Theoretical Analysis and Simulations of Vertically Vibrated Granular Materials

The dynamical properties ofshaken granular materials are important in many industrial applications where the shaking is used to mix, segregate and transport them. In this work asystematic, large scale simulation study has been performed to investigate the rheology of dense granular media, in the presence of gas, in a three dimensional vertical cylinder filled with glass balls. The base wall of the cylinder is subjected to sinusoidal oscillation in the vertical direction. The viscoelastic behavior of glass balls during a collision, have been studied experimentally using a modified Newton's Cradle device. By analyzing the results of the measurements, using numerical model based on finite element method, the viscous damping coefficient was determinedfor the glass balls. To obtain detailed information about the interparticle interactions in a shaker, a simplified model for collision between particles of a granular material was proposed. In order to simulate the flow of surrounding gas, a formulation of the equations for fluid flow in a porous medium including particle forces was proposed. These equations are solved with Large Eddy Simulation (LES) technique using a subgrid-model originally proposed for compressible turbulent flows. For a pentagonal prism-shaped container under vertical vibrations, the results show that oscillon type structures were formed. Oscillons are highly localized particle-like excitations of the granular layer. This self-sustaining state was named by analogy with its closest large-scale analogy, the soliton, which was first documented by J.S. Russell in 1834. The results which has been reportedbyBordbar and Zamankhan(2005b)also show that slightly revised fluctuation-dissipation theorem might apply to shaken sand, which appears to be asystem far from equilibrium and could exhibit strong spatial and temporal variations in quantities such as density and local particle velocity. In this light, hydrodynamic type continuum equations were presented for describing the deformation and flow of dense gas-particle mixtures. The constitutive equation used for the stress tensor provides an effective viscosity with a liquid-like character at low shear rates and a gaseous-like behavior at high shear rates. The numerical solutions were obtained for the aforementioned hydrodynamic equations for predicting the flow dynamics ofdense mixture of gas and particles in vertical cylindrical containers. For a heptagonal prism shaped container under vertical vibrations, the model results were found to predict bubbling behavior analogous to those observed experimentally. This bubbling behavior may be explained by the unusual gas pressure distribution found in the bed. In addition, oscillon type structures were found to be formed using a vertically vibrated, pentagonal prism shaped container in agreement with computer simulation results. These observations suggest that the pressure distribution plays a key rolein deformation and flow of dense mixtures of gas and particles under vertical vibrations. The present models provide greater insight toward the explanation of poorly understood hydrodynamic phenomena in the field of granular flows and dense gas-particle mixtures. The models can be generalized to investigate the granular material-container wall interactions which would be an issue of high interests in the industrial applications. By following this approach ideal processing conditions and powder transport can be created in industrial systems.

Viscosity of beta-glucan in oat products

Selostus: Kauran beetaglukaanin viskositeetti kauratuotteissa

Electrical characteristics of eddy current position sensor

In the thesis the principle of work of eddy current position sensors and the main cautions that must be taken into account while sensor design process are explained. A way of automated eddy current position sensor electrical characteristics measurement is suggested. A prototype of the eddy current position sensor and its electrical characteristics are investigated. The results obtained by means of the automated measuring system are explained.

Reaction Kinetics and Viscosity Modelling in the Fusion Syntheses of Ca- and Ca/Mg-resinates

Rosin is a natural product from pine forests and it is used as a raw material in resinate syntheses. Resinates are polyvalent metal salts of rosin acids and especially Ca- and Ca/Mg- resinates find wide application in the printing ink industry. In this thesis, analytical methods were applied to increase general knowledge of resinate chemistry and the reaction kinetics was studied in order to model the non linear solution viscosity increase during resinate syntheses by the fusion method. Solution viscosity in toluene is an important quality factor for resinates to be used in printing inks. The concept of critical resinate concentration, c crit, was introduced to define an abrupt change in viscosity dependence on resinate concentration in the solution. The concept was then used to explain the non-inear solution viscosity increase during resinate syntheses. A semi empirical model with two estimated parameters was derived for the viscosity increase on the basis of apparent reaction kinetics. The model was used to control the viscosity and to predict the total reaction time of the resinate process. The kinetic data from the complex reaction media was obtained by acid value titration and by FTIR spectroscopic analyses using a conventional calibration method to measure the resinate concentration and the concentration of free rosin acids. A multivariate calibration method was successfully applied to make partial least square (PLS) models for monitoring acid value and solution viscosity in both mid-infrared (MIR) and near infrared (NIR) regions during the syntheses. The calibration models can be used for on line resinate process monitoring. In kinetic studies, two main reaction steps were observed during the syntheses. First a fast irreversible resination reaction occurs at 235 °C and then a slow thermal decarboxylation of rosin acids starts to take place at 265 °C. Rosin oil is formed during the decarboxylation reaction step causing significant mass loss as the rosin oil evaporates from the system while the viscosity increases to the target level. The mass balance of the syntheses was determined based on the resinate concentration increase during the decarboxylation reaction step. A mechanistic study of the decarboxylation reaction was based on the observation that resinate molecules are partly solvated by rosin acids during the syntheses. Different decarboxylation mechanisms were proposed for the free and solvating rosin acids. The deduced kinetic model supported the analytical data of the syntheses in a wide resinate concentration region, over a wide range of viscosity values and at different reaction temperatures. In addition, the application of the kinetic model to the modified resinate syntheses gave a good fit. A novel synthesis method with the addition of decarboxylated rosin (i.e. rosin oil) to the reaction mixture was introduced. The conversion of rosin acid to resinate was increased to the level necessary to obtain the target viscosity for the product at 235 °C. Due to a lower reaction temperature than in traditional fusion synthesis at 265 °C, thermal decarboxylation is avoided. As a consequence, the mass yield of the resinate syntheses can be increased from ca. 70% to almost 100% by recycling the added rosin oil.

Eddy-current losses in rotor surface mounted permanent magnets

The aim of the work is to study the existing analytical calculation procedures found in literature to calculate the eddy-current losses in surface mounted permanent magnets within PMSM application. The most promising algorithms are implemented with MATLAB software under the dimensional data of LUT prototype machine. In addition finite elements analyze, utilized with help of Flux 2D software from Cedrat Ltd, is applied to calculate the eddy-current losses in permanent magnets. The results obtained from analytical methods are compared with numerical results.

Comparison and Evaluation of Eddy Current Sensors

In the work eddy current sensors are described and evaluated. Theoretical part includes physical basics of the eddy currents, overview of available commercial products and technologies. Industrial sensors operation was assessed based on several working modes. Apart from this, the model was created in Matlab Simulink with Xilinx Blockset and then translated into a Xilinx ISE Design Suite compatible project. The performance of the resulting implementation was compared to the existing implementation in the Xilinx Spartan 3 FPGA board with the custom made sensor. Additionally, an introduction to FPGAs and VHDL is presented.

Determination of slurry’s viscosity using case based reasoning approach

Case-based reasoning (CBR) is a recent approach to problem solving and learning that has got a lot of attention over the last years. In this work, the CBR methodology is used to reduce the time and amount of resources spent on carry out experiments to determine the viscosity of the new slurry. The aim of this work is: to develop a CBR system to support the decision making process about the type of slurries behavior, to collect a sufficient volume of qualitative data for case base, and to calculate the viscosity of the Newtonian slurries. Firstly in this paper, the literature review about the types of fluid flow, Newtonian and non-Newtonian slurries is presented. Some physical properties of the suspensions are also considered. The second part of the literature review provides an overview of the case-based reasoning field. Different models and stages of CBR cycles, benefits and disadvantages of this methodology are considered subsequently. Brief review of the CBS tools is also given in this work. Finally, some results of work and opportunities for system modernization are presented. To develop a decision support system for slurry viscosity determination, software application MS Office Excel was used. Designed system consists of three parts: workspace, the case base, and section for calculating the viscosity of Newtonian slurries. First and second sections are supposed to work with Newtonian and Bingham fluids. In the last section, apparent viscosity can be calculated for Newtonian slurries.

Large-eddy simulation of wind flows over complex terrains for wind energy applications

Wind energy has obtained outstanding expectations due to risks of global warming and nuclear energy production plant accidents. Nowadays, wind farms are often constructed in areas of complex terrain. A potential wind farm location must have the site thoroughly surveyed and the wind climatology analyzed before installing any hardware. Therefore, modeling of Atmospheric Boundary Layer (ABL) flows over complex terrains containing, e.g. hills, forest, and lakes is of great interest in wind energy applications, as it can help in locating and optimizing the wind farms. Numerical modeling of wind flows using Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) has become a popular technique during the last few decades. Due to the inherent flow variability and large-scale unsteadiness typical in ABL flows in general and especially over complex terrains, the flow can be difficult to be predicted accurately enough by using the Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes equations (RANS). Large- Eddy Simulation (LES) resolves the largest and thus most important turbulent eddies and models only the small-scale motions which are more universal than the large eddies and thus easier to model. Therefore, LES is expected to be more suitable for this kind of simulations although it is computationally more expensive than the RANS approach. With the fast development of computers and open-source CFD software during the recent years, the application of LES toward atmospheric flow is becoming increasingly common nowadays. The aim of the work is to simulate atmospheric flows over realistic and complex terrains by means of LES. Evaluation of potential in-land wind park locations will be the main application for these simulations. Development of the LES methodology to simulate the atmospheric flows over realistic terrains is reported in the thesis. The work also aims at validating the LES methodology at a real scale. In the thesis, LES are carried out for flow problems ranging from basic channel flows to real atmospheric flows over one of the most recent real-life complex terrain problems, the Bolund hill. All the simulations reported in the thesis are carried out using a new OpenFOAM® -based LES solver. The solver uses the 4th order time-accurate Runge-Kutta scheme and a fractional step method. Moreover, development of the LES methodology includes special attention to two boundary conditions: the upstream (inflow) and wall boundary conditions. The upstream boundary condition is generated by using the so-called recycling technique, in which the instantaneous flow properties are sampled on aplane downstream of the inlet and mapped back to the inlet at each time step. This technique develops the upstream boundary-layer flow together with the inflow turbulence without using any precursor simulation and thus within a single computational domain. The roughness of the terrain surface is modeled by implementing a new wall function into OpenFOAM® during the thesis work. Both, the recycling method and the newly implemented wall function, are validated for the channel flows at relatively high Reynolds number before applying them to the atmospheric flow applications. After validating the LES model over simple flows, the simulations are carried out for atmospheric boundary-layer flows over two types of hills: first, two-dimensional wind-tunnel hill profiles and second, the Bolund hill located in Roskilde Fjord, Denmark. For the twodimensional wind-tunnel hills, the study focuses on the overall flow behavior as a function of the hill slope. Moreover, the simulations are repeated using another wall function suitable for smooth surfaces, which already existed in OpenFOAM® , in order to study the sensitivity of the flow to the surface roughness in ABL flows. The simulated results obtained using the two wall functions are compared against the wind-tunnel measurements. It is shown that LES using the implemented wall function produces overall satisfactory results on the turbulent flow over the two-dimensional hills. The prediction of the flow separation and reattachment-length for the steeper hill is closer to the measurements than the other numerical studies reported in the past for the same hill geometry. The field measurement campaign performed over the Bolund hill provides the most recent field-experiment dataset for the mean flow and the turbulence properties. A number of research groups have simulated the wind flows over the Bolund hill. Due to the challenging features of the hill such as the almost vertical hill slope, it is considered as an ideal experimental test case for validating micro-scale CFD models for wind energy applications. In this work, the simulated results obtained for two wind directions are compared against the field measurements. It is shown that the present LES can reproduce the complex turbulent wind flow structures over a complicated terrain such as the Bolund hill. Especially, the present LES results show the best prediction of the turbulent kinetic energy with an average error of 24.1%, which is a 43% smaller than any other model results reported in the past for the Bolund case. Finally, the validated LES methodology is demonstrated to simulate the wind flow over the existing Muukko wind farm located in South-Eastern Finland. The simulation is carried out only for one wind direction and the results on the instantaneous and time-averaged wind speeds are briefly reported. The demonstration case is followed by discussions on the practical aspects of LES for the wind resource assessment over a realistic inland wind farm.

Performance Characteristics of an Axial-Flux Solid-Rotor-Core Induction Motor

The integration of electric motors and industrial appliances such as pumps, fans, and compressors is rapidly increasing. For instance, the integration of an electric motor and a centrifugal pump provides cost savings and improved performance characteristics. Material cost savings are achieved when an electric motor is integrated into the shaft of a centrifugal pump, and the motor utilizes the bearings of the pump. This arrangement leads to a smaller configuration that occupies less floor space. The performance characteristics of a pump drive can be improved by using the variable-speed technology. This enables the full speed control of the drive and the absence of a mechanical gearbox and couplers. When using rotational speeds higher than those that can be directly achieved by the network frequency the structure of the rotor has to be mechanically durable. In this thesis the performance characteristics of an axial-flux solid-rotor-core induction motor are determined. The motor studied is a one-rotor-one-stator axial-flux induction motor, and thus, there is only one air-gap between the rotor and the stator. The motor was designed for higher rotational speeds, and therefore a good mechanical strength of the solid-rotor-core rotor is required to withstand the mechanical stresses. The construction of the rotor and the high rotational speeds together produce a feature, which is not typical of traditional induction motors: the dominating loss component of the motor is the rotor eddy current loss. In the case of a typical industrial induction motor instead the dominating loss component is the stator copper loss. In this thesis, several methods to decrease the rotor eddy current losses in the case of axial-flux induction motors are presented. A prototype motor with 45 kW output power at 6000 min-1 was designed and constructed for ascertaining the results obtained from the numerical FEM calculations. In general, this thesis concentrates on the methods for improving the electromagnetic properties of an axial-flux solid-rotor-core induction motor and examines the methods for decreasing the harmonic eddy currents of the rotor. The target is to improve the efficiency of the motor and to reach the efficiency standard of the present-day industrial induction motors equipped with laminated rotors.

Analysis of Industrial Granular Flow Applications by Using Advanced Collision Models

Granular flow phenomena are frequently encountered in the design of process and industrial plants in the traditional fields of the chemical, nuclear and oil industries as well as in other activities such as food and materials handling. Multi-phase flow is one important branch of the granular flow. Granular materials have unusual kinds of behavior compared to normal materials, either solids or fluids. Although some of the characteristics are still not well-known yet, one thing is confirmed: the particle-particle interaction plays a key role in the dynamics of granular materials, especially for dense granular materials. At the beginning of this thesis, detailed illustration of developing two models for describing the interaction based on the results of finite-element simulation, dimension analysis and numerical simulation is presented. The first model is used to describing the normal collision of viscoelastic particles. Based on some existent models, more parameters are added to this model, which make the model predict the experimental results more accurately. The second model is used for oblique collision, which include the effects from tangential velocity, angular velocity and surface friction based on Coulomb's law. The theoretical predictions of this model are in agreement with those by finite-element simulation. I n the latter chapters of this thesis, the models are used to predict industrial granular flow and the agreement between the simulations and experiments also shows the validation of the new model. The first case presents the simulation of granular flow passing over a circular obstacle. The simulations successfully predict the existence of a parabolic steady layer and show how the characteristics of the particles, such as coefficients of restitution and surface friction affect the separation results. The second case is a spinning container filled with granular material. Employing the previous models, the simulation could also reproduce experimentally observed phenomena, such as a depression in the center of a high frequency rotation. The third application is about gas-solid mixed flow in a vertically vibrated device. Gas phase motion is added to coherence with the particle motion. The governing equations of the gas phase are solved by using the Large eddy simulation (LES) and particle motion is predicted by using the Lagrangian method. The simulation predicted some pattern formation reported by experiment.

Eräiden paperinvalmistuksessa käytettävien vahadispersioiden stabiilisuuden hallinta

Diplomityön tavoitteena oli selvittää millainen laaduntarkastus AKD-dispersioille tulisi suorittaa kuormien vastaanotossa ja tulisiko dispersioiden laatu tarkastaa uudelleen ennen annostelua. Tätä varten seurattiin toimituserien laadun tasaisuutta ja tarkasteltiin varastointiolosuhteiden vaikutusta dispersioiden säilyvyyteen. Lisäksi kartoitettiin dispersioiden käsittelyssä ja kartonginvalmistusprosessissa esiintyvien riskitekijöiden vaikutuksia kaupallisten dispersioiden stabiilisuuteen. Kirjallisuusosassa perehdyttiin kolloidisiin dispersioihin sekä niiden stabiilisuuteen vaikuttaviin tekijöihin. AKD-dispersiot valmistetaan emulgointitekniikoiden avulla, joten dispergointimenetelmien ohella käsiteltiin myös emulsioiden valmistamista. Lisäksi luotiin katsaus dispersioteknologian tärkeimpiin analyysimenetelmiin. Alkyyliketeenidimeerin osalta käsiteltiin emulgoinnin lisäksi vahan ja muiden lisäaineiden vaikutuksia dispersioiden stabiilisuuteen ja myös niiden merkitystä dispersioiden formuloinnissa. AKD-liimauksen osalta esiin tuotiin AKD:n tärkeimmät reaktiomekanismit, sillä ne liittyvät osittain myös dispersioiden stabiilisuuteen. Lopuksi luotiin lyhyt katsaus AKD-dispersioiden stabiilisuutta käsittelevään tutkimukseen, jota on toistaiseksi julkaistu varsin niukasti. Kokeellisessaosassa tarkastelun kohteeksi valittiin neljä kaupallista alkyyliketeenidimeerinvesidispersiota, joiden koostumus ja ominaisuudet selvitettiin perusteellisesti. Tarkoituksena oli auttaa ymmärtämään dispersioiden stabiilisuudessa mahdollisesti esiintyviä eroja. Laajamittainen dispersioiden karakterisointi näyttää olevan tarpeen ainakin otettaessa uutta AKD-laatua käyttöön, sillä dispersioiden koostumus ja ominaisuudet voivat vaihdella merkittävästi. AKD-dispersioiden laadussa esiintyi vaihtelua eri toimituserien välillä. Suurimmat vaihtelut havaittiin dispersioiden varaustiloissa ja partikkelikokojakaumissa. Laadun epätasaisuuden vuoksi vastaanottotarkastuksen merkitys korostuu. Vastaanottotarkastuksessa syytä olisi kiinnittää dispersion kuiva-ainepitoisuuden ohella sen viskositeettiin, varaustilaan, tehoainepitoisuuteen sekä rakenteeseen. Rakenteen tarkastelussa optinen mikroskooppi voi rutiininomaisessa seurannassa korvata partikkelikokojakauman määrittämisen. Varastointilämpötilan vaikutus dispersioidenlaatuun on merkittävä. Dispersiot säilyvät parhaiten viileässä, joten jos varastosäiliöissä ei ole jäähdytystä, on dispersioiden laadun tarkastus tarpeen myös ennen annostelua. Jotta dispersion kunnosta saadaan luotettava arvio, on viskositeetin määrittämiseen yhdistettävä vähintään rakenteen tarkastelu optisella mikroskoopilla. Mekaaninen rasitus voi dominoivasta stabilointimekanismistariippuen aiheuttaa dispersiossa hienoaineen muodostumista tai partikkelien flokkaantumista. Stabilointimekanismi vaikuttaa niin ikään partikkelien käyttäytymiseen korkeissa lämpötiloissa. Dispersioiden stabiilisuuden todettiin heikkenevän pH:n kohotessa emäksiselle alueelle. Elektrolyyttikonsentraatio vaikuttaa partikkelien mikroelektroforeettiseen ioniliikkuvuuteen merkittävästi. Kartonkikoneen märkäosan kemikaaleista anionisen retentioaineen (BMA) todettiin vuorovaikuttavan kationisten AKD-partikkelien kanssa selvimmin. Mikroelektroforeettisen ioniliikkuvuuden mittaaminen kiertovedessä todettiin tärkeäksi, sillä se kuvaa dispersion käyttäytymistä sen käyttöympäristössä.

Ilmanpoisto kiertovoiteluöljystä

Työn kirjallisuusosassa esitellään paperi- ja kartonkikoneiden kiertovoitelujärjestelmien rakennetta ja voitelussa käytettyjen öljyjen ominaisuuksia. Lisäksi on selvitetty voiteluöljyn kunnossapidon kannalta keskeisten epäpuhtauksien kuten veden, hiukkasten ja ilmakuplien analysointia. Suurissa voitelujärjestelmissä öljyn suuri ilmapitoisuus on usein ongelma, mihin ei ole ollut selkeää ratkaisua. Työn tavoitteena oli tutkia ilmakuplien poistamista voiteluöljystä alipainekäsittelyn avulla. Alipaineen vaikusta eri öljyille ja lämpötiloilla tutkittiin laboratoriossa standarditestillä ja määritettiin sopiva alipaine tehdaskokeisiin. Testeissä havaittiin odotutetusti viskositeetin eli käytännössä lämpötilan olevan ratkaiseva tekijä ilman poistumisnopeuteen. Tehdasmittakaavan kokeissa mitattiin rakenteeltaan yksinkertaisen ja vähän energiaa kuluttavan ilmanpoistolaitteen toimintaa. Laitteisto sijoitetaan paluuöljyputkistoon ja sen ei tarvitse olla kiertovoitelukeskuksen yhteydessä. Täysimittainen laitteisto rakennettiin kartonkikoneen ja paperikoneen kiertovoitelujärjestelmiin. Laitteen avulla voidaan käsitellä koko voitelujärjestelmän öljy. Tuloksien mukaan laite toimii odotetulla tavalla ja vähentää merkittävästi ilmapitoisuutta. Järjestelmä on heikoimmillaan tilanteessa, jossa lämpötilat on pidettävä alhaisina ja ilmakuplia on runsaasti.

Laimentimen merkitys metallien neste-nesteuutossa

Työssä tutkittiin korkean leimahduspisteen laimentimien vaikutusta uuton tehokkuuteen ja turvallisuuteen. Kirjallisuusosa sisältää katsauksen uuttolaitoksilla tapahtuneista suuronnettomuuksista, staattisen sähkön aiheuttamista vaaroista uuttolaitoksilla ja kaupallisesti saatavista laimentimista. Lisäksi kirjallisuusosassa tarkastellaan hiilivetyjen molekyylirakenteen vaikutusta niiden leimahduspisteeseen, haihtuvuuteen, viskositeettiin ja liuotinominaisuuksiin. Kokeellisessa osassa tutkittiin uuton tehokkuutta kuvaavia ominaisuuksia, joita olivat sekoituksen pisarakoko, faasien selkeytymisnopeus,uuton ja takaisinuuton kinetiikka, orgaanisen faasin viskositeetti ja tiheys. Uuttoliuosten turvallisuusominaisuuksia tutkittiin mittaamalla synteettisten uuttoliuosten ja laimentimien leimahduspisteitä sekä sähköisesti varattujen laimentimien relaksaatioaikoja. Korkean leimahduspisteen laimentimena käytettiin Orfom SX 11-laimenninta. Vertailukohteena käytettiin Shellsol D70- ja Escaid 100- laimentimia. Malliuuttona käytettiin kuparin uuttoa hydroksioksiimireagensilla happamasta sulfaattiliuoksesta. Kokeissa havaittiin, että korkean leimahduspisteen laimentimen viskositeetti oli huomattavasti suurempi kuin Shellsol D70- laimentimella. Korkea viskositeetti hidasti faasien selkeytymistä uutossa, mutta sillä ei ollut vaikutusta uuton kinetiikkaan tai sekoituksen aiheuttamaan pisarakokoon. Uuttoliuoksen reagenssipitoisuudella havaittiin olevan vaikutusta uuttoliuoksen leimahduspisteeseen, mutta uuttoliuoksen latausasteella ei havaittu olevan vaikutusta. Sähköisesti varattujen laimentimien varauksien relaksaatioajoissa oli hieman eroja, mutta relaksaatioajat olivat kaikilla laimentimilla liian pitkiä staattisen sähkön aiheuttaman vaaran poistamiseksi.

Natriumsilikaatin liuotuslaitoksen kapasiteetin nosto

Tässä työssä tutkittiin natriumsilikaatin (vesilasi) liuotukseen ja suodatukseen vaikuttavia tekijöitä. Työssä pyrittiin optimoimaan natriumsilikaatin liuotus- ja suodatuskapasiteetti J. M. Huber Finland Oy:n Haminan tehtaan liuotuslaitoksella. Kirjallisuusosassa perehdyttiin kiinteän natriumsilikaatin ja natriumsilikaatin vesiliuoksen ominaisuuksiin, sekä käsiteltiin soveltuvin osin liuotuksen ja suodatuksen teoriaa. Kokeellisessa osassa vertailtiin kahden eri valmistajan natriumsilikaatteja toisiinsa, sekä pyrittiin löytämään molemmille laseille optimaalisimmat prosessiparametrit liuotus- ja suodatuskokeiden avulla. Erilaisia prosessiparametreja ja ajotapoja testattiin tehdasmittakaavan koeajoilla todellisilla prosessilaitteilla. Eri natriumsilikaattien vertailu tehtiin tehdasmittakaavan koeajojen sekä laboratorioanalyysien avulla. Koeajojen tulosten perusteella Taavetista toimitettu vesilasi liukenee nopeammin kuin Puolasta toimitettu ostolasi, mutta puolalaisesta lasista liuotettu silikaatti suodattuu helpommin kuin Taavetin lasista liuotettu silikaatti. Liukenemisnopeuden eroon selitettävissä Taavetin lasin suuremmalla ominaispinta-alalla sekä hauraammalla rakenteella. Suodatuseroon ei löytynyt yksiselitteistä syytä, joten sen löytämiseksi vaadittaisiin jatkotutkimuksia. Kokeiden perusteellaparas keino puolalaisen lasin liuotuksen nopeuttamiseen olisi pitää liuotussäiliön lasiylimäärä mahdollisimman korkeana jokaisessa panoksessa ja nopeuttaa liuotussäiliön panostusta lasin ja veden yhtäaikaisella annostelulla. Tulosten perusteella paras keino Taavetin lasista liuotetun silikaatin suodatuksen helpottamiseen olisi laskea liuoksen tavoitetiheyttä nykyisestä arvostaan, jolloin viskositeetti pienenee merkittävästi ja suodatus onnistuu liuotuslaitoksen kapasiteetin kannalta paremmin. Edellä mainituilla ajotavoilla tehtyjen koeajojen perusteella, molemmilla laseilla on mahdollista päästä 150 MT/d tavoitekapasiteettiin, mutta varmin tapa kyseisen kapasiteetin saavuttamiseksi olisi lisätä suodatuskapasiteettia investoimalla toiseen silikaattisuodattimeen.