Preserving the health of ambulance personnel : some preliminary results from a study of pre-hospital emergency interventions

Little is known about the health of ambulance personnel, especially in Switzerland. This lack of knowledge is particularly striking in the specific field of occupational health. This study aims to identify and better understand protective and risk factors affecting the health of ambulance personnel. Both mental and physical health are considered. The approach used comprised two steps. The first step began in July 2008 and consisted in a qualitative study of real work activities performed by ambulance crews involved in pre-hospital emergency interventions. Researchers shadowed ambulance personnel for the duration of their entire work shift, in average for one week. The paper-pen technique was used to note dialogues, interactions, postural aspects, etc. When the situation allowed it, interventions were filmed. Some selected video sequences were used as a support for selfconfrontation interviews. Observations were performed by three researchers and took place in eleven services, for a total of 416 hours of observations (including 72 interventions + waiting time). Analysis, conducted by a multidisciplinary team (an ergonomist, an occupational therapist and a health psychologist), focused on individual and collective strategies used by ambulance personnel to protect their health. The second step, which is currently ongoing, aims to assess global health of ambulance personnel. A questionnaire is used to gather information about musculoskeletal complaints (Nordic questionnaire), mental health (GHQ-12), stress (Effort-Reward imbalance questionnaire), strategies implemented to cope with stress (Brief COPE), and working conditions. Specific items on strategies were developed based on observational data. It will be sent to all ambulance personnel employed in the French-speaking part of Switzerland. Preliminary analyses show different types of strategies used by ambulance personnel to preserve their health. These strategies involve postural aspects (e.g. use doorframe as a support to ease delicate manipulations), work environment adaptations (e.g. move furniture to avoid awkward postures), coping strategies (e.g. humor), as well as organisational (e.g. formal and informal debriefing) and collective (e.g. cooperation) mechanisms. In-depth analysis is still ongoing. However, patient safety and comfort, work environment and available resources appear to influence the choice of strategies ambulance personnel use. As far as possible, the strategies identified will be transformed into educational materials for professional ambulance personnel.

Facteurs et stratégies favorisant la préservation de la santé chez les ambulanciers

Cette étude s'est déroulée en Romandie en 2008-2009 et visait à connaître les stratégies de préservation de la santé chez les ambulanciers. Nous avons passé 416 heures à observer des ambulanciers travailler. Les stratégies observées touchent le travail d'équipe, l'organisation, la charge physique, etc. Un questionnaire a été envoyé à tous les ambulanciers en Romandie. Les ambulanciers sont nombreux à avoir des symptômes au dos et à avoir un score élevé pour le GHQ-12 (risque de trouble psychique). Des associations ont été observées entre certains symptômes et la fréquence et le type d'intervention, le ratio efforts-récompenses et certains aspects organisationnels.

Trouver un sens à son activité professionnelle : un aspect important de la santé au travail pour les ambulanciers

Le thème de la santé mentale des intervenants de l'Aide Médicale Urgente est particulièrement important. Le sens que revêt le travail pour ces professionnels semble central pour comprendre les motivations qui permettent aux personnes de gérer des situations à forte composante relationnelle. Comment faire pour éviter la perte de sens au travail ou la retrouver ? Une étude réalisée de suisse auprès de paramédics apporte quelques pistes de réflexion. Il convient de rappeler que les ambulanciers français ne disposent pas de la même formation que les ambulanciers suisses, paramédics. [Auteurs]

Les professions de la santé: guide des formations

[Table des matières] I. Formations de base : Aide-soignant - Ambulancier - Diététicien - Ergothérapeute - Hygiéniste dentaire - Infirmier niveau I; niveau II - Laborantin medical - Pédicure ; podologue - Physiothérapeute - Sage-femme - Technicien en radiologie médicale - Technicien en salle d'opération - Assistant social. II. Formations continues : Ambulancier - Ergothérapeutes - Centre romand d'éducation permanente, Association suisse des infirmières - Laborantin médical - Formation continue en physiothérapie- Technicien en radiologie médicale, Contrôle de qualité en radiodiagnostic - Technicien en radiologie médicale, Formation continue en radioprotection et technique radiologique - Laborantin médical - Programme du service de formation continue du CHUV - Activités de formation continue du centre de formation H+ - Introduction à l'éthique en psychiatrie. III. Formations complémentaires : ESEI - Les activités de formation complémentaire du centre de formation H+ - Infirmier, Formation complémentaire de clinicien niveau I - Infirmier, Formation complémentaire en anesthésie - Infirmier, Formation complémentaire en soins intensifs - Infirmier, Formation complémentaire en salle d'opération - Laborantin médical, Formation supérieure et de cadres - Laborantin médical, Formation complémentaire spécialisée cytotechnicien - Assistant social - Formation de physiothérapeute enseignant. IV. Formations universitaires : Séminaire de gestion hospitalière - Bioéthique - Diplôme en économie et administration de la santé - Management des Institutions de santé - Ingéniérie biomédicale - Certificat en nutrition humaine - Cours postgrade de santé au travail.

Un aspect important de la santé au travail pour les ambulanciers : trouver un sens à son activité professionnelle

Le thème de la santé mentale des intervenants de l'Aide médicale urgente est particulièrement important. Le sens que revêt le travail pour ces professionnels semble central pour comprendre les motivations qui permettent aux personnes de gérer des situations à forte composante relationnelle. Comment faire pour éviter la perte de sens au travail ou la retrouver ? Une étude réalisée en Suisse auprès de " paramédics " apporte quelques pistes de réflexion. Il convient de rappeler que les ambulanciers français ne disposent pas de la même formation que les ambulanciers suisses. Le sens que revêt le travail pour les ambulanciers est central pour expliquer ce choix de carrière et de vie. Il permet aussi en partie de compenser les différents risques pour la santé que comporte cette profession. C'est du moins ce que suggèrent certaines théories récentes en santé au travail. Selon ces théories, le fait d'accorder une certaine importance à son travail, de se sentir utile et engagé dans un projet qui a du sens contribuerait à préserver la santé et l'implication du travailleur. Toutefois, un travail qui demanderait un engagement trop important (en terme de temps, de compétences ou autre) de la part du travailleur pourrait mener à la sur-implication de ce dernier et dans certains cas porter atteinte à sa santé. Un certain équilibre doit alors être retrouvé. [Auteurs]

Risk factors of sunburns from occupational sun exposure in outdoor workers

Question: Outdoor workers can be exposed to intense ultraviolet (UV) solar radiation likely to results to sunburns. As sunburn is an important risk factor for skin cancer, in particular melanoma, we investigated the causes of occupational sunburns (OS) in French outdoor workers. Methods: A population-based survey was conducted in May-June 2012 through computer-assisted telephonic interviews in population 25 to 69 years of age. History of sunburn from occupational exposure within the year preceding interview was collected. We analysed the risk of OS in multivariate logistic regression. Results: Out of 1442 individuals who declared having an occupational exposure to solar UV radiation, 403 (27.9%) reported a sunburn from occupational exposure in the year preceding the interview. Sunburns were more frequent in women (30% vs. 26.4% in men although not significant p = 0.14), in younger workers (p = 0.0099), in sensitive phototype (40% in phototype I/II vs. 23% in phototype III/IV, p < 0.001) and in workers taking lunch outdoor (p = 0.0355). Some occupations were more associated with OS (more than 30%): health occupations, managing, research/engineering, construction workers and culture/art/social sciences workers. In multivariate analysis, risk factors for OS are phototype (I vs. IV, OR = 4.30 95% CI [2.65-6.98]), sunburn during leisure time (OR = 3.46 95% CI [2.62-4.59]), seasonality of exposure (seasonal vs. constant exposure OR = 1.36 95% CI [1.02-1.81] and annual UVA exposure (OR for 10J/m² daily average increment 1.08 95% CI [1.02-1.14]). In multivariate analysis the type of occupation was not associated with increased OS. Conclusion: Sunburns from occupation was also observed in non sensitive population, phototype IV, which shows that outdoor workers are potentially exposed to intense UV radiations. This study suggests that prevention should target UV sensitive outdoor workers as well as those cumulating intense UV exposure.

Health at work and risk factors related to ergonomics: some results from the Swiss sample of the 4th European working conditions survey

Introduction The European Foundation for the improvement of living and working conditions conducts a survey every 5 years since 1990. The foundation also offers the possibility to non-EU countries to be included in the survey: in 2005, Switzerland took part for the first time in the fourth edition of this survey. The Institute for Work and Health (IST) has been associated to the Swiss project conducted under the leadership of the SECO and the Fachhochschule Nordwestschweiz. The survey covers different aspects of work like job characteristics and employment conditions, health and safety, work organization, learning and development opportunities, and the balance between working and non-working life (Parent-Thirion, Fernandez Macias, Hurley, & Vermeylen, 2007). More particularly, one question assesses the worker's self-perception of the effects of work on health. We identified (for the Swiss sample) several factors affecting the risk to report health problems caused by work. The Swiss sample includes 1040 respondents. Selection of participants was based on a random multi-stage sampling and was carried out by M.I.S Trend S.A. (Lausanne). Participation rate was 59%. The database was weighted by household size, gender, age, region of domicile, occupational group, and economic sector. Specially trained interviewers carried out the interviews at the respondents home. The survey was carriedout between the 19th of September 2005 and the 30th of November 2005. As detailed in (Graf et al., 2007), 31% of the Swiss respondents identify work as the cause of health problems they experience. Most frequently reported health problems include back pain (18%), stress (17%), muscle pain (13%), and overall fatigue (11%). Ergonomic aspects associated with higher risk of reporting health problems caused by work include frequent awkward postures (odds ratio [OR] 4.7, 95% confidence interval [CI] 3.1 to 5.4), tasks involving lifting heavy loads (OR 2.7, 95% CI 2.0 to 3.6) or lifting people (OR 2.2, 95% CI 1.4 to 3.5), standing or walking (OR 1.4, 95% CI 1.1 to 1.9), as well as repetitive movements (OR 1.7, 95% CI 1.3 to 2.3). These results highlight the need to continue and intensify the prevention of work related health problems in occupations characterized by risk factors related to ergonomics.

Acknowledgment and health in police officers

The way colleagues and supervisors acknowledge specific contribution and efforts of individuals is crucial for occupational mental health and well being. It contributes to improve the self image of employees and it gives a sense to the activities performed. We carried out a study about occupational health in police officers with a special emphasis on acknowledgment and reward. A questionnaire was sent to 1000 police officers working for a cantonal administration in Switzerland. In total, 695 participants answered the questionnaire. We used the French version of the Langner's questionnaire on psychiatric symptoms to identify cases characterized by potential mental health problems. Multiple choice items (6 modalities ranging from "not at all" to "tremendously") to measure acknowledgment were used. Answers were later dichotomized (low annoyance- high annoyance). Questions we used are: "Do you feel annoyed due to a lack of support and attention from your supervisors?" "Do you feel annoyed because the authorities (politics, judges, etc.) have a low consideration of your occupation?" "Do you feel annoyed due to a low appreciation by the public?" and "Do you feel annoyed due to a lack of acknowledgment by the hierarchy?". The score for psychiatric symptoms was high for 86 police officers for whom health might be at risk. Acknowledgment aspects associated with a high score for psychiatric symptoms are : high annoyance due to a lack of support and attention from supervisors (odds ratio [OR] 3.2, 95% confidence interval [CI] 2.0 to 5.1), high annoyance because authorities seems to have a low consideration for police officers (OR 2.7, 95% CI 1.7 to 4.3), high annoyance due to a low appreciation by the public (OR 1.8, 95% CI 1.2 to 2.9), and high annoyance due to a lack of acknowledgment by the hierarchy (OR 3.0, 95% CI 1.9 to 4.8). Preserving mental health in occupations characterized by high emotional demand is challenging. The results from our study suggest that appropriate acknowledgment might contribute to the prevention of mental health problems. Further research should address a potential causal relation of acknowledgment on mental health.

Occupational exposure to beryllium in Switzerland : exposed workers and occupations at risk

Introduction: Beryllium (Be) is increasingly used in various industrial applications. Occupational exposure to Be may lead to chronic beryllium disease (CBD), a pulmonary granulomatous disorder closely similar to sarcoidosis, which develop in 1 to 15% of exposed workers. Although Switzerland is one of the major Be importers worldwide, little information is available about occurrence of exposure and the number of workers exposed in this country. Objectives: 1) evaluate the number of workers potentially exposed to Be in Switzerland; 2) construct a screening tool to allow potential Be exposure detection in a clinical setting. Methods: After identification of industrial sectors involving beryllium exposure based on expert reports and scientific literature, an estimation of the number of workers employed in these relevant industries was made using data from the Swiss federal population census and registries of economic activities. A second analysis was performed to estimate the fraction of workers really exposed to Be in each industrial sector. This adjustment was made according to the results of a French survey (INRS, Institut National de Recherche et de Sécurité) conducted by questionnaire addressed to 4500 companies in relevant industries on their use of beryllium and other issues such as percentage of employees really exposed. These realistic data were used to develop a self-administrated screening questionnaire allowed to identify patients with possible Be exposure. Results: In Switzerland, the number of workers employed in industries using Be was nearly 150 000. The estimated number of workers exposed to beryllium in these industries ranged from 2000 to 4000. Relevant sectors were: microengineering, precision turning, watchmaking and metal waste treatment and recycling. The validation of the self-administrated questionnaire containing a list of jobs and leisure activities associated with potential Be exposure is in progress within the framework of a national study. Conclusions: The number of workers potentially exposed to Be in Switzerland is rather high compared to estimations for other industrialized countries and might constitute an underestimated occupational health problem. Undetected Be exposure in patients with sarcoidosis may occur and result in misdiagnosis. Once validated, the self-administrated questionnaire could be used by clinicians to screen for Be exposure in patients with granulomatous lung disorders.