3 kW:n mikrokaasuturbiinin periaatesuunnittelu

Tässä työssä esitellään ensiksi yleisesti kaasuturbiini, sen toimintaperiaate ja sovelluskohteet. Lisäksi kaasuturbiinin yleinen suunnittelu käydään läpi mitoituksen kannalta. Mikrokaasuturbiini on kaasuturbiini pienemmässä mittakaavassa. Pienen kokonsa vuoksi mikrokaasuturbiinien suunnittelussa täytyy huomioida eri asioita kuin suurempien kaasuturbiinien suunnittelussa. Tämän työn tarkoituksena on selvittää mikrokaasuturbiinin periaatteellinen suunnittelu ja tarkastella, mitä eroa on mikrokaasuturbiinin ja kaasuturbiinin välisessä suunnittelussa. Lisäksi työssä esitellään mahdollisia sovelluskohteita 3 kilowatin mikrokaasuturbiinille. Mikrokaasuturbiineja tultaneen käyttämään tulevaisuudessa hajautetun energian tuotannossa kasvavissa määrin. Mikrokaasuturbiini voidaan helposti muokata käyttötarpeen mukaiseksi, mikä tekee mikrokaasuturbiinista vahvan kilpailijan perinteisten pienen teholuokan mäntäkoneiden rinnalle. Lopuksi työhön on laskettu suunnitteluesimerkki 3 kilowatin mikrokaasuturbiinille. Suunnitteluun on valittu lähtöarvot kirjallisuudessa tavallisesti esiintyvien arvojen mukaan.

Design of a 1 kW 150 rpm permanent-magnet synchronous generator for stand-alone wind-power applications

A program for calculating low-speed low-power synchronous machine is presented. A permanent-magnet synchronous generator for 1 kW 150 rpm is designed. Optimization of magnet’s and coil’s dimensions was made.

Performance Characteristics of an Axial-Flux Solid-Rotor-Core Induction Motor

The integration of electric motors and industrial appliances such as pumps, fans, and compressors is rapidly increasing. For instance, the integration of an electric motor and a centrifugal pump provides cost savings and improved performance characteristics. Material cost savings are achieved when an electric motor is integrated into the shaft of a centrifugal pump, and the motor utilizes the bearings of the pump. This arrangement leads to a smaller configuration that occupies less floor space. The performance characteristics of a pump drive can be improved by using the variable-speed technology. This enables the full speed control of the drive and the absence of a mechanical gearbox and couplers. When using rotational speeds higher than those that can be directly achieved by the network frequency the structure of the rotor has to be mechanically durable. In this thesis the performance characteristics of an axial-flux solid-rotor-core induction motor are determined. The motor studied is a one-rotor-one-stator axial-flux induction motor, and thus, there is only one air-gap between the rotor and the stator. The motor was designed for higher rotational speeds, and therefore a good mechanical strength of the solid-rotor-core rotor is required to withstand the mechanical stresses. The construction of the rotor and the high rotational speeds together produce a feature, which is not typical of traditional induction motors: the dominating loss component of the motor is the rotor eddy current loss. In the case of a typical industrial induction motor instead the dominating loss component is the stator copper loss. In this thesis, several methods to decrease the rotor eddy current losses in the case of axial-flux induction motors are presented. A prototype motor with 45 kW output power at 6000 min-1 was designed and constructed for ascertaining the results obtained from the numerical FEM calculations. In general, this thesis concentrates on the methods for improving the electromagnetic properties of an axial-flux solid-rotor-core induction motor and examines the methods for decreasing the harmonic eddy currents of the rotor. The target is to improve the efficiency of the motor and to reach the efficiency standard of the present-day industrial induction motors equipped with laminated rotors.

On the Condition Monitoring of Induction machines

The research of condition monitoring of electric motors has been wide for several decades. The research and development at universities and in industry has provided means for the predictive condition monitoring. Many different devices and systems are developed and are widely used in industry, transportation and in civil engineering. In addition, many methods are developed and reported in scientific arenas in order to improve existing methods for the automatic analysis of faults. The methods, however, are not widely used as a part of condition monitoring systems. The main reasons are, firstly, that many methods are presented in scientific papers but their performance in different conditions is not evaluated, secondly, the methods include parameters that are so case specific that the implementation of a systemusing such methods would be far from straightforward. In this thesis, some of these methods are evaluated theoretically and tested with simulations and with a drive in a laboratory. A new automatic analysis method for the bearing fault detection is introduced. In the first part of this work the generation of the bearing fault originating signal is explained and its influence into the stator current is concerned with qualitative and quantitative estimation. The verification of the feasibility of the stator current measurement as a bearing fault indicatoris experimentally tested with the running 15 kW induction motor. The second part of this work concentrates on the bearing fault analysis using the vibration measurement signal. The performance of the micromachined silicon accelerometer chip in conjunction with the envelope spectrum analysis of the cyclic bearing faultis experimentally tested. Furthermore, different methods for the creation of feature extractors for the bearing fault classification are researched and an automatic fault classifier using multivariate statistical discrimination and fuzzy logic is introduced. It is often important that the on-line condition monitoring system is integrated with the industrial communications infrastructure. Two types of a sensor solutions are tested in the thesis: the first one is a sensor withcalculation capacity for example for the production of the envelope spectra; the other one can collect the measurement data in memory and another device can read the data via field bus. The data communications requirements highly depend onthe type of the sensor solution selected. If the data is already analysed in the sensor the data communications are needed only for the results but in the other case, all measurement data need to be transferred. The complexity of the classification method can be great if the data is analysed at the management level computer, but if the analysis is made in sensor itself, the analyses must be simple due to the restricted calculation and memory capacity.

Nosturin tehonsyöttö rinnankytketyillä verkkovaihtosuuntaajilla

Taajuusmuuttajaohjatuissa nosturikäytöissä taakkaa laskettaessa syntyvä energia on muutettava lämmöksi jarruvastuksissa tai syötettävä takaisin sähköverkkoon esimerkiksi verkkovaihtosuuntaajalla. Verkkovaihtosuuntaajaa on tyypillisesti käytetty suurissa satamanostureissa, joiden tehontarve on yli 1000 kW. Työssä tutkitaan useista yhteiseen välipiiriin rinnankytketyistä nimellisteholtaan 250 kW:n verkkovaihtosuuntaajista koostuvan verkkoonjarrutuslaitteiston soveltuvuutta nosturikäyttöön. Lisäksi johdetaan yhtälöt verkkoonjarrutuslaitteiston virran laskemiseksi, kun nosturin mekaaniset arvot tunnetaan. Viidestä erityyppisestä nosturista esitellään esimerkkitoteutus rinnankytketyillä verkkovaihtosuuntaajilla. Aiemmin vastusjarruttavina toteutettujen nostureiden kustannuksia verrataan verkkovaihtosuuntaajilla toteutettuihin ratkaisuihin. Esimerkkinostureista esitetään nosturin työsykliin perustuva arvio verkkoonjarrutuksen tuomasta energian säästöstä. Tehtyjen mittausten perusteella käytetty menetelmä verkkovaihtosuuntaajien rinnan kytkemiseksi osoittautui nosturikäytössä toimivaksi. Kustannuslaskelmien perusteella verkkovaihtosuuntaajalla toteutetusta nosturista tulee materiaalikustannuksiltaan vastusjarruttavaa kalliimpi, vaikka paljon tilaa vievät vastuskaapit voidaankin jättää pois.

Nd:YAG Laser Welding of 5083 Aluminium Alloy using Filler Wire

High reflectivity and high thermal conductivity, high vapour pressure of alloyingelements as well as low liquid surface tension and low ionisation potential, make laser welding of aluminium and its alloys a demanding task.Problems that occur during welding are mainly process instabilities of the keyhole and the melt pool, increased plasma formation above the melt pool and loss of alloying elements. These problems lead to unwanted metallurgical defects like hot cracks and porosity in the weld bead andother problems concerning the shape and appearance of the weld bead. In order to minimise the defects and improve the weld quality, the process and beam parameters need to be carefully adjusted along with a consideration concerning the use of filler wire for the welding process. In this work the welding of 3,0 mm thick grade 5083 aluminium alloy plates using a 3,0 kW Nd:YAG laser with grade 5183 filler wire addition is investigated. The plates were welded as butt joints with air gap sizes 0,5 mm, 0,7mm and 1,0 mm. The analysis of the weld beads obtained from the weldedsamples showed that the least imperfections were produced with 0,7 mm air gaps at moderate welding speeds. The analysis also covered the calculation of the melting efficiency and the study of the shape of the weld bead. The melting efficiency was on average around 20 % for the melting process of the welded plates. The weld beads showed the characteristic V-shape of a laser weld and retained this shape during the whole series of experiments.

Plasmapolttoprosessin kehittäminen ja optimointi

Ydinvoimaloidenprimaarivesikierron puhdistukseen käytetään ioninvaihtohartsia. Käytönjälkeen ioninvaihtohartsi luokitellaan matalaja keskiaktiivisiin jätteisiin. Plasmakäsittelyllä käytetyn ioninvaihtohartsin tilavuutta voidaan pienentää sekä sen orgaaninen luonne poistaa. Plasmakäsittelyn tarkoituksena on hapettaa orgaaninen aines oksideiksi, jotka poistuvat prosessista savukaasuina. Epäorgaaninen aines, joka sisältää radioaktiivisen aineksen, on tarkoitus hapettaa oksideiksi ja sulfideiksi, jotka voidaan kerätä talteen tuhkana. Tässä diplomityössä käsitellään käytetyn ioninvaihtohartsin käsittelyyn suunnitellun plasmapolttoprosessin kehittämistä ja optimointia. Ioninvaihtohartsin plasmakäsittelyssä syntyvien reaktiotuotteiden selvittäminen suoritettiin tarkastelemalla ainetaseita sekä aihetta käsitteleviä tutkimuksia. Näiden perusteella parannettiin jäähdytystä, suunniteltiin jatkuvatoiminen syöttömenetelmä sekä laadittiin toimintaalueen reunaehdot laitteistolle. Koelaitteistossa 6,5 kW:n rfteho syötetään sovitinpiirin ja kuparisen induktiokelan kautta plasmaan. Plasmakaasuna on käytetty hapenja argonin seoskaasua. Plasmapolttoa on seurattu massaspektrometrilla, optisella emissiospektrometrilla, lämpösekä painemittareilla. Laskennan ja kokeiden pohjalta selvitettiin optimaalinen seossuhde plasmakaasulle, paineen ja tehon noston vaikutus hartsin polttonopeuteen sekä jatkuvatoimisen syöttömenetelmän edut panostoimiseen syöttöön. Rfgeneraattorin teho rajoitti jatkuvatoimisen polttonopeuden 130 g/h ja hetkellisen polttonopeuden 175 g/h. Radioaktiivisten aineiden pidätys oli 93,5 % cesiumin osalta. Tulosten perusteella 4 kg/h ioninvaihtohartsia polttavan laitteiston tehon lähteeksi tarvitaan 65 kW rfgeneraattori. Palamattoman hartsin ja tuhkan kulkeutuminen partikkelisuodattimille sekä reaktiotuotteena syntyvien rikinoksidien käsittely vaatii vielä jatkotutkimusta.

Ohutlevyn diodilaserhitsaus

Diplomityössä tutkitaan, miten diodilaserhitsauksen ominaisuuksia ja mahdollisuuksia voidaan hyödyntää teollisuuden käytännön sovellutuksissa. Työn alkuosassa esitelläändiodilaserin toimintaperiaatetta ja säteen muodostumista. Lisäksi työssä on esitetty laserin käyttöön liittyviä turvallisuusseikkoja. Hitsaukseen liittyviä teknisiä seikkoja on myös käyty läpi. Työn kokeellisessa osassa tutkitaan kylmävalssatun ja ruostumattoman teräksen hitsattavuutta eri liitosmuodoissa kuten päittäis-, laippa- ja päällekkäisliitoksissa. Hitsauskokeet suoritettiin eri paksuisille levyille. Tavoitteena oli löytää eri levymateriaaleille ja liitosmuodoille oikeat nopeus- ja tehoparametrit. Diodilaserkokeet suoritettiin käyttäen Hämeen ammattikorkeakoulun Riihimäen yksikön 2 kW:n tehoista diodilaserlaitteistoa. Koekappaleet olivat 100 x 200 mm kokoisia. Osalle hitsatuista kappaleista tehtiin vetokokeita ja mikrokovuuskokeita. Hitseille tehtiin silmämääräinen tarkastus ja lisäksi tutkittiin hitsejä mikroskooppikuvauksella. Koekappaleita hitsaamalla selvitettiin teho- ja nopeusparametrit. Hitsattaessa kylmävalssattuja levyjä muodostui hitsausvirheitä T- ja päittäisliitoksissa. Hitsausvirheet huomattiin, kun suoritettiin vetokokeita ja tehtiin hietä. Mutta yleensä kylmävalssattujen levyjen hitsaus onnistui moitteettomasti. Kun hitsaukset suoritettiin käyttämällä ruostumatonta terästä, hitsausvirheitä ei muodostunut, kuten kylmävalssattuihin levyihin. Ruostumattomien terästen hitsaus onnistui moitteettomasti. Tunkeuma molemmissa levytyypeissä oli hyvä. Todettiin, että levyt hitsautuivat yhteen hitsauksen alussa moitteettomasti, mutta loppuosa ei hitsautunut kunnolla, koska lämpötilanmuutos muokkasi levyjen muotoja.

ORC-voimalan soveltuvuus hyödyntämään dieselvoimalan hukkalämpöä, Tekes DrNo 1549/401/98. Loppuraportti

Tässä loppuraportissa esitetään projektin "Kannattavuusanalyysi ORC-voimalan soveltamisesta hyödyntämään dieselvoimalan hukkalämpöä, Tekes DrNo 1549/401/98" tulokset. ORC-prosessilla (Organic Rankine Cycle) tarkoitetaan Rankine-prosessia, jossakiertoaineena veden asemesta on sopiva orgaaninen neste, esimerkiksi tolueeni. ORC-prosessi soveltuu hyvin nimenomaan matalalla lämpötilatasolla vapautuvan hukkalämmön hyödyntämiseen. Tutkimus liittyy vuonna 1981 aloitettuun suurnopeustekniikan tutkimushankkeeseen. Tutkimuksen lähtökohtana oli tropiikin olosuhteissa peruskuormaa ajava raskasöljykäyttöinen Wärtsilä NSD 18V46 voimalaitosmoottori, jonka hukkalämmöistä tuli kyetä tuottamaan sähköä mahdollisimman alhaisilla investointikustannuksilla. Kaukolämmöntuotanto rajattiin tämän selvityksen ulkopuolelle. Edullisimmaksi perustapaukseksi valittiin seitsemän turbogeneraattorin ORC-laitos, joka hyödyntää ainoastaan moottorin pakokaasulämpöä. Kyseisen ORC-laitoksen nettosähköteho on 1142 kW, joten se lisäisi dieselmoottorin tehoa 6,8 %. ORC-laitoksen myyntihinta olisi noin 7,67 Mmk, mikäli lauhdutin voidaan rakentaa ruostumattomasta teräksestä ja noin 9,01 Mmk, mikäli olisi käytettävä titaanilauhdutinta. ORC-laitoksen ominaisinvestointikustannus olisi siten noin 6700 mk/kW - 7900 mk/kW materiaalivalinnoista riippuen. Mainittu hinta sisältää sekä komponenttien valmistajien että systeemi-integraattorin katteet. Koska höyrystimen hinta vaikuttaa olennaisesti ORC-laitoksen hintaan, voidaan puhtailla maakaasupolton savukaasuilla arvioida ominaisinvestoinnin olevan noin 1000 mk/kW alhaisempi. Olettaen 6000 h/a huipun käyttöaika saadaan ORC:llä tuotetun sähkön hinnaksi noin 0,11 mk/kWh. Suomeen rakennettavalle ORC-laitokselle on todennäköisesti lisäksi saatavissa 30 % investointituki ja sähköveron palautus. - Teoriassa voidaan osoittaa, että dieselmoottorin tehoa voidaan ORC:llä lisätä jopa 18 %, mutta ominaisinvestointi on tällöin merkittävästi korkeampi. ORC-laitoksen turbiinin 1D suunnittelua tarkennettiin sekä laitoksen turbiini mallinnettiin CFD-laskennan (numeerisen virtauslaskennan) avulla osana tätä tutkimusta. Näin kyettiin nostamaan turbiinin hyötysuhdetta, ja CFD-laskennan perusteella voidaan nyt aikaisempaa varmemmin ennustaa turbiinin todellinen hyötysuhde. ORC-laitoksen dynaaminen simulointiohjelma saatiin niin ikään valmiiksi tämän projektin puitteissa. Simulointiohjelman avulla voitiin asettaa laitoksen säädinparametrit sekä simuloida voimalan käynnistys-, ajo- sekä häiriötilanteita. Tehtyjen simulointien perusteella tehtiin johtopäätökset laitoksen säätöjärjestelmän toimivuudesta ja tuorehöyryn tilaarvojen valinnasta.

Electromagnetic Design of a Solid Steel Rotor Motor for Demanding Operation Environments

The solid-rotor induction motor provides a mechanically and thermally reliable solution for demanding environments where other rotor solutions are prohibited or questionable. Solid rotors, which are manufactured of single pieces of ferromagnetic material, are commonly used in motors in which the rotationspeeds exceed substantially the conventional speeds of laminated rotors with squirrel-cage. During the operation of a solid-rotor electrical machine, the rotor core forms a conductor for both the magnetic flux and the electrical current. This causes an increase in the rotor resistance and rotor leakage inductance, which essentially decreases the power factor and the efficiency of the machine. The electromagnetic problems related to the solid-rotor induction motor are mostly associated with the low performance of the rotor. Therefore, the main emphasis in this thesis is put on the solid steel rotor designs. The rotor designs studied in thisthesis are based on the fact that the rotor construction should be extremely robust and reliable to withstand the high mechanical stresses caused by the rotational velocity of the rotor. In addition, the demanding operation environment sets requirements for the applied materials because of the high temperatures and oxidizing acids, which may be present in the cooling fluid. Therefore, the solid rotors analyzed in this thesis are made of a single piece of ferromagnetic material without any additional parts, such as copper end-rings or a squirrel-cage. A pure solid rotor construction is rigid and able to keep its balance over a large speed range. It also may tolerate other environmental stresses such as corroding substances or abrasive particles. In this thesis, the main target is to improve the performance of an induction motor equipped with a solid steel rotor by traditional methods: by axial slitting of the rotor, by selecting a proper rotor core material and by coating the rotor with a high-resistive stainless ferromagnetic material. In the solid steel rotor calculation, the rotor end-effects have a significant effect on the rotor characteristics. Thus, the emphasis is also put on the comparison of different rotor endfactors. In addition, a corrective slip-dependent end-factor is proposed. The rotor designs covered in this thesis are the smooth solid rotor, the axially slitted solid rotor and the slitted rotor having a uniform ferromagnetic coating cylinder. The thesis aims at design rules for multi-megawatt machines. Typically, mega-watt-size solidrotor machines find their applications mainly in the field of electric-motor-gas-compression systems, in steam-turbine applications, and in various types of largepower pump applications, where high operational speeds are required. In this thesis, a 120 kW, 10 000 rpm solid-rotor induction motor is usedas a small-scale model for such megawatt-range solid-rotor machines. The performance of the 120 kW solid-rotor induction motors is determined by experimental measurements and finite element calculations.

Fractional slot permanent magnet synchronous motors for low speed applications

This study compares different rotor structures of permanent magnet motors with fractional slot windings. The surface mounted magnet and the embedded magnet rotor structures are studied. This thesis analyses the characteristics of a concentrated two-layer winding, each coil of which is wound around one tooth and which has a number of slots per pole and per phase less than one (q < 1). Compared to the integer slot winding, the fractional winding (q < 1) has shorter end windings and this, thereby, makes space as well as manufacturing cost saving possible. Several possible ways of winding a fractional slot machine with slots per pole and per phase lessthan one are examined. The winding factor and the winding harmonic components are calculated. The benefits attainable from a machine with concentrated windingsare considered. Rotor structures with surface magnets, radially embedded magnets and embedded magnets in V-position are discussed. The finite element method isused to solve the main values of the motors. The waveform of the induced electro motive force, the no-load and rated load torque ripple as well as the dynamic behavior of the current driven and voltage driven motor are solved. The results obtained from different finite element analyses are given. A simple analytic method to calculate fractional slot machines is introduced and the values are compared to the values obtained with the finite element analysis. Several different fractional slot machines are first designed by using the simple analytical methodand then computed by using the finite element method. All the motors are of thesame 225-frame size, and have an approximately same amount of magnet material, a same rated torque demand and a 400 - 420 rpm speed. An analysis of the computation results gives new information on the character of fractional slot machines.A fractional slot prototype machine with number 0.4 for the slots per pole and per phase, 45 kW output power and 420 rpm speed is constructed to verify the calculations. The measurement and the finite element method results are found to beequal.

Permanent magnet synchronous motor for industrial inverter applications - analysis and design

During the latest few years the need for new motor types has grown, since both high efficiency and an accurate dynamic performance are demanded in industrial applications. For this reason, new effective control systems such as direct torque control (DTC) have been developed. Permanent magnet synchronous motors (PMSM) are well suitable for new adjustable speed AC inverter drives, because their efficiency and power factor are not depending on the pole pair number and speed to the same extent as it is the case in induction motors. Therefore, an induction motor (IM) with a mechanical gearbox can often be replaced with a direct PM motor drive. Space as well as costs will be saved, because the efficiency increases and the cost of maintenance decreases as well. This thesis deals with design criterion, analytical calculation and analysis of the permanent magnet synchronous motor for both sinusoidal air-gap flux density and rectangular air-gapflux density. It is examined how the air-gap flux, flux densities, inductances and torque can be estimated analytically for salient pole and non-salient pole motors. It has been sought by means of analytical calculations for the ultimate construction for machines rotating at relative low 300 rpm to 600 rpm speeds, which are suitable speeds e.g. in Pulp&Paper industry. The calculations are verified by using Finite Element calculations and by measuring of prototype motor. The prototype motor is a 45 kW, 600 rpm PMSM with buried V-magnets, which is a very appropriate construction for high torque motors with a high performance. With the purposebuilt prototype machine it is possible not only to verify the analytical calculations but also to show whether the 600 rpm PMSM can replace the 1500 rpm IM with a gear. It can also be tested if the outer dimensions of the PMSM may be the same as for the IM and if the PMSM in this case can produce a 2.5 fold torque, in consequence of which it may be possible to achieve the same power. The thesis also considers the question how to design a permanent magnet synchronous motor for relatively low speed applications that require a high motor torqueand efficiency as well as bearable costs of permanent magnet materials. It is shown how a selection of different parameters affects the motor properties. Key words: Permanent magnet synchronous motor, PMSM, surface magnets, buried magnets

Applicability of Power-Line Communications to Data Transfer of On-line Condition Monitoring of Electrical Drives

The research of power-line communications has been concentrated on home automation, broadband indoor communications and broadband data transfer in a low voltage distribution network between home andtransformer station. There has not been carried out much research work that is focused on the high frequency characteristics of industrial low voltage distribution networks. The industrial low voltage distribution network may be utilised as a communication channel to data transfer required by the on-line condition monitoring of electric motors. The advantage of using power-line data transfer is that it does not require the installing of new cables. In the first part of this work, the characteristics of industrial low voltage distribution network components and the pilot distribution network are measured and modelled with respect topower-line communications frequencies up to 30 MHz. The distributed inductances, capacitances and attenuation of MCMK type low voltage power cables are measured in the frequency band 100 kHz - 30 MHz and an attenuation formula for the cables is formed based on the measurements. The input impedances of electric motors (15-250 kW) are measured using several signal couplings and measurement based input impedance model for electric motor with a slotted stator is formed. The model is designed for the frequency band 10 kHz - 30 MHz. Next, the effect of DC (direct current) voltage link inverter on power line data transfer is briefly analysed. Finally, a pilot distribution network is formed and signal attenuation in communication channels in the pilot environment is measured. The results are compared with the simulations that are carried out utilising the developed models and measured parameters for cables and motors. In the second part of this work, a narrowband power-line data transfer system is developed for the data transfer ofon-line condition monitoring of electric motors. It is developed using standardintegrated circuits. The system is tested in the pilot environment and the applicability of the system for the data transfer required by the on-line condition monitoring of electric motors is analysed.

Design of axial-flux permanent-magnet low-speed machines and performance comparison between radial-flux and axial-flux machines

This thesis presents an alternative approach to the analytical design of surface-mounted axialflux permanent-magnet machines. Emphasis has been placed on the design of axial-flux machines with a one-rotor-two-stators configuration. The design model developed in this study incorporates facilities to include both the electromagnetic design and thermal design of the machine as well as to take into consideration the complexity of the permanent-magnet shapes, which is a typical requirement for the design of high-performance permanent-magnet motors. A prototype machine with rated 5 kW output power at 300 min-1 rotation speed has been designed and constructed for the purposesof ascertaining the results obtained from the analytical design model. A comparative study of low-speed axial-flux and low-speed radial-flux permanent-magnet machines is presented. The comparative study concentrates on 55 kW machines with rotation speeds 150 min-1, 300 min-1 and 600 min-1 and is based on calculated designs. A novel comparison method is introduced. The method takes into account the mechanical constraints of the machine and enables comparison of the designed machines, with respect to the volume, efficiency and cost aspects of each machine. It is shown that an axial-flux permanent-magnet machine with one-rotor-two-stators configuration has generally a weaker efficiency than a radial-flux permanent-magnet machine if for all designs the same electric loading, air-gap flux density and current density have been applied. On the other hand, axial-flux machines are usually smaller in volume, especially when compared to radial-flux machines for which the length ratio (axial length of stator stack vs. air-gap diameter)is below 0.5. The comparison results show also that radial-flux machines with alow number of pole pairs, p < 4, outperform the corresponding axial-flux machines.