EADock : design of a new molecular docking algorithm and some of its applications

3 Summary 3. 1 English The pharmaceutical industry has been facing several challenges during the last years, and the optimization of their drug discovery pipeline is believed to be the only viable solution. High-throughput techniques do participate actively to this optimization, especially when complemented by computational approaches aiming at rationalizing the enormous amount of information that they can produce. In siiico techniques, such as virtual screening or rational drug design, are now routinely used to guide drug discovery. Both heavily rely on the prediction of the molecular interaction (docking) occurring between drug-like molecules and a therapeutically relevant target. Several softwares are available to this end, but despite the very promising picture drawn in most benchmarks, they still hold several hidden weaknesses. As pointed out in several recent reviews, the docking problem is far from being solved, and there is now a need for methods able to identify binding modes with a high accuracy, which is essential to reliably compute the binding free energy of the ligand. This quantity is directly linked to its affinity and can be related to its biological activity. Accurate docking algorithms are thus critical for both the discovery and the rational optimization of new drugs. In this thesis, a new docking software aiming at this goal is presented, EADock. It uses a hybrid evolutionary algorithm with two fitness functions, in combination with a sophisticated management of the diversity. EADock is interfaced with .the CHARMM package for energy calculations and coordinate handling. A validation was carried out on 37 crystallized protein-ligand complexes featuring 11 different proteins. The search space was defined as a sphere of 15 R around the center of mass of the ligand position in the crystal structure, and conversely to other benchmarks, our algorithms was fed with optimized ligand positions up to 10 A root mean square deviation 2MSD) from the crystal structure. This validation illustrates the efficiency of our sampling heuristic, as correct binding modes, defined by a RMSD to the crystal structure lower than 2 A, were identified and ranked first for 68% of the complexes. The success rate increases to 78% when considering the five best-ranked clusters, and 92% when all clusters present in the last generation are taken into account. Most failures in this benchmark could be explained by the presence of crystal contacts in the experimental structure. EADock has been used to understand molecular interactions involved in the regulation of the Na,K ATPase, and in the activation of the nuclear hormone peroxisome proliferatoractivated receptors a (PPARa). It also helped to understand the action of common pollutants (phthalates) on PPARy, and the impact of biotransformations of the anticancer drug Imatinib (Gleevec®) on its binding mode to the Bcr-Abl tyrosine kinase. Finally, a fragment-based rational drug design approach using EADock was developed, and led to the successful design of new peptidic ligands for the a5ß1 integrin, and for the human PPARa. In both cases, the designed peptides presented activities comparable to that of well-established ligands such as the anticancer drug Cilengitide and Wy14,643, respectively. 3.2 French Les récentes difficultés de l'industrie pharmaceutique ne semblent pouvoir se résoudre que par l'optimisation de leur processus de développement de médicaments. Cette dernière implique de plus en plus. de techniques dites "haut-débit", particulièrement efficaces lorsqu'elles sont couplées aux outils informatiques permettant de gérer la masse de données produite. Désormais, les approches in silico telles que le criblage virtuel ou la conception rationnelle de nouvelles molécules sont utilisées couramment. Toutes deux reposent sur la capacité à prédire les détails de l'interaction moléculaire entre une molécule ressemblant à un principe actif (PA) et une protéine cible ayant un intérêt thérapeutique. Les comparatifs de logiciels s'attaquant à cette prédiction sont flatteurs, mais plusieurs problèmes subsistent. La littérature récente tend à remettre en cause leur fiabilité, affirmant l'émergence .d'un besoin pour des approches plus précises du mode d'interaction. Cette précision est essentielle au calcul de l'énergie libre de liaison, qui est directement liée à l'affinité du PA potentiel pour la protéine cible, et indirectement liée à son activité biologique. Une prédiction précise est d'une importance toute particulière pour la découverte et l'optimisation de nouvelles molécules actives. Cette thèse présente un nouveau logiciel, EADock, mettant en avant une telle précision. Cet algorithme évolutionnaire hybride utilise deux pressions de sélections, combinées à une gestion de la diversité sophistiquée. EADock repose sur CHARMM pour les calculs d'énergie et la gestion des coordonnées atomiques. Sa validation a été effectuée sur 37 complexes protéine-ligand cristallisés, incluant 11 protéines différentes. L'espace de recherche a été étendu à une sphère de 151 de rayon autour du centre de masse du ligand cristallisé, et contrairement aux comparatifs habituels, l'algorithme est parti de solutions optimisées présentant un RMSD jusqu'à 10 R par rapport à la structure cristalline. Cette validation a permis de mettre en évidence l'efficacité de notre heuristique de recherche car des modes d'interactions présentant un RMSD inférieur à 2 R par rapport à la structure cristalline ont été classés premier pour 68% des complexes. Lorsque les cinq meilleures solutions sont prises en compte, le taux de succès grimpe à 78%, et 92% lorsque la totalité de la dernière génération est prise en compte. La plupart des erreurs de prédiction sont imputables à la présence de contacts cristallins. Depuis, EADock a été utilisé pour comprendre les mécanismes moléculaires impliqués dans la régulation de la Na,K ATPase et dans l'activation du peroxisome proliferatoractivated receptor a (PPARa). Il a également permis de décrire l'interaction de polluants couramment rencontrés sur PPARy, ainsi que l'influence de la métabolisation de l'Imatinib (PA anticancéreux) sur la fixation à la kinase Bcr-Abl. Une approche basée sur la prédiction des interactions de fragments moléculaires avec protéine cible est également proposée. Elle a permis la découverte de nouveaux ligands peptidiques de PPARa et de l'intégrine a5ß1. Dans les deux cas, l'activité de ces nouveaux peptides est comparable à celles de ligands bien établis, comme le Wy14,643 pour le premier, et le Cilengitide (PA anticancéreux) pour la seconde.

An objective anisotropic elastic plastic model and Algorithm applicable to bone mechanics

The implicit projection algorithm of isotropic plasticity is extended to an objective anisotropic elastic perfectly plastic model. The recursion formula developed to project the trial stress on the yield surface, is applicable to any non linear elastic law and any plastic yield function.A curvilinear transverse isotropic model based on a quadratic elastic potential and on Hill's quadratic yield criterion is then developed and implemented in a computer program for bone mechanics perspectives. The paper concludes with a numerical study of a schematic bone-prosthesis system to illustrate the potential of the model.

A Survey of Active Learning Algorithms for Supervised Remote Sensing Image Classification

Defining an efficient training set is one of the most delicate phases for the success of remote sensing image classification routines. The complexity of the problem, the limited temporal and financial resources, as well as the high intraclass variance can make an algorithm fail if it is trained with a suboptimal dataset. Active learning aims at building efficient training sets by iteratively improving the model performance through sampling. A user-defined heuristic ranks the unlabeled pixels according to a function of the uncertainty of their class membership and then the user is asked to provide labels for the most uncertain pixels. This paper reviews and tests the main families of active learning algorithms: committee, large margin, and posterior probability-based. For each of them, the most recent advances in the remote sensing community are discussed and some heuristics are detailed and tested. Several challenging remote sensing scenarios are considered, including very high spatial resolution and hyperspectral image classification. Finally, guidelines for choosing the good architecture are provided for new and/or unexperienced user.

An iterative Multiscale Finite-Volume algorithm converging to the exact solution

The multiscale finite volume (MsFV) method has been developed to efficiently solve large heterogeneous problems (elliptic or parabolic); it is usually employed for pressure equations and delivers conservative flux fields to be used in transport problems. The method essentially relies on the hypothesis that the (fine-scale) problem can be reasonably described by a set of local solutions coupled by a conservative global (coarse-scale) problem. In most cases, the boundary conditions assigned for the local problems are satisfactory and the approximate conservative fluxes provided by the method are accurate. In numerically challenging cases, however, a more accurate localization is required to obtain a good approximation of the fine-scale solution. In this paper we develop a procedure to iteratively improve the boundary conditions of the local problems. The algorithm relies on the data structure of the MsFV method and employs a Krylov-subspace projection method to obtain an unconditionally stable scheme and accelerate convergence. Two variants are considered: in the first, only the MsFV operator is used; in the second, the MsFV operator is combined in a two-step method with an operator derived from the problem solved to construct the conservative flux field. The resulting iterative MsFV algorithms allow arbitrary reduction of the solution error without compromising the construction of a conservative flux field, which is guaranteed at any iteration. Since it converges to the exact solution, the method can be regarded as a linear solver. In this context, the schemes proposed here can be viewed as preconditioned versions of the Generalized Minimal Residual method (GMRES), with a very peculiar characteristic that the residual on the coarse grid is zero at any iteration (thus conservative fluxes can be obtained).

Risk assessment of recurrence in sporadic retinoblastoma using a molecular-based algorithm

Le rétinoblastome (Rb) est une tumeur provenant des cellules rétiniennes progénitrices des photorécepteurs. C'est la tumeur pédiatrique maligne la plus fréquente avec une incidence par naissance évaluée entre 1/15Ό00 et 1/20Ό00. Les enfants atteints de Rb sont diagnostiqué dans leur grande majorité avant l'âge de 4 ans, soit le temps nécessaire à la différentiation et à la maturation des photorécepteurs et donc à la disparition de la cellule d'origine du Rb. La survie du patient, la sauvegarde oculaire et le pronostic visuel restent excellents pour autant que le traitement ne soit pas différé. Dans sa variante non héréditaire (60%) le Rb est toujours unilatéral et sporadique. Le Rb héréditaire de transmission dominante autosomique (40%), se décline sous toutes les formes, familiale (10%) ou sporadique (30%), que l'atteinte soit unilatérale ou bilatérale. La majorité des mutations causales sont uniques et distribuées de façon aléatoire sur la totalité du gène RB1 sans région prédisposante. La détection de ces mutations est couteuse et chronophage, tout en présentant un taux de détection relativement bas; surtout dans les cas de Rb sporadiques unilatéraux. Dans le but d'identifier les patients présentant un risque réel de développer un Rb, et de réduire le nombre d'examens sous narcose requis pour le dépistage de la maladie chez les sujets à risque, nous avons développé une stratégie sensible, rapide, efficace et peu couteuse basée sur une analyse de l'haplotype intragénique. Cet algorithme prend en compte a) la perte d'hétérozygotie intratumorale du gène RB1, b) l'origine paternelle préférentielle des nouvelles mutations germinales et c) un risque a priori dérivé des données empiriques de Vogel. Pendant la période allant de janvier 1994 à décembre 2006, nous avons comparé l'apparition de nouveau Rb parmi la fratrie et la descendance de patient atteints au nombre de nouveaux cas attendus calculé par notre algorithme. 134 familles ont été étudiées. L'analyse moléculaire a été effectuée chez 570 personnes dont 99 patients âgés de moins de 4 ans et donc à risque de développer un Rb. Parmi cette cohorte, nous avons observé l'apparition d'un cas de Rb, alors que les risques cumulés a posteriori calculé par notre algorithme prédisait l'apparition de 1.77 nouveau cas. Dans cette étude, nous avons pu valider notre algorithme prédisant la récurrence de Rb chez les parents de 1er degré de patients atteints. Cet outil devrait grandement faciliter le conseil génétique ainsi que le suivi des patients à risque de développer un Rb, surtout dans les cas ou le séquençage direct du gène RB1 n'est pas disponible ou est resté non informatif. - Purpose: Most RBI mutations are unique and distributed throughout the RBI gene. Their detection can be time-consuming and the yield especially low in cases of conservatively-treated sporadic unilateral retinoblas-toma (Rb) patients. In order to identify patients with true risk of developing Rb, and to reduce the number of unnecessary examinations under anesthesia in all other cases, we developed a universal sensitive, efficient and cost-effective strategy based on intragenic haplotype analysis. Methods: This algorithm allows the calculation of the a posteriori risk of developing Rb and takes into account (a) RBI loss of heterozygosity in tumors, (b) preferential paternal origin of new germline mutations, (c) a priori risk derived from empirical data by Vogel, and (d) disease penetrance of 90% in most cases. We report the occurrence of Rb in first degree relatives of patients with sporadic Rb who visited the Jules Gonin Eye Hospital, Lausanne, Switzerland, from January 1994 to December 2006 compared to expected new cases of Rb using our algorithm. Results: A total of 134 families with sporadic Rb were enrolled; testing was performed in 570 individuals and 99 patients younger than 4 years old were identified. We observed one new case of Rb. Using our algorithm, the cumulated total a posteriori risk of recurrence was 1.77. Conclusions: This is the first time that linkage analysis has been validated to monitor the risk of recurrence in sporadic Rb. This should be a useful tool in genetic counseling, especially when direct RBI screening for mutations leaves a negative result or is unavailable.

Risk assessment of recurrence in sporadic retinoblastoma using a molecular-based algorithm.

PURPOSE: Most RB1 mutations are unique and distributed throughout the RB1 gene. Their detection can be time-consuming and the yield especially low in cases of conservatively-treated sporadic unilateral retinoblastoma (Rb) patients. In order to identify patients with true risk of developing Rb, and to reduce the number of unnecessary examinations under anesthesia in all other cases, we developed a universal sensitive, efficient and cost-effective strategy based on intragenic haplotype analysis. METHODS: This algorithm allows the calculation of the a posteriori risk of developing Rb and takes into account (a) RB1 loss of heterozygosity in tumors, (b) preferential paternal origin of new germline mutations, (c) a priori risk derived from empirical data by Vogel, and (d) disease penetrance of 90% in most cases. We report the occurrence of Rb in first degree relatives of patients with sporadic Rb who visited the Jules Gonin Eye Hospital, Lausanne, Switzerland, from January 1994 to December 2006 compared to expected new cases of Rb using our algorithm. RESULTS: A total of 134 families with sporadic Rb were enrolled; testing was performed in 570 individuals and 99 patients younger than 4 years old were identified. We observed one new case of Rb. Using our algorithm, the cumulated total a posteriori risk of recurrence was 1.77. CONCLUSIONS: This is the first time that linkage analysis has been validated to monitor the risk of recurrence in sporadic Rb. This should be a useful tool in genetic counseling, especially when direct RB1 screening for mutations leaves a negative result or is unavailable.

Treatment algorithm for moderate to severe ulcerative colitis.

The care for a patient with ulcerative colitis (UC) remains challenging despite the fact that morbidity and mortality rates have been considerably reduced during the last 30 years. The traditional management with intravenous corticosteroids was modified by the introduction of ciclosporin and infliximab. In this review, we focus on the treatment of patients with moderate to severe UC. Four typical clinical scenarios are defined and discussed in detail. The treatment recommendations are based on current literature, published guidelines and reviews, and were discussed at a consensus meeting of Swiss experts in the field. Comprehensive treatment algorithms were developed, aimed for daily clinical practice.

Recognition judgments and the performance of the recognition heuristic depend on the size of the reference class

In a series of three experiments, participants made inferences about which one of a pair of two objects scored higher on a criterion. The first experiment was designed to contrast the prediction of Probabilistic Mental Model theory (Gigerenzer, Hoffrage, & Kleinbölting, 1991) concerning sampling procedure with the hard-easy effect. The experiment failed to support the theory's prediction that a particular pair of randomly sampled item sets would differ in percentage correct; but the observation that German participants performed practically as well on comparisons between U.S. cities (many of which they did not even recognize) than on comparisons between German cities (about which they knew much more) ultimately led to the formulation of the recognition heuristic. Experiment 2 was a second, this time successful, attempt to unconfound item difficulty and sampling procedure. In Experiment 3, participants' knowledge and recognition of each city was elicited, and how often this could be used to make an inference was manipulated. Choices were consistent with the recognition heuristic in about 80% of the cases when it discriminated and people had no additional knowledge about the recognized city (and in about 90% when they had such knowledge). The frequency with which the heuristic could be used affected the percentage correct, mean confidence, and overconfidence as predicted. The size of the reference class, which was also manipulated, modified these effects in meaningful and theoretically important ways.

Validation of a clinical algorithm to identify low-risk patients with pulmonary embolism.

Summary Background: We previously derived a clinical prognostic algorithm to identify patients with pulmonary embolism (PE) who are at low-risk of short-term mortality who could be safely discharged early or treated entirely in an outpatient setting. Objectives: To externally validate the clinical prognostic algorithm in an independent patient sample. Methods: We validated the algorithm in 983 consecutive patients prospectively diagnosed with PE at an emergency department of a university hospital. Patients with none of the algorithm's 10 prognostic variables (age >/= 70 years, cancer, heart failure, chronic lung disease, chronic renal disease, cerebrovascular disease, pulse >/= 110/min., systolic blood pressure < 100 mm Hg, oxygen saturation < 90%, and altered mental status) at baseline were defined as low-risk. We compared 30-day overall mortality among low-risk patients based on the algorithm between the validation and the original derivation sample. We also assessed the rate of PE-related and bleeding-related mortality among low-risk patients. Results: Overall, the algorithm classified 16.3% of patients with PE as low-risk. Mortality at 30 days was 1.9% among low-risk patients and did not differ between the validation and the original derivation sample. Among low-risk patients, only 0.6% died from definite or possible PE, and 0% died from bleeding. Conclusions: This study validates an easy-to-use, clinical prognostic algorithm for PE that accurately identifies patients with PE who are at low-risk of short-term mortality. Low-risk patients based on our algorithm are potential candidates for less costly outpatient treatment.