Regulation of horizontal gene transfer of the catabolic island ICEclc

ICEclc is a mobile genetic element found in two copies on the chromosome of the bacterium Pseudomonas knackmussii B13. ICEclc harbors genes encoding metabolic pathways for the degradation of chlorocatechols (CLC) and 2-aminophenol (2AP). At low frequencies, ICEclc excises from the chromosome, closes into a circular DNA molecule which can transfer to another bacterium via conjugation. Once in the recipient cell, ICEclc can reintegrate into the chromosome by site-specific recombination. This thesis aimed at identifying the regulatory network underlying the decisions for ICEclc horizontal transfer (HGT). The first chapter is an introduction on integrative and conjugative elements (ICEs) more in general, of which ICEclc is one example. In particular I emphasized the current knowledge of regulation and conjugation machineries of the different classes of ICE. In the second chapter, I describe a transcriptional analysis using microarrays and other experiments to understand expression of ICEclc in exponential and stationary phase. By overlaying transcriptomic profiles with Northern hybridizations and RT- PCR data, we established a transcription map for the entire core region of ICEclc, a region assumed to encode the ICE conjugation process. We also demonstrated how transcription of the ICEclc core is maximal in stationary phase, which correlates to expression of reporter genes fused to key ICEclc promoters. In the third chapter, I present a transcriptome analysis of ICEclc in a variety of different host species, in order to explore whether there are species-specific differences. In the fourth chapter, I focus on the role of a curious ICEclc-encoded TetR-type transcriptional repressor. We find that this gene, which we name mfsR, not only controls its own expression but that of a set of genes for a putative multi-drug efflux pump (mfsABC) as well. By using a combination of biochemical and molecular biology techniques, I could show that MfsR specifically binds to operator boxes in two ICEclc promoters (PmfsR and PmfsA), inhibiting the transcription of both the mfsR and mfsABC-orf38184 operons. Although we could not detect a clear phenotype of an mfsABC deletion, we discuss the implications of pump gene reorganizations in ICEclc and close relatives. In the fifth chapter, we find that mfsR not only controls its own expression and that of the mfsABC operon, but is also indirectly controlling ICEclc transfer. Using gene deletions, microarrays, transfer assays and microscopy-based reporter fusions, we demonstrate that mfsR actually controls a small operon of three regulatory genes. The last gene of this mfsR operon, orf17162, encodes a LysR-type activator that when deleted strongly impairs ICEclc transfer. Interestingly, deletion of mfsR leads to transfer competence in almost all cells, thereby overruling the bistability process in the wild-type. In the final sixth chapter, I discuss the relevance of the present thesis and the resulting perspectives for future studies.

Host and invader impact of transfer of the clc genomic island into Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1

Genomic islands, large potentially mobile regions of bacterial chromosomes, are a major contributor to bacteria evolution. Here, we investigated the fitness cost and phenotypic differences between the bacterium Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1 and a derivative carrying one integrated copy of the clc element, a 103-kb genomic island [and integrative and conjugative element (ICE)] originating in Pseudomonas sp. strain B13 and a close relative of genomic islands found in clinical and environmental isolates of P. aeruginosa. By using a combination of whole genome transcriptome profiling, phenotypic arrays, competition experiments, and biofilm formation studies, only few differences became apparent, such as reduced biofilm growth and fourfold stationary phase repression of genes involved in acetoin metabolism in PAO1 containing the clc element. In contrast, PAO1 carrying the clc element acquired the capacity to grow on 3-chlorobenzoate and 2-aminophenol as sole carbon and energy substrates. No fitness loss >1% was detectable in competition experiments between PAO1 and PAO1 carrying the clc element. The genes from the clc element were not silent in PAO1, and excision was observed, although transfer of clc from PAO1 to other recipient bacteria was reduced by two orders of magnitude. Our results indicate that newly acquired mobile DNA not necessarily invoke an important fitness cost on their host. Absence of immediate detriment to the host may have contributed to the wide distribution of genomic islands like clc in bacterial genomes

Transcriptome analysis of the mobile genome ICEclc in Pseudomonas knackmussii B13.

Background: Integrative and conjugative elements (ICE) form a diverse group of DNA elements that are integrated in the chromosome of the bacterial host, but can occasionally excise and horizontally transfer to a new host cell. ICE come in different families, typically with a conserved core for functions controlling the element's behavior and a variable region providing auxiliary functions to the host. The ICEclc element of Pseudomonas knackmussii strain B13 is representative for a large family of chromosomal islands detected by genome sequencing approaches. It provides the host with the capacity to degrade chloroaromatics and 2-aminophenol. Results: Here we study the transcriptional organization of the ICEclc core region. By northern hybridizations, reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) and Rapid Amplification of cDNA Ends (5'-RACE) fifteen transcripts were mapped in the core region. The occurrence and location of those transcripts were further confirmed by hybridizing labeled cDNA to a semi-tiling micro-array probing both strands of the ICEclc core region. Dot blot and semi-tiling array hybridizations demonstrated most of the core transcripts to be upregulated during stationary phase on 3-chlorobenzoate, but not on succinate or glucose. Conclusions: The transcription analysis of the ICEclc core region provides detailed insights in the mode of regulatory organization and will help to further understand the complex mode of behavior of this class of mobile elements. We conclude that ICEclc core transcription is concerted at a global level, more reminiscent of a phage program than of plasmid conjugation.

The TetR-type MfsR protein of the integrative and conjugative element (ICE) ICEclc controls both a putative efflux system and initiation of ICE transfer.

Integrative and conjugating elements (ICE) are self-transferable DNAs widely present in bacterial genomes, which often carry a variety of auxiliary genes of potential adaptive benefit. One of the model ICE is ICEclc, an element originally found in Pseudomonas knackmussii B13 and known for its propensity to provide its host with the capacity to metabolize chlorocatechols and 2-aminophenol. In this work, we studied the mechanism and target of regulation of MfsR, a TetR-type repressor previously found to exert global control on ICEclc horizontal transfer. By using a combination of ICEclc mutant and transcriptome analysis, gene reporter fusions, and DNA binding assays, we found that MfsR is a repressor of both its own expression and that of a gene cluster putatively coding for a major facilitator superfamily efflux system on ICEclc (named mfsABC). Phylogenetic analysis suggests that mfsR was originally located immediately adjacent to the efflux pump genes but became displaced from its original cis target DNA by a gene insertion. This resulted in divergence of the original bidirectional promoters into two separated individual regulatory units. Deletion of mfsABC did not result in a strong phenotype, and despite screening a large number of compounds and conditions, we were unable to define the precise current function or target of the putative efflux pump. Our data reconstruct how the separation of an ancestor mfsR-mfsABC system led to global control of ICEclc transfer by MfsR.

The clc element of Pseudomonas sp. strain B13, a genomic island with various catabolic properties.

Pseudomonas sp. strain B13 is a bacterium known to degrade chloroaromatic compounds. The properties to use 3- and 4-chlorocatechol are determined by a self-transferable DNA element, the clc element, which normally resides at two locations in the cell's chromosome. Here we report the complete nucleotide sequence of the clc element, demonstrating the unique catabolic properties while showing its relatedness to genomic islands and integrative and conjugative elements rather than to other known catabolic plasmids. As far as catabolic functions, the clc element harbored, in addition to the genes for chlorocatechol degradation, a complete functional operon for 2-aminophenol degradation and genes for a putative aromatic compound transport protein and for a multicomponent aromatic ring dioxygenase similar to anthranilate hydroxylase. The genes for catabolic functions were inducible under various conditions, suggesting a network of catabolic pathway induction. For about half of the open reading frames (ORFs) on the clc element, no clear functional prediction could be given, although some indications were found for functions that were similar to plasmid conjugation. The region in which these ORFs were situated displayed a high overall conservation of nucleotide sequence and gene order to genomic regions in other recently completed bacterial genomes or to other genomic islands. Most notably, except for two discrete regions, the clc element was almost 100% identical over the whole length to a chromosomal region in Burkholderia xenovorans LB400. This indicates the dynamic evolution of this type of element and the continued transition between elements with a more pathogenic character and those with catabolic properties.

Regulation of bistable ICEclc transfer in pseudomonas knackmussii B13

L'élément génétique intégratif et conjugatif auto-transférable de 103 kb qui se trouve dans le génome de Pseudomonas knackmussii B13 (ICEc/c) confère la capacité de dégrader le 3-chlorobenzoate et le 2-aminophénol. L'élément ICE c/c peut être transféré par conjugaison de la souche B13 à diverses bêta- et gamma- protéobactéries. Seule une sous-population de 3 à 5% des cellules transfère l'élément, les cellules dites "compétentes pour le transfert". L'acquisition de la compétence pour le transfert est vraisemblablement la conséquence d'une régulation bistable, conduisant une partie des cellules au transfert de l'élément ICE c/c tandis que, dans les autres, l'élément reste quiescent et ne se transfère pas. À ce jour, les mécanismes et les acteurs moléculaires qui régulent l'activation bistable de l'élément sont restés inconnus. Mon travail de doctorat visait à identifier les éléments bistables du régulon de la compétence pour le transfert et d'analyser les fondements moléculaires de la bistabilité de l'élément ICE c/c chez P. knackmussii. Le premier chapitre introduit le thème du transfert génétique horizontal avec un accent particulier sur les éléments intégratifs et conjugatifs (ICE) et ICEcIc. L'état actuel des connaissances sur l'organisation génétique, la régulation, l'intégration et le transfert de différents modèles de ICEs est exposé en détail. En outre, je m'étends sur les phénomènes d'hétérogénéité et de bistabilité phénotyplques, qu'on peut distinguer dans une population isogénique dans des conditions de culture homogènes, et qui sont susceptibles de jouer un rôle dans le transfert de l'élément ICE c/c, dans la mesure où il ne s'active et n'est transférable que dans une très petite sous-population de cellules. Dans le chapitre 2, je présente une analyse globale des régions promotrices minimales des gènes appartenant au régulon de la compétence pour le transfert de l'élément ICE c/c. Nous avons étudié les caractéristiques d'expression des promoteurs et, s'ils s'avéraient bistables, leur activation dans le temps par comparaison avec le mutant lntB13. Pour ce faire, nous avons utilisé des fusions de promoteurs avec des gènes rapporteurs et testé l'expression bistable chez P. knackmussii par microscopie à épifluorescence. Pour six promoteurs présentant une expression bistable, nous avons employé de la microscopie temporelle pour déterminer la chronologie de leur expression par rapport à Pint et PinR. Parmi eux, nous avons identifié deux gènes exprimés précocement et trois gènes exprimés tardivement dans le processus d'acquisition de la compétence de transfert. Dans le chapitre 3, j'expose une analyse d'expression génétique pour l'un des groupes de gènes dont la transcription est la plus élevée dans la région conservée de ICE c/c, les gènes orf81655-orf68241 contenus dans une région de 14 kb. Nous montrons d'abord que cet opéron fait partie du même régulon bistable que intB13 et inrR et analysons les caractéristiques génétiques qui conduisent à une transcription élevée. Nous étudions les fonctions biologiques de ce groupe de gènes par des délétlons ciblées et montrons que certaines d'entre elles empêchent le transfert de l'élément. Nous approfondissons la caractérlsatlon de I'orf8l655 en construisant une fusion transcrlptionnelle avec le gène codant pour la protéine fluorescente verte (egfp) (en utilisant le système minl-Tn5). L'expression de Vorf81655 dans des cellules individuelles est comparée au signal mesuré par hybridation in situ en fluorescence (FISH) sur le ARN messager du gène. En utilisant FISH, des délétlons du promoteur et de l'analyse directe de transcription, nous avons localisé la région promotrice du groupe de gènes. En outre, nous avons utilisé des mutations dirigées pour comprendre la bistabilité de cette région promotrice, caractérisée par une transcription très élevée et une traduction lente de l'ARN messager.  Dans le chapitre 4, nous nous efforçons de comprendre comment la bistabilité est générée au sein du régulon te de l'élément ICE c/c. Pour ce faire, nous avons tenté de reconstituer une expression bistable, dans un hôte qui ne présente pas de bistabilité naturellement, à partir d'éléments génétiques individuels. L'hôte choisi est Pseudomonas putida dans lequel nous avons introduit une copie unique de Pint, PinR ou PaipA fusionnés à la egfp, construits qui permettent d'observer l'apparition de bistabilité. Nous avons ensuite construit différents assemblages de composants génétiques de l'élément ICE c/c, en nous concentrant sur la région parA-inrR. En effet, nous avons pu démontrer qu'une expression bistable apparaît dans P. putida grâce à ces éléments en l'absence de l'élément ICE c/c complet. À noter que la plupart des construits génétiques activent PaipA ou P|,,R, mais qu'un seul recrée la bistabilité de Pint, ce qui suggère que la région parA-inrR permet à la fois d'engendrer la bistabilité et d'opérer la transition entre les promoteurs précoces et les promoteurs tardifs du régulon de la bistabilité. Dans le chapitre 5, nous concluons sur une discussion de la pertinence de nos résultats et sur de futures perspectives de recherche. -- The 103-kb self-transmissible integrative and conjugative element (ICE) of Pseudomonas knackmussii B13 (ICEc/c) confers the capacity to degrade 3- chlorobenzoate and 2-aminophenol. ICEc/c can be conjugated from strain B13 to a variety of Beta- and Gammaproteobacteria. Interestingly, ICE c/c transfer is observed in a subpopulatlon of cells (3-5%) only, the so-called 'transfer competent' cells. The formation of transfer competence (tc) is thought to be the consequence of a 'bistable' decision, which forces those cells to follow the developmental path which leads to ICEc/c transfer, whereas in others ICE c/c remains silent and does not transfer. So far, the mechanisms and molecular partners generating this bistable transfer activation in cells of P. knackmussii B13 remain mostly unidentified. This thesis aimed at understanding the extent of the tc bistability regulon and to dissect the molecular basis of bistabillty formation of ICEc/c in P. knackmussii. The first chapter is a general Introduction on horizontal gene transfer (HGT) with particular emphasis on ICEs and ICE c/c. The emphasis is made on the current knowledge about the HGT gene organization, regulation and specific integration and transfer aspects of the different ICEs models. Furthermore, I focus on the phenomena of phenotypic heterogeneity and bistability (the property of two distinguishable phenotypes existing within an isogenic population under homogeneous conditions), which may play a particular role in ICEc/c behaviour, since ICE activation and transfer only occurs in a very small subpopulation of cells. In Chapter Two, I focus on a global analysis of the different core promoters that might belong to the ICEc/c tc pathway regulon. We studied both expression patterns of ICEc/c promoters and, once being identified as "bistable", their temporal activation compared to that of intB13. In order to do this, we used promoter reporter fusions and tested blstability expression in P. knackmussii using epifluorescence microscopy. For the 6 promoters that showed bistable expression, we used time-lapse microscopy to study the timing of promoter expression in comparison to that of P,,,t or PlnR. We could establish two "early" and 3 "late" phase promoters in the process of transfer competence. In Chapter Three, I focused my attention on analysis of gene expression of one of the most highly transcribed gene clusters in the conserved core region of ICEc/c, a 14-kb gene cluster formed by the genes orf81655-orf68241. First we showed that this operon is part of the same bistability 'regulon' as intB13 and inrR, and analysed the genetic features that lead to high transcription. We studied the potential biological function of this cluster for ICE c/c by making specific gene deletions, showing that some interrupt ICEc/c transfer. We further analysed the orfdl655 promoter by constructing transcriptional egfp fusion reporter strains using the miniTn5 delivery system. Expression of the orf81655 promoter in single cells was compared to signals measured by Fluorescence In Situ Hybridization (FISH) on orfSl655 mRNA. We localized the promoter region of the gene cluster using FISH, promoter deletions, and by direct transcript analysis. We further used site-directed mutagenesis to understand the bistability character of the promoter region and the extremely high transcription but low translation from this mRNA. In Chapter Four, we set out to understand how bistability is generated in the tc pathway of ICEc/c. For this we tried rebuilding bistable expression from ICEc/c individual gene components in a host, which normally does not display bistability. As host we used P. putida without ICEc/c but with a single copy Pint-, PlnR- or PalpA- egfp fusion that enabled us to verify bistability formation. Subsequently, we built different assemblages of ICEc/c gene components, focusing on the parA-inrR region. Indeed, we found that bistable expression can be build from those components in P. putida without ICEc/c. Interestingly, most genetic constructs activated PaipA or PlnR, but only one resulted in bistable activation of PinT. This suggests that the parA-inrR region acts as a bistability "generator", but also as a bistability "relay" from early to late promoters in the tc pathway hierarchy. In the final fifth chapter, we conclude with a discussion of the relevance of the present thesis and the resulting perspectives for future studies.