Deicing Salt Corrosion with and without Inhibitors, MLR-87-8, 1989

Chloride ion penetration through concrete to reinforcing steel is causing the premature deterioration of numerous bridge decks in Iowa. The purpose of the research reported in this paper was to determine whether any of several additives or alternative deicing chemicals could inhibit corrosion of reinforcing steel. The deicers tested were calcium magnesium acetate (CMA), CMA plus NaCl (NaCl: sodium chloride), Quicksalt plus PCI, and CG-90, a polyphosphate solution being developed by Cargill. Two tests were established. First, steel coupons were placed in a 15% solution of a deicer and distilled water to determine which alternative deicer would cause the least amount of corrosion in solution. The coupons were weighed periodically to determine each coupon's weight loss from corrosion. The second test involved ponding a 15% solution of each material on reinforced concrete blocks. Weekly copper-copper sulfate electrical half-cell (CSE) potential readings were taken on each block to determine whether corrosive activity was occurring at the steel surface. When the ponding research was concluded, concrete samples were taken from one of the three blocks ponded with each deicer. The samples were used to determine the chloride ion content at the level of the steel. Results show that all the deicers were less corrosive than NaCl. Only pure CMA, however, significantly inhibited the corrosion of steel embedded in concrete.

Reduction of Concrete Deterioration by Ettringite Using Crystal Growth Inhibition Techniques: Part II Field Evaluation of Inhibitor Effectiveness, TR-469, 2004

The effects of diethylenetriaminpenta(methylenephosphonic acid) (DTPMP), a phosphonate inhibitor, on the growth of delayed ettringite have been evaluated using concrete in highway US 20 near Williams, Iowa, and the cores of six highways subject to moderate (built in 1992) or minor (built in 1997) deterioration. Application of 0.01 and 0.1 vol. % DTPMP to cores was made on a weekly or monthly basis for one year under controlled laboratory-based freeze-thaw and wet-dry conditions over a temperature range of -15 degrees to 58 degrees C to mimic extremes in Iowa roadway conditions. The same concentrations of phosphonate were also applied to cores left outside (roof of Science I at Iowa State University) over the same period of time. Nineteen applications of 0.1 vol. % DTPMP with added deicing salt solution (about 23 weight % NACL) were made to US 20 during the winters of 2003 and 2004. In untreated samples, air voids, pores, and occasional cracks are lined with acicular ettringite crystals (up to 50 micrometers in length) whereas air voids, pores, and cracks in concrete from the westbound lane of US 20 are devoid of ettringite up to a depth of about 0.5 mm from the surface of the concrete. Ettringite is also absent in zones up to 6 mm from the surface of concrete slabs placed on the roof of Science I and cores subject to laboratory-based freeze-thaw experiments. In these zones, the relatively high concentration of DTPMP caused it to behave as a chelator. Stunted ettringite crystals 5 to 25 micrometers in length, occasionally coated with porlandite, form on the margins of these zones indicating that in these areas DTPMP behaved as an inhibitor due to a reduction in the concentration of phosphonate. Analyses of mixes of ettringite and DTPMP using electrospray mass spectrometry suggests that the stunting of ettringite growth is caused by the adsorption of a Ca2+ ion and a water molecule to deprotonated DTPMP on the surface of the {0001} face of ettringite. It is anticipated that by using a DTPMP concentration of between 0.001 and 0.01 vol. % for the extended life of a highway (i.e. >20 years), deterioration caused by the expansive growth of ettringite will be markedly reduced.