Immobilization of Burkholderia cepacia Lipase: Kinetic Resolution in Organic Solvents, Ionic Liquids and in Their Mixtures

Immobilization of Burkholderia cepacia Lipase: Kinetic Resolution in Organic Solvents, Ionic Liquids and in Their Mixtures Biocatalysis opens the door to green and sustainable processes in synthetic chemistry allowing the preparation of single enantiomers, since the enzymes are chiral and accordingly able to catalyze chemical reactions under mild conditions. Immobilization of enzymes enhances process robustness, often stabilizes and activates the enzyme, and enables reuse of the same enzyme preparation in multiple cycles. Although hundreds of variations of immobilization methods exist, there is no universal method to yield the highly active, selective and stable enzyme catalysts. Therefore, new methods need to be developed to obtain suitable catalysts for different substrates and reaction environments. Lipases are the most widely used enzymes in synthetic organic chemistry. The literature part together with the experimental part of this thesis discusses of the effects of immobilization methods mostly used to enhance lipase activity, stability and enantioselectivity. Moreover, the use of lipases in the kinetic resolution of secondary alcohols in organic solvents and in ionic liquids is discussed. The experimental work consists of the studies of immobilization of Burkholderia cepacia lipase (lipase PS) using three different methods: encapsulation in sol-gels, cross-linked enzyme aggregates (CLEAs) and supported ionic liquids enzyme catalysts (SILEs). In addition, adsorption of lipase PS on celite was studied to compare the results obtained with sol-gels, CLEAs and SILEs. The effects of immobilization on enzyme activity, enantioselectivity and hydrolysis side reactions were studied in kinetic resolution of three secondary alcohols in organic solvents, in ionic liquids (ILs), and in their mixtures. Lipase PS sol-gels were shown to be active and stable catalysts in organic solvents and solvent:IL mixtures. CLEAs and SILEs were highly active and enantioselective in organic solvents. Sol-gels and SILEs were reusable in several cycles. Hydrolysis side reaction was suppressed in the presence of sol-gels and CLEAs.

Removal of Cadmium, Lead and Arsenic from Water by Lactic Acid Bacteria

A number of contaminants such as arsenic, cadmium and lead are released into the environment from natural and anthropogenic sources contaminating food and water. Chronic oral ingestion of arsenic, cadmium and lead is associated with adverse effects in the skin, internal organs and nervous system. In addition to conventional methods, biosorption using inactivated biomasses of algae, fungi and bacteria has been introduced as a novel method for decontamination of toxic metals from water. The aim of this work was to evaluate the applicability of lactic acid bacteria as tools for heavy metal removal from water and characterize their properties for further development of a biofilter. The results established that in addition to removal of mycotoxins, cyanotoxins and heterocyclic amines, lactic acid bacteria have a capacity to bind cationic heavy metals, cadmium and lead. The binding was found to be dependent on the bacterial strain and pH, and occurred rapidly on the bacterial surface, but was reduced in the presence of other cationic metals. The data demonstrates that the metals were bound by electrostatic interactions to cell wall components. Transmission electron micrographs showed the presence of lead deposits on the surface of biomass used in the lead binding studies, indicating involvement of another uptake/binding mechanism. The most efficient strains bound up to 55 mg Cd and 176 mg Pb / g dry biomass. A low removal of anionic As(V) was also observed after chemical modification of the cell wall. Full desorption of bound cadmium and lead using either dilute HNO₃ or EDTA established the reversibility of binding. Removal of both metals was significantly reduced when biomass regenerated with EDTA was used. Biomass regenerated with dilute HNO3 retained its cadmium binding capacity well, but lead binding was reduced. The results established that the cadmium and lead binding capacity of lactic acid bacteria, and factors affecting it, are similar to what has been previously observed for other biomasses used for the same purpose. However, lactic acid bacteria have a capacity to remove other aqueous contaminants such as cyanotoxins, which may give them an additional advantage over the other alternatives. Further studies focusing on immobilization of biomass and the removal of several contaminants simultaneously using immobilized bacteria are required.

Sakkaroosin hydrolyysi immobilisoidulla entsyymillä

Työssä tutkittiin sakkaroosin hydrolyysiä anioninvaihtohartseihin immobilisoidun entsyymin avulla tavoitteena löytää sellainen kantaja-entsyymi -yhdistelmä, jolla konversio halutuiksi lopputuotteiksi olisi mahdollisimman korkea. Työhön valittiin aikaisemmissa laboratoriokokeissa parhaita tuloksia saavuttaneet kantaja-entsyymi -parit. Entsyymeinä oli kaksi nestemäistä Saccharomyces cerevisiae -hiivasta eristettyjä entsyymivalmistetta. Kokeissa käytetyt kantajamateriaalit olivat erilaisia heikkoja anioninvaihtohartseja. Entsyymit immobilisoitiin kantajaan sekoitusreaktorissa ja niiden aktiivisuudet määritettiin sitomisen jälkeen. Hydrolyysikokeet tehtiin jatkuvatoimisessa kiintopetireaktorissa ja lisäksi panos-kokeina tutkittiin ominaisuuksiltaan erilaisten kantajien eroja hydrolyysissä. Reaktio-olosuhteet pidettiin kaikissa kokeissa samoina. Sakkaroosiliuoksen pitoisuus oli 50 p-%, reaktiolämpötila 50 oC ja pH 5. Kiintopetikolonnissa tutkittiin myös sakkaroosi-liuoksen viipymäajan vaikutusta sivutuotteiden syntyyn. Näytteet analysoitiin neste-kromatografilla. Kiintopetikolonnissa lyhimmän viipymäajan (15 min) kokeissa ainoastaan hitaimmilla kantaja-entsyymi -pareilla muodostui sivutuotteita, jotka hydrolyysireaktion edetessä kuitenkin hävisivät. Kun viipymäaikaa kasvatettiin sivutuotteiden synty väheni ja lopulta niitä ei havaittu syntyvän lainkaan. Hydrolyysin edetessä viipymäajan ollessa tarpeeksi pitkä pienet sivutuotekomponentit hävisivät sakkaroosin hajotessa kokonaan glukoosiksi ja fruktoosiksi. Verrattaessa partikkelikoon ja hartsimatriisin vaikutusta samaan entsyymiin sidottuna havaittiin, että niillä kummallakin on vaikutusta sekä sakkaroosin hydrolyysi-nopeuteen että sivutuotteiden muodostumiseen.

Streptavidin - A Versatile Binding Protein for Solid-Phase Immunoassays

Streptavidin, a tetrameric protein secreted by Streptomyces avidinii, binds tightly to a small growth factor biotin. One of the numerous applications of this high-affinity system comprises the streptavidin-coated surfaces of bioanalytical assays which serve as universal binders for straightforward immobilization of any biotinylated molecule. Proteins can be immobilized with a lower risk of denaturation using streptavidin-biotin technology in contrast to direct passive adsorption. The purpose of this study was to characterize the properties and effects of streptavidin-coated binding surfaces on the performance of solid-phase immunoassays and to investigate the contributions of surface modifications. Various characterization tools and methods established in the study enabled the convenient monitoring and binding capacity determination of streptavidin-coated surfaces. The schematic modeling of the monolayer surface and the quantification of adsorbed streptavidin disclosed the possibilities and the limits of passive adsorption. The defined yield of 250 ng/cm² represented approximately 65 % coverage compared with a modelled complete monolayer, which is consistent with theoretical surface models. Modifications such as polymerization and chemical activation of streptavidin resulted in a close to 10-fold increase in the biotin-binding densities of the surface compared with the regular streptavidin coating. In addition, the stability of the surface against leaching was improved by chemical modification. The increased binding densities and capacities enabled wider high-end dynamic ranges in the solid-phase immunoassays, especially when using the fragments of the capture antibodies instead of intact antibodies for the binding of the antigen. The binding capacity of the streptavidin surface was not, by definition, predictive of the low-end performance of the immunoassays nor the assay sensitivity. Other features such as non-specific binding, variation and leaching turned out to be more relevant. The immunoassays that use a direct surface readout measurement of time-resolved fluorescence from a washed surface are dependent on the density of the labeled antibodies in a defined area on the surface. The binding surface was condensed into a spot by coating streptavidin in liquid droplets into special microtiter wells holding a small circular indentation at the bottom. The condensed binding area enabled a denser packing of the labeled antibodies on the surface. This resulted in a 5 - 6-fold increase in the signal-to-background ratios and an equivalent improvement in the detection limits of the solid-phase immunoassays. This work proved that the properties of the streptavidin-coated surfaces can be modified and that the defined properties of the streptavidin-based immunocapture surfaces contribute to the performance of heterogeneous immunoassays.

Villieläinlääketiedettä uusitussa painoksessa

Kirjallisuusarvostelu

Ultrasuodatusmembraanin modifiointi entsyymeillä suodatusominaisuuksien parantamiseksi

Tämän diplomityön tarkoituksena oli kiinnittää lakkaasientsyymi polyeetterisulfonimembraaniin suodatusominaisuuksien parantamiseksi. Lakkaasientsyymin tiedetään pilkkovan ligniiniä ja kiinnittämällä lakkaasientsyymi membraaniin tavoiteltiin ligniinin aiheuttaman membraanin likaantumisen vähentämistä. Tällöin vältyttäisiin lisäksi erilliseltä esikäsittely vaiheelta ja voitaisiin saada puhtaampi lopputuote. Lakkaasientsyymivalmisteena tutkimuksessa käytettiin Novozym® 51003 ja ristisilloittajana käytettiin glutaarialdehydiä. Vapaan ja kiinnitetyn lakkaasientsyymin aktiivisuuden määritettiin 2,2-atso-bis(3- etyylibentsotiatsolyyli-6-sulfonihappo):n avulla. Lakkaasin kiinnittymistä membraaniin tutkittiin ATR-FTIR spektroskoopilla kiinnittymisen varmentamiseksi. Lakkaasi modifioituja membraaneja testattiin koivu-uute suodatuksella ja adsorptio kokeella. Lakkaasientsyymi saatiin kiinnitettyä membraaniin ristisilloittajan avulla, mutta lakkaasilla modifioitujen membraanien vesivuot laskivat noin puoleen alkuperäisestä. Koivu-uuteen suodatuksissa modifioidusta membraanista ei saatu permeaattia lävitse, mutta adsorptiokokeen tulosten perusteella voidaan todeta lakkaasientsyymin pilkkoneen ligniiniä. Kiinnitetyn lakkaasin aktiivisuus vaihteli rinnakkaisten määritysten välillä, minkä vuoksi lakkaasin kiinnitysmekanismin lisätutkiminen olisi tarpeen luotettavimpien tulosten saamiseksi.

Lipase and omega-transaminase catalysis in preparation of alcohol and amine enantiomers

Enantiopure intermediates are of high value in drug synthesis. Biocatalysis alone or combined with chemical synthesis provides powerful tools to access enantiopure compounds. In biocatalysis, chemo-, regio- and enantioselectivity of enzymes are combined with their inherent environmentally benign nature. Enzymes can be applied in versatile chemical reactions with non-natural substrates under synthesis conditions. Immobilization of an enzyme is a crucial part of an efficient biocatalytic synthesis method. Successful immobilization enhances the catalytic performance of an enzyme and enables its reuse in successive reactions. This thesis demonstrates the feasibility of biocatalysis in the preparation of enantiopure secondary alcohols and primary amines. Viability and synthetic usability of the studied biocatalytic methods have been addressed throughout this thesis. Candida antarctica lipase B (CAL-B) catalyzed enantioselective O-acylation of racemic secondary alcohols was successfully incorporated with in situ racemization in the dynamic kinetic resolution, affording the (R)-esters in high yields and enantiopurities. Side reactions causing decrease in yield and enantiopurity were suppressed. CAL-B was also utilized in the solvent-free kinetic resolution of racemic primary amines. This method produced the enantiomers as (R)-amides and (S)-amines under ambient conditions. An in-house sol-gel entrapment increased the reusability of CAL-B. Arthrobacter sp. omega-transaminase was entrapped in sol-gel matrices to obtain a reusable catalyst for the preparation enantiopure primary amines in an aqueous medium. The obtained heterogeneous omega-transaminase catalyst enabled the enantiomeric enrichment of the racemic amines to their (S)-enantiomers. The synthetic usability of the sol-gel catalyst was demonstrated in five successive preparative kinetic resolutions.

Extended hydrogen photoproduction by nitrogen-fixing cyanobacteria

Cyanobacteria are the only prokaryotic organisms performing oxygenic photosynthesis. They comprise a diverse and versatile group of organisms in aquatic and terrestrial environments. Increasing genomic and proteomic data launches wide possibilities for their employment in various biotechnical applications. For example, cyanobacteria can use solar energy to produce H2. There are three different enzymes that are directly involved in cyanobacterial H2 metabolism: nitrogenase (nif) which produces hydrogen as a byproduct in nitrogen fixation; bidirectional hydrogenase (hox) which functions both in uptake and in production of H2; and uptake hydrogenase (hup) which recycles the H2 produced by nitrogenase back for the utilization of the cell. Cyanobacterial strains from University of Helsinki Cyanobacteria Collection (UHCC), isolated from the Baltic Sea and Finnish lakes were screened for efficient H2 producers. Screening about 400 strains revealed several promising candidates producing similar amounts of H2 (during light) as the ΔhupL mutant of Anabaena PCC 7120, which is specifically engineered to produce higher amounts of H2 by the interruption of uptake hydrogenase. The optimal environmental conditions for H2 photoproduction were significantly different between various cyanobacterial strains. All suitable strains revealed during screening were N2-fixing, filamentous and heterocystous. The top ten H2 producers were characterized for the presence and activity of the enzymes involved in H2 metabolism. They all possess the genes encoding the conventional nitrogenase (nifHDK1). However, the high H2 photoproduction rates of these strains were shown not to be directly associated with the maximum capacities of highly active nitrogenase or bidirectional hydrogenase. Most of the good producers possessed a highly active uptake hydrogenase, which has been considered as an obstacle for efficient H2 production. Among the newly revealed best H2 producing strains, Calothrix 336/3 was chosen for further, detailed characterization. Comparative analysis of the structure of the nif and hup operons encoding the nitrogenase and uptake hydrogenase enzymes respectively showed minor differences between Calothrix 336/3 and other N2-fixing model cyanobacteria. Calothrix 336/3 is a filamentous, N2-fixing cyanobacterium with ellipsoidal, terminal heterocysts. A common feature of Calothrix 336/3 is that the cells readily adhere to substrates. To make use of this feature, and to additionally improve H2 photoproduction capacity of the Calothrix 336/3 strain, an immobilization technique was applied. The effects of immobilization within thin alginate films were evaluated by examining the photoproduction of H2 of immobilized Calothrix 336/3 in comparison to model strains, the Anabaena PCC 7120 and its ΔhupL mutant. In order to achieve optimal H2 photoproduction, cells were kept under nitrogen starved conditions (Ar atmosphere) to ensure the selective function of nitrogenase in reducing protons to H2. For extended H2 photoproduction, cells require CO2 for maintenance of photosynthetic activity and recovery cycles to fix N2. Application of regular H2 production and recovery cycles, Ar or air atmospheres respectively, resulted in prolongation of H2 photoproduction in both Calothrix 336/3 and the ΔhupL mutant of Anabaena PCC 7120. However, recovery cycles, consisting of air supplemented with CO2, induced a strong C/N unbalance in the ΔhupL mutant leading to a decrease in photosynthetic activity, although total H2 yield was still higher compared to the wild-type strain. My findings provide information about the diversity of cyanobacterial H2 capacities and mechanisms and provide knowledge of the possibilities of further enhancing cyanobacterial H2 production.

Entsyymien talteenotto ja kierrätys selluloosaetanolin valmistuksessa

Bioetanolin valmistus selluloosapitoisista raaka-aineista vaatii selluloosapolymeerien pilkkomisen liukoisiksi sokereiksi. Tämä voidaan toteuttaa entsymaattisella hydrolyysillä. Selluloosan pilkkomiseen tarkoitetut entsyymit, sellulaasit, ovat entsymaattisen hydrolyysin jälkeen sitoutuneet joko kiintoainefaasiin tai ovat nestemäisessä faasissa ns. vapaina entsyymeinä. Prosessin taloudellisuuden kannalta on erityisen tärkeää minimoida siinä käytettävien entsyymien tarve, sillä tehokkaat entsyymivalmisteet ovat suhteellisen kalliita. Yksi varteenotettava vaihtoehto bioetanoliprosessin saamiseksi taloudellisemmaksi on käytettyjen entsyymien talteenotto ja kierrätys. Työn tarkoituksena oli selvittää kirjallisuudesta, millaisia menetelmiä on kehitetty entsyymien talteenottoon ja kierrätykseen lignoselluloosasta valmistettavan bioetanolin valmistuksessa. Työssä on keskitytty tuoreisiin tutkimuksiin ja menetelmien käyttökelpoisuuteen ja taloudellisuuteen. Viime vuosina sellulaasien talteenotto- ja kierrätysmenetelmiä koskevat tutkimukset ovat keskittyneet pääasiassa käsittelemään nanopartikkelien avulla tapahtuvaa entsyymien immobilisointia, ultrasuodatusta, erilaisia desorptiomenetelmiä, kiinteän hydrolyysijäännöksen kierrättämistä, tuoreen substraatin lisäämistä sekä myös tislausvaiheen jälkeistä entsyymien kierrättämistä. Jotta kierrätysmenetelmä olisi tehokas, tulisi sen pyrkiä säilyttämään entsyymien aktiivisuuksia, sokerisaantoa menettämättä ja sisältää sekä neste-, että kiintoainefaasista tapahtuva kierrätys. Jokaisella kierrätysmenetelmällä on hyvät ja huonot puolensa. Entsyymien talteenottoastetta saadaan kuitenkin parannettua yhdistämällä erilaisia menetelmiä. Useista tutkimuksista huolimatta, taloudellisinta ja käyttökelpoisinta entsyymien talteenotto- ja kierrätysmenetelmää ei ole vielä saavutettu.

Sinkin stabiloiminen pilaantuneesta maa-aineksesta: 28 vuorokauden stabilointiajan riittävyys liukoisuustesteissä eri sinkkiyhdisteillä

Tässä kandidaatintyössä selvitettiin, onko 28 vuorokautta riittävä aika sinkillä pilaantuneen maaperän massastabilointiin, ja kuinka sinkin esiintymismuoto vaikuttaa sen stabilointiaikaan. Kokeellisessa osassa jäljiteltiin malmijätteessä, orgaanisessa aineksessa sekä liuenneena maaperässä esiintyvän sinkin stabiloitumista lisäämällä maanäytteeseen sinkkiä eri yhdisteinä; sinkkirakeina, -kloridina ja -asetaattina. Näytteet stabiloitiin sementti-lentotuhkaseoksella 1–28 vuorokauden pituisia ajanjaksoja, minkä jälkeen ne kuvattiin pyyhkäisyelektronimikroskoopilla (SEM) ja niille tehtiin liukoisuustestit. Liukoisuustestien tuloksista voidaan huomata sinkkikloridin stabiloituvan jo ensimmäisen vuorokauden aikana ja pysyvän samalla tasolla koko tarkasteluajan. Sinkkirakeiden ja -asetaatin stabiloituminen ei ole yhtä tasaista; alun sitoutumisen jälkeen niiden liukoisuuksissa on havaittavissa selkeät piikit 21 vuorokauden kohdalla. Tämän jälkeen ne alkavat sitoutua uudelleen. Tulosten perusteella sinkin esiintymismuoto vaikuttaa sen stabilointiaikaan, eikä 28:aa vuorokautta voida pitää riittävänä aikana sinkillä pilaantuneen maa-aineksen stabilointiin. Vaikka liukoinen sinkki stabiloituu jo yhdessä vuorokaudessa, ei malmijätteessä tai orgaanisessa aineksessa esiintyvä sinkki ehdi stabiloitua vakaalle tasolle vielä 28 vuorokaudenkaan aikana. Tämä tulisi ottaa huomioon suunniteltaessa ja toteutettaessa sinkkiä sisältävien maiden kunnostushankkeita.

Feasibility of the use of recycled nutrients in fast growing pulpwood production

The application of pulp and paper mill (PPM) sludge in agriculture and forestry has been acknowledged as soil amendments and a plant nutrient source. The main objectives of this study were to evaluate the total cost of the use of recycled nutrients from PPM sludge in fast growing pulpwood production, and the financial profitability of fast growing pulpwood production with the use of these recycled nutrients. The investment and production costs of fast growing pulpwood plantation were directly acquired from a previous research, while the other data was compiled through different studies. The total cost of the use of PPM sludge was evaluated based on assumed factors. Discounted cash flow method was used to evaluate the financial profitability, using NPV and IRR as indicators. The results of estimated sludge nutrient contents were 16.2 g N, 2.9 g P, and 2.4 g K kg-1 of dry sludge. The sludge application rate was estimated at 1.36 Mg/ha in the first year. The total cost of the use of PPM sludge involved transport and spreading cost of US$49.15/dry ton. The fertilization cost applied in the financial model was designed in 3 different options and their results were as follows: option (1) was taken directly from the reference research (US$97/ha); option (2) was the use of sludge alone (US$66.75/ha); and option (3) was the use of sludge and TSP fertilizer (US$83.80/ha). The average NPV without discounting was US$248,180 while the IRRs ranged between approximately 3-4% with an average of 3.63%. Although option (2) and (3) contributed to higher IRRs compared to option (1), this increase was still not significant as the IRR was not sensitive to the total fertilization cost. The advantages are that this practice can be performed at a lower cost and the application rate can be still increased if necessary. It is better for forest plantations compared to agriculture and consequently supports reforestation program. In addition, it can be similarly applied in wood biomass production. A disadvantage is that the IRRs were not very favorable compared to the criterion of 11%. The sludge high in C:N ratio can cause nitrogen immobilization, and regulatory concerns may restrict and complicate the use of sludge landspreading and contribute to additional costs and processes.

Modification of Photocatalyst with Enhanced Photocatalytic Activity for Water

Increasing demand and shortage of energy resources and clean water due to the rapid development of industry, population growth and long term droughts have become an issue worldwide. As a result, global warming, long term droughts and pollution-related diseases are becoming more and more serious. The traditional technologies, such as precipitation, neutralization, sedimentation, filtration and waste immobilization, cannot prevent the pollution but restrict the waste chemicals only after the pollution emission. Meanwhile, most of these treatments cannot thoroughly degrade the contaminants and may generate toxic secondary pollutants into ecosystem. Heterogeneous photocatalysis as the innovative wastewater technology attracts many attention, because it is able to generate highly reactive transitory species for total degradation of organic compounds, water pathogens and disinfection by-products. Semiconductor as photocatalysts have demonstrated their efficiency in degrading a wide range of organics into readily biodegradable compounds, and eventually mineralized them to innocuous carbon dioxide and water. But, the efficiency of photocatalysis is limited, and hence, it is crucial issue to modify photocatalyst to enhance photocatalytic activity. In this thesis, first of all, two literature views are conducted. A survey of materials for photocatalysis has been carried out in order to summarize the properties and the applications of photocatalysts that have been developed in this field. Meanwhile, the strategy for the improvement of photocatalytic activity have been explicit discussed. Furthermore, all the raw material and chemicals used in this work have been listed as well as a specific experimental process and characterization method has been described. The synthesize methods of different photocatalysts have been depicted step by step. Among these cases, different modification strategies have been used to enhance the efficiency of photocatalyst on degradation of organic compounds (Methylene Blue or Phenol). For each case, photocatalytic experiments have been done to exhibit their photocatalytic activity.The photocatalytic experiments have been designed and its process have been explained and illustrated in detailed. Moreover, the experimental results have been shown and discussion. All the findings have been demonstrated in detail and discussed case by case. Eventually, the mechanisms on the improvement of photocatalytic activities have been clarified by characterization of samples and analysis of results. As a conclusion, the photocatalytic activities of selected semiconductors have been successfully enhanced via choosing appropriate strategy for the modification of photocatalysts.

Teollisuusjätteen käyttö kiinteytys-stabiloinnin sideaineena ja haitta-aineiden stabiloinnin tehostamisessa

Tässä kanditaatintyössä selvitettiin kuinka erilaiset sideaineseokset soveltuvat raskas-metallien sitomiseen 28 vuorokautta stabiloiduissa näytteistä. Työssä oletettiin teollisten jätefraktioiden käytön tehostavan eräiden metallien, kuten kupari ja sinkki, immobilisointia lievästi pilaantuneista maa-aineksista. Kokeellisessa osassa stabiloitiin Kokkolan satamasta ruopattua sedimenttiä, jonka sinkkipitoisuudet olivat ylittäneet saastuneen sedimentin ohjearvon (≥400 mg/kg). Sedimenttiin lisättiin eri sideaineseoksia ja näytteiden annettiin stabiloitua 28 vuorokautta, minkä jälkeen niistä testattiin liukenevat raskasmetallit muokatulla ravistelutestillä. Eri sideaineseoksilla saatuja tuloksia verrattiin pelkän yleissementin käyttöön. Lisäksi erillisistä näytteistä otettiin pyyhkäisyelektronimikros-koopilla (SEM) kuvia havainnollistamaan stabiloitumista. Näissä näytteissä käytettiin samoja sideaineita kuin tehdyissä kokeissa. Liukoisuustestien tuloksista voidaan huomata näytteissä ongelmalliseksi raskasmetalliksi identifioidun sinkin sitoutuvan parhaiten sementin ja kipsin sekoituksella. Myös tuhkaa sisältävät sideainesekoitukset pienensivät sinkin liukoisuutta verrattuna pelkkään yleis-sementtiin. Jatkotutkimuksissa voitaisiin testata erilaisia sideainesekoituksia betonira-kentamisessa, joilla saadaan ainakin 25 MPa lujuusarvo, pilaantunutta sedimenttiä tai maa-ainesta käyttäen.