Effect of the Scapulo-Humeral Rhythm on Anatomical and Reverse Shoulder Prostheses

Introduction: Several studies have reported significant alteration of the scapula-humeral rythm after total shoulder arthroplasty. However, the biomechanical and clinical effects, particularly on implants lifespan, are still unknown. The goal of this study was to evaluate the biomechanical consequences of an altered scapula-humeral rhythm. Methods: A numerical musculoskeletal model of the shoulder was used. The model included the scapula, the humerus and 6 scapulohumeral muscles: middle, anterior, and posterior deltoid, supraspinatus, subscapularis and infraspinatus combined with teres minor. Arm motion and joint stability were achieved by muscles. The reverse and anatomic Aequalis prostheses (Tornier Inc) were inserted. Two scapula-humeral rhythms were considered for each prosthesis: a normal 2:1 rhythm, and an altered 1:2 rhythm. For the 4 configurations, a movement of abduction in the scapular plane was simulated. The gleno-humeral force and contact pattern, but also the stress in the polyethylene and cement were evaluated. Results: With the anatomical prosthesis, the gleno-humeral force increased of 23% for the altered rhythm, with a more eccentric (posterior and superior) contact. The contact pressure, polyethylene stress, and cement stress increased respectively by 20%, 48% and 64%. With the reverse prosthesis, the gleno-humeral force increased of 11% for an altered rhythm. There was nearly no effect on the contact pattern on the polyethylene component surface. Conclusion: The present study showed that alteration oft the scapula-humeral rythm induced biomechanical consequences which could preclude the long term survival of the glenoid implant of anatomic prostheses. However,an altered scapula-humeral rhythm, even severe, should not be a contra indication for the use of a reverse prosthesis.