The data treatment dependent variability of U-Pb zircon ages obtained using mono-collector, sector field, laser ablation ICP-MS

U-Pb dating of zircons by laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (LA-ICPMS) is a widely used analytical technique in Earth Sciences. For U-Pb ages below 1 billion years (1 Ga), Pb-206/U-238 dates are usually used, showing the least bias by external parameters such as the presence of initial lead and its isotopic composition in the analysed mineral. Precision and accuracy of the Pb/U ratio are thus of highest importance in LA-ICPMS geochronology. We consider the evaluation of the statistical distribution of the sweep intensities based on goodness-of-fit tests in order to find a model probability distribution fitting the data to apply an appropriate formulation for the standard deviation. We then discuss three main methods to calculate the Pb/U intensity ratio and its uncertainty in the LA-ICPMS: (1) ratio-of-the-mean intensities method, (2) mean-of-the-intensity-ratios method and (3) intercept method. These methods apply different functions to the same raw intensity vs. time data to calculate the mean Pb/U intensity ratio. Thus, the calculated intensity ratio and its uncertainty depend on the method applied. We demonstrate that the accuracy and, conditionally, the precision of the ratio-of-the-mean intensities method are invariant to the intensity fluctuations and averaging related to the dwell time selection and off-line data transformation (averaging of several sweeps); we present a statistical approach how to calculate the uncertainty of this method for transient signals. We also show that the accuracy of methods (2) and (3) is influenced by the intensity fluctuations and averaging, and the extent of this influence can amount to tens of percentage points; we show that the uncertainty of these methods also depends on how the signal is averaged. Each of the above methods imposes requirements to the instrumentation. The ratio-of-the-mean intensities method is sufficiently accurate provided the laser induced fractionation between the beginning and the end of the signal is kept low and linear. We show, based on a comprehensive series of analyses with different ablation pit sizes, energy densities and repetition rates for a 193 nm ns-ablation system that such a fractionation behaviour requires using a low ablation speed (low energy density and low repetition rate). Overall, we conclude that the ratio-of-the-mean intensities method combined with low sampling rates is the most mathematically accurate among the existing data treatment methods for U-Pb zircon dating by sensitive sector field ICPMS.

Basement lithostratigraphy of the Adula nappe: implications for Palaeozoic evolution and Alpine kinematics

The Adula nappe belongs to the Lower Penni- nic domain of the Central Swiss Alps. It consists mostly of pre-Triassic basement lithologies occurring as strongly folded and sheared gneisses of various types with mafic boudins. We propose a new lithostratigraphy for the northern Adula nappe basement that is supported by detailed field investigations, U-Pb zircon geochronology, and whole-rock geochemistry. The following units have been identified: Cambrian clastic metasediments with abundant carbonate lenses and minor bimodal magmatism (Salahorn Formation); Ordovician metapelites associated with amphibolite boudins with abundant eclogite relicts representing oceanic metabasalts (Trescolmen Formation); Ordovician peraluminous metagranites of calc-alkaline affinity ascribed to subduction-related magmatism (Ga- renstock Augengneiss); Ordovician metamorphic volcanic- sedimentary deposits (Heinisch Stafel Formation); Early Permian post-collisional granites recording only Alpine orogenic events (Zervreila orthogneiss). All basement lithologies except the Permian granites record a Vari- scan ? Alpine polyorogenic metamorphic history. They document a complex Paleozoic geotectonic evolution consistent with the broader picture given by the pre- Mesozoic basement framework in the Alps. The internal consistency of the Adula basement lithologies and the stratigraphic coherence of the overlying Triassic sediments suggest that most tectonic contacts within the Adula nappe are pre-Alpine in age. Consequently, me ́lange models for the Tertiary emplacement of the Adula nappe are not consistent and must be rejected. The present-day structural complexity of the Adula nappe is the result of the intense Alpine ductile deformation of a pre-structured entity.

Structural analysis of Turtle Mountain: Origin and influence of fractures in the development of rock slope failures

Large slope failures in fractured rocks are often controlled by the combination of pre-existing tectonic fracturing and brittle failure propagation in the intact rock mass during the pre-failure phase. This study focuses on the influence of fold-related fractures and of post-folding fractures on slope instabilities with emphasis on Turtle Mountain, located in SW Alberta (Canada). The structural features of Turtle Mountain, especially to the south of the 1903 Frank Slide, were investigated using a high-resolution digital elevation model combined with a detailed field survey. These investigations allowed the identification of six main discontinuity sets influencing the slope instability and surface morphology. According to the different deformation phases affecting the area, the potential origin of the detected fractures was assessed. Three discontinuity sets are correlated with the folding phase and the others with post-folding movements. In order to characterize the rock mass quality in the different portions of the Turtle Mountain anticline, the geological strength index (GSI) has been estimated. The GSI results show a decrease in rock mass quality approaching the fold hinge area due to higher fracture persistence and higher weathering. These observations allow us to propose a model for the potential failure mechanisms related to fold structures.

Climate and sea-level variations along the northwestern Tethyan margin during the Valanginian C-isotope excursion: Mineralogical evidence from the Vocontian Basin (SE France)

A high resolution mineralogical study (bulk-rock and clay-fraction) was carried out upon the hemipelagic strata of the Angles section (Vocontian Basin, SE France) in which the Valanginian positive C-isotope excursion occurs. To investigate sea-level fluctuations and climate change respectively, a Detrital Index (DI: (phyllosilicates and quartz)/calcite) and a Weathering Index (WI: kaolinite/(illite + chlorite)) were established and compared to second-order sea-level fluctuations. In addition, the mineralogical data were compared with the High Nutrient Index (HNI, based on calcareous nannofossil taxa) data obtained by Duchamp-Alphonse et al. (2007), in order to assess the link between the hydrolysis conditions recorded on the surrounding continents and the trophic conditions inferred for the Vocontian Basin. It appears that the mineralogical distribution along the northwestern Tethyan margin is mainly influenced by sea-level changes during the Early Valanginian (Pertransiens to Stephanophorus ammonite Zones) and by climate variations from the late Early Valanginian to the base of the Hauterivian (top of the Stephanophorus to the Radiatus ammonite Zones). The sea-level fall observed in the Pertransiens ammonite Zone (Early Valanginian) is well expressed by an increase in detrital inputs (an increase in the DI) associated with a more proximal source and a shallower marine environment, whereas the sea-level rise recorded in the Stephanophorus ammonite Zone corresponds to a decrease in detrital influx (a decrease in the DI) as the source becomes more distal and the environment deeper. Interpretation of both DI and WI, indicates that the positive C-isotope excursion (top of the Stephanophorus to the Verrucosum ammonite Zones) is associated with an increase of detrital inputs under a stable, warm and humid climate, probably related to greenhouse conditions, the strongest hydrolysis conditions being reached at the maximum of the positive C-isotope excursion. From the Verrucosum ammonite Zone to the base of the Hauterivian (Radiatus ammonite Zone) climatic conditions evolved from weak hydrolysis conditions and, most likely, a cooler climate (resulting in a decrease in detrital inputs) to a seasonal climate in which more humid seasons alternated with more arid ones. The comparison of the WI to the HNI shows that the nutrification recorded al: the Angles section from the top of the Stephanophorus to the Radiatus ammonite Zones (including the positive C-isotope shift), is associated with climatic changes in the source areas. At that time, increased nutrient inputs were generally triggered by increased weathering processes in the source areas due to acceleration in the hydrological cycle under greenhouse conditions This scenario accords with the widely questioned palaeoenvironmental model proposed by Lini et al., (1992) and suggests that increasing greenhouse conditions are the main factor that drove the palaeoenvironmental changes observed in the hemipelagic realm of the Vocontian Basin, during the Valanginian positive C-isotope shift. This high-resolution mineralogical study highlights short-term climatic changes during the Valanginian, probably associated to rapid changes in the C-cycle. Coeval Massive Parana-Etendeka flood basalt eruptions may explain such rapid perturbations. (C) 2011 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Origin of cadmium enrichments in carbonate rocks deposited in the Alpine Tethys area during the Middle-Late Jurassic

ABSTRACTThe pollution of air, soil and water by heavy metals through anthropogenic activities is an object of numerous environmental studies since long times. A number of natural processes, such as volcanic activity, hydrothermal fluid circulation and weathering of metal-rich deposits may lead to an additional and potentially important input and accumulation of heavy metals in the environment. In the Swiss and French Jura Mountains, anomalous high cadmium (Cd) concentrations (up to 16 ppm) in certain soils are related to the presence of underlying Cd-enriched (up to 21 ppm) carbonate rocks of Middle to Late Jurassic age. The aim of this study is to understand the processes controlling Cd incorporation into carbonate rocks of Middle and Late Jurassic age and to reconstruct the sedimentary and environmental conditions, which have led to Cd enrichments in these sedimentary rocks.Cd concentrations in studied hemipelagic sections in France vary between 0.1 and 0.5 ppm (mean 0.15 ppm). Trace-element behavior and high Mn concentrations suggest that sediment accumulation occurred in a well-oxygenated environment. Increases in Cd contents in the bulk-rock carbonate sediments may be related to increases in surface-water productivity under oxic conditions and important remineralization of organic matter within the water column. In platform settings preserved in the Swiss Jura Mountains, no correlation is observed between Cd contents and evolution of environmental conditions. Cd concentrations in these platform sections are often below the detection limit, with isolated peaks of up to 21 ppm. These important Cd enrichments are associated with peaks in Zn concentrations and are present in carbonate rocks independently of facies and age. The high Cd contents in these shallow-water carbonate rocks are partly related to the presence of disseminated, Cd-rich (up to 1.8%), sphalerite (ZnS) mineralization. The basement rocks are considered to be the source of metals for sulfide mineralization in the overlying Jurassic strata, as the sphalerite Pb isotope pattern is comparable to that of granite rocks from the nearby southern Black Forest crystalline massif. The Rb-Sr ages of sphalerite samples indicate that a main phase of sphalerite formation occurred near the boundary between the late Middle and early Late Jurassic, at around 162 Ma, as a result of enhanced tectonic and hydrothermal activity in Europe, related to the opening of the Central Atlantic and to the tectonic/thermal subsidence during spreading of the Alpine Tethys. I therefore propose to use unusually high Cd concentrations in carbonates as a tracer of tectonic activity in the Jura Mountains area, especially in the case when important enrichments in Zn co-occur. Paleoproductivity reconstructions based on records of authigenic Cd may be compromised not only by post-depositional redistribution, but also by incorporation of additional Cd from hydrothermal solutions circulating in the rock.The circulation of metal-rich hydrothermal fluids through the sediment sequence, in addition to specific environmental conditions during sedimentation, contributes to the incorporation of Cd into the carbonate rocks. However, only hydrothermal activity has led to the unusually high concentrations of Cd in carbonate rocks of Bajocian-Oxfordian age, through the formation of sphalerite mineralization.

Événements et déformations tardi-métamorphiques dans le segment Ossola-Ticino (Val Vigezzo-Centovalli, Italie-Suisse)

RESUME: Une zone tectonique large et complexe, connue sous le nom de ligne des Centovalli, traverse le secteur des Alpes Centrales compris entre Domodossola et Locarno. Cette région, formée par le Val Vigezzo et la vallée des Centovalli, constitue la terminaison méridionale du dôme Lepontin et représente une portion de la zone des racines des nappes alpines. Elle fait partie d’une grande et complexe zone de cisaillement, en partie associée à des phénomènes hydrothermaux d’âge alpin (<20 Ma), qui comprend le système tectonique Insubrien et celui du Simplon. Le Val Vigezzo et les Centovalli constituent un vrai carrefour entre les principaux accidents tectoniques des Alpes ainsi qu'une zone de juxtaposition du socle Sudalpin avec la zone des racines de l’Austroalpin et du Pennique. Les phases de déformation et les structures géologiques qui peuvent être étudiées s'étalent sur une période comprise entre environ 35 Ma et l'actuel. L’étude détaillée de terrain a mis en évidence la présence de nombreuses roches et structures de déformation de type ductile et cassant tels que des mylonites, des cataclasites, des pseudotachylites, des kakirites, des failles minéralisées, des gouges de faille et des plis. Sur le terrain on a pu distinguer au moins quatre générations de plis liés aux différentes phases de déformation. Le nombre et la complexité de ces structures indiquent une histoire très compliquée, selon plusieurs étapes distinctes, parfois liées, voire même superposées. Une partie de ces structures de déformation affectent aussi les dépôts sédimentaires d’âge quaternaire, notamment des limons et des sables lacustres. Ces sédiments constituent les restes d'un bassin lacustre attribué à l'époque interglaciaire Riss/Würm (éemien, 67.000-120.000 ans) et ils affleurent dans la partie centrale de la zone étudiée, à l'Est de la plaine de Santa Maria Maggiore. Ces sédiments montrent en leur sein toute une série de structures de déformation tels que des plans de faille inverses, des structures conjuguées de raccourcissement et des véritables plis. Ces failles et ces plis représenteraient les évidences de surface d’une déformation probablement active en époque quaternaire. Une autre formation rocheuse a retenu tout notre attention; il s'agit d'un corps de brèches péridotitiques monogéniques qui affleure en discontinuité le long du versant méridional et le long du fond de la vallée Vigezzo sur environ 20 km. Ces brèches se posent indifféremment sur le socle (unités Finero, Orselina) ou sur les sédiments lacustres. Elles sont traversées par des plans de failles qui développent des véritables stries de faille et des gouges de faille; l’orientation de ces plans est la même que celle affectant les failles à gouges du socle. La genèse de cette brèche est liée à l'altération et au modelage glacier (rock-glaciers) d'une brèche tectonique originelle qui borde la partie externe du Corps de Finero. Les structures de déformation de cette brèche, pareillement à celles des sédiments lacustres, ont été considérées comme les évidences de surface d'une tectonique quaternaire active dans la région. La dernière phase de déformation cassante qui affecte cette région peut donc être considérée comme active en époque quaternaire. Une vue d’ensemble de la région étudiée nous permet de reconnaître à l’échelle régionale une zone de cisaillement complexe orientée E-W, parallèlement à l’axe de la vallée Centovalli-Val Vigezzo. Les données de terrain, indiquent que cette zone de cisaillement débute sous conditions ductiles et évolue en plusieurs étapes jusqu’à des conditions de failles cassantes de surface. La reconstruction de l'évolution géodynamique de la région a permis de définir trois étapes distinctes qui marquent le passage, de ce secteur de socle cristallin, de conditions P-T profondes à des conditions de surface. Dans ce contexte, on a reconnu trois phases principales de déformation à l’échelle régionale qui caractérisent ces trois étapes. La phase la plus ancienne est constituée par des mylonites en faciès amphibolite, associées à des mouvements de cisaillement dextre, qui sont ensuite remplacés par des mylonites en faciès schistes verts et des plis rétrovergentes liés au rétrocharriage des nappes alpines. Une deuxième étape est identifiée par le développement d’une phase hydrothermale liée à un système de failles extensives et décrochantes dextres à direction principale E-W, NE-SW et NW-SE. Leur caractérisation minéralogique a permis la mise en évidence des phases cristallines de néoformation liées à cet événement constituées par : K-feldspath (microcline), chlorites (Fe+Mg), épidotes, prehnite, zéolites (laumontite), sphène, calcite. Dans ce contexte, pour obtenir une meilleure caractérisation de cet événement hydrothermal on a utilisé des géothermomètres sur chlorites, sensible aussi à la pression et a la a(H2O), qui ont donné des valeurs descendantes comprises entre 450-200°C. Les derniers mouvements sont mis en évidence par le développement d’une série de plans majeurs de failles à gouge, qui forment une structure en sigmoïdes d’épaisseur kilométrique reconnaissable à l’échelle de la vallée et caractérisée par des mouvements transpressifs avec une composante décrochante dextre toujours importante. Cette phase de déformation forme un système conjugué de failles avec direction moyenne E-W qui coupent la zone des racines des nappes alpines, la zone du Canavese et le corps ultramafique de Finero. Ce système se déroule de manière subparallèle à l'axe de la vallée le long de plusieurs dizaines de kilomètres. Une analyse complète et détaillée des gouges de faille par XRD a montré que la fraction argileuse (<2 µm) de ces gouges contient une partie de néoformation très importante constituée par, des illites, des chlorites et des interstratifiés de type illite/smectite ou chlorite/smectite. Des datations avec méthode K-Ar sur ces illites ont donné des valeurs comprises entre 12 et 4 Ma qui représentent l'âge de cette dernière déformation cassante. L'application de la méthode de la cristallinité de l'illite (C.I.) a permis d'évaluer les conditions thermiques qui caractérisent le déroulement de cette dernière phase tectonique qui se produit sous conditions de température caractéristiques de l'anchizone et de la diagenèse. L'ensemble des structures de déformation qu'on vient de décrire s'insère parfaitement dans le contexte de convergence oblique entre la plaque adriatique et celle européenne qui à produit l'orogène alpin. On peut considérer les structures tectoniques du Val Vigezzo-Centovalli comme l'expression d'une zone majeure de cisaillement "Simplo-Insubrienne". L'empilement structural et les structures tectoniques affleurantes dans la région sont le résultat de l'interaction entre un régime tectonique transpressif et un régime transtensif. Ces deux champs de tension sont antagonistes entre eux mais sont reliés, de toute façon, à une seule phase décrochante dextre principale, due à une convergence oblique entre deux plaques. À l'échelle de l'évolution géodynamique on peut distinguer différentes étapes au cours desquelles les structures de ces deux régimes tectoniques interagissent en manière différente. En accord avec les données géophysiques et les reconstructions paléodynamiques prises dans la littérature on considère que la ligne Rhône-Simplon-Centovalli représente l'évidence de surface de la suture majeure profonde entre la plaque Adriatique et celle Européenne. Les vitesses de soulèvement qui ont été calculées dans cette étude pour cette région des Alpes donnent une valeur moyenne de 0.8 mm/a qui est tout à fait comparable avec les données proposées par la littérature sur cette zone. La zone Val Vigezzo-Centovalli peut être donc considérée comme un carrefour géologique où se croisent différentes phases tectoniques qui représentent les évidences de surface d'une suture profonde majeure entre deux plaques dans un contexte de collision continentale. ABSTRACT: A wide and complex tectonic zone known as Centovalli line, crosses the Central Alps sector between Domodossola and Locarno. This area, formed by the Vigezzo Valley and Centovalli valley, constitutes the southernmost termination of the Lepontin dome and represents a portion of the alpine nappes root zone. It belongs to a large and complex shear-zone, partly associated with hydrothermal phenomena of alpine age (<20 My), which includes the Insubric Line and the Simplon fault zone. Vigezzo Valley and Centovalli constitute a real crossroads between the mains alpines tectonics lines as well as a zone of juxtaposition of the Southalpine basement with the Austroalpin and Pennique root zone. The deformation phases and the geological structures that can be studied between approximately 35 My and the present. The detailed field study showed the presence of many brittle and ductile deformation structures and fault rocks such as mylonites, cataclasites, pseudotachylites, kakirites, mineralized faults, fault gouges and folds. In the field we could distinguish at least four folds generations related to the various deformation phases. The number and the complexity of these structures indicate a very complicated history, comprising several different stages, that sometimes are related and even superimposed. Part of these deformation structures affect also the sedimentary deposits of quaternary age, in particular the silts and sands lake deposit. These sediments constitute the remainders of a lake basin ascribed to the interglacial Riss/Würm (Eemien, 67.000-120.000 years) and outcroping in the central part of the studied area, in the Eastern part of Santa Maria Maggiore plain. These sediments show a whole series of deformation structures such as inverse fault planes, combined shortening structures and true folds. These faults and folds would represent the surface evidence of a probably active tectonic deformation in quaternary time. Another rock formation attracted all our attention. It is a body of monogenic peridotite breccia which outcrops in discontinuity along the southernmost slope and the bottom of the Vigezzo valley on approximately 20 km. This breccia lies indifferently on the basement (Finero and Orselina units) or on the lake sediments. They are crossed by fault planes which developed slikenside and fault gouges whose orientation is the same of the faults gouges in the alpine basement. This breccia results from the weathering and the surface modelling of an original tectonic breccia which borders the external part of Finero peridotite body. This breccia deformation structures, like those of the lake sediments, were regarded as the surface interaction of active quaternary tectonics in the area. So the last brittle deformation phases which affects this area seems to be actives in quaternary time. Theoverall picture of the studied area on a regional scale enables us to point out a complex shear-zone directed E-W, parallel to the axis of the Centovalli and Vigezzo Valley. The field analysis indicates that this shear-zone began under ductile conditions and evolved in several stages to brittle faulting under surface conditions. The analysis of the geodynamic evolution of the area allows to define three different stages which mark the transition of this alpine basement root zone, from deep P-T conditions to P-T surface conditions. In this context on regional scale three principal deformation phases, which characterize these three stages can be distinguished. The oldest phase consisted of the amphibolitie facies mylonites, associated to dextral strikeslip movements. They are then replaced by green-schists facies mylonites and backfolds related to the backthrusting of the alpines nappes. A second episode is caracterized by the development of an hydrothermal phase bound to an extensive fault and dextral strike-slip fault system, with E-W, NW-SE and SE-NW principal directionsThe principal neoformed mineral phases related to this event are: K-feldspar (microcline), chlorites (Fe+Mg), epidotes prehnite, zéolites (laumontite), sphene and calcite. In this context, to obtain a better characterization of this hydrothermal event, we have used an chlorite geothermometer, sensitive also to the pressure and has the a(H2O), which gave downward values ranging between 450-200°C. The last movements are caracterized by the development of important gouge fault plans, which form a sigmoid structure of kilometric thickness which is recognizable at the valley scale, and is characterized by transpressive movements always with a significant dextral strike-slip component. This deformation phase forms a combined faults system with an average E-W direction, which cuts trough the alpine root zone, the Canavese zone and the Finero ultramafic body. This fault system takes place subparallel to the axis of the valley over several tens of kilometers. A complete and detailed XRD analysis of the gouges fault showed that the clay fraction (<2µm) contains a very significant neo-formation of illite, chlorites and mixed layered clays such as illite/smectite or chlorite/smectite. The K-Ar datings of the illite fraction <2µm gave values ranging between 12 and 4 My and the illite fraction <0.2µm gave more recents values until to 2,4-0 My.This values represent the age of this last brittle deformation. The application of the illite crystallinity method (C.I.) allowed evaluating the thermal conditions which characterize this tectonic phase that occured under temperature conditions of the anchizone and diagenesis. The whole set of deformation structures which we just described, perfectly fit the context of oblique convergence between the Adriatic and the European plate that produced the alpine orogen. We can regard the Vigezzo valley and Centovalli tectonic structures as the expression of a major "Simplo-Insubric" shear-zone. Structural stacking and tectonic structures that outcrop in the studied area, are the result of the interaction between a transpressive and a transtensve tectonic phases. These two tension fields are antagonistic but they are also connected, in any event, with only one principal dextral strike-slip movement, caused by an oblique convergence between two plates. On the geodynamic evolution scale we can distinguish various stages during which these two tectonic structures fields interact in various ways. In agreement with the geophysical data and the paleodynamic recostructions taken in the literature we considers that the Rhone-Simplon-Centovalli line are the surface feature of the major collision between the Adriatique and the European plate at depth. The uplift speeds we calculated in this study for this Alpine area give an average value of 0.8 mm/a, which is in good agreement with the data suggested by the literature on this zone. TheVigezzo Valley and Centovalli zone can therefore be regarded as a geological crossroad where various tectonic phases are superimposed. They represent the evidences of a major and deeper suture between two plates in a continental collision context.