Pulsed corona discharge as an advanced oxidation process for degradation of organic

Advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) have been studied and developed to suffice the effective removal of refractory and toxic compounds in polluted water. The quality and cost of wastewater treatment need improvements, and electric discharge technology has a potential to make a significant difference compared to other established AOPs based on energy efficiency. The generation of active oxidant species such as ozone and hydroxyl radicals by high voltage discharge is a relatively new technology for water treatment. Gas-phase pulsed corona discharge (PCD), where a treated aqueous solution is dispersed between corona-producing electrodes free of the dielectric barriers, was developed as an alternative approach to the problem. The short living radicals and ozone formed in the gas phase and at the gas-liquid interface react with dissolved impurities. PCD equipment has a relatively simple configuration, and with the reactor in an enclosed compartment, it is insensitive towards gas humidity and does not need the gas transport. In this thesis, PCD was used to study and evaluate the energy efficiency for degrading various organic compounds, as well as the chemistry of the oxidation products formed. The experiments investigate the aqueous oxidation of phenol, humic substances, pharmaceutical compounds (paracetamol, ibuprofen, indomethacin, salicylic acids, -estradiol), as well as lignin degradation and transformation to aldehydes. The study aims to establish the influence of initial concentration of the target pollutant, the pulsed discharge parameters, gas phase composition and the pH on the oxidation kinetics and the efficiency. Analytical methods to measure the concentrations of the target compounds and their by-products include HPLC, spectrophotometry, TOC and capillary electrophoresis. The results of the research included in this summary are presented in the attached publications and manuscripts accepted for publication. Pulsed corona discharge proved to be highly effective in oxidizing each of the target compounds, surpassing the closest competitor, conventional ozonation. The increase in oxidation efficiencies for some compounds in oxygen media and at lower pulse repetition frequencies shows a significant role of ozone. The role of the ·OH radicals was established in the surface reactions. The main oxidation products, formation of nitrates, and the lignin transformation were quantified. A compound specific approach is suggested for optimization of the PCD parameters that have the most significant impact on the oxidation energy efficiency because of the different characteristics and responses of the target compound to the oxidants, as well as different admixtures that are present in the wastewater. Further studies in the method’s safety (nitration and nitrosation of organic compounds, nitrite and nitrate formation enhancement) are needed for promoting the method.

Wet oxidation of biomass for chemical production

Tämän kandidaatintyön tarkoituksena oli tutkia märkähapetusprosessia jätevesien käsittely-menetelmänä ja mahdollisena menetelmänä kemikaalien tuottamiseksi jätevesistä. Erityishuomio on kiinnitetty paperiteollisuudessa syntyviin jätevesiin. Teoriaosassa käsitellään vesikiertoja paperitehtaassa, paperitehtaalla syntyvän jäteveden ominaisuuksia sekä itse märkähapetusprosessia. Märkähapetusprosessissa perehdytään tavalliseen happea käyttävään märkähapetukseen sekä vetyperoksidia käyttävään menetelmään sekä näissä prosesseissa syntyviin väli- ja lopputuotteisiin. Märkähapetus (WO) on terminen hapetusmenetelmä, jolla voidaan käsitellä jätevesiä, jotka ovat liian konsentroituja biologisiin käsittelyihin tai jotka ovat huonosti biohajoavia. Märkähapetuksen tarkoituksena on parantaa molekulaarisen hapen ja orgaanisen aineen välistä kontaktia, jolloin orgaaninen aines pilkkoutuu muodostaen pääasiassa karboksyylihappoja, aldehydejä, hiilidioksidia ja vettä. Märkähapetuksessa hapettavana kaasuna voidaan käyttää joko puhdasta happea tai ilmaa. Vetyperoksidia käyttävässä märkähapetuksessa (WPO) hapettava kaasu on korvattu nestemäisellä vetyperoksidilla. Kokeellisessa osassa tutkittiin orgaanisen aineksen hapetusta käyttäen Fentonin reagenssia, jolloin katalyyttina reaktiossa toimii rautaionit (Fe2+ ja Fe3+) ja hapettimena vetyperoksidi. Hapetettavana jätevetenä käytettiin paperitehtaan hiomolta saatua kiertovettä, TMP-vettä. Hapetuskokeita tehtiin eri vetyperoksidin annoksilla ja katalyytin määrillä eri lämpötiloissa. Hapetuksen jälkeen näytteistä mitattiin kemiallinen hapenkulutus (COD), orgaanisen hiilen kokonaismäärä (TOC) sekä pH. Lisäksi näytteistä määritettiin nestekromatografilla (HPLC) tyypillisten välituotteiden, kuten oksaalihapon, muurahaishapon ja etikkahapon, määrät. Tehdyissä kokeissa COD-arvoja saatiin pienennettyä 50-88 % siten, että suodatetuissa näytteissä muutos oli suurempi kuin suodattamattomissa näytteissä. Lisäksi TOC-arvot laskivat 28-58 %. Tehdyissä kokeissa saatiin myös tuotettua välituotteina karboksyylihappoja, joista etikkahappoa ja oksaalihappoa tuotettiin suurimmat määrät. Myös muurahaishappoa ja meripihkahappoa saatiin tuotettua.

Production of Chemicals from Woody Biomass by Wet Oxidation

The production of chemicals from sawdust by wet oxidation has been investigated. Two different concentrations of sawdust; 54054 mg/l and 32683 mg/l were used in the study. The wet oxidation operating conditions were; 175 deg.C – 225 deg.C, 1MPa Oxygen, and 40 minutes to 120 minutes reaction time. Carboxylic acids were among the chemicals produced in the process. The total yield of carboxylic acids was found to increase with temperature. Also, higher yields of carboxylic acids were observed at a lower sawdust concentration. This was probably due to the high oxygen-biomass ratio at lower sawdust concentration. Higher oxygen availability at low sawdust concentration resulted in increased conversion of the sawdust; hence the higher yields of carboxylic acids. At lower sawdust concentration, a total carboxylic acid yield of 25.59 wt% was attained at 200 deg.C and 40 minutes reaction time. At higher sawdust concentration, a total carboxylic acid yield of 15.57 wt% was attained at 200 deg.C and 40-minutes reaction time. The carboxylic acids identified include formic acid, acetic acid, succinic acid and oxalic acid. The optimum temperature for the production of formic acid was found to be 200 deg.C, while the optimum temperature for the production of acetic acid was found to be 225 deg.C. A temperature of 225 deg.C and relatively short reaction time of 10 minutes was found to be the optimal condition for the production of succinic acid. Formic acid was produced in the highest yield, with an optimal yield of 13.69wt %, when the reaction temperature and time are 200 deg.C and 40 minutes respectively. The yield of formic acid was found to decrease significantly when further increasing the temperature to 225 deg.C. This was presumably due to thermal decomposition of formic acid at relatively higher temperature. However, the yield of acetic acid was found to steadily increase with temperature. This is because acetic is more thermally stable than formic acid. The yield of acetic acid did not decrease after the temperature was increased to 225 deg.C. Optimal yield of acetic acid (7.98wt %) was achieved at; 225 deg.C, and 40 minutes reaction time. Succinic acid was produced only at temperatures of 200 deg.C and 225 deg.C. Optimal yield of succinic acid (5.66wt %) was attained under the following conditions; 32683 mg/l, 225 deg.C, 1MPa O2, and 10-minutes reaction time. Oxalic acid was produced in the lowest yield and, less frequently. The optimal yield of oxalic acid (4.02 wt%) was attained at 175 deg.C and 80-minutes of reaction time The Total Organic Carbon (TOC) is found to be higher when increasing the operating temperature, thus suggesting that more organic compounds are formed at higher temperatures. The identified carboxylic acids could only account for less than 30% of the measured COD content of the various wet oxidation samples. This implies that some other unidentified compounds (reaction products) must have been present. In general, wet oxidation seems to be an effective method for converting lignocellulosic biomass into useful chemicals. Relatively higher temperatures have been found to favor the production of carboxylic acids from sawdust.

Oxygen Photoreduction in Cyanobacteria

Cyanobacteria are well-known for their role in the global production of O2 via photosynthetic water oxidation. However, with the use of light energy, cyanobacteria can also reduce O2. In my thesis work, I have investigated the impact of O2 photoreduction on protection of the photosynthetic apparatus as well as the N2-fixing machinery. Photosynthetic light reactions produce intermediate radicals and reduced electron carriers, which can easily react with O2 to generate various reactive oxygen species. To avoid prolonged reduction of photosynthetic components, cyanobacteria use “electron valves” that dissipate excess electrons from the photosynthetic electron transfer chain in a harmless way. In Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803, flavodiiron proteins Flv1 and Flv3 comprise a powerful electron sink redirecting electrons from the acceptor side of Photosystem I to O2 and reducing it directly to water. In this work, I demonstrate that upon Ci-depletion Flv1/3 can dissipate up to 60% of the electrons delivered from Photosystem II. O2 photoreduction by Flv1/3 was shown to be vital for cyanobacteria in natural aquatic environments and deletion of Flv1/3 was lethal for both Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 and Anabaena sp. PCC 7120 under fluctuating light conditions. The lethal phenotype observed in the absence of Flv1/3 results from oxidative damage to Photosystem I, which appeared to be a primary target of reactive oxygen species produced upon sudden increases in light intensity. Importantly, cyanobacteria also possess other O2 photoreduction pathways which can protect the photosynthetic apparatus. This study demonstrates that respiratory terminal oxidases are also capable of initiating O2 photoreduction in mutant cells lacking the Flv1/3 proteins and grown under fluctuating light. Photoreduction of O2 by Rubisco was also shown in Ci-depleted cells of the mutants lacking Flv1/3, and thus provided the first evidence for active photorespiratory gas-exchange in cyanobacteria. Nevertheless, and despite the existence of other O2 photoreduction pathways, the Flv1/3 route appears to be the most robust and rapid system of photoprotection. Several groups of cyanobacteria are capable of N2 fixation. Filamentous heterocystous N2- fixing species, such as Anabaena sp. PCC 7120, are able to differentiate specialised cells called heterocysts for this purpose. In contrast to vegetative cells which perform oxygenic photosynthesis, heterocysts maintain a microoxic environment for the proper function of the nitrogenase enzyme, which is extremely sensitive to O2. The genome of Anabaena sp. PCC 7120 harbors two copies of genes encoding Flv1 and Flv3 proteins, designated as “A” and “B” forms. In this thesis work, I demonstrate that Flv1A and Flv3A are expressed only in the vegetative cells of filaments, whilst Flv1B and Flv3B are localized exclusively in heterocysts. I further revealed that the Flv3B protein is most responsible for the photoreduction of O2 in heterocysts, and that this reaction plays an important role in protection of the N2-fixing machinery and thus, the provision of filaments with fixed nitrogen. The function of the Flv1B protein remains to be elucidated; however the involvement of this protein in electron transfer reactions is feasible. Evidence provided in this thesis indicates the presence of a great diversity of O2 photoreduction reactions in cyanobacterial cells. These reactions appear to be crucial for the photoprotection of both photosynthesis and N2 fixation processes in an oxygenic environment.

Lignin oxidation by PCD technology

The purpose of this study is to investigate whether commercial Kraft lignin can be treated with pulsed corona discharge apparatus so that it becomes active. Active lignin refers to the kind of lignin that can be precipitated on the surface of a fiber by lowering the pH. A secondary agenda here is to remove the pungent smell of kraft lignin, which is caused by organically bound sulfur. It is expected that the study will identify mild processing conditions and parameters for achievement of the desired outcome. In the literature review, the properties of lignin are explained, as is their impact on any further processing. In addition, a number of processes are described for the oxidation of lignin in a variety of applications. In the experimental part of the study, test runs were conducted to determine the effects of oxygen supply and pulse frequency on oxidation results, where the purpose is to produce reactive lignin and to find a process that is feasible at an industrial scale. Based on the reported experiments, lignin could not be made active or precipitated to the surface of the fiber. Actual changes in the structure of lignin were not observed, but the pungent smell of lignin was removed. The exact reason for this change could not be established because sulfur NMR analysis did not work for the lignin samples.

Responses of soil respiration and barley growth to modified supply of oxygen in the soil

Selostus: Maan hengityksen ja ohran kasvun reagointi hapensaannin muutoksiin maassa

Aqueous photocatalytic oxidation of steroid estrogens

Concerns have increased regarding the detection of endocrine-disrupting compounds in the effluents of sewage treatment plants (STPs). These compounds are able to disrupt normal function of the endocrine system of living organisms even at trace concentrations. Natural and synthetic steroid estrogens (SEs) are believed to be responsible for the majority of the endocrine-disrupting effects. Municipal sewage, the main source of SEs in the environment, is a complex mixture of a wide range of pollutants at concentrations much higher than those of SEs. Low concentrations of SEs in the presence of copollutants thus make their removal problematic. The main objectives of the present work were to study the potential of photocatalytic oxidation (PCO) to effectively treat SE-containing aqueous solutions and to identify the optimum conditions for such treatment. The results showed that SEs can be effectively degraded photocatalytically. Due to the adsorption properties of SEs on the TiO2 photocatalyst surface alkaline medium was found to be beneficial for SE oxidation despite the presence of co-pollutants in concentrations characteristic for the sanitary fraction of municipal sewage. The potential of PCO to selectively oxidise SEs was examined in the presence of copollutants of the sanitary fraction of sewage - urea, saccharose and human urine. The impact of ethanol, often used as a solvent in the preparation of SE stock solutions, was also studied and the results indicated the need to use organic solvent-free solutions for the study of SE behaviour. Photocatalytic oxidation of SEs appeared to be indifferent towards the presence of urea in concentrations commonly found in domestic sewage. The effect of other co-pollutants under consideration was far weaker than could be expected from their concentrations, which are from one hundred to a few thousands times higher than those of the SEs. Although higher concentrations can dramatically slow down the PCO of SEs, realistic concentrations of co-pollutants characteristic for the sanitary fraction of domestic sewage allowed selective removal of SEs. This indicates the potential of PCO to be a selective oxidation method for SE removal from the separate sanitary fraction of municipal sewage.

0 AND 02 ADSORPTION ON Ag/Cu[100]

In this work the adsorption mechanisms of atomic and molecular oxygen on Cu(100) surface are studied using ab initio simulation methods. Through the atomistic scale under-standing of the elementary oxidation processes we can further understand the large-scale oxidation. Copper is a material widely used in industry which makes it an interesting subject, and also understanding the oxidation of copper helps us understand the oxidation mechanism of other metals. First we have a look on some theory on surface alloys in general and behaviour of Ag on Cu(100) surface. After that the physical background there is behind the methods of density functional calculations are discussed, and some methods, namely potential energy surfaces and molecular dynamics, are introduced. Then there is a brief look on the numerical details used in the calculations, and after that, the results of the simulations are exhibited.

Photocatalytic oxidation of humic substances and lignins in aqueous solutions

Tässä tutkimuksessa tarkastellaan kahden yleisen, veden ympäristökuormitusta aiheuttavan kemikaaliryhmän, ligniinin ja humusaineiden, fotokatalyyttistahapetusta (photocatalytic oxidation, PCO) vesiliuoksessa. Fotokatalyyttina käytettiin titaanidioksidia, jota säteilytettiin ultraviolettivalolla. Työssä selvitettiin useiden eri olosuhdeparametrien vaikutusta fotokatalyysiin. Tutkittavia parametreja olivat mm. kontaminanttien alkukonsentraatio, pH, vetyperoksidilisäys, rauta-ionien lisäys, fotokatalyysimenetelmä, fotokatalyytin pintakonsentraatioja titaanidioksidin määrä lasisissa mikropartikkeleissa. Ultraviolettivalon lähteinä käytettiin sekä keinovaloa että auringonvaloa. Katalyytin kantoaineena käytettiin huokoisia lasisia mikropartikkeleita, joiden pintaan kiinnittynyt titaanidioksidi pystyi hyvin vähentämään kontaminanttien määrää vedessä. Fotokatalyysin tehokkuus kasvoi humusaine- ja ligniinikonsentraatioiden kasvaessa. Korkeimmat hapetustehokkuudet kumallakin kontaminantilla saavutettiin neutraaleissa jalievästi emäksisissä olosuhteissa huolimatta siitä, että paras adsorboituminen tapahtui happamissa olosuhteissa. Tämän perusteella voidaan olettaa, että humusaineiden ja ligniinin hapetus tapahtuu pääosin radikaalimekanismilla. Vetyperoksidin lisääminen humusaineliuokseen lisäsi hapettumisnopeutta, vaikka näennäinen hapetustehokkuus ei muuttunut. Tämän perusteella vetyperoksidi hapetti myös humusaineita referenssinäytteessä. Ligniinin fotokatalyyttinen hapettuminen parani vetyperoksidilisäyksellä happamissa olosuhteissa johtuen lisääntyneestä OH-radikaalien muodostumisesta. Ligniini ei hapettunut vetyperoksidilla, jos fotokatalyyttiä ei¿ollut läsnä. Rauta-ionit eivät lisänneet humushappojen fotokatalyyttistähapettumista, mutta Fe2+-ionien lisäys aina konsentraatioon 0.05 mM johti ligniinin hapettumistehokkuuden voimakkaaseen kasvuun. Rauta-ionikonsentraation kasvattaminen edelleen johti ligniinin hapetustehokkuuden alenemiseen.

Oxygen adsorption on Cu(510)

Tässä työssä on tutkittu kuparin (510)-askelpinnan reaktiivisuutta käyttäen apuna kvanttimekaanisia ab initio laskentamenetelmiä. Tutkimus on toteutettu laskemalla happiatomin adsorptioenergia ja tilatiheys erilaisissa potentiaalisissa adsorptiopaikoissa pinnalla. Myös happimolekyylin adsorptiota ja hajoamista ontarkasteltu laskemalla pintaa lähestyvälle molekyylille potentiaalienergiapintoja. Energiapintojen tuloksia on myös täydennetty kvanttimekaanisilla molekyylidynamiikkalaskuilla. Metallisia askelpintoja pidetään yleisesti sileitä pintoja reaktiivisempina happea kohtaan, johtuen askeleen reunan pienentävästä vaikutuksesta molekyylin hajoamisen tiellä olevaan energiavaliin. On kuitenkin olemassa myös tuloksia, jotka osoittavat hapen tarttumisprosessin olevan hallitseva juuri terassialueella, askeleen reunan sijasta. Tässä työssä on todettu hapen adsorboituvan Cu(510)-pinnalla tehokkaimmin juuri terassilla olevaan hollow-paikkaan. Myös adsorptioenergiat ovat tällä pinnalla pienempiä kuin sileällä (100)-pinnalla. Potentiaalienergiapintojen perusteella Cu(510)-pinnan todetaan myös olevan vähemmän reaktiivinen kuin askelpintojen yleisesti odotetaan olevan, vaikka askeleen reunan todetaankin pienentävän happiatominhajoamisen esteenä olevaa energiavallia.

Effect of antifoams on oxygen mass transfer in pulp and paper mill effluents

Vaahdonestoaineiden haitallinen vaikutus hapen liukenemisnopeuteen biologisen puhdistamon jätevesissä on yleisesti tunnettua. Aineiden eri vaikutusmekanismien takia on silti vaikea etukäteen arvioida, miten ja kuinka paljon aineensiirto muuttuu. Työn tavoitteena oli saada tietoa vaahdonestoaineiden ja muiden pinta-aktiivisten aineiden vaikutuksesta kuplakokoon, kaasun tilavuusosuuteen ja kaasu-neste aineensiirtoon. Työn teoriaosassa on kuvailtu vaahdon muodostumiseen vaikuttavia tekijöitä sekä eri vaahdonestoaineiden vaikutusmekanismeja sellu- ja paperitehtaan jätevedessä. Edelleen on esitetty useita hapen siirtoa estäviä ja parantavia aineita. Työn kokeellisessa osassa tutkittiin kahdenkymmenenviiden eri pinta-aktiivisen aineen vaikutusta hapen liukenemisnopeuteen yksivaiheisessa kuplakolonnissa. Kokeet tehtiin kahdella pitoisuudella, kahdella eri kaasunjakolaitteella ja kolmella eri kaasun tyhjäputkinopeudella. Aineensiirtokokeiden rinnalla tutkittiin jätevesien laatu- ja fysikaalisiaominaisuuksia, niiden vaikutusta hapen liukenemisnopeuteen sekä testattavien koeaineiden vaikutusta fysikaalisin ominaisuuksiin. Kokeet osoittavat että pinta-aktiivisten aineiden vaikutus hapen aineensiirtoon vaihtelee riippuen kaasunjakolaitteesta ja aineen pitoisuuksista. Testatuista vaahdonestonaineista pienin negatiivinen vaikutus oli aineella AT 35 ja positiivinen vaikutustodettiin olevan vaahdonestoaineiden komponenteilla: P2, S1, F4 ja T9.

The effect of oxygen delignification on fiber properties in kraft pulp production - a review

Fiber damages comprise fiber deformations, characterized as fiber curl, kink, dislocations and strength losses as well as some yet unidentified factors. This recently discovered phenomenon is especially evident in mill scale kraftpulps. Laboratory produced pulps tend to have less damages and superior strength properties compared to those produced in pulp mills. Generally fiber damages pose a problem in the production of reinforcement pulp because they tend to decrease the ability of fibers to transmit load. Previous studies on fiber damage have shown that most of the fiber damages occur during brown stock processing starting from cooking and discharging. This literature review gives an overall picture on fiber damages occurring during softwood kraft pulp production with an emphasis on the oxygen delignification stage. In addition the oxygen delignification stage itself is described in more detailed extent in order to understand the mechanisms behind the delignification and fiber damaging effect. The literature available on this subject is unfortunately quite contradictory and implicates a lotof different terms. Only a few studies have been published which help to understand the nature of fiber damages. For that reason the knowledge presented in this work is not only based on previous studies but also on research scientist and mill staff interviews.

Effects of Dietary Fat Oxidation Products and Flavonols on Lipoprotein Oxidation

Various studies suggest that oxidative modifications of low density lipoprotein (LDL), and also other lipoproteins, have an important role in the development of atherosclerosis. In addition to the oxidation products formed endogenously, oxidised triacylglycerols (TAG) and oxysterols in the diet contribute to the oxidised lipoproteins found in circulation. However, studies on both the effect of oxidised dietary lipids on lipoprotein lipid oxidation and the reactions that modify oxidised fat after ingestion have been scarce. Studies on the effects of dietary antioxidants on the lipid oxidation in vivo and the risk of atherosclerosis have been inconclusive. More clinical trials are needed to test the importance of lipoprotein oxidation as a cardiovascular risk factor in humans. In the recent years, various methods have been optimised and applied to the analysis of lipid oxidation products in vivo, and information on the molecular structures of oxidised lipids in plasma, lipoproteins and atherosclerotic plaques has started to accumulate. However, specific structures of oxidised TAG molecules present in these tissues and lipoprotein fractions have not been investigated earlier. In the orginal research in this thesis, an approach based on highperformance liquid chromatographyelectrospray ionisationmass spectrometry (HPLCESIMS) and baseline diene conjugation (BDC) methods was used in order to investigate lipid oxidation level and oxidised TAG molecular structures in pig and human lipoproteins after dietary interventions. The approach was optimised with human LDL samples, which contained various oxidation products of TAG. LDL particles of hyperlipidaemic subjects contained an elevated amount of conjugated dienes. In the pig studies, several oxidised TAG structures with hydroxy, keto, epoxy or aldehydic groups were found in chylomicrons and VLDL after diets rich in sunflower seed oil. Also, the results showed that oxidised sunflower seed oil increased the oxidation of lipoprotein lipids and their TAG molecules. TAG hydroperoxides could be detected neither in the small intestinal mucosa of the pigs fed on the oxidised oil nor in their chylomicrons or VLDL.6 In the clinical studies, dietary flavonol aglycones extracted from sea buckthorn berries did not have an effect on lipoprotein lipid oxidation and other potential risk factors of atherosclerosis, but their absorption was demonstrated. Oil supplementation seemed to increase the bioavailability of the flavonols. Oxidised TAG molecules were detected in LDL particles of the subjects after both flavonol and control diets.

Biologisen jätevedenpuhdistuksen ilmastuksen tehostaminen

Työssä tutkittiin, mikä on kustannustehokkain tapa lisätä ilmastuskapasiteettia ja selvitettiin, saostaako vesilaitokselta flotaatioaltaasta poistettava ferrisulfaattisakka jäteveden fosforia esiselkeyttimessä. Työssä määritettiin teoreettinen hapentarve ilmastusaltaassa maksimikuormituksen aikana ja hapensiirtonopeus jäteveteen olemassa olevalla laitteistolla. Hapensiirtonopeuden funktion korjauskertoimet  ja  sekä kokonaishapensiirtokerroin määritettiin laboratorio-olosuhteissa. Lisäksi laskettiin kuinka paljon nykyisten ilmastimien kautta saadaan happea jäteveteen liukenemaan ja verrattiin tätä lukua teoreettiseen hapentarpeeseen. Jälkimmäistä menettelytapaa käyttäen arvioitiin lisähapen tarve. Tulokseksi saatiin, että maksimi BOD-kuormituksen aikana happea tarvitsee saada jäteveteen liuotettua 5200 m³/d lisää. Ilmastuskapasiteetin lisäyksen kustannuslaskelmassa verrattiin neljää vaihtoehtoa: puhdasta happea liuotettuna happimattojen kautta tai OKI-ilmastimen kautta, onsite-happilaitoksen puhdasta happea liuotettuna OKI-ilmastimen kautta tai ilman happea liuotettuna jäteveteen EDI-ilmastimien kautta. Laskelmat osoittivat uusien EDI-ilmastimien hankinnan olevan edullisin vaihtoehto pitkällä aikavälillä. Vaikka EDI-ilmastimien investointikustannukset ovat korkeat, tulevat ne käyttökustannuksiltaan kaikkein edullisimmaksi. Vesilaitokselta tulevan rautasuolasakan fosforia saostavaa vaikutusta tutkittiin laboratoriossa astiakokein. Näytteet otettiin vesilaitokselta jätevesilaitokselle menevästä rautasuolasakasta sekä esiselkeyttimen kirkasteesta. Näitä eri suhteissa keskenään sekoittamalla saatiin selville, että rautasuolasakka ja sakan mukana tuleva reagoimaton rautasuola saostavat liukoista ja kokonaisfosforia esiselkeytyksessä.