Disaggregating chaperones: an unfolding story.

Stress, molecular crowding and mutations may jeopardize the native folding of proteins. Misfolded and aggregated proteins not only loose their biological activity, but may also disturb protein homeostasis, damage membranes and induce apoptosis. Here, we review the role of molecular chaperones as a network of cellular defenses against the formation of cytotoxic protein aggregates. Chaperones favour the native folding of proteins either as "holdases", sequestering hydrophobic regions in misfolding polypeptides, and/or as "unfoldases", forcibly unfolding and disentangling misfolded polypeptides from aggregates. Whereas in bacteria, plants and fungi Hsp70/40 acts in concert with the Hsp100 (ClpB) unfoldase, Hsp70/40 is the only known chaperone in the cytoplasm of mammalian cells that can forcibly unfold and neutralize cytotoxic protein conformers. Owing to its particular spatial configuration, the bulky 70 kDa Hsp70 molecule, when distally bound through a very tight molecular clamp onto a 50-fold smaller hydrophobic peptide loop extruding from an aggregate, can locally exert on the misfolded segment an unfolding force of entropic origin, thus destroying the misfolded structures that stabilize aggregates. ADP/ATP exchange triggers Hsp70 dissociation from the ensuing enlarged unfolded peptide loop, which is then allowed to spontaneously refold into a closer-to-native conformation devoid of affinity for the chaperone. Driven by ATP, the cooperative action of Hsp70 and its co-chaperone Hsp40 may thus gradually convert toxic misfolded protein substrates with high affinity for the chaperone, into non-toxic, natively refolded, low-affinity products. Stress- and mutation-induced protein damages in the cell, causing degenerative diseases and aging, may thus be effectively counteracted by a powerful network of molecular chaperones and of chaperone-related proteases.

Molecular chaperones and associated cellular clearance mechanisms against toxic protein conformers in Parkinson's disease.

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a slowly progressive neurodegenerative disorder marked by the loss of dopaminergic neurons (in particular in the substantia nigra) causing severe impairment of movement coordination and locomotion, associated with the accumulation of aggregated α-synuclein (α-Syn) into proteinaceous inclusions named Lewy bodies. Various early forms of misfolded α-Syn oligomers are cytotoxic. Their formation is favored by mutations and external factors, such as heavy metals, pesticides, trauma-related oxidative stress and heat shock. Here, we discuss the role of several complementing cellular defense mechanisms that may counteract PD pathogenesis, especially in youth, and whose effectiveness decreases with age. Particular emphasis is given to the 'holdase' and 'unfoldase' molecular chaperones that provide cells with potent means to neutralize and scavenge toxic protein conformers. Because chaperones can specifically recognize misfolded proteins, they are key specificity factors for other cellular defenses, such as proteolysis by the proteasome and autophagy. The efficiency of the cellular defenses decreases in stressed or aging neurons, leading to neuroinflammation, apoptosis and tissue loss. Thus, drugs that can upregulate the molecular chaperones, the ubiquitin-proteasome system and autophagy in brain tissues are promising avenues for therapies against PD and other mutation-, stress- or age-dependent protein-misfolding diseases.

Proteinaceous infectious behavior in non-pathogenic proteins is controlled by molecular chaperones.

External stresses or mutations may cause labile proteins to lose their distinct native conformations and seek alternatively stable aggregated forms. Molecular chaperones that specifically act on protein aggregates were used here as a tool to address the biochemical nature of stable homo- and hetero-aggregates from non-pathogenic proteins formed by heat-stress. Confirmed by sedimentation and activity measurements, chaperones demonstrated that a single polypeptide chain can form different species of aggregates, depending on the denaturing conditions. Indicative of a cascade reaction, sub-stoichiometric amounts of one fast-aggregating protein strongly accelerated the conversion of another soluble, slow-aggregating protein into insoluble, chaperone-resistant aggregates. Chaperones strongly inhibited seed-induced protein aggregation, suggesting that they can prevent and cure proteinaceous infectious behavior in homo- and hetero-aggregates from common and disease-associated proteins in the cell.

Active solubilization and refolding of stable protein aggregates by cooperative unfolding action of individual hsp70 chaperones.

Hsp70 is a central molecular chaperone that passively prevents protein aggregation and uses the energy of ATP hydrolysis to solubilize, translocate, and mediate the proper refolding of proteins in the cell. Yet, the molecular mechanism by which the active Hsp70 chaperone functions are achieved remains unclear. Here, we show that the bacterial Hsp70 (DnaK) can actively unfold misfolded structures in aggregated polypeptides, leading to gradual disaggregation. We found that the specific unfolding and disaggregation activities of individual DnaK molecules were optimal for large aggregates but dramatically decreased for small aggregates. The active unfolding of the smallest aggregates, leading to proper global refolding, required the cooperative action of several DnaK molecules per misfolded polypeptide. This finding suggests that the unique ATP-fueled locking/unlocking mechanism of the Hsp70 chaperones can recruit random chaperone motions to locally unfold misfolded structures and gradually disentangle stable aggregates into refoldable proteins.

Native folding of aggregation-prone recombinant proteins in Escherichia coli by osmolytes, plasmid- or benzyl alcohol-overexpressed molecular chaperones.

When massively expressed in bacteria, recombinant proteins often tend to misfold and accumulate as soluble and insoluble nonfunctional aggregates. A general strategy to improve the native folding of recombinant proteins is to increase the cellular concentration of viscous organic compounds, termed osmolytes, or of molecular chaperones that can prevent aggregation and can actively scavenge and convert aggregates into natively refoldable species. In this study, metal affinity purification (immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography [IMAC]), confirmed by resistance to trypsin digestion, was used to distinguish soluble aggregates from soluble nativelike proteins. Salt-induced accumulation of osmolytes during induced protein synthesis significantly improved IMAC yields of folding-recalcitrant proteins. Yet, the highest yields were obtained with cells coexpressing plasmid-encoded molecular chaperones DnaK-DnaJ-GrpE, ClpB, GroEL-GroES, and IbpA/B. Addition of the membrane fluidizer heat shock-inducer benzyl alcohol (BA) to the bacterial medium resulted in similar high yields as with plasmid-mediated chaperone coexpression. Our results suggest that simple BA-mediated induction of endogenous chaperones can substitute for the more demanding approach of chaperone coexpression. Combined strategies of osmolyte-induced native folding with heat-, BA-, or plasmid-induced chaperone coexpression can be thought to optimize yields of natively folded recombinant proteins in bacteria, for research and biotechnological purposes.

Stable alpha-synuclein oligomers strongly inhibit chaperone activity of the Hsp70 system by weak interactions with J-domain co-chaperones.

α-Synuclein aggregation and accumulation in Lewy bodies are implicated in progressive loss of dopaminergic neurons in Parkinson disease and related disorders. In neurons, the Hsp70s and their Hsp40-like J-domain co-chaperones are the only known components of chaperone network that can use ATP to convert cytotoxic protein aggregates into harmless natively refolded polypeptides. Here we developed a protocol for preparing a homogeneous population of highly stable β-sheet enriched toroid-shaped α-Syn oligomers with a diameter typical of toxic pore-forming oligomers. These oligomers were partially resistant to in vitro unfolding by the bacterial Hsp70 chaperone system (DnaK, DnaJ, GrpE). Moreover, both bacterial and human Hsp70/Hsp40 unfolding/refolding activities of model chaperone substrates were strongly inhibited by the oligomers but, remarkably, not by unstructured α-Syn monomers even in large excess. The oligomers acted as a specific competitive inhibitor of the J-domain co-chaperones, indicating that J-domain co-chaperones may preferably bind to exposed bulky misfolded structures in misfolded proteins and, thus, complement Hsp70s that bind to extended segments. Together, our findings suggest that inhibition of the Hsp70/Hsp40 chaperone system by α-Syn oligomers may contribute to the disruption of protein homeostasis in dopaminergic neurons, leading to apoptosis and tissue loss in Parkinson disease and related neurodegenerative diseases.

Hsp70 chaperones accelerate protein translocation and the unfolding of stable protein aggregates by entropic pulling.

Hsp70s are highly conserved ATPase molecular chaperones mediating the correct folding of de novo synthesized proteins, the translocation of proteins across membranes, the disassembly of some native protein oligomers, and the active unfolding and disassembly of stress-induced protein aggregates. Here, we bring thermodynamic arguments and biochemical evidences for a unifying mechanism named entropic pulling, based on entropy loss due to excluded-volume effects, by which Hsp70 molecules can convert the energy of ATP hydrolysis into a force capable of accelerating the local unfolding of various protein substrates and, thus, perform disparate cellular functions. By means of entropic pulling, individual Hsp70 molecules can accelerate unfolding and pulling of translocating polypeptides into mitochondria in the absence of a molecular fulcrum, thus settling former contradictions between the power-stroke and the Brownian ratchet models for Hsp70-mediated protein translocation across membranes. Moreover, in a very different context devoid of membrane and components of the import pore, the same physical principles apply to the forceful unfolding, solubilization, and assisted native refolding of stable protein aggregates by individual Hsp70 molecules, thus providing a mechanism for Hsp70-mediated protein disaggregation.

The mechanism of Hsp70 chaperones: (entropic) pulling the models together.

Hsp70s are conserved molecular chaperones that can prevent protein aggregation, actively unfold, solubilize aggregates, pull translocating proteins across membranes and remodel native proteins complexes. Disparate mechanisms have been proposed for the various modes of Hsp70 action: passive prevention of aggregation by kinetic partitioning, peptide-bond isomerase, Brownian ratcheting or active power-stroke pulling. Recently, we put forward a unifying mechanism named 'entropic pulling', which proposed that Hsp70 uses the energy of ATP hydrolysis to recruit a force of entropic origin to locally unfold aggregates or pull proteins across membranes. The entropic pulling mechanism reproduces the expected phenomenology that inspired the other disparate mechanisms and is, moreover, simple.

Molecular chaperones as enzymes that catalytically unfold misfolded polypeptides.

Stress-denatured or de novo synthesized and translocated unfolded polypeptides can spontaneously reach their native state without assistance of other proteins. Yet, the pathway to native folding is complex, stress-sensitive and prone to errors. Toxic misfolded and aggregated conformers may accumulate in cells and lead to degenerative diseases. Members of the canonical conserved families of molecular chaperones, Hsp100s, Hsp70/110/40s, Hsp60/CCTs, the small Hsps and probably also Hsp90s, can recognize and bind with high affinity, abnormally exposed hydrophobic surfaces on misfolded and aggregated polypeptides. Binding to Hsp100, Hsp70, Hsp110, Hsp40, Hsp60, CCTs and Trigger factor may cause partial unfolding of the misfolded polypeptide substrates, and ATP hydrolysis can induce further unfolding and release from the chaperone, leading to spontaneous refolding into native proteins with low-affinity for the chaperones. Hence, specific chaperones act as catalytic polypeptide unfolding isomerases, rerouting cytotoxic misfolded and aggregated polypeptides back onto their physiological native refolding pathway, thus averting the onset of protein conformational diseases.

Molecular chaperones are nanomachines that catalytically unfold misfolded and alternatively folded proteins.

By virtue of their general ability to bind (hold) translocating or unfolding polypeptides otherwise doomed to aggregate, molecular chaperones are commonly dubbed "holdases". Yet, chaperones also carry physiological functions that do not necessitate prevention of aggregation, such as altering the native states of proteins, as in the disassembly of SNARE complexes and clathrin coats. To carry such physiological functions, major members of the Hsp70, Hsp110, Hsp100, and Hsp60/CCT chaperone families act as catalytic unfolding enzymes or unfoldases that drive iterative cycles of protein binding, unfolding/pulling, and release. One unfoldase chaperone may thus successively convert many misfolded or alternatively folded polypeptide substrates into transiently unfolded intermediates, which, once released, can spontaneously refold into low-affinity native products. Whereas during stress, a large excess of non-catalytic chaperones in holding mode may optimally prevent protein aggregation, after the stress, catalytic disaggregases and unfoldases may act as nanomachines that use the energy of ATP hydrolysis to repair proteins with compromised conformations. Thus, holding and catalytic unfolding chaperones can act as primary cellular defenses against the formation of early misfolded and aggregated proteotoxic conformers in order to avert or retard the onset of degenerative protein conformational diseases.

L'agrégation toxique des protéines: une forme de "delinquance moléculaire" activement combattue dans la cellule par les chaperones moléculaires et les protéases [The toxic aggregation of proteins: a kind of "molecular delinquency" actively fought in the cell by molecular chaperones and proteases]

Under various stresses, mutation-sensitised proteins may spontaneously convert into inactive, aggregation-prone structures, which may be cytotoxic and infectious. In the cell, this new kind of "molecular criminality" is actively fought against by a network of molecular chaperones that can specifically identify, isolate and unfold damaged (delinquent) proteins and favour their subsequent native refolding. Irreversibly damaged molecules unable to natively refold are preferentially "executed" and recycled by proteases. Failing that, they are "imprisoned" within compact amyloids, or "evicted" from the cell. Thus, striking parallels, although of questionable ethical value, exist between protein and human criminality, and between the cellular and social responses to these different types of criminality. Fundamental differences also exist. Whereas programmed death (apoptosis) is the preferred solution chosen by aged and aggregation-stressed cells, collective suicide is seldom an option chosen by lawless human societies. More significantly, there is no clear cellular equivalent for the role of the family and the education system, which are so essential to the proper shaping of functional individuals in the society, and give rise to humanism, that favours crime prevention, reeducation and reinsertion programs over capital punishment. To the cardiologist and transplantation surgeon, the interest of molecular chaperones, in particular of Hsp70, Hsp90 and Hsp27, lays in their ability to inhibit the signalling pathway of programmed cell death. Their induction before and during ischemia, by various treatments and drugs could significantly reduce damages from the post ischemic reperfusion of organs.

Mechanistic insights into cytosolic molecular chaperones in protein unfolding and disaggregation

Under optimal non-physiological conditions of low concentrations and low temperatures, proteins may spontaneously fold to the native state, as all the information for folding lies in the amino acid sequence of the polypeptide. However, under conditions of stress or high protein crowding as inside cells, a polypeptide may misfold and enter an aggregation pathway resulting in the formation of misfolded conformers and fibrils, which can be toxic and lead to neurodegenerative illnesses, such as Alzheimer's, Parkinson's or Huntington's diseases and aging in general. To avert and revert protein misfolding and aggregation, cells have evolved a set of proteins called molecular chaperones. Here, I focussed on the human cytosolic chaperones Hsp70 (DnaK) and HspllO, and co-chaperone Hsp40 (DnaJ), and the chaperonin CCT (GroEL). The cytosolic molecular chaperones Hsp70s/Hspll0s and the chaperonins are highly upregulated in bacterial and human cells under different stresses and are involved both in the prevention and the reversion of protein misfolding and aggregation. Hsp70 works in collaboration with Hsp40 to reactivate misfolded or aggregated proteins in a strict ATP dependent manner. Chaperonins (CCT and GroEL) also unfold and reactivate stably misfolded proteins but we found that it needed to use the energy of ATP hydrolysis in order to evict over- sticky misfolded intermediates that inhibited the unfoldase catalytic sites. Ill In this study, we initially characterized a particular type of inactive misfolded monomeric luciferase and rhodanese species that were obtained by repeated cycles of freeze-thawing (FT). These stable misfolded monomeric conformers (FT-luciferase and FT-rhodanese) had exposed hydrophobic residues and were enriched with wrong ß-sheet structures (Chapter 2). Using FT-luciferase as substrate, we found that the Hsp70 orthologs, called HspllO (Sse in yeast), acted similarly to Hsp70 as were bona fide ATP- fuelled polypeptide unfoldases and was much more than a mere nucleotide exchange factor, as generally thought. Moreover, we found that HspllO collaborated with Hsp70 in the disaggregation of stable protein aggregates in which Hsp70 and HspllO acted as equal partners that synergistically combined their individual ATP-consuming polypeptide unfoldase activities to reactivate the misfolded/aggregated proteins (Chapter 3). Using FT-rhodanese as substrate, we found that chaperonins (GroEL and CCT) could catalytically reactivate misfolded rhodanese monomers in the absence of ATP. Also, our results suggested that encaging of an unfolding polypeptide inside the GroEL cavity under a GroES cap was not an obligatory step as generally thought (Chapter 4). Further, we investigated the role of Hsp40, a J-protein co-chaperone of Hsp70, in targeting misfolded polypeptides substrates onto Hsp70 for unfolding. We found that even a large excess of monomeric unfolded a-synuclein did not inhibit DnaJ, whereas, in contrast, stable misfolded a-synuclein oligomers strongly inhibited the DnaK-mediated chaperone reaction by way of sequestering the DnaJ co-chaperone. This work revealed that DnaJ could specifically distinguish, and bind potentially toxic stably aggregated species, such as soluble a-synuclein oligomers involved in Parkinson's disease, and with the help of DnaK and ATP convert them into from harmless natively unfolded a-synuclein monomers (chapter 5). Finally, our meta-analysis of microarray data of plant and animal tissues treated with various chemicals and abiotic stresses, revealed possible co-expressions between core chaperone machineries and their co-chaperone regulators. It clearly showed that protein misfolding in the cytosol elicits a different response, consisting of upregulating the synthesis mainly of cytosolic chaperones, from protein misfolding in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) that elicited a typical unfolded protein response (UPR), consisting of upregulating the synthesis mainly of ER chaperones. We proposed that drugs that best mimicked heat or UPR stress at increasing the chaperone load in the cytoplasm or ER respectively, may prove effective at combating protein misfolding diseases and aging (Chapter 6).  - Dans les conditions optimales de basse concentration et de basse température, les protéines vont spontanément adopter un repliement natif car toutes les informations nécessaires se trouvent dans la séquence des acides aminés du polypeptide. En revanche, dans des conditions de stress ou de forte concentration des protéines comme à l'intérieur d'une cellule, un polypeptide peu mal se replier et entrer dans un processus d'agrégation conduisant à la formation de conformères et de fibrilles qui peuvent être toxiques et causer des maladies neurodégénératives comme la maladie d'Alzheimer, la maladie de Parkinson ou la chorée de Huntington. Afin d'empêcher ou de rectifier le mauvais repliement des protéines, les cellules ont développé des protéines appelées chaperonnes. Dans ce travail, je me suis intéressé aux chaperonnes cytosoliques Hsp70 (DnaK) et HspllO, la co-chaperones Hsp40 (DnaJ), le complexe CCT/TRiC et GroEL. Chez les bactéries et les humains, les chaperonnes cytosoliques Hsp70s/Hspl 10s et les « chaperonines» sont fortement activées par différentes conditions de stress et sont toutes impliquées dans la prévention et la correction du mauvais repliement des protéines et de leur agrégation. Hsp70 collabore avec Hsp40 pour réactiver les protéines agrégées ou mal repliées et leur action nécessite de 1ATP. Les chaperonines (GroEL) déplient et réactivent aussi les protéines mal repliées de façon stable mais nous avons trouvé qu'elles utilisent l'ATP pour libérer les intermédiaires collant et mal repliés du site catalytique de dépliage. Nous avons initialement caractérisé un type particulier de formes stables de luciférase et de rhodanese monomériques mal repliées obtenues après plusieurs cycles de congélation / décongélation répétés (FT). Ces monomères exposaient des résidus hydrophobiques et étaient plus riches en feuillets ß anormaux. Ils pouvaient cependant être réactivés par les chaperonnes Hsp70+Hsp40 (DnaK+DnaJ) et de l'ATP, ou par Hsp60 (GroEL) sans ATP (Chapitre 2). En utilisant la FT-Luciferase comme substrat nous avons trouvé que HspllO (un orthologue de Hsp70) était une authentique dépliase, dépendante strictement de l'ATP. De plus, nous avons trouvé que HspllO collaborait avec Hsp70 dans la désagrégation d'agrégats stables de protéines en combinant leurs activités dépliase consommatrice d'ATP (Chapitre 3). En utilisant la FT-rhodanese, nous avons trouvé que les chaperonines (GroEL et CCT) pouvaient réactiver catalytiquement des monomères mal repliés en absence d'ATP. Nos résultats suggérèrent également que la capture d'un polypeptide en cours de dépliement dans la cavité de GroEL et sous un couvercle du complexe GroES ne serait pas une étape obligatoire du mécanisme, comme il est communément accepté dans la littérature (Chapitre 4). De plus, nous avons étudié le rôle de Hsp40, une co-chaperones de Hsp70, dans l'adressage de substrats polypeptidiques mal repliés vers Hsp70. Ce travail a révélé que DnaJ pouvait différencier et lier des polypeptide mal repliés (toxiques), comme des oligomères d'a-synucléine dans la maladie de Parkinson, et clairement les différencier des monomères inoffensifs d'a-synucléine (Chapitre 5). Finalement une méta-analyse de données de microarrays de tissus végétaux et animaux traités avec différents stress chimiques et abiotiques a révélé une possible co-expression de la machinerie des chaperonnes et des régulateurs de co- chaperonne. Cette meta-analyse montre aussi clairement que le mauvais repliement des protéines dans le cytosol entraîne la synthèse de chaperonnes principalement cytosoliques alors que le mauvais repliement de protéines dans le réticulum endoplasmique (ER) entraine une réponse typique de dépliement (UPR) qui consiste principalement en la synthèse de chaperonnes localisées dans l'ER. Nous émettons l'hypothèse que les drogues qui reproduisent le mieux les stress de chaleur ou les stress UPR pourraient se montrer efficaces dans la lutte contre le mauvais repliement des protéines et le vieillissement (Chapitre 6).

Chaperones and proteases: cellular fold-controlling factors of proteins in neurodegenerative diseases and aging.

The formation of toxic protein aggregates is a common denominator to many neurodegenerative diseases and aging. Accumulation of toxic, possibly infectious protein aggregates induces a cascade of events, such as excessive inflammation, the production of reactive oxygen species, apoptosis and neuronal loss. A network of highly conserved molecular chaperones and of chaperone-related proteases controls the fold-quality of proteins in the cell. Most molecular chaperones can passively prevent protein aggregation by binding misfolding intermediates. Some molecular chaperones and chaperone-related proteases, such as the proteasome, can also hydrolyse ATP to forcefully convert stable harmful protein aggregates into harmless natively refoldable, or protease-degradable, polypeptides. Molecular chaperones and chaperone-related proteases thus control the delicate balance between natively folded functional proteins and aggregation-prone misfolded proteins, which may form during the lifetime and lead to cell death. Abundant data now point at the molecular chaperones and the proteases as major clearance mechanisms to remove toxic protein aggregates from cells, delaying the onset and the outcome of protein-misfolding diseases. Therapeutic approaches include treatments and drugs that can specifically induce and sustain a strong chaperone and protease activity in cells and tissues prone to toxic protein aggregations.