Interactions between genes and alcohol on aggressive behavior and anger related traits : the oxytocin receptor gene as a candidate

Alkoholberusning är en av de starkaste riskfaktorerna för aggressivt beteende. Alla individer blir dock inte aggressiva under alkoholberusning. I sin doktorsavhandling undersökte Johansson ifall individens genetiska uppsättning kan förklara skillnader i vem som reagerar på alkohol med ökat aggressivt beteende och ilska och vem som inte gör det. Resultaten visade att individer som är bärare av en viss variant av genen som kodar för oxytocinets receptorer är i högre grad benägna att uppvisa aggressivt beteende än andra när de är alkoholberusade. Sambandet mellan alkohol och ilska påverkades även av individens genetiska uppsättning av två oxytocinreceptorgenvarianter, vilket antyder att dessa genvarianter även påverkar benägenheten att känna ilska under alkoholberusning. Oxytocinet, som fungerar både som ett hormon och en neurotransmittor, har i tidigare studier visats ha breda effekter på sociala förmågor hos människan, såsom förmåga till igenkännande av andras känslouttryck. Resultaten är de första att hos människan experimentellt påvisa att vissa individer beter sig mer aggressivt än andra när de är berusade, beroende på individens genetiska uppsättning. ”Det är viktigt att komma ihåg att genens effekt i det här fallet inte är av en sådan natur att den direkt och ofrånkomligen orsakar aggressivt beteende. Med andra ord är det orimligt i detta fall att tänka att en individ skulle tillmätas ansvarsfrihet i exempelvis ett våldsbrottmål om hon bär på en viss variant av denna gen”, påpekar Johansson. Oxytocinreceptorgenens effekter analyserades i två olika urval. I ett experimentellt upplägg indelades 116 män slumpässigt i två grupper: en grupp som tilldelades alkoholhaltiga drycker, och en kontrollgrupp som tilldelades alkoholfria drycker. Aggressivt beteende mättes med ett laboratorietest där försökspersonerna fick bestraffa en fiktiv motspelare genom att spela upp motbjudande ljud för denne. Resultaten replikerades i ett populationsbaserat urval av män och kvinnor (n = 3755) vilka besvarat frågor om deras aggressiva beteenden, ilska, och alkoholanvändning.

Effects of methylation and hydroxylation of sphingomyelins on their biophysical properties and interactions with cholesterol

Sfingomyeliner är viktiga sphingolipidmolekyler som finns i cellmembranets exoplastiska monolager. Sfingomyeliner är sällsynta i växter och mikroorganismer. Den enigmatiska sfingomelinmolekylen som Thudicum isolerade från hjärnvävnad i slutet på 1800-talet fick sitt namn på basen av det grekiska ordet”sfinx”. Sfingomyeliner återfinns speciallt rikligt i myelinskidorna i nervvävnad, var de sfingomyelinrika membranen bildar ett isolerande lager runt nervcellernas axoner. De polära sfingomyelinerna är viktiga beståndsdelar av ägg, mjölk och kött, och betraktas som viktiga näringsämnen speciellt för spädbarn. Det finns ett flertal sjukdomar uppstår på grund av defekter i sfingomyelinmetabolismen., t.ex. Niemann-Picks sjukdom, som är en obotlig ärftlig metabolisk sjukdom. Nyligen har det rapporterats att sfingomyelin tillsammans med kolesterol och specifika proteiner bildar funtionella domäner, s.k. membranflottar, i cellers membran. Membranflottar anses delta i många viktiga biologiska processer som t.ex. signalöverföring, lipid- och proteinsortering, apoptos, celladhesion, cellmigration och synapsers signalöverföring. Därför är det ytterst viktigt att förstå samverkan mellan sfingomyelin och kolesterol och hur denna samverkan påverkar bildandet membranflottar. I avhandlingen presenteras data från våra studier av sfingomyelin samverkan med kolesterol. För avhandlingen syntetiserade vi unika sfingomyelin molekyler genom att införa metyl- och hydroxylgrupper i olika positioner i sphingomyelinmolekylerna, med målet att lära oss mera om sphingomyelinets membranegenskaper och samverkan med kolesterol. Alla sfingomyelin molekyler som användes i avhandlingsarbetet är biologiskt relevanta. I studierna fann vi att hydroxyl- och amidgrupperna i sfingomyelin är viktiga i vätebindningar mellan sfingomyelinmolekyler samt mellan sfingomyelin och kolesterol. Vi upptäckte ytterligare att substition av metylgrupper i acylkedjan eller i interfasregionen hos sfingomyelinmolekyler signifikant destabiliserade sphingomyelin bilagret och försvagade/upphävde molekylernas samverkan med kolesterol. Hur sfingomyelinbilagrens stabilitet och sfingomyelinen-koleterol samverkan påverkades av hydroxylgrupper var beroende av hydrohygruppens position. Förekomst av en extra hydroxylgrupp i sfingomyelionmolekylens sfingoidbasen ökade stabilitetnen hos sfingomyelinbilagren samt stabiliserade sfingomyelinets samverkan med kolesterol.

The role of van der Waals interactions in the case of H2 adsorption on ruthenium (0001) surface

Computational material science with the Density Functional Theory (DFT) has recently gained a method for describing, for the first time the non local bonding i.e., van der Waals (vdW) bonding. The newly proposed van der Waals-Density Functional (vdW-DF) is employed here to address the role of non local interactions in the case of H2 adsorption on Ru(0001) surface. The later vdW-DF2 implementation with the DFT code VASP (Vienna Ab-initio Simulation Package) is used in this study. The motivation for studying H2 adsorption on ruthenium surface arose from the interest to hydrogenation processes. Potential energy surface (PES) plots are created for adsorption sites top, bridge, fcc and hcp, employing the vdW-DF2 functional. The vdW-DF yields 0.1 eV - 0.2 eV higher barriers for the dissociation of the H2 molecule; the vdW-DF seems to bind the H2 molecule more tightly together. Furthermore, at the top site, which is found to be the most reactive, the vdW functional suggests no entrance barrier or in any case smaller than 0.05 eV, whereas the corresponding calculation without the vdW-DF does. Ruthenium and H2 are found to have the opposite behaviors with the vdW-DF; Ru lattice constants are overestimated while H2 bond length is shorter. Also evaluation of the CPU time demand of the vdW-DF2 is done from the PES data. From top to fcc sites the vdW-DF computational time demand is larger by 4.77 % to 20.09 %, while at the hcp site it is slightly smaller. Also the behavior of a few exchange correlation functionals is investigated along addressing the role of vdW-DF. Behavior of the different functionals is not consistent between the Ru lattice constants and H2 bond lengths. It is thus difficult to determine the quality of a particular exchange correlation functional by comparing equilibrium separations of the different elements. By comparing PESs it would be computationally highly consuming.

Functional Genomic Approaches for Deciphering Plant-Virus Interactions

Plant-virus interactions are very complex in nature and lead to disease and symptom formation by causing various physiological, metabolic and developmental changes in the host plants. These interactions are mainly the outcomes of viral hijacking of host components to complete their infection cycles and of host defensive responses to restrict the viral infections. Viral genomes contain only a small number of genes often encoding for multifunctional proteins, and all are essential in establishing a viral infection. Thus, it is important to understand the specific roles of individual viral genes and their contribution to the viral life cycles. Among the most important viral proteins are the suppressors of RNA silencing (VSRs). These proteins function to suppress host defenses mediated by RNA silencing and can also serve in other functions, e.g. in viral movement, transactivation of host genes, virus replication and protein processing. Thus these proteins are likely to have a significant impact on host physiology and metabolism. In the present study, I have examined the plant-virus interactions and the effects of three different VSRs on host physiology and gene expression levels by microarray analysis of transgenic plants that express these VSR genes. I also studied the gene expression changes related to the expression of the whole genome of Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) in transgenic tobacco plants. Expression of the VSR genes in the transgenic tobacco plants causes significant changes in the gene expression profiles. HC-Pro gene derived from the Potyvirus Y (PVY) causes alteration of 748 and 332 transcripts, AC2 gene derived from the African cassava mosaic virus (ACMV) causes alteration of 1118 and 251transcripts, and P25 gene derived from the Potyvirus X (PVX) causes alterations of 1355 and 64 transcripts in leaves and flowers, respectively. All three VSRs cause similar up-regulation in defense, hormonally regulated and different stress-related genes and down-regulation in the photosynthesis and starch metabolism related genes. They also induce alterations that are specific to each viral VSR. The phenotype and transcriptome alterations of the HC-Pro expressing transgenic plants are similar to those observed in some Potyvirus-infected plants. The plants show increased protein degradation, which may be due to the HC-Pro cysteine endopeptidase and thioredoxin activities. The AC2-expressing transgenic plants show a similar phenotype and gene expression pattern as HC-Pro-expressing plants, but also alter pathways related to jasmonic acid, ethylene and retrograde signaling. In the P25 expressing transgenic plants, high numbers of genes (total of 1355) were up-regulated in the leaves, compared to a very low number of down-regulated genes (total of 5). Despite of strong induction of the transcripts, only mild growth reduction and no other distinct phenotype was observed in these plants. As an example of whole virus interactions with its host, I also studied gene expression changes caused by Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) in tobacco host in three different conditions, i.e. in transgenic plants that are first resistant to the virus, and then become susceptible to it and in wild type plants naturally infected with this virus. The microarray analysis revealed up and down-regulation of 1362 and 1422 transcripts in the TMV resistant young transgenic plants, and up and down-regulation of a total of 1150 and 1200 transcripts, respectively, in the older plants, after the resistance break. Natural TMV infections in wild type plants caused up-regulation of 550 transcripts and down-regulation of 480 transcripts. 124 up-regulated and 29 down-regulated transcripts were commonly altered between young and old TMV transgenic plants, and only 6 up-regulated and none of the down-regulated transcripts were commonly altered in all three plants. During the resistant stage, the strong down-regulation in translation-related transcripts (total of 750 genes) was observed. Additionally, transcripts related to the hormones, protein degradation and defense pathways, cell division and stress were distinctly altered. All these alterations may contribute to the TMV resistance in the young transgenic plants, and the resistance may also be related to RNA silencing, despite of the low viral abundance and lack of viral siRNAs or TMV methylation activity in the plants.

Membrane properties of structurally modified ceramides : effects on lipid lateral distribution and sphingomyelin-interactions in artificial bilayer membranes

Ceramides comprise a class of sphingolipids that exist only in small amounts in cellular membranes, but which have been associated with important roles in cellular signaling processes. The influences that ceramides have on the physical properties of bilayer membranes reach from altered thermodynamical behavior to significant impacts on the molecular order and lateral distribution of membrane lipids. Along with the idea that the membrane physical state could influence the physiological state of a cell, the membrane properties of ceramides have gained increasing interest. Therefore, membrane phenomena related to ceramides have become a subject of intense study both in cellular as well as in artificial membranes. Artificial bilayers, the so called model membranes, are substantially simpler in terms of contents and spatio-temporal variation than actual cellular membranes, and can be used to give detailed information about the properties of individual lipid species in different environments. This thesis focuses on investigating how the different parts of the ceramide molecule, i.e., the N-linked acyl chain, the long-chain sphingoid base and the membrane-water interface region, govern the interactions and lateral distribution of these lipids in bilayer membranes. With the emphasis on ceramide/sphingomyelin(SM)-interactions, the relevance of the size of the SMhead group for the interaction was also studied. Ceramides with methylbranched N-linked acyl chains, varying length sphingoid bases, or methylated 2N (amide-nitrogen) and 3O (C3-hydroxyl) at the interface region, as well as SMs with decreased head group size, were synthesized and their bilayer properties studied by calorimetric and fluorescence spectroscopic techniques. In brief, the results showed that the packing of the ceramide acyl chains was more sensitive to methyl-branching in the mid part than in the distal end of the N-linked chain, and that disrupting the interfacial structure at the amide-nitrogen, as opposed to the C3-hydroxyl, had greater effect on the interlipid interactions of ceramides. Interestingly, it appeared that the bilayer properties of ceramides could be more sensitive to small alterations in the length of the long-chain base than what was previously reported for the N-linked acyl chain. Furthermore, the data indicated that the SM-head group does not strongly influence the interactions between SMs and ceramides. The results in this thesis illustrate the pivotal role of some essential parts of the ceramide molecules in determining their bilayer properties. The thesis provides increased understanding of the molecular aspects of ceramides that possibly affect their functions in biological membranes, and could relate to distinct effects on cell physiology.

Phase variation in Flavobacterium psychrophilum : influence on host-pathogen interactions

-

Host Parasite Interactions in Damselflies. From Individuals to Populations

The main goal of this thesis is to increase understanding on evolutionary and ecological factors that have contributed to differences in parasite numbers in insects. Furthermore, the thesis addresses the effects of parasites on their hosts. The most important findings were: The Northern damselfly’s (Coenagrion hastulatum) immune response to artificial pathogen increased with increasing parasite numbers (Article I). Marginal, more isolated C. hastulatum populations on the edge of distribution have fewer parasites when compared to distribution’s core populations (Article II). The Banded damselfly Calopteryx splendens individuals with higher homozygosity have more parasites, however, the rate of homozygosity did not differ between populations (Article III). Parasite prevalence was affected by whether the host species occurred in allopatric or sympatric population: sympatric C. splendens populations with sister species the Beautiful damselfly Calopteryx virgo harbored more parasites (Article IV). Parasites were associated with the wing spot size, an ornament under sexual selection, and thus may play an important role in character displacement, i.e. the size of the wing spot (Article V). To conclude with, this thesis brings about new information on the parasite infection patterns in insects, proposing several factors to contribute to these patters, as well as it addresses the effects of parasites on their hosts, from individual to population level.

Molecular Mechanisms and Interactions in Regulation of Photosynthetic Reactions

In photosynthesis, light energy is converted to chemical energy, which is consumed for carbon assimilation in the Calvin-Benson-Bassham (CBB) cycle. Intensive research has significantly advanced the understanding of how photosynthesis can survive in the ever-changing light conditions. However, precise details concerning the dynamic regulation of photosynthetic processes have remained elusive. The aim of my thesis was to specify some molecular mechanisms and interactions behind the regulation of photosynthetic reactions under environmental fluctuations. A genetic approach was employed, whereby Arabidopsis thaliana mutants deficient in specific photosynthetic protein components were subjected to adverse light conditions and assessed for functional deficiencies in the photosynthetic machinery. I examined three interconnected mechanisms: (i) auxiliary functions of PsbO1 and PsbO2 isoforms in the oxygen evolving complex of photosystem II (PSII), (ii) the regulatory function of PGR5 in photosynthetic electron transfer and (iii) the involvement of the Calcium Sensing Receptor CaS in photosynthetic performance. Analysis of photosynthetic properties in psbo1 and psbo2 mutants demonstrated that PSII is sensitive to light induced damage when PsbO2, rather than PsbO1, is present in the oxygen evolving complex. PsbO1 stabilizes PSII more efficiently compared to PsbO2 under light stress. However, PsbO2 shows a higher GTPase activity compared to PsbO1, and plants may partially compensate the lack of PsbO1 by increasing the rate of the PSII repair cycle. PGR5 proved vital in the protection of photosystem I (PSI) under fluctuating light conditions. Biophysical characterization of photosynthetic electron transfer reactions revealed that PGR5 regulates linear electron transfer by controlling proton motive force, which is crucial for the induction of the photoprotective non-photochemical quenching and the control of electron flow from PSII to PSI. I conclude that PGR5 controls linear electron transfer to protect PSI against light induced oxidative damage. I also found that PGR5 physically interacts with CaS, which is not needed for photoprotection of PSII or PSI in higher plants. Rather, transcript profiling and quantitative proteomic analysis suggested that CaS is functionally connected with the CBB cycle. This conclusion was supported by lowered amounts of specific calciumregulated CBB enzymes in cas mutant chloroplasts and by slow electron flow to PSI electron acceptors when leaves were reilluminated after an extended dark period. I propose that CaS is required for calcium regulation of the CBB cycle during periods of darkness. Moreover, CaS may also have a regulatory role in the activation of chloroplast ATPase. Through their diverse interactions, components of the photosynthetic machinery ensure optimization of light-driven electron transport and efficient basic production, while minimizing the harm caused by light induced photodamage.

Flavonoids and other phenolic compounds: characterization and interactions with lepidopteran and sawfly larvae

This thesis focuses on flavonoids, a subgroup of phenolic compounds produced by plants, and how they affect the herbivorous larvae of lepidopterans and sawflies. The first part of the literature review examines different techniques to analyze the chemical structures of flavonoids and their concentrations in biological samples. These techniques include, for example, ultraviolet-visible spectroscopy, mass spectrometry, and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. The second part of the literature review studies how phenolic compounds function in the metabolism of larvae. The harmful oxidation reactions of phenolic compounds in insect guts are also emphasized. In addition to the negative effects, many insect species have evolved the use of phenolic compounds for their own benefit. In the experimental part of the thesis, high concentrations of complex flavonoid oligoglycosides were found in the hemolymph (the circulatory fluid of insects) of birch and pine sawflies. The larvae produced these compounds from simple flavonoid precursors present in the birch leaves and pine needles. Flavonoid glycosides were also found in the cocoon walls of sawflies, which suggested that flavonoids were used in the construction of cocoons. The second part of the experimental work studied the modifications of phenolic compounds in conditions that mimicked the alkaline guts of lepidopteran larvae. It was found that the 24 plant species studied and their individual phenolic compounds had variable capacities to function as oxidative defenses in alkaline conditions. The excrements of lepidopteran and sawfly species were studied to see how different types of phenolics were processed by the larvae. These results suggested that phenolic compounds were oxidized, hydrolyzed, or modified in other ways during their passage through the digestive tract of the larvae.

Hyperfine interactions in the new Fe-based superconducting structures and related magnetic phases

This thesis is devoted to the study of the hyperfine properties in iron-based superconductors and the synthesis of these compounds and related phases. During this work polycrystalline chalcogenide samples with stoichiometry 1:1 (FeTe1-χSχ, FeSe1-x) and pnictide samples with stoichiometry 1:2:2 (BaFe2(As1-χPχ)2, EuFe2(As1-x Px)2) were synthesized by solid-state reaction methods in vacuum and in a protecting Ar atmosphere. In several cases post-annealing in oxygen atmosphere was employed. The purity and superconducting properties of the obtained samples were checked with X-ray diffraction, SQUID and resistivity measurements. For studies of the magnetic properties of the investigated samples Mössbauer spectroscopy was used. Using low-temperature measurements around Tc and various values of the source velocity the hyperfine interactions were obtained and the magnetic and structural properties in the normal and superconducting states could be studied. Mössbauer measurements together with XRD characterization were also used for the detection of impurity phases. DFT calculations were used for the theoretical study of Mössbauer parameters for pnictide-based ᴻsamples BaFe2(As1-xPx)2 and EuFe2(As1-xPx)2.

VAP-1 as drug target in inflammation : structural features determining ligand interactions

Vascular adhesion protein-1 (VAP-1), which belongs to the copper amine oxidases (CAOs), is a validated drug target in inflammatory diseases. Inhibition of VAP-1 blocks the leukocyte trafficking to sites of inflammation and alleviates inflammatory reactions. In this study, a novel set of potent pyridazinone inhibitors is presented together with their X-ray structure complexes with VAP-1. The crystal structure of serum VAP-1 (sVAP-1) revealed an imidazole binding site in the active site channel and, analogously, the pyridazinone inhibitors were designed to bind into the channel. This is the first time human VAP-1 has been crystallized with a reversible inhibitor and the structures reveal detailed information of the binding mode on the atomic level. Similarly to some earlier studied inhibitors of human VAP-1, the designed pyridazinone inhibitors bind rodent VAP-1 with a lower affinity than human VAP-1. Therefore, we made homology models of rodent VAP-1 and compared human and rodent enzymes to determine differences that might affect the inhibitor binding. The comparison of the crystal structures of the human VAP-1 and the mouse VAP-1 homology model revealed key differences important for the species specific binding properties. In general, the channel in mouse VAP-1 is more narrow and polar than the channel in human VAP-1, which is wider and more hydrophobic. The differences are located in the channel leading to the active site, as well as, in the entrance to the active site channel. The information obtained from these studies is of great importance for the development and design of drugs blocking the activity of human VAP-1, as rodents are often used for in vivo testing of candidate drugs. In order to gain more insight into the selective binding properties of the different CAOs in one species a comprehensive evolutionary study of mammalian CAOs was performed. We found that CAOs can be classified into sub-families according to the residues X1 and X2 of the Thr/Ser-X1-X2-Asn-Tyr-Asp active site motif. In the phylogenetic tree, CAOs group into diamine oxidase, retina specific amine oxidase and VAP-1/serum amine oxidase clades based on the residue in the position X2. We also found that VAP-1 and SAO can be further differentiated based on the residue in the position X1. This is the first large-scale comparison of CAO sequences, which explains some of the reasons for the unique substrate specificities within the CAO family.

Unconventional integrin-ligand interactions

Integrins are cell surface adhesion and signaling receptors. Cells use integrins to attach to the extracellular matrix and to other cells, as well as for sensing their environment. In addition to adhesion and migration, integrins have been shown to be important for many biological processes including apoptosis, cell proliferation, and differentiation into specific tissues. Many important next generation biological drugs inhibit integrin functions. Thus, research into interactions between integrins and their ligands under different physiological and pathological conditions is not only of academic interest, but is also important for the field of drug discovery. In this Ph.D. project, the functions of integrin-ligand interactions were studied under different physiologically interesting conditions including 1) human echovirus 1 binding to integrin α2β1, 2) integrin α2β1 binding to collagen under flow conditions, 3) integrin α2β1 binding to a ligand in the presence of the angiogenesis inhibitor histidine rich glycoprotein (HRG) and 4) integrin binding to posttranslationally citrullinated ligands. As a result of the project, we could show that for each condition the integrin-ligand interaction is somewhat unconventional. 1) Echovirus 1 binds only to non-activated conformations of integrin α2β1. 2) Surprisingly, the non-activated conformation is also the primary conformation of integrin α2β1 when it binds to collagen under flow conditions, like when platelets adhere to subendothelial collagen in vascular injuries. In addition, the pre-activation of integrin α2β1 does not increase adhesion under flow. 3) HRG binds to integrin α2β1 through a low-affinity interaction that inhibits integrin binding to collagen. This shows that low affinity interactions could be biologically relevant and possibly regulate angiogenesis. 4) The citrullination of collagen, a posttranslational modification reported to occur in rheumatoid arthritis, specifically inhibits the binding of integrin α10β1 and α11β1, but does not affect the binding of α1β1 ja α2β1. On the other hand, the citrullination of isoDGR in fibronectin and RGD in pro-TGF- β:n inhibit integrin binding completely. Citrullination seems to be an inflammation related process and integrin ligands become citrullinated frequently in vivo. This Ph.D. thesis suggests that unconventional interaction mechanisms between integrins and their ligands, such as posttranslational modifications, low affinity interactions, and non-activated integrin conformations, can have an important role in pathological processes. The study of these kinds of integrin-ligand interactions is important for understanding biological phenomena more deeply. The research might also be beneficial for the development of integrin based therapies for treating diseases.

Probing MST1 Kinase Sequence and Structure for Rational Drug Discovery (Targeting diabetes by blocking protein-protein interactions)

Apoptotic beta cell death is an underlying cause majorly for type I and to a lesser extent for type II diabetes. Recently, MST1 kinase was identified as a key apoptotic agent in diabetic condition. In this study, I have examined MST1 and closely related kinases namely, MST2, MST3 and MST4, aiming to tackle diabetes by exploring ways to selectively block MST1 kinase activity. The first investigation was directed towards evaluating possibilities of selectively blocking the ATP binding site of MST1 kinase that is essential for the activity of the enzymes. Structure and sequence analyses of this site however revealed a near absolute conservation between the MSTs and very few changes with other kinases. The observed residue variations also displayed similar physicochemical properties making it hard for selective inhibition of the enzyme. Second, possibilities for allosteric inhibition of the enzyme were evaluated. Analysis of the recognized allosteric site also posed the same problem as the MSTs shared almost all of the same residues. The third analysis was made on the SARAH domain, which is required for the dimerization and activation of MST1 and MST2 kinases. MST3 and MST4 lack this domain, hence selectivity against these two kinases can be achieved. Other proteins with SARAH domains such as the RASSF proteins were also examined. Their interaction with the MST1 SARAH domain were evaluated to mimic their binding pattern and design a peptide inhibitor that interferes with MST1 SARAH dimerization. In molecular simulations the RASSF5 SARAH domain was shown to strongly interact with the MST1 SARAH domain and possibly preventing MST1 SARAH dimerization. Based on this, the peptidic inhibitor was suggested to be based on the sequence of RASSF5 SARAH domain. Since the MST2 kinase also interacts with RASSF5 SARAH domain, absolute selectivity might not be achieved.