi hieman alhaisemmaksi (61,7 %) johtuen monosakkaridi- ja rikkihappo-profiilien hankalasta erottamisesta. Ulostulo virtojen puhtaudet olivat korkeat: 89 % monosakkarideille, 89 % rikkihapolle ja 100 % etikkahapolle.

Chromatographic recovery of chemicals from acidic biomass hydrolysates

Lignocellulosic biomasses (e.g., wood and straws) are a potential renewable source for the production of a wide variety of chemicals that could be used to replace those currently produced by petrochemical industry. This would lead to lower greenhouse gas emissions and waste amounts, and to economical savings. There are many possible pathways available for the manufacturing of chemicals from lignocellulosic biomasses. One option is to hydrolyze the cellulose and hemicelluloses of these biomasses into monosaccharides using concentrated sulfuric acid as catalyst. This process is an efficient method for producing monosaccharides which are valuable platforn chemicals. Also other valuable products are formed in the hydrolysis. Unfortunately, the concentrated acid hydrolysis has been deemed unfeasible mainly due to high chemical consumption resulting from the need to remove sulfuric acid from the obtained hydrolysates prior to the downstream processing of the monosaccharides. Traditionally, this has been done by neutralization with lime. This, however, results in high chemical consumption. In addition, the by-products formed in the hydrolysis are not removed and may, thus, hinder the monosaccharide processing. In order to improve the feasibility of the concentrated acid hydrolysis, the chemical consumption should be decreased by recycling of sulfuric acid without neutralization. Furthermore, the monosaccharides and the other products formed in the hydrolysis should be recovered selectively for efficient downstream processing. The selective recovery of the hydrolysis by-products would have additional economical benefits on the process due to their high value. In this work, the use of chromatographic fractionation for the recycling of sulfuric acid and the selective recovery of the main components from the hydrolysates formed in the concentrated acid hydrolysis was investigated. Chromatographic fractionation based on the electrolyte exclusion with gel type strong acid cation exchange resins in acid (H+) form as a stationary phase was studied. A systematic experimental and model-based study regarding the separation task at hand was conducted. The phenomena affecting the separation were determined and their effects elucidated. Mathematical models that take accurately into account these phenomena were derived and used in the simulation of the fractionation process. The main components of the concentrated acid hydrolysates (sulfuric acid, monosaccharides, and acetic acid) were included into this model. Performance of the fractionation process was investigated experimentally and by simulations. Use of different process options was also studied. Sulfuric acid was found to have a significant co-operative effect on the sorption of the other components. This brings about interesting and beneficial effects in the column operations. It is especially beneficial for the separation of sulfuric acid and the monosaccharides. Two different approaches for the modelling of the sorption equilibria were investigated in this work: a simple empirical approach and a thermodynamically consistent approach (the Adsorbed Solution theory). Accurate modelling of the phenomena observed in this work was found to be possible using the simple empirical models. The use of the Adsorbed Solution theory is complicated by the nature of the theory and the complexity of the studied system. In addition to the sorption models, a dynamic column model that takes into account the volume changes of the gel type resins as changing resin bed porosity was also derived. Using the chromatography, all the main components of the hydrolysates can be recovered selectively, and the sulfuric acid consumption of the hydrolysis process can be lowered considerably. Investigation of the performance of the chromatographic fractionation showed that the highest separation efficiency in this separation task is obtained with a gel type resin with a high crosslinking degree (8 wt. %); especially when the hydrolysates contain high amounts of acetic acid. In addition, the concentrated acid hydrolysis should be done with as low sulfuric acid concentration as possible to obtain good separation performance. The column loading and flow rate also have large effects on the performance. In this work, it was demonstrated that when recycling of the fractions obtained in the chromatographic fractionation are recycled to preceding unit operations these unit operations should included in the performance evaluation of the fractionation. When this was done, the separation performance and the feasibility of the concentrated acid hydrolysis process were found to improve considerably. Use of multi-column chromatographic fractionation processes, the Japan Organo process and the Multi-Column Recycling Chromatography process, was also investigated. In the studied case, neither of these processes could compete with the single-column batch process in the productivity. However, due to internal recycling steps, the Multi-Column Recycling Chromatography was found to be superior to the batch process when the product yield and the eluent consumption were taken into account.

Recovery of biomass-derived valuable compounds using chromatographic and membrane separations

Utilization of biomass-based raw materials for the production of chemicals and materials is gaining an increasing interest. Due to the complex nature of biomass, a major challenge in its refining is the development of efficient fractionation and purification processes. Preparative chromatography and membrane filtration are selective, energy-efficient separation techniques which offer a great potential for biorefinery applications. Both of these techniques have been widely studied. On the other hand, only few process concepts that combine the two methods have been presented in the literature. The aim of this thesis was to find the possible synergetic effects provided by combining chromatographic and membrane separations, with a particular interest in biorefinery separation processes. Such knowledge could be used in the development of new, more efficient separation processes for isolating valuable compounds from complex feed solutions that are typical for the biorefinery environment. Separation techniques can be combined in various ways, from simple sequential coupling arrangements to fully-integrated hybrid processes. In this work, different types of combined separation processes as well as conventional chromatographic separation processes were studied for separating small molecules such as sugars and acids from biomass hydrolysates and spent pulping liquors. The combination of chromatographic and membrane separation was found capable of recovering high-purity products from complex solutions. For example, hydroxy acids of black liquor were successfully recovered using a novel multistep process based on ultrafiltration and size-exclusion chromatography. Unlike any other separation process earlier suggested for this challenging separation task, the new process concept does not require acidification pretreatment, and thus it could be more readily integrated into a pulp-mill biorefinery. In addition to the combined separation processes, steady-state recycling chromatography, which has earlier been studied for small-scale separations of high-value compounds only, was found a promising process alternative for biorefinery applications. In comparison to conventional batch chromatography, recycling chromatography provided higher product purity, increased the production rate and reduced the chemical consumption in the separation of monosaccharides from biomass hydrolysates. In addition, a significant further improvement in the process performance was obtained when a membrane filtration unit was integrated with recycling chromatography. In the light of the results of this work, separation processes based on combining membrane and chromatographic separations could be effectively applied for different biorefinery applications. The main challenge remains in the development of inexpensive separation materials which are resistant towards harsh process conditions and fouling.

In-House Validation of Capillary Electrophoresis Method

Capillary electrophoresis method designed originally for the analysis of monosaccharides was validated using reference solutions of polydatin. The validation was conducted by studying and determining the concentration levels of LOD and LOQ and the range of linearity and by determining levels of uncertainty in respect to repeatability and reproducibility. The reliability of the gained results is also discussed. A guide with recommendations considering the validation and overall design of analysis sequences with CE is also produced as a result of this study.

Ionic liquid mediated biomass deconstruction: from analysis challenges to fermentable sugars

Ionic liquids, ILs, have recently been studied with accelerating interest to be used for a deconstruction/fractionation, dissolution or pretreatment processing method of lignocellulosic biomass. ILs are usually utilized combined with heat. Regarding lignocellulosic recalcitrance toward fractionation and IL utilization, most of the studies concern IL utilization in the biomass fermentation process prior to the enzymatic hydrolysis step. It has been demonstrated that IL-pretreatment gives more efficient hydrolysis of the biomass polysaccharides than enzymatic hydrolysis alone. Both cellulose (especially cellulose) and lignin are very resistant towards fractionation and even dissolution methods. As an example, it can be mentioned that softwood, hardwood and grass-type plant species have different types of lignin structures leading to the fact that softwood lignin (guaiacyl lignin dominates) is the most difficult to solubilize or chemically disrupt. In addition to the known conventional biomass processing methods, several ILs have also been found to efficiently dissolve either cellulose and/or wood samples – different ILs are suitable for different purposes. An IL treatment of wood usually results in non-fibrous pulp, where lignin is not efficiently separated and wood components are selectively precipitated, as cellulose is not soluble or degradable in ionic liquids under mild conditions. Nevertheless, new ILs capable of rather good fractionation performance have recently emerged. The capability of the IL to dissolve or deconstruct wood or cellulose depends on several factors, (e.g. sample origin, the particle size of the biomass, mechanical treatments as pulverization, initial biomassto-IL ratio, water content of the biomass, possible impurities of IL, reaction conditions, temperature etc). The aim of this study was to obtain (fermentable) saccharides and other valuable chemicals from wood by a combined heat and IL-treatment. Thermal treatments alone contribute to the degradation of polysaccharides (e.g. 150 °C alone is said to cause the degradation of polysaccharides), thus temperatures below that should be used, if the research interest lies on the IL effectiveness. On the other hand, the efficiency of the IL-treatment can also be enhanced to combine other treatment methods, (e.g. microwave heating). The samples of spruce, pine and birch sawdust were treated with either 1-Ethyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride, Emim Cl, or 1-Ethyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate, Emim Ac, (or with ionized water for comparison) at various temperatures (where focus was between 80 and 120 °C). The samples were withdrawn at fixed time intervals (the main interest treatment time area lied between 0 and 100 hours). Double experiments were executed. The selected mono- and disaccharides, as well as their known degradation products, 5-hydroxymethylfurfural, 5-HMF, and furfural were analyzed with capillary electrophoresis, CE, and high-performance liquid chromatography, HPLC. Initially, even GC and GC-MS were utilized. Galactose, glucose, mannose and xylose were the main monosaccharides that were present in the wood samples exposed to ILs at elevated temperatures; in addition, furfural and 5-HMF were detected; moreover, the quantitative amount of the two latter ones were naturally increasing in line with the heating time or the IL:wood ratio.

Biomassaperäisen liuoksen fraktiointi membraanisuodatuksella

Työn tavoitteena oli hiilihydraattien ja aminohappojen talteenotto biomassaperäisistä liuoksista erilaisina fraktioina ultra- ja nanosuodattamalla niitä erilaisilla membraaneilla. Työ tehtiin selvitystyönä Senson Oy:lle syystalven 2015 ja kevään 2016 välisenä aikana. Teoriaosassa perehdyttiin nanosuodatukseen ja sen erilaisiin sovelluksiin teollisuudessa, sekä lyhyesti muihin paineavusteisiin membraanisuodatusprosesseihin. Teoriaosassa myös keskityttiin erityisesti nanosuodatuksessa käytettyihin membraaneihin sekä niiden likaantumismekanismeihin. Kokeellisessa osassa keskityttiin hiilihydraattien ja aminohappojen talteenottoon kolmesta biomassaperäisestä liuoksesta. Tutkimuksen osa-alueita olivat ultrasuodatus, ultrasuodatuksen konsentraatin kirkastaminen sekä ultrasuodatuksen permeaatin fraktiointi nanosuodatuksella. Tutkimuksessa kiinnitettiin myös erityistä huomiota suodatuskalvojen likaantumiseen ja peseytyvyyteen sekä kalvojen käytettävyyteen pesujen jälkeen. Ultrasuodatuksessa kaikkien kolmen liuoksen kohdalla tutkittavien hiilihydraattien saanto permeaattiin oli hyvä, noin 90 %. Ultrasuodatuksissa käytettyjen membraanien osalta ei myöskään ollut havaittavissa merkittävää likaantumista. Ultrasuodatuksen konsentraattien kirkastamiskokeissa sameutta aiheuttavat komponentit saatiin poistettua kaikista liuoksista yli 94 %:in tehokkuudella. Nanosuodatuksissa monosakkaridit saatiin erotettua suuremmista hiilihydraattikomponenteista joko täysin tai lähes täysin (97 - 100 %). Nanosuodatuksissa käytettyjen membraanien osalta huomattavaa likaantumista oli havaittavissa vain membraanilla 2. Tulosten perusteella nanosuodatuksen voidaan sanoa olevan tehokas tapa erottaa pienet monosakkaridit suuremmista hiilihydraattiyhdisteistä.

Hydrothermal carbonization in the synthesis of sustainable porous carbon materials

Carbon materials are found versatile and applicable in wide range of applications. During the recent years research of carbon materials has focussed on the search of environmentally friendly, sustainable, renewable and low-cost starting material sources as well as simple cost-efficient synthesis techniques. As an alternative synthesis technique in the production of carbon materials hydrothermal carbonization (HTC) has shown a great potential. Depending on the application HTC can be performed as such or as a pretreatment technique. This technique allows synthesis of carbon materials i.e. hydrochars in closed vessel in the presence of water and self-generated pressure at relatively low temperatures (180-250 ˚C). As in many applications well developed porosity and heteroatom distribution are in a key role. Therefore in this study different techniques e.g. varying feedstock, templating and post-treatment in order to introduce these properties to the hydrochars structure were performed. Simple monosaccharides i.e. fructose or glucose and more complex compounds such as cellulose and sludge were performed as starting materials. Addition of secondary precursor e.g. thiophenecarboxaldehyde and ovalbumin was successfully exploited in order to alter heteroatom content. It was shown that well-developed porosity (SBET 550 m2/g) can be achieved via one-pot approach (i.e. exploitation of salt mixture) without conventionally used post-carbonization step. Nitrogen-enriched hydrochars indicated significant Pb(II) and Cr(VI) removal efficiency of 240 mg/g and 68 mg/g respectively. Sulphur addition into carbon network was not found to have enhancing effect on the adsorption of methylene blue or change acidity of the carbon material. However, these hydrochars were found to remove 99.9 % methylene blue and adsorption efficiency of these hydrochars remained over 90 % even after regeneration. In addition to water treatment application N-rich high temperature treated carbon materials were proven applicable as electrocatalyst and electrocatalyst support. Hydrothermal carbonization was shown to be workable technique for the production of carbon materials with variable physico-chemical properties and therefore hydrochars could be applied in several different applications e.g. as alternative low-cost adsorbent for pollutant removal from water.