Integration of a Bioethanol Process to a Pulp Mill

Tässä diplomityössä tutkittiin puuhakkeen esihydrolyysi- ja hakkuujätteen hydrolyysiprosessien integroimista sellutehtaaseen bioetanolin tuottamiseksi. Tällaisesta ns. biojalostamosta luotiin WinGEMS-simulointiohjelmalla simulointimalli, jonka avulla tutkittiin bioetanoliprosessin vaikutusta sellutehtaan massa- ja energiataseisiin sekä alustavaa biojalostamon kannattavuutta. Simuloinnissa tarkasteltiin kolmea eri tapausta, joissa mäntysellun tuotannon ajateltiin olevan 1000 tonnia päivässä ja hakkuujätettä käytettävän 10 % tarvittavan kuitupuun määrästä: 1) Puuhakkeen esihydrolyysi ja hakkuujätteen hydrolyysi etanolin tuottamiseksi 2) Puuhakkeen esihydrolyysi, hakkuujäte kuorikattilaan poltettavaksi 3) Ei esihydrolyysiä, hakkuujäte kuorikattilaan poltettavaksi Verrattuna tapaukseen 3, puun kulutus kasvaa 16 % esihydrolysoitaessa puuhake ennen keittoa tapauksissa 1 ja 2. Kasvaneella puun kulutuksella tuotetaan tapauksessa 1 149 tonnia etanolia ja 240 MWh enemmän ylimääräsähköä päivässä. Tapauksessa 2 tuotetaan 68 tonnia etanolia ja 460 MWh enemmän ylimääräsähköä päivässä. Tämä tuottaisi vuotuista lisäkassavirtaa 18,8 miljoonaa euroa tapauksessa 1 ja 9,4 miljoonaa euroa tapauksessa 2. Hydrolyysin tuoteliuoksen, hydrolysaatin, haihduttaminen sekä hydrolyysiprosessien orgaanisten jäännöstuotteiden haihduttaminen ja polttaminen kasvattavat haihduttamon ja soodakattilan kuormitusta. Verrattuna tapaukseen 3, tapauksissa 1 ja 2 haihduttamon vaiheiden määrä on kasvatettava viidestä seitsemään ja tarvittavat lämmönsiirtopinta-alat lähes kaksinkertaistettava. Soodakattilan kuormitus kasvaa 39 % tapauksessa 1 ja 26 % tapauksessa 2.

Pressure filtration characteristics of enzymatically hydrolyzed biomass suspensions

Enzymatic hydrolysis of lignocellulosic polymers is likely to become one of the key technologies enabling industrial production of liquid biofuels and chemicals from lignocellulosic biomass. Certain types of enzymes are able to hydrolyze cellulose and hemicellulose polymers to shorter units and finally to sugar monomers. These monomeric sugars are environmentally acceptable carbon sources for the production of liquid biofuels, such as bioethanol, and other chemicals, such as organic acids. Liquid biofuels in particular have been shown to contribute to the reduction of net emissions of greenhouse gases. The solid residue of enzymatic hydrolysis is composed mainly of lignin and partially degraded fibers, while the liquid phase contains the produced sugars. It is usually necessary to separate these two phases at some point after the hydrolysis stage. Pressure filtration is an efficient technique for this separation. Solid-liquid separation of biomass suspensions is difficult, because biomass solids are able to retain high amounts of water, which cannot be readily liberated by mechanical separation techniques. Most importantly, the filter cakes formed from biomaterials are compressible, which ultimately means that the separation may not be much improved by increasing the filtration pressure. The use of filter aids can therefore facilitate the filtration significantly. On the other hand, the upstream process conditions have a major influence on the filtration process. This thesis investigates how enzymatic hydrolysis and related process conditions affect the filtration properties of a cardboard suspension. The experimental work consists of pressure filtration and characterization of hydrolysates. The study provides novel information about both issues, as the relationship between enzymatic hydrolysis conditions and subsequent filtration properties has so far not been considered in academic studies. The results of the work reveal that the final degree of hydrolysis is an important factor in the filtration stage. High hydrolysis yield generally increases the average specific cake resistance. Mixing during the hydrolysis stage resulted in undefined changes in the physical properties of the solid residue, causing a high filtration resistance when the mixing intensity was high. Theoretical processing of the mixing data led to an interesting observation: the average specific cake resistance was observed to be linearly proportional to the mixer shear stress. Another finding worth attention is that the size distributions of the solids did not change very dramatically during enzymatic hydrolysis. There was an observable size reduction during the first couple of hours, but after that the size reduction was minimal. Similarly, the size distribution of the suspended solids remained almost constant when the hydrolyzed suspension was subjected to intensive mixing. It was also found that the average specific cake resistance was successfully reduced by the use of filter aids. This reduction depended on the method of how the filter aids were applied. In order to obtain high filtration capacity, it is recommended to use the body feed mode, i.e. to mix the filter aid with the slurry prior to filtration. Regarding the quality of the filtrate, precoat filtration was observed to produce a clear filtrate with negligible suspended solids content, while the body feed filtrates were turbid, irrespective of which type of filter aid was used.

Biocide analysis, usability and stability

Biosidien toimittajat tavallisesti suorittavat biosidien annostelumäärien hallinnan paperi- ja kartonkiteollisuudessa. Useimmiten annostelun hallinta määritetään epäsuorilla menetelmillä, kuten esimerkiksi määrittämällä bakteerien kasvua. Biosidien tehoaineiden todellista konsentraatiota tai määrää prosessivesissä tai lopputuotteessa ei tavallisesti mitata. Diplomityössä kehitettiin kolmelle paperiteollisuudessa yleisesti käytetyllä biosidin tehoaineelle analyyttiset menetelmät. Menetelmät kehitettiin glutaraldehydille, 2,2-dibromi-3-nitriilipropionamidi:lle (DBNPA) ja 5-kloori-2-metyyli-4-isotiatsoliini-3-oni:lle (CMI). Kehitettyjä menetelmiä käytettiin tehoaineiden stabiilisuuden seuraamiseen vesiliuoksessa eri pH:ssa ja lämpötilassa. Lisäksi kartonkinäytteistä tehtiin uuttokokeita ja yritettiin kehittää uuttomenetelmät, joilla pystyttäisiin määrittämään biosidien tehoaineiden jäännöspitoisuuksia lopputuotteesta. Glutaraldehydille ja CMI:lle onnistuttiin kehittämään uuttomenetelmät, joilla pystyttiin määrittämään kartongista tutkittujen tehoaineiden jäännöspitoisuudet. Saadut tulokset vaikuttavat realistisilta. Glutaraldehydille ja DBNPA:lle tehtiin stabiilisuuskokeita ja tulokset ovat samankaltaisia mitä muut tutkijat ovat saaneet.

Testing of Vacuum Drum Filter

Tämän diplomityön tavoitteena oli testata ja optimoida erään alipainerumpusuodattimen toimivuutta, ja lisäksi maksimoida tuottavuus ja vertailla erilaisten pesumenetelmientehokkuutta. Testilietteiden ¿ rautarikasteen ja täyteainepastan ¿ karakterisointi oli myös tärkeää. Kirjallisuusosassa tarkasteltiin lyhyesti neste-kiintoaine-erotuksen teoriaa, erityisesti alipainesuodatusta ja alipainerumpusuodattimia. Lisäksi käsiteltiin kapillaarisuodatuksen toimintaperiaatteita sekä selvitettiin kaivosteollisuuden veden talteenottokeinoja, kiintoainejäämien käsittelymenetelmiä ja Chilen kaivosteollisuuden nykytilaa. Työn kokeellinen osa suoritettiin käyttämällä raskaita ja kiintoainepitoisuuksiltaan korkeita lietteitä, eli rautarikastetta ja täyteainepastaa. Kokeet suoritettiin erityisellä alipainerumpusuodattimella, joka oli muokattu perinteisestäpäältä syötettävästä alipainerumpusuodattimesta. Kokeissa tutkittiin pyörimisnopeuden ja erilaisten pesumenetelmien vaikutusta kakun kosteuteen ja suodatuskapasiteettiin. Koelietteiden karakterisointi suoritettiin analysoimalla partikkelikokojakauma, kiintoainepitoisuus, metallipitoisuus ja koostumus. Kokeiden perusteella havaittiin, että rummun pyörimisnopeudella ja lietteen kiintoainepitoisuudella on merkittävä vaikutus suodatuskapasiteettiin ja kakun kosteuspitoisuuteen. Havaittiin myös, että kakun kosteuspitoisuuksissa ja rummun suodatuskapasiteeteissa oli eroja, kun verrattiin eri suodatinväliaineen pesumenetelmiä. Täten oikean pesumenetelmän valinta on tärkeää, ja sillä pystytään lisäämään suodatinväliaineen käyttöikää.

Improvement of pyrolysis oil quality by scrubbing

Diplomityössä tutkittiin kuuman pyrolyysihöyryn puhdistamista haisevista ja kevyistä haihtuvista yhdisteistä. Työn kirjallisuusosassa selvitettiin pyrolyysiöljyn kannattavuutta uusiutuvana energialähteenä. Lisäksi eri pesurityyppejä tarkasteltiin ja ja vertailtiin. Työn kokeellisessa osassa käytettiin kahta erilaista koelaitteistoa. Tuotteen talteenotossa vertailtiin reaktorilämpötilan ja raaka-aineen kosteuden vaikutusta pyrolyysisaantoihin. Komponenttien talteenotossa tutkittiin epästabiilien ja pistävän hajuisten yhdisteiden poistamista kuumasta pyrolyysihöyrystä. Raaka-aineena käytettiin kuusen metsätäh-dehaketta, joka sisältää runsaasti neulasia ja kaarnaa. Kokeet toteutettiin lämpötila-alueella 460 - 520 °C. Koelaitteistot koostuivat kaasun (N2) syöttöjärjestelmään kytketystä kuumasta ja kyl-mästä puolesta. Tuotteen talteenotossa kuuma pyrolyysihöyry jäähdytettiin ja otettiin talteen. Komponenttien talteenotossa tuote kerättiin suodattimelle ja metyleeniklo-ridiloukkuun. Tuotteiden koostumukset analysoitiin kaasukromatokrafilla. Korkeimmat orgaaniset saannot saatiin 480 °C reaktorilämpötilalla ja 8-9 p-% raaka-ainekosteudella. Pyrolyysiveden määrä putosi raaka-aineen kosteutta nostettaessa. Eri reaktorilämpötiloilla ja raaka-ainekosteuksilla ei ollut vaikutusta hiiltosaantoihin. Kaasusaannot (pääosin CO2, CO ja hiilivedyt) olivat noin 10 p-%. Komponenttien talteenotossa suodatin tukkeutui matalissa (< 250 °C) lämpötiloissa. Suodattimelle jäänyt materiaali oli pääosin neulasista ja kaarnasta peräisin olevia uuteaineita (pääosin hartsi- rasvahappoja) ja sokereita. Korkeimmissa lämpötiloissa (> 250 °C) uuteaineet läpäisivät suodattimen paremmin. 250 ja 300 °C:n lämpötiloissa suuri määrä lyhytketjuisia helposti haihtuvia epästabiileja ja haisevia yhdisteitä (ketoneja, furaani- ja furfuraalijohdannaisia jne.) jäi metyleenikloridi- ja metanoliloukkuihin.

Differential Regulation of c-FLIP Isoforms Through Post-translational Modifications

Cells are constantly responding to signals from the surrounding tissues and the environment. To dispose of infected and potentially dangerous cells, to ensure the optimal execution of developmental processes and to maintain tissue homeostasis, a multicellular organism needs to tightly control both the number and the quality of its cells. Apoptosis is a form of active cellular self-destruction that enables an organism to regulate its cell number by deleting damaged or potentially dangerous cells. Apoptosis can be induced by death ligands, which bind to death receptors on the cell surface. Ligation of the receptors leads to the formation of an intracellular death inducing signaling complex (DISC). One of the DISC components is caspase-8, a protease that triggers the caspase cascade and is thereby a key initiator of programmed cell death. The activation of caspase-8 is controlled by the cellular FLICE-inhibitory proteins (c-FLIPs). Consequently, sensitivity towards receptor-mediated apoptosis is determined by the amount of c-FLIP, and the c-FLIP levels are actively regulated for example during erythroid differentiation of K562 erythroleukemia cells and by hyperthermia in Jurkat leukemia cells. The aim of my thesis was to investigate how c-FLIP is regulated during these processes. We found that c-FLIP isoforms are short-lived proteins, although c-FLIPS had an even shorter half-life than c-FLIPL. In both experimental models, increased death receptor sensitivity correlated with induced ubiquitylation and consequent proteasomal degradation of c-FLIP. Furthermore, we elucidated how phosphorylation regulates the biological functions and the turnover of c-FLIP, thereby contributing to death receptor sensitivity. We mapped the first phosphorylation sites on c-FLIP and dissected how their phosphorylation affects c-FLIP. Moreover, we demonstrated that phosphorylation of serine 193, a phosphorylated residue common to all c-FLIPs, is primarily mediated by the classical PKC. Furthermore, we discovered a novel connection between the phosphorylation and ubiquitylation of c-FLIP: phosphorylation of S193 protects c-FLIP from ubiquitylation. Surprisingly, although all c-FLIP isoforms are phosphorylated on this conserved residue, the biological outcome is different for the long and short isoforms, since S193 specifically prolongs the half-lives of the short c-FLIP isoforms, but not c-FLIPL. To summarize, we show that c-FLIP proteins are modified by ubiquitylation and phosphorylation, and that the biological outcomes of these modifications are isoform-specifically determined.

Evolution of Bioaffinity Reagents by Phage Display

Antibodies are natural binding proteins produced in vertebrates as a response to invading pathogens and foreign substances. Because of their capability for tight and specific binding, antibodies have found use as binding reagents in research and diagnostics. Properties of cloned recombinant antibodies can be further improved by means of in vitro evolution, combining mutagenesis with subsequent phage display selection. It is also possible to isolate entirely new antibodies from vast naïve or synthetic antibody libraries by phage display. In this study, library techniques and phage display selection were applied in order to optimise binding scaffolds and antigen recognition of antibodies, and to evolve new and improved bioaffinity reagents. Antibody libraries were generated by random and targeted mutagenesis. Expression and stability were mainly optimised by the random methods whereas targeted randomisation of the binding site residues was used for optimising the binding properties. Trinucleotide mutagenesis allowed design of defined randomisation patterns for a synthetic antibody library. Improved clones were selected by phage display. Capture by a specific anti- DHPS antibody was exploited in the selection of improved phage display of DHPS. Efficient selection for stability was established by combining phage display selection with denaturation under reducing conditions. Broad-specific binding of a generic anti-sulfonamide antibody was improved by selection with one of the weakest binding sulfonamides. In addition, p9 based phage display was studied in affinity selection from the synthetic library. A TIM barrel protein DHPS was engineered for efficient phage display by combining cysteinereplacement with random mutagenesis. The resulting clone allows use of phage display in further engineering of DHPS and possibly use as an alternative-binding scaffold. An anti-TSH scFv fragment, cloned from a monoclonal antibody, was engineered for improved stability to better suite an immunoassay. The improved scFv tolerates 8 – 9 °C higher temperature than the parental scFv and should have sufficient stability to be used in an immunoanalyser with incubation at 36 °C. The anti-TSH scFv fragment was compared with the corresponding Fab fragment and the parental monoclonal antibody as a capturing reagent in a rapid 5-min immunoassay for TSH. The scFv fragment provided some benefits over the conventionally used Mab in anayte-binding capacity and assay kinetics. However, the recombinant Fab fragment, which had similar kinetics to the scFv, provided a more sensitive and reliable assay than the scFv. Another cloned scFv fragment was engineered in order to improve broad-specific recognition of sulfonamides. The improved antibody detects different sulfonamides at concentrations below the maximum residue limit (100 μg/kg in EU and USA) and allows simultaneous screening of different sulfonamide drug residues. Finally, a synthetic antibody library was constructed and new antibodies were generated and affinity matured entirely in vitro. These results illuminate the possibilities of phage display and antibody engineering for generation and optimisation of binding reagents in vitro and indicate the potential of recombinant antibodies as affinity reagents in immunoassays.

Characterisation of Human Neutral and Lysosomal alpha-Mannosidases

Neutral alpha-mannosidase and lysosomal MAN2B1 alpha-mannosidase belong to glycoside hydrolase family 38, which contains essential enzymes required for the modification and catabolism of asparagine-linked glycans on proteins. MAN2B1 catalyses lysosomal glycan degradation, while neutral α-mannosidase is most likely involved in the catabolism of cytosolic free oligosaccharides. These mannose containing saccharides are generated during glycosylation or released from misfolded glycoproteins, which are detected by quality control in the endoplasmic reticulum. To characterise the biological function of human neutral α-mannosidase, I cloned the alpha-mannosidase cDNA and recombinantly expressed the enzyme. The purified enzyme trimmed the putative natural substrate Man9GlcNAc to Man5GlcNAc, whereas the reducing end GlcNAc2 limited trimming to Man8GlcNAc2. Neutral α-mannosidase showed highest enzyme activity at neutral pH and was activated by the cations Fe₂+, Co2+ and Mn₂+, Cu2+ in turn had a strong inhibitory effect on alpha-mannosidase activity. Analysis of its intracellular localisation revealed that neutral alpha-mannosidase is cytosolic and colocalises with proteasomes. Further work showed that the overexpression of neutral alpha-mannosidase affected the cytosolic free oligosaccharide content and led to enhanced endoplasmic reticulum associated degradation and underglycosylation of secreted proteins. The second part of the study focused on MAN2B1 and the inherited lysosomal storage disorder α-mannosidosis. In this disorder, deficient MAN2B1 activity is associated with mutations in the MAN2B1 gene. The thesis reports the molecular consequences of 35 alpha-mannosidosis associated mutations, including 29 novel missense mutations. According to experimental analyses, the mutations fall into four groups: Mutations, which prevent transport to lysosomes are accompanied with a lack of proteolytic processing of the enzyme (groups 1 and 3). Although the rest of the mutations (groups 2 and 4) allow transport to lysosomes, the mutated proteins are less efficiently processed to their mature form than is wild type MAN2B1. Analysis of the effect of the mutations on the model structure of human lysosomal alpha-mannosidase provides insights on their structural consequences. Mutations, which affect amino acids important for folding (prolines, glycines, cysteines) or domain interface interactions (arginines), arrest the enzyme in the endoplasmic reticulum. Surface mutations and changes, which do not drastically alter residue volume, are tolerated better. Descriptions of the mutations and clinical data are compiled in an α-mannosidosis database, which will be available for the scientific community. This thesis provides a detailed insight into two ubiquitous human alpha-mannosidases. It demonstrates that neutral alpha-mannosidase is involved in the degradation of cytosolic oligosaccharides and suggests that the regulation of this α-mannosidase is important for maintaining the cellular homeostasis of N-glycosylation and glycan degradation. The study on alpha-mannosidosis associated mutations identifies multiple mechanisms for how these mutations are detrimental for MAN2B1 activity. The α-mannosidosis database will benefit both clinicians and scientific research on lysosomal alpha‑mannosidosis.

Unraveling the functional divergence of membrane-bound pyrophosphatases

Inorganic pyrophosphatases (PPases) are enzymes that hydrolyze pyrophosphate (PPi)which is produced as a byproduct in many important growth related processes e.g. in the biosynthesis of DNA, proteins and lipids. PPases can be either soluble or membranebound. Membrane-bound PPases (mPPases) are ion transporters that couple the energy released during PPi hydrolysis to Na+ or H+ transport. When I started the project, only three Na+-transporting mPPases were known to exist. In this study, I aimed to confirm if Na+-transport is a common function of mPPases. Furthermore, the amino acid residues responsible for determining the transporter specificity were unknown. I constructed a phylogenetic tree for mPPases and selected the representative bacterial and archaeal mPPases to be investigated. I expressed different prokaryotic mPPases in Escherichia coli, isolated these as inverted membrane vesicles and characterized their functions. In the first project I identified four new Na+-PPases, two K+-dependent H+-PPases and one K+-independent mPPase. The residues determining the transporter specificity were identified by site-directed mutagenesis. I showed that the conserved glutamate residues are important for specificity, though are not the only residues that influence it. This research clarified the ion transport specificities throughout the mPPase phylogenetic tree, and revealed that Na+ transport is a widespread function of mPPases. In addition, it became clear that the transporter specificity can be predicted from the amino acid sequence in combination with a phylogenetic analysis. In the second project, I identified a novel class of mPPases, which is capable of transporting both Na+ and H+ ions and is mainly found in bacteria of the human gastrointestinal tract. The physiological role of these novel enzymes may be to help the bacteria survive in the demanding conditions of the host. In the third project, I characterized the Chlorobium limicola Na+-PPase and found that this and related mPPases are able to transport H+ ions at subphysiological Na+ concentrations. In addition, the H+-transport activity was shown to be a common function of all studied Na+-PPases at low Na+ concentrations. I observed that mutating gate-lysine to asparagine eliminated the H+ but not the Na+ ion transport function, indicating the important role of the residue in the transport of H+. In the fourth project, I characterized the unknown and evolutionary divergent mPPase clade of the phylogenetic tree. The enzymes belonging to this clade are able to transport H+ ions and, based on their sequence, were expected to be K+- and Na+-independent. The sequences of membrane-bound PPase are usually highly conserved, but the enzymes belonging to this clade are more divergent and usually contain 100−150 extra amino acid residues compared to other known mPPases. Despite the vast sequence differences, these mPPases have the full set of important residues and, surprisingly, are regulated by Na+ and K+ ions. These enzymes are mainly of bacterial origin.

Effect of Material Recycling on the Feasibility of Solid Recovered Fuel Fired Power Plant

This master’s thesis examines the effects of increased material recycling on different waste-to-energy concepts. With background study and a developed techno-economic computational method the feasibility of chosen scenarios with different combinations of mechanical treatment and waste firing technologies can be evaluated. The background study covers the waste scene of Finland, and potential market areas Poland and France. Calculated cases concentrate on municipal solid waste treatment in the Finnish operational environment. The chosen methodology to approach the objectives is techno-economic feasibility assessment. It combines calculation methods of literature and practical engineering to define the material and energy balances in chosen scenarios. The calculation results together with other operational and financial data can be concluded to net present values compared between the scenarios. For the comparison, four scenarios, most vital and alternative between each other, are established. The baseline scenario is grate firing of source separated mixed municipal solid waste. Second scenario is fluidized bed combustion of solid recovered fuel produced in mechanical treatment process with metal separation. Third scenario combines a biomaterial separation process to the solid recovered fuels preparation and in the last scenario plastics are separated in addition to the previous operations. The results indicated that the mechanical treatment scenarios still need to overcome some problems to become feasible. Problems are related to profitability, residue disposal and technical reliability. Many uncertainties are also related to the data gathered over waste characteristics, technical performance and markets. With legislative support and development of further processing technologies and markets of the recycled materials the scenarios with biomaterial and plastic separation may operate feasibly in the future.

Optimal Recycling Combination of Ash in South-East Finland

The present world energy production is heavily relying on the combustion of solid fuels like coals, peat, biomass, municipal solid waste, whereas the share of renewable fuels is anticipated to increase in the future to mitigate climate change. In Finland, peat and wood are widely used for energy production. In any case, the combustion of solid fuels results in generation of several types of thermal conversion residues, such as bottom ash, fly ash, and boiler slag. The predominant residue type is determined by the incineration technology applied, while its composition is primarily relevant to the composition of fuels combusted. An extensive research has been conducted on technical suitability of ash for multiple recycling methods. Most of attention was drawn to the recycling of the coal combustion residues, as coal is the primary solid fuel consumed globally. The recycling methods of coal residues include utilization in a cement industry, in concrete manufacturing, and mine backfilling, to name few. Biomass combustion residues were also studied to some extent with forest fertilization, road construction, and road stabilization being the predominant utilization options. Lastly, residues form municipal solid waste incineration attracted more attention recently following the growing number of waste incineration plants globally. The recycling methods of waste incineration residues are the most limited due to its hazardous nature and varying composition, and include, among others, landfill construction, road construction, mine backfilling. In the study, environmental and economic aspects of multiple recycling options of thermal conversion residues generated within a case-study area were studied. The case-study area was South-East Finland. The environmental analysis was performed using an internationally recognized methodology — life cycle assessment. Economic assessment was conducted applying a widely used methodology — cost-benefit analysis. Finally, the results of the analyses were combined to enable easier comparison of the recycling methods. The recycling methods included the use of ash in forest fertilization, road construction, road stabilization, and landfill construction. Ash landfilling was set as a baseline scenario. Quantitative data about the amounts of ash generated and its composition was obtained from companies, their environmental reports, technical reports and other previously published literature. Overall, the amount of ash in the case-study area was 101 700 t. However, the data about 58 400 t of fly ash and 35 100 t of bottom ash and boiler slag were included in the study due to lack of data about leaching of heavy metals in some cases. The recycling methods were modelled according to the scientific studies published previously. Overall, the results of the study indicated that ash utilization for fertilization and neutralization of 17 600 ha of forest was the most economically beneficial method, which resulted in the net present value increase by 58% compared to ash landfilling. Regarding the environmental impact, the use of ash in the construction of 11 km of roads was the most attractive method with decreased environmental impact of 13% compared to ash landfilling. The least preferred method was the use of ash for landfill construction since it only enabled 11% increase of net present value, while inducing additional 1% of negative impact on the environment. Therefore, a following recycling route was proposed in the study. Where possible and legally acceptable, recycle fly and bottom ash for forest fertilization, which has strictest requirements out of all studied methods. If the quality of fly ash is not suitable for forest fertilization, then it should be utilized, first, in paved road construction, second, in road stabilization. Bottom ash not suitable for forest fertilization, as well as boiler slag, should be used in landfill construction. Landfilling should only be practiced when recycling by either of the methods is not possible due to legal requirements or there is not enough demand on the market. Current demand on ash and possible changes in the future were assessed in the study. Currently, the area of forest fertilized in the case-study are is only 451 ha, whereas about 17 600 ha of forest could be fertilized with ash generated in the region. Provided that the average forest fertilizing values in Finland are higher and the area treated with fellings is about 40 000 ha, the amount of ash utilized in forest fertilization could be increased. Regarding road construction, no new projects launched by the Center of Economic Development, Transport and the Environment in the case-study area were identified. A potential application can be found in the construction of private roads. However, no centralized data about such projects is available. The use of ash in stabilization of forest roads is not expected to increased in the future with a current downwards trend in the length of forest roads built. Finally, the use of ash in landfill construction is not a promising option due to the reducing number of landfills in operation in Finland.