Performance Comparison of Behavioral Finance -based Investment Strategies in the Finnish Stock Market 1996-2010

In this thesis traditional investment strategies (value and growth) are compared to modern investment strategies (momentum, contrarian and GARP) in terms of risk, performance and cumulative returns. Strategies are compared during time period reaching from 1996 to 2010 in the Finnish stock market. Used data includes all listed main list stocks, dividends and is adjusted in case of splits, and mergers and acquisitions. Strategies are tested using different holding periods (6, 12 and 36 months) and data is divided into tercile portfolios based on different ranking criteria. Contrarian and growth strategies are the only strategies with improved cumulative returns when longer holding periods are used. Momentum (52-week high price1) and GARP strategies based on short holding period have the best performance and contrarian and growth strategies the worst. Momentum strategies (52-week high price) along with short holding period contrarian strategies (52-week low price2) have the lowest risk. Strategies with the highest risk are both growth strategies and two momentum strategies (52-week low price). The empirical results support the efficiency of momentum, GARP and value strategies. The least efficient strategies are contrarian and growth strategies in terms of risk, performance and cumulative returns. Most strategies outperform the market portfolio in all three measures. 1 Stock ranking criterion (current price/52-week highest price) 2 Stock ranking criterion (current price/52-week lowest price)

Liquidity Risk in the Finnish Stock Market

This study explores the pricing of liquidity risk and its effect on stock returns in the Finnish stock market. In addition to that, it investigates whether there is a trend in liquidity risk. Finally, it analyzes whether the two chosen liquidity measures provide different results. The data consists of all the common shares listed in the Finnish stock market during the period of 1/1997–7/2015. To examine whether liquidity risk affects stock returns in the Finnish stock market, this study utilizes a conditional version of liquidity-adjusted capital asset pricing model (LCAPM) by Acharya and Pedersen (2005). Two recently proposed illiquidity measures – PQS and AdjILLIQ – are used in the empirical estimation to see whether there are differences in the results between the measures. The time-varying conditional liquidity risks are estimated by using a multivariate DCC-GARCH model, while the pricing of the liquidity risk is conducted by applying fixed effect panel regression. The results imply that investors in the Finnish stock market are willing to pay a premium to hedge from wealth shocks and having liquid assets during the declined market liquidity. However, investors are not willing to pay a premium for stocks with higher returns during illiquid markets. The total annualized illiquidity premiums found in the Finnish stock market are 1.77% and 1.04%, based on the PQS and AdjILLIQ measures, respectively. The study also shows that liquidity risk does not exhibit decreasing trend, and investors should consider liquidity risk in their portfolio diversification in the Finnish stock market.

Suomalaisen rahastosijoittajan profiili

Tutkimuksen tarkoituksena on luoda suomalaisen rahastosijoittajan profiili. Tutkimuskohteena ovat sijoittajien demografiset ominaisuudet, rahastosijoitukset sekä rahastotransaktiot. Aineistona on erään suomalaisen rahastoyhtiön henkilöasiakastietokanta vuosilta 1998 - 2003. Tutkimustulosten mukaan rahastosijoittaminen on yleistynyt Suomessa viime vuosien aikana. Erityisesti naisten määrä rahastosijoittajien joukossa on kasvussa. Rahastosijoitusten suuruus riippuu sijoittajan iästä sekä sukupuolesta. Mitä vanhempi sijoittaja on, sitä enemmän hän on sijoittanut rahastoihin. Lisäksi miehet sijoittavat suurempia summia kuin naiset. Viimeisten kolmen vuoden aikana suomalaisten rahastosijoittajien sijoituskohteiden painopiste on muuttunut riskillisemmistä rahastoista vähäriskisiin rahastoihin, erityisesti lyhyen koron rahastoihin. Osakemarkkinoiden mennyt kehitys vaikuttaa sijoituspäätöksiin. Rahastosijoittajien markkina-ajoituskyky on kuitenkin melko heikko. Miehet tekevät aktiivisemmin merkintöjä ja lunastuksia ja lisäksi reagoivat naisia nopeammin markkinoiden muutoksiin.

Subjectivity in the valuation : Case study on the Finnish biotechnology industry

The thesis combines valuation and behavioral economics literature, which is not common among the Finnish management accounting research. Furthermore, the valuation is studied in biotechnology context and those type of studies are rather rare as well. The thesis studies the valuation in the Finnish biotechnology industry. The concepts of behavioral finance are employed in the empirical part of the study to explore decision-makers’ behavior in valuation processes. The main interest of this study is to explore how subjectivity of a decision-maker affects the valuation in the biotechnology industry. The valuation is studied from two perspectives. First, what is the best valuation model for biotechnology companies suggested by the valuation literature? Second, how the valuation in biotechnology industry is done in practice and how the decision-makers subjectivity affects the valuation? The literature review aims at seeking the best valuation model. The real options were found to be the most suitable valuation model for biotechnology companies, especially in the early stages of product development. The real option’s ability to take the value of the inherent options into account results in theoretically most correct valuations. The only disadvantage is the model’s complexity when compared to other models, such as discounted cash flow models. The empirical part of the study consists of a case study, which examines the valuation practices of the Finnish biotechnology companies. When it comes to the valuation models used in practice, it was found that the companies were using rather simple valuation models, which was due to two reasons. First, the interviewees did not believe in the valuation models and second, they were familiar neither with the most sophisticated models nor with all the theoretical aspects of the models they were using. The material for the study was collected with theme interviews. Four CEO’s of highly successful Finnish biotechnology companies. Strong signs of the decision-makers’ subjectivity in valuation were observed. Most obvious were the signs of framing. Furthermore, herding, excessive optimism, and overconfidence were present. All the behavioral concepts observed most likely have a severe effect on the valuation. As a result, the valuation can easily become overly optimistic, which leads to overvalued investments and to continuation of already unprofitable projects. Framing had the strongest evidence. If the product being valued is framed successfully, the risk of overvaluation is high, thus a strong belief can justify almost any value.

Consumption of Fashion Luxury Brands

The main objective of this study is to find out why people buy luxury brands and which factors influence their decisions. The elements of luxury brands as well as motivation, culture and self-concept is researched as being the main factors behind luxury consumption. It was important to conduct this study because the luxury market is growing with a fast pace and it has hardly been research before. This study was conducted as a qualitative research. Theoretical part is based on the literature and on researches conducted before about the matter. Purposeful sampling method was used in empirical part by interviewing designers Jukka Rintala and Hanna Sarén as well as consumers of luxury brands, who work in the fashion industry. Two different viewpoints were chosen in order to research if designers’ and consumers’ thoughts differed. This study shows that the elements of luxury brands are deemed pretty much the same all around the world and also between the designers and consumers interviewed. Exclusivity referring to unique design and “hard to get” as well as good quality meaning superior materials, were mentioned as the most important elements of luxury brands. According to this study motivation behind luxury consumption is to a great extent dependent on the culture where the luxuries are consumed. However, self-concept has the biggest effect on luxury consumption. This study shows that people in individualistic cultures buy luxuries because they want to. People tend to spoil themselves and show off, thus making them feel good when buying luxuries. However, uniqueness is appreciated. On contrast, in collectivistic cultures people buy luxuries because they have to. Social pressure is much greater in Eastern than in Western culture that being the reason wealth is expected show. This study shows that in some cases designers' and consumers' thoughts about luxury consumption differ. Especially, a big gap was found when talking about materialism behind luxury consumption. The designers did not believe it to be the reason behind luxury consumption where consumers strongly did.

Tietointensiivisten yrityspalveluiden tuotteistaminen Case: Lappeenrannan teknillisen yliopiston Tietohallinto

Työ käsittelee tietohallintoa tietointensiivisenä yrityspalveluna Lappeenrannan teknillisessä yliopistossa. Yliopiston tulee keskittyä omaan ydinosaamiseensa sekä erottaa sisäiset yrityspalvelut omiksi kokonaisuuksikseen. Tähän on käytetty tietohallinnon osalta tilaaja tuottajamallia. Mallin puitteissa tietohallintoyksikkö on kattavasti tunnistanut ja määritellyt oman toimintansa sekä asiakkaidensa perustarpeet. Tietohallinnon palvelut ovat tietointensiivisiä yrityspalveluita, joiden tarkoituksena on täydentää asiakkaiden osaamista ja kykyä tuottaa innovaatioita sekä välittää muualla tuotettua tietoa ja teknisiä ratkaisuja tähän tarpeeseen. Tietointensiivisen palveluntuottajan asiantuntijuus on kokemusperäistä ja hiljaista tietoa, jota on lähtökohtaisesti vaikea muuttaa organisatoriseksi tiedoksi eli lisäarvoksi organisaation toiminnalle. Tuotteistamista on hyödynnetty tietohallinnon prosessien muuttamiseksi eksplisiittisiksi. Tuotteistamalla standardoidaan prosesseihin liittyvät parhaat käytänteet, joka tarkoittaa kokemusperäisesti hyväksi havaittujen toimintatapojen rutinoimista. Tuotetut palvelut on tuotteistettu palvelupaketeiksi, joista on laadittu yksityiskohtainen palvelukuvaus sekä laskettu tuotekohtainen hinta. Palvelumallin soveltaminen takaa yksikkökustannusten, skaalaetujen, riskin jakaantumisen ja teknologisen kehityksen optimoinnin yliopistossa.

The Evolution of Securities Lending and Risk Mitigation: A Finnish Market Case Study

Although securities lending is an important function of the financial markets, it has not received that much academic attention. This study examines the evolution of European securities lending and risk management with an emphasis on the development of collateral management, the function responsible for reducing credit risk. The effects of the recent financial instabilities are also considered. The evolution of the Finnish securities lending market is examined in more detail through a case-study. This study can be classified as a constructive qualitative case study. The initial practical knowledge comes from the author's own experience and additional insight and theoretical background is acquired through a literature review. The case study is based on research, semi-structured interviews and a brief analysis of numerical data. The main observation of this study was that securities lending is now recognized as more of an investment management discipline than an operational support function. The recent financial instabilities have resulted in an increased focus on risk and transparency. In securities lending this is directly reflected in collateral management guidelines and procedures. Collateral management has become increasingly technologically developed and automated. Collateral optimization initiatives have been started to make the process more efficient, liquid, and cost effective. Although securities lending is generally an OTC-market with no standard market place, centralized exchange-like models have been introduced. Finnish securities lending has now shifted towards the more common global OTC model. Although the Finnish securities lending industry has developed, and the main laws governing it (tax legislation) have changed, there is still need for development. There are still not many Finnish participants involved and due to legal issues most securities loans are collateralized with cash and not securities (e.g. government bonds).

Omnibus accounts to Finnish investors? – An analysis of the costs and benefits that omnibus account structure brings to Finnish account operators and investors

The Finnish Securities Markets are being harmonized to enable better, more reliable and timely settlement of securities. Omnibus accounts are a common practice in the European securities markets. Finland forbids the use of omnibus accounts from its domestic investors. There is a possibility that the omnibus account usage is allowed for Finnish investors in the future. This study aims to build a comprehensive image to Finnish investors and account operators in determining the costs and benefits that the omnibus account structure would have for them. This study uses qualitative research methods. A literature review provides the framework for this study. Different kinds of research articles, regulatory documents, studies performed by European organisations, and Finnish news reportages are used to analyse the costs and benefits of omnibus accounts. The viewpoint is strictly of account operators and investors, and different effects on them are contemplated. The results of the analysis show that there are a number of costs and benefits that investors and account operators must take into consideration regarding omnibus accounts. The costs are related to development of IT-systems so that participants are able to adapt to the new structure and operate according to its needs. Decrease in the holdings’ transparency is a disadvantage of the structure and needs to be assessed precisely to avoid some problems it might bring. Benefits are mostly related to the increased competition in the securities markets as well as to the possible cost reductions of securities settlement. The costs and benefits were analysed according to the study plan of this thesis and as a result, the significance and impact of omnibus accounts to Finnish investors and account operators depends on the competition level and the decisions that all market participants make when determining if the account structure is beneficial for their operations.

Ohjelmistoalan pk-yrityksen kansainvälistyminen

Pienen ohjelmistoyrityksen kansainvälistyminen on haasteellista niukkojen resurssien ja dynaamisen liiketoimintaympäristön paineessa. Työn tarkoituksena on selvittää sitä, millaisin perustein pieni tai keskisuuri ohjelmistotekniikan yritys tekee päätöksen kansainvälisille markkinoille siirtymisestä ja millaisen toimintamuodon yritys valitsee uudella markkinalla. Työn teoreettinen osa käsittelee päätöksenteon taustalla olevia vaikuttavia tekijöitä liiketoimintaympäristön, yritysjohdon ja yrityksen erityispiirteiden näkökulmista. Empiirinen osa on toteutettu kanden laajan ja neljän suppean yrityshaastat- telun muodossa. Karkeasti jaoteltuna yrityksen kansainvälistymiseen käyttämä polku voi olla joko orgaaniseen kasvuunperustuva tai Born Global-tyyppinen. Tutkimus nosti esille kansainvälistymispolun valintaan vaikuttavina tekijöinä yrittäjien riskinottohalukkuuden ja kansainvälisen kokemuksen, tuotteen palveluintensiivisyyden asteen sekä toimintakon- septin markkina- tai tuoteorientaation. Yleisellä tasolla korkea riskinottohalu, vähäinen kansainvälinen kokemus, standardinomainen tuote ja markkinaorientoitunut toimintatapa kannustivat yritystä valitsemaan Born Global-tyyppisen kansainvälistymispolun. Vastaavasti pieni riskinottohalu, runsaampi kansainvälinen kokemus, palveluintensiivinen tuote ja tuoteorientoitunut toimintatapa olivat kannustimia orgaaniselle kasvulle kansainvälisesti.

Determinants of credit default swap spread: evidence from european credit derivatives market

Tämän tutkielman tavoitteena on selvittää, mitkä tekijät vaikuttavat yrityksen ja valtion velkakirjojen väliseen tuottoeroon. Strukturaalisten luottoriskin hinnoittelumallien mukaan luottoriskiin vaikuttavia tekijöitä ovat yrityksen velkaantumisaste, volatiliteetti ja riskitön korkokanta. Tavoitteena on erityisesti tutkia, kuinka hyvin nämä teoreettiset tekijät selittävät tuottoeroja ja onko olemassa muita tärkeitä selittäviä tekijöitä. Luottoriskinvaihtosopimusten noteerauksia käytetään tuottoerojen määrittämiseen. Selittävät tekijät koostuvat sekä yrityskohtaisista että markkinalaajuisista muuttujista. Luottoriskinvaihtosopimusten ja yrityskohtaisten muuttujien data on kerätty yhteensä 50 yritykselle Euroalueen maista. Aineisto koostuu kuukausittaisista havainnoista aikaväliltä 01.01.2003-31.12.2006. Empiiriset tulokset osoittavat, että strukturaalisten mallien mukaiset tekijät selittävät vain pienen osan tuottoeron muutoksista yli ajan. Toisaalta nämä teoreettiset tekijät selittävät huomattavasti paremmin tuottoeron vaihtelua yli poikkileikkauksen. Muut kuin teoreettiset tekijät pystyvät selittämään suuren osan tuottoeron vaihtelusta. Erityisen tärkeäksi tuottoeron selittäväksi tekijäksi osoittautui yleinen riskipreemio velkakirjamarkkinoilla. Tulokset osoittavat, että luottoriskin hinnoittelumalleja on kehitettävä edelleenniin, että ne ottaisivat huomioon yrityskohtaisten tekijöiden lisäksi myös markkinalaajuisia tekijöitä.

Sähkönmyyntisopimusten markkinalähtöinen hinnoittelu

Vuonna 1995 alkanut sähkömarkkinoiden vapautuminen on muuttanut sähköyhtiöiden myyntisopimusten hinnoittelua merkittävästi. Ennen markkinauudistusta voitiin sähkön myyntisopimukset hinnoitella perustuen oman sähkön tuotannon kustannuksiin ja haluttuun katteeseen. Nykyään sähköpörssissä noteerattava sähkön hinta muodostaa perustan kaikkien myyntisopimusten hinnoittelulle. Sähkön markkinahinnan lisäksi on myyntisopimusten hinnoittelussa otettava huomioon sähkömarkkinoiden ominaispiirteistä aiheutuvat riskit sähkön myyjälle. Tässä työssä mallinnetaan Lappeenrannan Energia Oy:n markkinalähtöiset hinnoittelumenetelmät kahdelle sähkönmyyntisopimustyypille. Lisäksi tutkitaan markkinalähtöisen hinnoittelun tärkeimpien riskikomponenttien, aluehintaeron sekä profiililisän, merkitystä markkinalähtöisten myyntisopimusten hinnoittelussa. Aluehintaeron hyväksikäyttöä myyntisopimusten hinnoittelussa on tutkittu selvittämällä Suomen hinta-alueen CfD-johdannaisten riskipreemiot. Profiililisän merkitystä myyntisopimusten hinnoittelussa on tutkittu havainnoimalla profiililisän muutoksia hinta- ja kulutusaikasarjoissa sekä suojaushinta ja tehotasossa tapahtuneiden muutosten suhteen. Ennustetun ja toteutuneen profiililisän eroja on tutkittu laskemalla ne seitsemälle Lappeenrannan Energia Oy:n merkittävälle asiakkaalle. Lisäksi on tarkasteltu profiililisän laskentaan tarvittavan hinta-aikasarjan mallintamiseen käytettyjen termiinituotteiden hintojen merkitystä lasketun profiililisän suuruuteen. Työn lopuksi esitetään kaksi vaihtoehtoista sähkösopimusten hinnoittelumenetelmää ja vertaillaan esitettyjä hinnoittelumenetelmiä keskenään. Työssä havaitaan, että aluehintaerolta suojautumiseen käytettävien CfD-johdannaisten avulla olisi ollut mahdollista lisätä markkinalähtöisten myyntisopimusten tuottoa viimeisen kolmen vuoden aikana. Suoritettujen herkkyysanalyysien perusteella voidaan todeta, että toteutuneen ja ennustetun profiililisän erot johtuvat laskentaan käytettävien hinta- sekä kulutusaikasarjojen epätarkkuudesta. Lappeenrannan Energia Oy:n käyttämät profiililisät osoittautuivat ex-post -tarkastelussa liian suuriksi yhtä asiakasta lukuun ottamatta. Lisäksi tarjousaikana laskettujen profiililisien voidaan katsoa muuttuvan täysin samassa suhteessa hinta-aikasarjan mallintamiseen käytettyjen termiinituotteiden volatiliteettien kanssa. Esiteltyjen vaihtoehtoisten myyntisopimusten hinnoittelumenetelmien voidaan katsoa antavan varsin samanlaisia tuloksia kuin Lappeenrannan Energia Oy:n nykyinen hinnoittelumenetelmä. Saatuihin tuloksiin vaikuttavat kuitenkin painokertoimien estimointiin käytetyn vuoden volatiliteetti sekä profiililisän laskentamenetelmä

Tests of International Asset Pricing Models in Scandinavian Stock Markets

This thesis examines whether global, local and exchange risks are priced in Scandinavian countries’ equity markets by using conditional international asset pricing models. The employed international asset pricing models are the world capital asset pricing model, the international asset pricing model augmented with the currency risk, and the partially segmented model augmented with the currency risk. Moreover, this research traces estimated equity risk premiums for the Scandinavian countries. The empirical part of the study is performed using generalized method of moments approach. Monthly observations from February 1994 to June 2007 are used. Investors’ conditional expectations are modeled using several instrumental variables. In order to keep system parsimonious the prices of risk are assumed to be constant whereas expected returns and conditional covariances vary over time. The empirical findings of this thesis suggest that the prices of global and local market risk are priced in the Scandinavian countries. This indicates that the Scandinavian countries are mildly segmented from the global markets. Furthermore, the results show that the exchange risk is priced in the Danish and Swedish stock markets when the partially segmented model is augmented with the currency risk factor.

Nordic banks’ entry into the Russian market: motives, processes and challenges

The importance of services in the global economy has grown steadily in the past decades and the growth of services sector’s direct investments has been increasing. Nowadays, all companies are influenced by the much changing global environment and the financial services companies are no exception. The internationalization of financial services companies is an expanding and accelerating phenomenon which has various motivations. The overall aim of this thesis is to shed light on the market entry processes of the Nordic financial services companies when they have entered the Russian market. In this study, the factors affecting Nordic banks’ market entry to Russia are presented in order to better understand what have been the main motives for market entry, what kind of processes the banks have used and what kind of challenges they have faced along the way. A case study approach was used in conducting the empirical research and it aims at investigating a specific case: Nordic banks’ entry into the Russian market. The empirical research was carried out by conducting qualitative interviews for employees involved in entry processes of the case banks. These interviews aimed at examining the Nordic banks’ motives for entering the Russian financial market. This includes reflections on the reasons why the studied banks have decided to enter Russia and what have been the motives behind these decisions. Also, the market entry processes the banks have used when they have entered the Russian market were investigated. The findings allowed comparing the related theories and different market entry modes the case banks have used. Furthermore, the market-related challenges faced by the case banks were mapped and described. In addition, the main factors related to the entry processes of the studied banks were identified and key elements of successful market entry were mapped. The findings suggest that the main motivator for banks have been to follow their customers and hence, increase the revenues and add the value to the shareholders; consequently, being a win-win-win situation to all the related parties. It was also discovered that the banks market entry processes have had resemblances but the banks have taken different paths to get where they are nowadays. As the Russian market environment differs from the one in Nordic countries, also challenges were faced by the case banks. However, the internal challenges were considered more troublesome than the external ones. As the foreign market entry process is complex as well as time and resources consuming, it is vital to understand the specifics of the target market, organizational capabilities and individuals enabling a successful entry process.