Having Your Cake and Eating It, Too: Can Regulatory Agencies Be Both Independent and Accountable?

Independent regulatory agencies (IRAs) were created in various sectors and on different governmental levels to implement liberalization policies. This paper investigates the link between IRAs' independence, which is said to promote regulatory credibility and the use of technical expertise, and their accountability, which is related to the need for controlling and legitimizing independent regulators. The literature on the regulatory state anticipates a positive relation between the independence and accountability of IRAs, but systematic empirical evidence is still lacking. To tackle this question, this paper measures and compares the independence and the accountability of IRAs in three differentially liberalized sectors in Switzerland (telecommunications, electricity and railways). With the application of Social Network Analysis, this piece of research shows that IRAs can be de facto independent and accountable at the same time, but the two features do not necessarily co-evolve in the same direction.

Paediatric oral peanut challenges: a comparison of practice in London and Western Switzerland.

BACKGROUND: There are guidelines on how to develop a food challenge protocol, but at present there is no gold standard guidance on method, and separate units produce differing protocols. METHODS: We performed a retrospective analysis of 200 patients' data from the paediatric allergy units in Lausanne and Geneva, Western Switzerland, and St Thomas' Hospital (STH), UK. RESULTS: St Thomas' Hospital has a younger cohort with a lower overall mean spIgE (2.36 kU/l vs 8.00 kU/l, P = 0.004). The target peanut protein volumes differed: Switzerland 4.4 g vs STH 8.4 g. Despite this, the dose actually achieved in positive challenges was not significantly different (2.33 g vs 1.49 g, P = 0.16). 26% of challenges reacted at 4 g or more of peanut protein. CONCLUSIONS: The differences in results highlight how the variation in reasoning behind food challenge alters the outcome. Standardization of food challenges would allow easy comparison between hospitals and geographical areas for research purposes.

Comparison of the methodologies of paediatric peanut food challenges in England and Switzerland

Document Type: Meeting Abstract

Predicting positive food challenges in children sensitised to peanuts/tree nuts.

BACKGROUND: Children with atopic diseases in early life are frequently found with positive IgE tests to peanuts/tree nuts without a history of previous ingestion. We aimed to identify risk factors for reactions to nuts at first introduction. METHODS: A retrospective case-note and database analysis was performed. Recruitment criteria were: patients aged 3-16 yr who had a standardized food challenge to peanut and/or tree nuts due to sensitisation to the peanut/tree nut (positive spIgE or SPT) without previous consumption. A detailed assessment was performed of factors relating to food challenge outcome with univariate and multivariate logistic regression analysis. RESULTS: There were 98 food challenges (47 peanut, 51 tree nut) with 29 positive, 67 negative and 2 inconclusive outcomes. A positive maternal history of allergy and a specific IgE >5 kU/l were strongly associated with a significantly increased risk of a positive food challenge (OR 3.73; 95% CI 1.31-10.59; p = 0.013 and OR 3.35; 95% CI 1.23-9.11; p = 0.007, respectively). Adjusting for age, a three year-old with these criteria has a 67% probability of a positive challenge. There was no significant association between types of peanut/tree nut, other food allergies, atopic conditions or severity of previous food reactions and positive challenges. CONCLUSIONS: We have demonstrated an association between the presence of maternal atopic history and a specific IgE >5 kU/l, with a significant increase in the likelihood of a positive food challenge. Although requiring further prospective validation these easily identifiable components should be considered when deciding the need for a challenge.

Predicting positive food challenges at the introduction of nuts in sensitised children

Rationale: Children with atopic diseases in early life are frequently found with positive IgE tests to nuts, without a history of previous ingestion. We aimed to identify risk factors for reactions to nuts at their first introduction. Methods: A detailed retrospective case note and database analysis was performed. Inclusion criteria were: patients aged 3 to 16 years who had had a standardized food challenge to peanut and/or tree nuts due to primary sensitisation to the nut (positive specific IgE or SPT). A detailed assessment was performed of factors relating to food challenge outcome with univariate and multivariate logistic regression analysis. Results: There were 98 food challenges (48% peanut, 52% tree nut) with 29 positive, 67 negative and 2 inconclusive challenges. A positive maternal history and a specific IgE > 2 kU/l were strongly associated with a significantly increased risk of a positive food challenge (OR 3.54; 95% CI 1.28 to 9.81; and OR 4.82; 95% CI 1.57 to 14.86; respectively). There was no significant association between the type of nut, age, presence of other food allergies, paternal or sibling atopic history, other atopic conditions or severity of previous reaction to other foods. Conclusions: We have demonstrated an association between the presence of a maternal atopic history and a specific IgE > 2 kU/l, and a significant increase in the likelihood of a positive food challenge in children with primary sensitisation to nuts. Although requiring further prospective validation we suggest these easily identifiable components should be considered when deciding the need for a nut challenge.

Retinal pigment epithelium protein of 65 kDA gene-linked retinal degeneration is not modulated by chicken acidic leucine-rich epidermal growth factor-like domain containing brain protein/Neuroglycan C/ chondroitin sulfate proteoglycan 5.

PURPOSE: To analyze in vivo the function of chicken acidic leucine-rich epidermal growth factor-like domain containing brain protein/Neuroglycan C (gene symbol: Cspg5) during retinal degeneration in the Rpe65⁻/⁻ mouse model of Leber congenital amaurosis. METHODS: We resorted to mice with targeted deletions in the Cspg5 and retinal pigment epithelium protein of 65 kDa (Rpe65) genes (Cspg5⁻/⁻/Rpe65⁻/⁻). Cone degeneration was assessed with cone-specific peanut agglutinin staining. Transcriptional expression of rhodopsin (Rho), S-opsin (Opn1sw), M-opsin (Opn1mw), rod transducin α subunit (Gnat1), and cone transducin α subunit (Gnat2) genes was assessed with quantitative PCR from 2 weeks to 12 months. The retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) was analyzed at P14 with immunodetection of the retinol-binding protein membrane receptor Stra6. RESULTS: No differences in the progression of retinal degeneration were observed between the Rpe65⁻/⁻ and Cspg5⁻/⁻/Rpe65⁻/⁻ mice. No retinal phenotype was detected in the late postnatal and adult Cspg5⁻/⁻ mice, when compared to the wild-type mice. CONCLUSIONS: Despite the previously reported upregulation of Cspg5 during retinal degeneration in Rpe65⁻/⁻ mice, no protective effect or any involvement of Cspg5 in disease progression was identified.

Lentiviral vector-mediated gene transfer in adult mouse photoreceptors is impaired by the presence of a physical barrier

RESUME L'utilisation de la thérapie génique dans l'approche d'un traitement des maladies oculaires dégénératives, plus particulièrement de la rétinite pigmentaire, semble être très prometteuse (Acland et al. 2001). Parmi les vecteurs développés, les vecteurs lentiviraux (dérivé du virus humain HIV-1), permettent la transduction des photorécepteurs après injection sous-rétinienne chez la souris durant les premiers jours de vie. Cependant l'efficacité du transfert de gène est nettement plus limitée dans ce type cellulaire après injection chez l'adulte (Kostic et al. 2003). L'objet de notre étude est de déterminer si la présence d'une barrière physique produite au cours du développement, située entre les photorécepteurs et l'épithélium pigmentaire ainsi qu'entre les photorécepteurs eux-mêmes, est responsable de: la diminution de l'entrée en masse du virus dans les photorécepteurs, minimisant ainsi son efficacité chez la souris adulte. De précédentes recherches, chez le lapin, ont décrit la capacité d'enzymes spécifiques comme la Chondroïtinase ABC et la Neuraminidase X de modifier la structure de la matrice entourant les photorécepteurs (Inter Photoreceptor Matrix, IPM) par digestion de certains de ses constituants suite à leur injection dans l'espace sous-rétinien (Yao et al. 1990). Considérant l'IPM comme une barrière physique, capable de réduire l'efficacité de transduction des photorécepteurs chez la souris adulte, nous avons associé différentes enzymes simultanément à l'injection sous-rétinienne de vecteurs lentiviraux afin d'améliorer la transduction virale en fragilisant I'IPM, la rendant ainsi plus perméable à la diffusion du virus. L'injection sous-rétinienne de Neuraminidase X et de Chondroïtinase ABC chez la souris induit des modifications structurales de l'IPM qui se manifestent respectivement par la révélation ou la disparition de sites de liaison de la peanut agglutinin sur les photorécepteurs. L'injection simultanée de Neuraminidase X avec le vecteur viral contenant le transgène thérapeutique augmente significativement le nombre de photorécepteurs transduits (environ cinq fois). Nous avons en fait démontré que le traitement enzymatique augmente principalement la diffusion du lentivirus dans l'espace situé entre l'épithélium pigmentaire et les photorécepteurs. Le traitement à la Chondroïtinase ABC n'entraîne quant à elle qu'une légère amélioration non significative de la transduction. Cette étude montre qu'une meilleure connaissance de l'IPM ainsi que des substances capables de la modifier (enzymes, drogues etc.) pourrait aider à élaborer de nouvelles stratégies afin d'améliorer la distribution de vecteurs viraux dans la rétine adulte.