Police work and new 'security devices' : a tale from the beat

Mobile technologies have brought about major changes in police equipment and police work. If a utopian narrative remains strongly linked to the adoption of new technologies, often formulated as 'magic bullets' to real occupational problems, there are important tensions between their 'imagined' outcomes and the (unexpected) effects that accompany their daily 'practical' use by police officers. This article offers an analysis of police officers' perceptions and interactions with security devices. In so doing, it develops a conceptual typology of strategies for coping with new technology inspired by Le Bourhis and Lascoumes: challenging, neutralizing and diverting. To that purpose, we adopt an ethnographic approach that focuses on the discourses, practices and actions of police officers in relation to three security devices: the mobile digital terminal, the mobile phone and the body camera. Based on a case study of a North American municipal police department, the article addresses how these technological devices are perceived and experienced by police officers on the beat.

Grundriss innovativer Polizeiansätze. Eine kritische Begutachtung verschiedener Strategien und Tätigkeiten und deren Implementierung in der Schweiz in Theorie und Praxis.

This thesis contains three parts. The first one offers the theoretical basement, where the history of the police from their beginning in the early 19th century to this day is shown. The emphasis however is laid on the last 40 years, which gave birth to a multitude of innovations, such as community, problem-oriented, hot-spots or zero-tolerance policing. Those innovations are described in detail and are critically commented. At the end of this section, I present a scheme, where all the approaches are classified as strategic or methodic innovations, but united under a model called "modern policing". The fact that the innovations are not competitive but rather complementary is the most important finding of this examination. The second part of this work deals with a unique survey about the implementation of four innovations and eight problem- and community-oriented activities in 85 Swiss police forces. This explorative study shows that in the last 15 years the Swiss police forces have increasingly adopted innovative approaches. The most frequent innovation is community policing, which has been implemented all over the country. Due to the results, we can also assume that the implementation of the innovations is mostly substantial and profound. However, particularly in the area of problem-solving there is still a need for improvements. The third section consists of a scientific evaluation of a temporary special unit of the municipal police Zurich, which, during nine months, fought against public drug dealing and illegal prostitution in a particular neighborhood called Langstrasse. The effects of this hot-spot project were measured with police data, observations and several population surveys. In general, the special unit achieved a positive outcome and helped to defuse the hot-spot. Additionally, a survey conducted within the police department showed that the personal attitude towards the special unit differed widely between the policemen. We found significant differences between both police regions East and West, rank-and-file and higher ranking officers, different ages and the personal connection to the special unit. In fact, the higher the rank, the lower the age, and the closer the relationship, the more positive the officers were towards the unit.

Acknowledgment and psychiatric symptoms in police officers in Switzerland

The way supervisors acknowledge specific contribution and efforts of their employees has an impact on occupational health and wellbeing. Acknowledgement is a protective factor when it is sufficiently provided. We carried out a study about occupational health in police officers with special emphasis on acknowledgment and reward. A questionnaire was sent to 1000 police officers and inspectors working for a cantonal administration in Switzerland. In total, 695 participants answered the questionnaire. We used the TST questionnaire (French version of the Langner's questionnaire on psychiatric symptoms) to identify cases characterized by potential mental health problems. Multiple choice items (5 modalities ranging from "not at all" to "tremendously") were used to measure acknowledgment. The score for psychiatric symptoms was high (TST score >or= 9) for 86 police officers and inspectors for whom health might be at risk. Compared with police officers having low or medium scores for psychiatric symptoms (TST score < 9), police officers with high TST scores were more likely to report the lack of support and attention from the supervisors (odds ratio [OR] 3.2, 95% confidence interval [CI] 2.0 to 5.1) and the lack of acknowledgment by the hierarchy (OR 3.0, 95% CI 1.9 to 4.8). They were also more likely to mention that judicial authorities have a low consideration for police officers (OR 2.7, 95% CI 1.7 to 4.3) and that the public in general have a low appreciation of police officers (OR 1.8, 95% CI 1.2 to 2.9). Preserving mental health in occupations characterized by high emotional demand is challenging. Our results show that acknowledgment and mental health are associated. Further research should address a potential causal relation of acknowledgment on mental health in police officers and inspectors.

The Inter-municipal Cooperation in Switzerland and the Trend towards Amalgamation

In Switzerland, the ongoing reforms of fiscal federalism put municipalities under increased fiscal stress. A majority of the municipalities had responded by increasing the cooperation with neighbouring municipalities over the last few years. Simultaneously, many discuss or are directly involved in a possible amalgamation project. Accordingly, the paper aimed at describing how cooperation has presently developed between Swiss municipalities, in order to illustrate the existing trend towards amalgamation. Current surveys helped us estimate the growing importance of inter-municipal arrangements together with the surge of amalgamations. A further goal was to investigate if cantonal financial incentives to municipal amalgamation essentially benefit the cantonal community, following the fiscal equivalence principle, or if they rather benefit amalgamating municipalities. In reality, equivalence does not exist. However, this may possibly be the condition to reduce inequality among amalgamating municipalities.

La force publique devant les caméras. Considérations sur la sous-veillance de la police par ses publics

Les médias de masse, en particulier Internet, ont profondément modifié la distribution du pouvoir dans notre société. Sous l'oeil des caméras et des citoyens-reporters, le pouvoir policier est l'objet d'une intense « sous-veillance » publique et médiatique. Pourquoi et comment sensibiliser les nouveaux entrants aux « risques médiatiques » de leur future profession ?

Copwatching et perception publique de la police. L'intervention policière comme performance sous surveillance

Envisagée comme une situation sociale de rassemblement en rue, l'intervention policière se caractérise par sa nature publique et observable. Le « copwatching », en tant que pratique amateur de captation vidéo des interventions de police, problématise la visibilité des agents sur la voie publique en les soumettant à une surveillance médiatique. M'appuyant sur des exemples vidéos, j'explore les dimensions visuelles et symboliques du travail policier. De la performance policière en rue à la figuration médiatique du policier, l'étude des médiations entre action et image permet d'interroger la perception publique de la police engagée dans les rassemblements. Abstract Cop-watching and the public perception of the police. Police intervention as performance under surveillance. This paper deals with police work as a public performance on the street. Cop-watching, a way of publicly observing and documenting police activities, reveals the complex relationship between public perceptions of law enforcement and the visual nature of much police work. Three methodological approaches to cop-watching videos allow us to highlight the visual dimensions of police work : the study of mass-media images of cops, the study of street performance by real cops, and the study of the ways people make sense of the visual symbolic environment present in everyday police work.

Médiatiser la police. Policer les médias

Le travail policier est depuis longtemps l'objet de récits etd'images qui ont durablement influencé notre imaginaire.Cette puissance narrative acquise fait aujourd'hui del'univers policier l'un des arrière-plans préférés des médias.À partir de ce constat, cet ouvrage se propose d'explorercomment des représentations de la police sont produiteset circulent dans, et entre, les champs du divertissement etde l'information, mais également comment l'institutionpolicière s'est elle-même constituée en pourvoyeuse et engardienne de son « image publique ». Plus que jamais, lemonde réel et le monde médiatique de la police coexistentet se confrontent, car les corps de police sont devenus desproducteurs actifs d'images et de discours sur leurspropres actions.Par un double mouvement, «médiatiser la police » et«policer les médias », ce livre étudie l'imaginaire social surla police, sa diffusion dans les médias de masse (télévision,presse, affiches, espaces muséaux...) ainsi que le travailcommunicationnel des polices modernes.

Traçologie: la trace, vecteur fondamental de la police scientifique

Les développements technologiques et la spécialisation des laboratoires de police scientifique et de science forensique éloignent de plus en plus les spécialistes de leur objet d'étude: la trace comme vestige, avec toutes les difficultés associées à son caractère unique, non contrôlé qui lui donnent la dimension d'une recherche historique plus qu'expérimentale. Pour paraphraser Kirk (Kirk 1963), la discipline qui touche à l'exploitation des traces fait appel à une pléthore de moyens techniques, mais manque cruellement de recherches et de développements fondamentaux. Cela se reflète d'ailleurs dans l'absence de rigueur quant au vocabulaire utilisé et une confusion dans la nomenclature, par exemple entre l'empreinte (référent) et la trace, l'échantillon (statistiquement sélectionné) et le spécimen, l'analyse, qui n'est pas que chimique, la contamination et la pollution. Ce manque de rigueur traverse la littérature scientifique et cet essai vise à clarifier la terminologie et à proposer un emploi sémantique strict du vocabulaire et des notions de base qui touchent aux fondements de la discipline.