Modeling of residual stresses and distortion due to welding in fillet welds

Welding has a growing role in modern world manufacturing. Welding joints are extensively used from pipes to aerospace industries. Prediction of welding residual stresses and distortions is necessary for accurate evaluation of fillet welds in relation to design and safety conditions. Residual stresses may be beneficial or detrimental, depending whether they are tensile or compressive and the loading. They directly affect the fatigue life of the weld by impacting crack growth rate. Beside theoretical background of residual stresses this study calculates residual stresses and deformations due to localized heating by welding process and subsequent rapid cooling in fillet welds. Validated methods are required for this purpose due to complexity of process, localized heating, temperature dependence of material properties and heat source. In this research both empirical and simulation methods were used for the analysis of welded joints. Finite element simulation has become a popular tool of prediction of welding residual stresses and distortion. Three different cases with and without preload have been modeled during this study. Thermal heat load set is used by calculating heat flux from the given heat input energy. First the linear and then nonlinear material behavior model is modeled for calculation of residual stresses. Experimental work is done to calculate the stresses empirically. The results from both the methods are compared to check their reliability. Residual stresses can have a significant effect on fatigue performance of the welded joints made of high strength steel. Both initial residual stress state and subsequent residual stress relaxation need to be considered for accurate description of fatigue behavior. Tensile residual stresses are detrimental and will reduce the fatigue life and compressive residual stresses will increase it. The residual stresses follow the yield strength of base or filler material and the components made of high strength steel are typically thin, where the role of distortion is emphasizing.

Tehollisen lovijännityksen menetelmän käytettävyys ultralujien terästen korkealaatuisten hitsien väsymismitoituksessa

Tässä diplomityössä on tutkittu tehollisen lovijännityksen menetelmän soveltuvuutta ultralujien terästen korkealaatuisten hitsien väsymismitoitukseen. International Institute of Welding suosittelee käyttämään elementtimenetelmässä hitsin rajaviivoilla sekä juuressa fiktiivistä 1 mm pyöristystä, jonka avulla tehollinen lovijännitys määritetään. Kaikille liitostyypeille sovelletaan samaa, kaltevuudeltaan m = 3 olevaa SN-käyrää, jolloin maksimipääjännitystä vastaava väsymisluokka FAT saa arvon 225. Nykyisiä mitoitusohjeita on pidetty kuitenkin liian konservatiivisina, etenkin jos kyseessä on suurilujuuksisesta teräksestä valmistettu korkealaatuinen hitsi. Rajaviivalla vaikuttavaa lovijännitystä on tutkittu mallintamalla liitokset FEMAP – elementtimenetelmäohjelmalla varioimalla rajaviivan pyöristystä. Elementtimenetelmän tuloksia on verrattu analyyttisiin loven muotoluvun laskentakaavoihin. Tutkittavana on ollut Ruukin Optim 960 QC sekä Optim 1100 QC – teräksistä valmistettuja koesauvoja. Koesauvat on valmistettu sekä koestettu pääasiassa Lappeenrannan teknillisen yliopiston teräsrakenteiden laboratoriossa. Tutkittavat koesauvat ovat olleet kuormaa kantamattomia ristiliitoksia sekä päittäisliitoksia. Suurin osa koesauvoista on väsytetty käyttämällä jännityssuhdetta R < 0,11. Koesauvat on jaoteltu jännityssuhteen sekä liitostyypin mukaan. Kaikkien koekappaleiden karakteristiseksi väsymisluokan arvoksi on määritetty FAT 200. Alle 0,11 jännityssuhteella väsytettyjen koekappaleiden karakteristinen väsymisluokka on FAT 230 ja isoilla jännityssuhteilla väsytettyjen FAT 126. Tulosten perusteella nykyiset mitoitusohjeet eivät ole liian konservatiivisia. Väsymisluokkaa FAT 225 voidaan käyttää väsymislaskennassa, mikäli rakenteen kuormitusten suhde on alle 0,1. Isoilla jännityssuhteilla koestettujen koekappaleiden lukumäärä on ollut pieni, joten niiden mitoitukselle ei voida antaa tarkkoja ohjeita.

Defining the keyhole modes – the effects on the weld geometry and the molten pool behaviour in high power laser welding of stainless steels

Keyhole welding, meaning that the laser beam forms a vapour cavity inside the steel, is one of the two types of laser welding processes and currently it is used in few industrial applications. Modern high power solid state lasers are becoming more used generally, but not all process fundamentals and phenomena of the process are well known and understanding of these helps to improve quality of final products. This study concentrates on the process fundamentals and the behaviour of the keyhole welding process by the means of real time high speed x-ray videography. One of the problem areas in laser welding has been mixing of the filler wire into the weld; the phenomena are explained and also one possible solution for this problem is presented in this study. The argument of this thesis is that the keyhole laser welding process has three keyhole modes that behave differently. These modes are trap, cylinder and kaleidoscope. Two of these have sub-modes, in which the keyhole behaves similarly but the molten pool changes behaviour and geometry of the resulting weld is different. X-ray videography was used to visualize the actual keyhole side view profile during the welding process. Several methods were applied to analyse and compile high speed x-ray video data to achieve a clearer image of the keyhole side view. Averaging was used to measure the keyhole side view outline, which was used to reconstruct a 3D-model of the actual keyhole. This 3D-model was taken as basis for calculation of the vapour volume inside of the keyhole for each laser parameter combination and joint geometry. Four different joint geometries were tested, partial penetration bead on plate and I-butt joint and full penetration bead on plate and I-butt joint. The comparison was performed with selected pairs and also compared all combinations together.

Weldability of powder bed fusion fabricated stainless steel 316L sheets to cold rolled sheet metal

Weldability of powder bed fusion (PBF) fabricated components has come to discussion in past two years due to resent developments in the PBF technology and limited size of the machines used in the fabrication process. This study concentrated on effects of energy input of welding on mechanical properties and microstructural features of welds between PBF fabricated stainless steel 316L sheets and cold rolled sheet metal of same composition by the means of destructive testing and microscopic analysis. Optical fiber diameter, laser power and welding speed were varied during the experiments that were executed following one variable at a time (OVAT) method. One of the problems of welded PBF fabricated components has been lower elongations at break comparing to conventionally manufactured components. Decreasing energy input of the laser keyhole welding decreased elongations at break of the welded specimens. Ultimate tensile strengths were not affected significantly by the energy input of the welding, but fracturing of the specimens welded using high energy input occurred from the weld metal. Fracturing of the lower energy input welds occurred from the PBF fabricated base metal. Energy input was found to be critical factor for mechanical properties of the welds. Multioriented grain growth and formation of neck at fusion zone boundary on the cold rolled side of the weld was detected and suspected to be result from weld pool flows caused by differences in molten weld pool behaviour between the PBF fabricated and cold rolled sides of the welds.

Thick Section Laser Beam Welding of Structural Steels: Methods for Improving Welding Efficiency

Laser beam welding (LBW) is applicable for a wide range of industrial sectors and has a history of fifty years. However, it is considered an unusual method with applications typically limited to welding of thin sheet metal. With a new generation of high power lasers there has been a renewed interest in thick section LBW (also known as keyhole laser welding). There was a growing body of publications during 2001-2011 that indicates an increasing interest in laser welding for many industrial applications, and in last ten years, an increasing number of studies have examined the ways to increase the efficiency of the process. Expanding the thickness range and efficiency of LBW makes the process a possibility for industrial applications dealing with thick metal welding: shipbuilding, offshore structures, pipelines, power plants and other industries. The advantages provided by LBW, such as high process speed, high productivity, and low heat input, may revolutionize these industries and significantly reduce the process costs. The research to date has focused on either increasing the efficiency via optimizing process parameters, or on the process fundamentals, rather than on process and workpiece modifications. The argument of this thesis is that the efficiency of the laser beam process can be increased in a straightforward way in the workshop conditions. Throughout this dissertation, the term “efficiency” is used to refer to welding process efficiency, specifically, an increase in efficiency refers an increase in weld’s penetration depth without increasing laser power level or decreasing welding speed. These methods are: modifications of the workpiece – edge surface roughness and air gap between the joining plates; modification of the ambient conditions – local reduction of the pressure in the welding zone; modification of the welding process – preheating of the welding zone. Approaches to improve the efficiency are analyzed and compared both separately and combined. These experimentally proven methods confirm previous findings and contribute additional evidence which expand the opportunities for laser beam welding applications. The focus of this research was primarily on the effects of edge surface roughness preparation and pre-set air gap between the plates on weld quality and penetration depth. To date, there has been no reliable evidence that such modifications of the workpiece give a positive effect on the welding efficiency. Other methods were tested in combination with the two methods mentioned above. The most promising - combining with reduced pressure method - resulted in at least 100% increase in efficiency. The results of this thesis support the idea that joining those methods in one modified process will provide the modern engineering with a sufficient tool for many novel applications with potential benefits to a range of industries.

Simulation and material calibration of ultra high strength steel (UHSS) S960 welded joint under static tensile test utilizing finite element method (FEM)

The aim of this work was to calibrate the material properties including strength and strain values for different material zones of ultra-high strength steel (UHSS) welded joints under monotonic static loading. The UHSS is heat sensitive and softens by heat due to welding, the affected zone is heat affected zone (HAZ). In this regard, cylindrical specimens were cut out from welded joints of Strenx® 960 MC and Strenx® Tube 960 MH, were examined by tensile test. The hardness values of specimens’ cross section were measured. Using correlations between hardness and strength, initial material properties were obtained. The same size specimen with different zones of material same as real specimen were created and defined in finite element method (FEM) software with commercial brand Abaqus 6.14-1. The loading and boundary conditions were defined considering tensile test values. Using initial material properties made of hardness-strength correlations (true stress-strain values) as Abaqus main input, FEM is utilized to simulate the tensile test process. By comparing FEM Abaqus results with measured results of tensile test, initial material properties will be revised and reused as software input to be fully calibrated in such a way that FEM results and tensile test results deviate minimum. Two type of different S960 were used including 960 MC plates, and structural hollow section 960 MH X-joint. The joint is welded by BöhlerTM X96 filler material. In welded joints, typically the following zones appear: Weld (WEL), Heat affected zone (HAZ) coarse grained (HCG) and fine grained (HFG), annealed zone, and base material (BaM). Results showed that: The HAZ zone is softened due to heat input while welding. For all the specimens, the softened zone’s strength is decreased and makes it a weakest zone where fracture happens while loading. Stress concentration of a notched specimen can represent the properties of notched zone. The load-displacement diagram from FEM modeling matches with the experiments by the calibrated material properties by compromising two correlations of hardness and strength.

Weldability of high strength aluminium alloys

The need for reduced intrinsic weight of structures and vehicles in the transportation industry has made aluminium research of interest. Aluminium has properties that are favourable for structural engineering, including good strength-to-weight ratio, corrosion resistance and machinability. It can be easily recycled saving energy used in smelting as compared to steel. Its alloys can have ultimate tensile strength of up to 750 MPa, which is comparable to steel. Aluminium alloys are generally weldable, however welding of high strength alloys like the 7xxx series pose considerable challenges. This paper presents research on the weldability of high strength aluminium alloys, principally the 7xxx series. The weldability with various weld processes including MIG, TIG, and FSW, is discussed in addition to consideration of joint types, weld defects and recommendations for minimizing or preventing weld defects. Experimental research was carried out on 7025-T6 and AW-7020 alloys. Samples were welded, and weld cross sections utilized in weld metallurgy studies. Mechanical tests were carried out including hardness tests and tensile tests. In addition, testing was done for the presence of Al2O3 on exposed aluminium alloy. It was observed that at constant weld heat input using a pulsed MIG system, the welding speed had little or no effect on the weld hardness. However, the grain size increased as the filler wire feed rate, welding current and welding speed increased. High heat input resulted in lower hardness of the weld profile. Weld preheating was detrimental to AW- 7020 welds; however, artificial aging was beneficial. Acceptable welds were attained with pulsed MIG without the removal of the Al2O3 layer prior to welding. The Al2O3 oxide layer was found to have different compositions in different aluminium alloys. These findings contribute useful additional information to the knowledge base of aluminium welding. The application of the findings of this study in welding will help reduce weld cost and improve high strength aluminium structure productivity by removing the need for pre-weld cleaning. Better understanding of aluminium weld metallurgy equips weld engineers with information for better aluminium weld design.

Effects of Fabrication Processes on the Behavior of S960 Ultra High Strength Steel (UHSS)

Strenx® 960 MC is a direct quenched type of Ultra High Strength Steel (UHSS) with low carbon content. Although this material combines high strength and good ductility, it is highly sensitive towards fabrication processes. The presence of stress concentration due to structural discontinuity or notch will highlight the role of these fabrication effects on the deformation capacity of the material. Due to this, a series of tensile tests are done on both pure base material (BM) and when it has been subjected to Heat Input (HI) and Cold Forming (CF). The surface of the material was dressed by laser beam with a certain speed to study the effect of HI while the CF is done by bending the specimen to a certain angle prior to tensile test. The generated results illustrate the impact of these processes on the deformation capacity of the material, specially, when the material has HI experience due to welding or similar processes. In order to compare the results with those of numerical simulation, LS-DYNA explicit commercial package has been utilized. The generated results show an acceptable agreement between experimental and numerical simulation outcomes.

Effect of loading type on the fatigue strength of symmetric and asymmetric welded joints made of ultra high strength steel

In this study, finite element analyses and experimental tests are carried out in order to investigate the effect of loading type and symmetry on the fatigue strength of three different non-load carrying welded joints. The current codes and recommendations do not give explicit instructions how to consider degree of bending in loading and the effect of symmetry in the fatigue assessment of welded joints. The fatigue assessment is done by using effective notch stress method and linear elastic fracture mechanics. Transverse attachment and cover plate joints are analyzed by using 2D plane strain element models in FEMAP/NxNastran and Franc2D software and longitudinal gusset case is analyzed by using solid element models in Abaqus and Abaqus/XFEM software. By means of the evaluated effective notch stress range and stress intensity factor range, the nominal fatigue strength is assessed. Experimental tests consist of the fatigue tests of transverse attachment joints with total amount of 12 specimens. In the tests, the effect of both loading type and symmetry on the fatigue strength is studied. Finite element analyses showed that the fatigue strength of asymmetric joint is higher in tensile loading and the fatigue strength of symmetric joint is higher in bending loading in terms of nominal and hot spot stress methods. Linear elastic fracture mechanics indicated that bending reduces stress intensity factors when the crack size is relatively large since the normal stress decreases at the crack tip due to the stress gradient. Under tensile loading, experimental tests corresponded with finite element analyzes. Still, the fatigue tested joints subjected to bending showed the bending increased the fatigue strength of non-load carrying welded joints and the fatigue test results did not fully agree with the fatigue assessment. According to the results, it can be concluded that in tensile loading, the symmetry of joint distinctly affects on the fatigue strength. The fatigue life assessment of bending loaded joints is challenging since it depends on whether the crack initiation or propagation is predominant.

Ultralujan teräksen kaarijuotto

Tässä diplomityössä tutkitaan ultralujan rakenneteräksen kaarijuotolla valmistettujen liitosten väsymiskestävyyttä. Tutkittavat liitokset ovat kuormaa kantamattomia X-liitoksia. Tutkinnassa vertaillaan puhtaasti juottamalla valmistettua liitosta hitsauksen ja juoton kombinaatioliitokseen, jossa pohjapalkona toimivan hitsin rajaviivalle on juotettu lisäpalko. Kaarijuottoa esitellään yleisesti liittämismenetelmänä. Ultralujaa rakenneterästä esitellään yleisesti ja tarkastellaan sen metallurgista käyttäytymistä sekä juotettaessa, että hitsattaessa. Tutkimuksessa tehtiin kaikkiaan 21 väsytystestiä. Väsytystestit muodostuivat kolmesta eri koekappalesarjasta. Ensimmäisen ja toisen sarjan koekappaleet tehtiin juottamalla, eri lisäaineilla. 3. sarjassa pienat hitsattiin, jonka jälkeen hitsin rajaviivalle tehtiin juotto. Kappaleiden geometriat mitattiin ennen testejä, ja osasta kappaleista mitattiin jäännösjännitykset. Kappaleista otettiin hieitä, joista tehtiin kovuusmittaukset ja suoritettiin makro- ja mikrotason tarkastelua liitosprosessin lämmöntuonnin vaikutuksesta. Väsytyskokeiden perusteella kappaleille määritettiin nimelliset ja rakenteelliset väsymisluokat. Tuloksista piirrettiin S-N –käyrät. Liitoksista tehtiin FEA-mallit, joista määritettiin liitoksen rajaviivalle muodostuva jännitys ja 2. sarjan koekappaleiden laskennalliset kestoiät. 1. sarjan juotoksissa oli ongelmana juotoksen tarttuvuus teräksen pintaan. 2. sarjan koetulokset olivat kaikkein parhaita. 3. sarjan kombinaatioliitokset ylsivät kohtalaisiin väsymisluokkiin. 2. sarjan koetulosten perusteella kaarijuotossa on potentiaalia ultralujan rakenneteräksen liittämismenetelmänä. Jatkotutkimuksen tarve on kuitenkin laaja. Tämä työ osoitti, että kaarijuottaminen voi olla vaativa liittämisprosessi, sillä toimiakseen se vaatii varsin tarkat parametrit, ja lisäksi prosessi on melko herkkä olosuhdemuutoksille.

Investigation of the fatigue performance of welded duplex stainless steel

Diplomityössä tutkitaan hitsatun duplex-teräksen, laatu: EN 1.4462 (Outokumpu laatu 2205) väsymislujuutta. Tutkimusmetodologia noudattaa sekä kokeellisia että laskennallisia menetelmiä. Kokeelliset menetelmät sisältävät hitsatun teräksen väsytystestaukset laboratoriossa, hitsausten jälkikäsittelyt (HiFIT) sekä perusaineelle ja hitseille tehtävät metallurgiset tutkimukset. Väsytyskokeista saatavia tuloksia verrataan kansainvälisen hitsausinstituutin (IIW) vahvistamiin rakennekohtaisiin standardeihin sekä kirjallisuudessa esiintyviin tutkimustuloksiin. Laskennalliset menetelmät sisältävät vertailulaskelmia tehollisen lovijännityksen (ENS) menetelmää hyödyntäen. Tehollisen lovijännityksen menetelmässä liitoksissa vaikuttavat teholliset lovijännitykset selvitetään elementtimenetelmän (FEM) avulla. Tulokset vahvistavat, että hitsauksella ja hitsausten jälkikäsittelyllä on suuri merkitys rakenteen kestoikään. Suurin osa väsytyskokeiden tuloksista osoitti parempia väsymiskestävyyden arvoja kuin rakennekohtaiset standardit, mutta liitosten liitosvirheiden todettiin heikentävän väsytyskestävyyttä. Jälkikäsittelyiden todettiin parantavan liitosten väsymiskestävyyden tuloksia ja todettiin tulosten olevan hyödynnettävissä mitoituksessa.

Possibilities of advanced MAG-welding processes in shipbuilding

In shipbuilding industry welding of primer coated and tack welded steel products cause different issues. Primer coated steel products are commonly used at shipyards to ensure corrosion free storage of products in outdoor conditions. However usage of primer can cause imperfections to welds. To prevent porosity primed steel products are usually welded with tubular welding wires. Tack welds cause commonly interferences in mechanized welding when over welded, which increases costs related to welding due to increased need of preparing and repairing. The aim of this study is to research possibilities of advanced solid wire MAG-welding processes to deal with these two previously mentioned problems. This study concentrates to examine possibilities of MAG-welding, pulse MAG-welding, double pulse MAG-welding, RapidArc and ForceArc processes. Large amount of experiments were made to find out the produced porosity and the ability to over weld tack welds with each process in different circumstances. In welding of primed steel products porosity is caused mainly by hydrogen, CO, CO2, nitrous gases and zinc fumes. It was found in experiments that porosity of MAG-welding can be greatly decreased by using pulse MAG-welding instead. Also reduction of welding speed, usage of air gap and usage of solid wire product with higher amount of alloying elements reduces porosity. Researched advanced MAG-welding processes did not have an improvement into over welding of tack welds. With studied throat thicknesses and welding positions conventional MAG-welding managed better over welding of tack welds than the four studied advanced MAG-welding processes. Studied solid wire MAG-welding processes would be best suited at shipyard for mechanized welding in welding position PB. In welding positions PD and PG tubular welding wires are clearly more productive.