Simulation of hydrogen peroxide direct synthesis in a microreactor

A set of models in Aspen plus was built to simulate the direct synthesis process of hydrogen peroxide in a micro-reactor system. This process model can be used to carry out material balance calculation under various experimental conditions. Three thermodynamic property methods were compared by calculating gas solubility and Uniquac-RK method was finally selected for process model. Two different operation modes with corresponding operation conditions were proposed as the starting point of future experiments. Simulations for these two modes were carried out to get the information of material streams. Moreover, some hydrodynamic parameters such as gas/liquid superficial velocity, gas holdup were also calculated with improved process model. These parameters proved the proposed experimental conditions reasonable to some extent. The influence of operation conditions including temperature, pressure and circulation ratio was analyzed for the first operation mode, where pure oxygen was fed into dissolving tank and hydrogen-carbon dioxide mixture was fed into microreactor directly. The preferred operation conditions for the system are low temperature (2°C) and high pressure (30 bar) in dissolving tank. High circulation ratio might be good in the sense that more oxygen could be dissolved and fed into reactor for reactions, but meanwhile hydrodynamics of microreactor should be considered. Furthermore, more operation conditions of reactor gas/liquid feeds in both of two operation modes were proposed to provide guidance for future experiment design and corresponding hydrodynamic parameters were also calculated. Finally, safety issue was considered from thermodynamic point of view and there is no explosion danger at given experimental plan since the released reaction heat will not cause solvent vaporization inside the microchannels. The improvement of process model still needs further study based on the future experimental results.

Safety study of hydrogen peroxide direct synthesis

Kandidaatintyön johdantokappaleessa esitellään vetyperoksidi ja mihin sitä käytetään teollisuudessa. Työssä vertaillaan antrakinoniprosessia ja suoraa prosessia sekä selvitetään nykyisin enemmän vetyperoksidituotantoon käytetyn antrakinoniprosessin ongelmakohdat ja osoitetaan, miksi suora synteesi vetyperoksidin tuotannossa olisi parempi vaihtoehto. Kandidaatintyön käsittelee suurilta osin turvallisuusongelmia, joita esiintyy suoran synteesin yhteydessä. Kirjallisuudesta on etsitty ratkaisuja näihin ongelmiin, kuten membraaniprosessin käyttöä räjähdysvaaran välttämiseksi. Pienemmän reaktorin eli ns. mikroreaktorin käyttö tuo mukanaan monia etuja vetyperoksidin tuotantoon. Tällöin prosessi on turvallisempi ja sitä on helpompi hallita. Mikroreaktorissa voidaan käyttää korkeampia lämpötiloja ja paineita kuin makroreaktorilla ilman, että räjähdysvaara prosessissa kasvaisi. Mikroreaktorin sisällä olevat mikrokanavat luovat turvallisen ympäristön synteesille. Aspen plus – simulointiohjelmalla mallinnettiin ja simulointiin suoran prosessin kriittisiä virtoja mikroreaktorissa. Tarkoituksena oli löytää virrat, joissa kulkee mahdollisesti räjähtävä kaasuseos. Kaasumaiset prosessivirrat ovat kriittisimmät vetyperoksidin suorassa synteesissä, koska ne aiheuttavat todennäköisemmin räjähdyksen kuin nestemäiset prosessivirrat. Kaikkein eniten prosessiturvallisuutta uhkaavat ainevirrat ennen ja jälkeen mikroreaktoria.

Development of a process for the direct synthesis of hydrogen peroxide in a novel microstructured reactor

Microreactors have proven to be versatile tools for process intensification. Over recent decades, they have increasingly been used for product and process development in chemical industries. Enhanced heat and mass transfer in the reactors due to the extremely high surfacearea- to-volume ratio and interfacial area allow chemical processes to be operated at extreme conditions. Safety is improved by the small holdup volume of the reactors and effective control of pressure and temperature. Hydrogen peroxide is a powerful green oxidant that is used in a wide range of industries. Reduction and auto-oxidation of anthraquinones is currently the main process for hydrogen peroxide production. Direct synthesis is a green alternative and has potential for on-site production. However, there are two limitations: safety concerns because of the explosive gas mixture produced and low selectivity of the process. The aim of this thesis was to develop a process for direct synthesis of hydrogen peroxide utilizing microreactor technology. Experimental and numerical approaches were applied for development of the microreactor. Development of a novel microreactor was commenced by studying the hydrodynamics and mass transfer in prototype microreactor plates. The prototypes were designed and fabricated with the assistance of CFD modeling to optimize the shape and size of the microstructure. Empirical correlations for the mass transfer coefficient were derived. The pressure drop in micro T-mixers was investigated experimentally and numerically. Correlations describing the friction factor for different flow regimes were developed and predicted values were in good agreement with experimental results. Experimental studies were conducted to develop a highly active and selective catalyst with a proper form for the microreactor. Pd catalysts supported on activated carbon cloths were prepared by different treatments during the catalyst preparation. A variety of characterization methods were used for catalyst investigation. The surface chemistry of the support and the oxidation state of the metallic phase in the catalyst play important roles in catalyst activity and selectivity for the direct synthesis. The direct synthesis of hydrogen peroxide was investigated in a bench-scale continuous process using the novel microreactor developed. The microreactor was fabricated based on the hydrodynamic and mass transfer studies and provided a high interfacial area and high mass transfer coefficient. The catalysts were prepared under optimum treatment conditions. The direct synthesis was conducted at various conditions. The thesis represents a step towards a commercially viable direct synthesis. The focus is on the two main challenges: mitigating the safety problem by utilization of microprocess technology and improving the selectivity by catalyst development.

Catalytic direct synthesis of hydrogen peroxide in a novel microstructured reactor

The direct synthesis from hydrogen and oxygen is a green alternative for production of hydrogen peroxide. However, this process suffers from two challenges. Firstly, mixtures of hydrogen and oxygen are explosive over a wide range of concentrations (4-94% H2 in O2). Secondly, the catalytic reaction of hydrogen and oxygen involves several reaction pathways, many of them resulting in water production and therfore decreasing selectivity. The present work deals with these two challenges. The safety problem was dealed by employing a novel microstructured reactor. Selectivity of the reaction was highly improved by development a set of new catalysts. The final goal was to develop an effective and safe continuous process for direct synthesis of hydrogen peroxide from H2 and O2. Activated carbon cloth and Sibunit were examined as the catalysts’ supports. Palladium and gold monometallic and palladium-gold bimetallic catalysts were thoroughly investigated by numerous kinetic experiments performed in a tailored batch reactor and several catalyst charachterization methods. A complete set of data for direct synthesis of H2O2 and its catalytic decomposition and hydrogenation was obtained. These data were used to assess factors influencing selectivity and activity of the catalysts in direct synthesis of H2O2 as well as its decomposition and hydrogenation. A novel microstructured reactor was developed based on hydrodynamics and mass transfer studies in prototype microstractural plates. The shape and the size of the structural elements in the microreactor plate were optimized in a way to get high gas-liquid interfacial area and gas-liquid mass transfer. Finally, empirical correlations for the volumetric mass transfer coefficient were derived. A bench-scale continuous process was developed by using the novel microstructral plate reactor. A series of kinetic experiments were performed to investigate the effects of the gas and the liquid feed rates and their ratio, the amount of the catalyst, the gas feed composition and pressure on the final rate of H2O2 production and selectivity.

Concentration of hydrogen peroxide and improving its energy efficiency

Distillation is a unit operation of process industry, which is used to separate a liquid mixture into two or more products and to concentrate liquid mixtures. A drawback of the distillation is its high energy consumption. An increase in energy and raw material prices has led to seeking ways to improve the energy efficiency of distillation. In this Master's Thesis, these ways are studied in connection with the concentration of hydrogen peroxide at the Solvay Voikkaa Plant. The aim of this thesis is to improve the energy efficiency of the concentration of the Voikkaa Plant. The work includes a review of hydrogen peroxide and its manufacturing. In addition, the fundamentals of distillation and its energy efficiency are reviewed. An energy analysis of the concentration unit of Solvay Voikkaa Plant is presented in the process development study part. It consists of the current and past information of energy and utility consumptions, balances, and costs. After that, the potential ways to improve the energy efficiency of the distillation unit at the factory are considered and their feasibility is evaluated technically and economically. Finally, proposals to improve the energy efficiency are suggested. Advanced process control, heat integration and energy efficient equipment are the most potential ways to carry out the energy efficient improvements of the concentration at the Solvay Voikkaa factory. Optimization of the reflux flow and the temperatures of the overhead condensers can offer immediate savings in the energy and utility costs without investments. Replacing the steam ejector system with a vacuum pump would result in savings of tens of thousands of euros per year. The heat pump solutions, such as utilizing a mechanical vapor recompression or thermal vapor recompression, are not feasible due to the high investment costs and long pay back times.

Development of an environmentally friendly method of starch oxidation by hydrogen peroxide and a complex water-soluble Iron catalyst

Oxidized starch is a key component in the paper industry, where it is used as both surfacing sizer and filler. Large quantities are annually used for this purpose; however, the methods for the oxidation are not environmentally friendly. In our research, we have studied the possibility to replace the harmful oxidation agents, such as hypochlorite or iodates and transition metal catalysts, with a more environmentally friendly oxidant, hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), and a special metal complex catalyst (FePcS), of which only a small amount is needed. The work comprised batch and semi-batch studies by H2O2, ultrasound studies of starch particles, determination of low-molecular by-products and determination of the decomposition kinetics of H2O2 in the presence of starch and the catalyst. This resulted in a waste-free oxidation method, which only produces water and oxygen as side products. The starch oxidation was studied in both semi-batch and batch modes in respective to the oxidant (H2O2) addition. The semi-batch mode proved to yield a sufficient degree of substitution (COOH groups) for industrial purposes. Treatment of starch granules by ultrasound was found to improve the reactivity of starch. The kinetic results were found out to have a rather complex pattern – several oxidation phases were observed, apparently due to the fact that the oxidation reaction in the beginning only took place on the surface, whereas after a prolonged reaction time, partial degradation of the solid starch granules allowed further reaction in the interior parts. Batch-mode experiments enabled a more detailed study of the mechanisms of starch in the presence of H2O2 and the catalyst, but yielded less oxidized starch due to rapid decomposition of H2O2 due to its high concentrations. The effect of the solid-liquid (S/L) ratio in the reaction system was studied in batch experiments. These studies revealed that the presence of the catalyst and the starch enhance the H2O2 decomposition.

Combination of catalyst development and chemical reaction engineering : a key aspect to improve the hydrogen peroxide direct synthesis

-

Photocatalytic oxidation of humic substances and lignins in aqueous solutions

Tässä tutkimuksessa tarkastellaan kahden yleisen, veden ympäristökuormitusta aiheuttavan kemikaaliryhmän, ligniinin ja humusaineiden, fotokatalyyttistahapetusta (photocatalytic oxidation, PCO) vesiliuoksessa. Fotokatalyyttina käytettiin titaanidioksidia, jota säteilytettiin ultraviolettivalolla. Työssä selvitettiin useiden eri olosuhdeparametrien vaikutusta fotokatalyysiin. Tutkittavia parametreja olivat mm. kontaminanttien alkukonsentraatio, pH, vetyperoksidilisäys, rauta-ionien lisäys, fotokatalyysimenetelmä, fotokatalyytin pintakonsentraatioja titaanidioksidin määrä lasisissa mikropartikkeleissa. Ultraviolettivalon lähteinä käytettiin sekä keinovaloa että auringonvaloa. Katalyytin kantoaineena käytettiin huokoisia lasisia mikropartikkeleita, joiden pintaan kiinnittynyt titaanidioksidi pystyi hyvin vähentämään kontaminanttien määrää vedessä. Fotokatalyysin tehokkuus kasvoi humusaine- ja ligniinikonsentraatioiden kasvaessa. Korkeimmat hapetustehokkuudet kumallakin kontaminantilla saavutettiin neutraaleissa jalievästi emäksisissä olosuhteissa huolimatta siitä, että paras adsorboituminen tapahtui happamissa olosuhteissa. Tämän perusteella voidaan olettaa, että humusaineiden ja ligniinin hapetus tapahtuu pääosin radikaalimekanismilla. Vetyperoksidin lisääminen humusaineliuokseen lisäsi hapettumisnopeutta, vaikka näennäinen hapetustehokkuus ei muuttunut. Tämän perusteella vetyperoksidi hapetti myös humusaineita referenssinäytteessä. Ligniinin fotokatalyyttinen hapettuminen parani vetyperoksidilisäyksellä happamissa olosuhteissa johtuen lisääntyneestä OH-radikaalien muodostumisesta. Ligniini ei hapettunut vetyperoksidilla, jos fotokatalyyttiä ei¿ollut läsnä. Rauta-ionit eivät lisänneet humushappojen fotokatalyyttistähapettumista, mutta Fe2+-ionien lisäys aina konsentraatioon 0.05 mM johti ligniinin hapettumistehokkuuden voimakkaaseen kasvuun. Rauta-ionikonsentraation kasvattaminen edelleen johti ligniinin hapetustehokkuuden alenemiseen.

Removal of Lipophilic Wood Extractives from TMP Process Waters by Wet Oxidation

Työssä tutkittiin kokeellisesti rasvaliukoisten uuteaineiden poistamista TMP -prosessin vesikierroista märkähapetuksen avulla. Työn tavoitteena oli tutkia mahdollisuudet hyödyntää TMP -prosessissa vallitsevaa korkeaa lämpötilaa rasvaliukoisten uuteaineiden poistamiseen hapettamalla niitä puhtaalla hapella. Kirjallisuusosassa tarkasteltiin märkähapetuksen teknologiaa, reaktiomekanismia, käytettyjä katalyyttejä, käyttökohteita sekä kustannuksia. Kokeita suoritettiin autoklaavireaktorissa lämpötiloissa 140 °C, 160 °C ja 180 °C. Vetyperoksidia käytettiin katalyyttinä lisätyn vetyperoksidin määrän ollessa 100 - 1800 mg/l ja hapen osapaineen ollessa 0 ( typpiatmosfääri) - 15 baria. Kokeissa tarkasteltiin kemiallisen hapenkulutuksen (COD), rasvaliukoisten uuteaineiden konsentraation, orgaanisen kokonaishiilen (TOC) ja värin muutoksia kokeiden aikana eri lämpötiloilla, hapen osapaineilla ja lisätyn vetyperoksidin määrillä. Kokeissa saavutettiin 30 %:n COD:n vähenemä sekä 90 %:n vähenemä rasvaliukoisissa uuteaineissa lämpötiloissa 160 °C ja 180 °C. Lisäämällä vetyperoksidia katalyyttinä saavutettiin lähes sama tulos lämpötilassa 140 °C. Suurin tässä työssä havaittu ongelma oli lisääntynyt värinmuodostus vedessä olevassa hienojakoisessa kiintoaineessa hapetuksen aikana. Tämän vuoksi lisätutkimukset ovat tarpeellisia sen seikan selvittämiseksi, voidaanko muodostunut väri mahdollisesti poistaa massan valkaisussa.

The Significance of Hydrogen Bonding Interactions in the Cleavage of RNA

RNA is essential for all living organisms. It has important roles in protein synthesis, controlling gene expression as well as catalyzing biological reactions. Chemically RNA is a very stable molecule, although in biological systems many agents catalyze the cleavage of RNA, such as naturally occurring enzymes and ribozymes. Much effort has been put in the last decades in developing highly active artificial ribonucleases since such molecules could have potential in the therapeutic field and provide tools for molecular biology. Several potential catalysts have emerged, but usually detailed cleavage mechanism remains unresolved. This thesis is aimed at clarifying mechanistic details of the cleavage and isomerization of RNA by using simpler nucleoside models of RNA. The topics in the experimental part cover three different studies, one concerning the mechanism of catalysis by large ribozymes, one dealing with the reactivity of modified and unmodified RNA oligonucleotides and one showing an efficient catalysis of the cleavage and isomerization of an RNA phosphodiester bond by a dinuclear metal ion complex. A review of the literature concerning stabilization of the phosphorane intermediate of the hydrolysis and isomerization of RNA phosphodiester bond is first presented. The results obtained in the experimental work followed by mechanistic interpretations are introduced in the second part of the thesis. Especially the significance of hydrogen bonding interactions is discussed.

Synthesis of percarboxylic acids in microreactor

Percarboxylic acids are commonly used as disinfection and bleaching agents in textile, paper, and fine chemical industries. All of these applications are based on the oxidative potential of these compounds. In spite of high interest in these chemicals, they are unstable and explosive chemicals, which increase the risk of synthesis processes and transportation. Therefore, the safety criteria in the production process should be considered. Microreactors represent a technology that efficiently utilizes safety advantages resulting from small scale. Therefore, microreactor technology was used in the synthesis of peracetic acid and performic acid. These percarboxylic acids were produced at different temperatures, residence times and catalyst i.e. sulfuric acid concentrations. Both synthesis reactions seemed to be rather fast because with performic acid equilibrium was reached in 4 min at 313 K and with peracetic acid in 10 min at 343 K. In addition, the experimental results were used to study the kinetics of the formation of performic acid and peracetic acid. The advantages of the microreactors in this study were the efficient temperature control even in very exothermic reaction and good mixing due to the short diffusion distances. Therefore, reaction rates were determined with high accuracy. Three different models were considered in order to estimate the kinetic parameters such as reaction rate constants and activation energies. From these three models, the laminar flow model with radial velocity distribution gave most precise parameters. However, sulfuric acid creates many drawbacks in this synthesis process. Therefore, a ´´greener´´ way to use heterogeneous catalyst in the synthesis of performic acid in microreactor was studied. The cation exchange resin, Dowex 50 Wx8, presented very high activity and a long life time in this reaction. In the presence of this catalyst, the equilibrium was reached in 120 second at 313 K which indicates a rather fast reaction. In addition, the safety advantages of microreactors were investigated in this study. Four different conventional methods were used. Production of peracetic acid was used as a test case, and the safety of one conventional batch process was compared with an on-site continuous microprocess. It was found that the conventional methods for the analysis of process safety might not be reliable and adequate for radically novel technology, such as microreactors. This is understandable because the conventional methods are partly based on experience, which is very limited in connection with totally novel technology. Therefore, one checklist-based method was developed to study the safety of intensified and novel processes at the early stage of process development. The checklist was formulated using the concept of layers of protection for a chemical process. The traditional and three intensified processes of hydrogen peroxide synthesis were selected as test cases. With these real cases, it was shown that several positive and negative effects on safety can be detected in process intensification. The general claim that safety is always improved by process intensification was questioned.

Application of electrokinetic Fenton process for the remediation of soil contaminated with HCB

Electrokinetic remediation coupled with Fenton oxidation, widely called as Electrokinetic Fenton process is a potential soil remediation technique used for low permeable soil. The applicability of the process has been proved with soil contaminated with a wide range of organic compounds from phenol to the most recalcitrant ones such as PAHs and POPs. This thesis summarizes the major findings observed during an Electrokinetic Fenton Process study conducted for the remediation of low permeable soil contaminated with HCB, a typical hydrophobic organic contaminant. Model low permeable soil, kaolin, was artificially contaminated with HCB and subjected to Electrokinetic Fenton treatments in a series of laboratory scale batch experiments. The use of cyclodextrins as an enhancement agent to mobilize the sorbed contaminant through the system was investigated. Major process hindrances such as the oxidant availability and treatment duration were also addressed. The HCB degradation along with other parameters like soil pH, redox and cumulative catholyte flow were analyzed and monitored. The results of the experiments strengthen the existing knowledge on electrokinetic Fenton process as a promising technology for the treatment of soil contaminated with hydrophobic organic compounds. It has been demonstrated that HCB sorbed to kaolin can be degraded by the use of high concentrations of hydrogen peroxide during such processes. The overall system performances were observed to be influenced by the point and mode of oxidant delivery. Furthermore, the study contributes to new knowledge in shortening the treatment duration by adopting an electrode polarity reversal during the process.

Optimization of hydrogen plant efficiency

The purpose of this master’s thesis was to study ways to increase the operating cost-efficiency of the hydrogen production process by optimizing the process parameters while, at the same time, maintaining plant reliability and safety. The literature part reviewed other hydrogen production and purification processes as well as raw material alternatives for hydrogen production. The experimental part of the master’s thesis was conducted at Solvay Chemicals Finland Oy’s hydrogen plant in spring 2012. It was performed by changing the process parameters, first, one by one, aiming for a more efficient process with clean product gas and lower natural gas consumption. The values of the process parameters were tested based on the information from the literature, process simulation and experiences of previous similar processes. The studied parameters were reformer outlet temperature, shift converter inlet temperature and steam/carbon ratio. The results show that the optimal process conditions are a lower steam/carbon ratio and reformer outlet temperature than the current values of 3.0 and 798 °C. An increase/decrease in the shift conversion inlet temperature does not affect natural gas consumption, but it has an effect on minimizing the process steam overload.

Adsorption of hydrogen sulfide by modified cellulose nano/microcrystals

Hydrogen sulfide is toxic and hazardous pollutant. It has been under great interest for past few years because of all the time tighten environmental regulations and increased interest of mining. Hydrogen sulfide gas originates from mining and wastewater treatment systems have caused death in two cases. It also causes acid rains and corrosion for wastewater pipelines. The aim of this master thesis was to study if chemically modified cellulose nanocrystals could be used as adsorbents to purify hydrogen sulfide out from water and what are the adsorption capacities of these adsorbents. The effects of pH and backgrounds on adsorption capacities of different adsorbents are tested. In theoretical section hydrogen sulfide, its properties and different purification methods are presented. Also analytical detection methods for hydrogen sulfide are presented. Cellulose nano/microcrystals, properties, application and different modification methods are discussed and finally theory of adsorption and modeling of adsorption is shortly discussed. In experimental section different cellulose nanocrystals based adsorbents are prepared and tested at different hydrogen sulfide concentrations and in different conditions. Result of experimental section was that the highest adsorption capacity at one component adsorption had wet MFC/CaCO3. At different pH the adsorption capacities of adsorbents changed quite dramatically. Also change of hydrogen sulfide solution background did have effect on adsorption capacities. Although, when tested adsorbents’ adsorption capacities are compared to those find in literatures, it seems that more development of MFC based adsorbents is needed.

Wet oxidation of biomass for chemical production

Tämän kandidaatintyön tarkoituksena oli tutkia märkähapetusprosessia jätevesien käsittely-menetelmänä ja mahdollisena menetelmänä kemikaalien tuottamiseksi jätevesistä. Erityishuomio on kiinnitetty paperiteollisuudessa syntyviin jätevesiin. Teoriaosassa käsitellään vesikiertoja paperitehtaassa, paperitehtaalla syntyvän jäteveden ominaisuuksia sekä itse märkähapetusprosessia. Märkähapetusprosessissa perehdytään tavalliseen happea käyttävään märkähapetukseen sekä vetyperoksidia käyttävään menetelmään sekä näissä prosesseissa syntyviin väli- ja lopputuotteisiin. Märkähapetus (WO) on terminen hapetusmenetelmä, jolla voidaan käsitellä jätevesiä, jotka ovat liian konsentroituja biologisiin käsittelyihin tai jotka ovat huonosti biohajoavia. Märkähapetuksen tarkoituksena on parantaa molekulaarisen hapen ja orgaanisen aineen välistä kontaktia, jolloin orgaaninen aines pilkkoutuu muodostaen pääasiassa karboksyylihappoja, aldehydejä, hiilidioksidia ja vettä. Märkähapetuksessa hapettavana kaasuna voidaan käyttää joko puhdasta happea tai ilmaa. Vetyperoksidia käyttävässä märkähapetuksessa (WPO) hapettava kaasu on korvattu nestemäisellä vetyperoksidilla. Kokeellisessa osassa tutkittiin orgaanisen aineksen hapetusta käyttäen Fentonin reagenssia, jolloin katalyyttina reaktiossa toimii rautaionit (Fe2+ ja Fe3+) ja hapettimena vetyperoksidi. Hapetettavana jätevetenä käytettiin paperitehtaan hiomolta saatua kiertovettä, TMP-vettä. Hapetuskokeita tehtiin eri vetyperoksidin annoksilla ja katalyytin määrillä eri lämpötiloissa. Hapetuksen jälkeen näytteistä mitattiin kemiallinen hapenkulutus (COD), orgaanisen hiilen kokonaismäärä (TOC) sekä pH. Lisäksi näytteistä määritettiin nestekromatografilla (HPLC) tyypillisten välituotteiden, kuten oksaalihapon, muurahaishapon ja etikkahapon, määrät. Tehdyissä kokeissa COD-arvoja saatiin pienennettyä 50-88 % siten, että suodatetuissa näytteissä muutos oli suurempi kuin suodattamattomissa näytteissä. Lisäksi TOC-arvot laskivat 28-58 %. Tehdyissä kokeissa saatiin myös tuotettua välituotteina karboksyylihappoja, joista etikkahappoa ja oksaalihappoa tuotettiin suurimmat määrät. Myös muurahaishappoa ja meripihkahappoa saatiin tuotettua.