Trabecular bone score in kidney transplant recipients.

UNLABELLED: It is uncertain whether bone mineral density (BMD) can accurately predict fracture in kidney transplant recipients. Trabecular bone score (TBS) provides information independent of BMD. Kidney transplant recipients had abnormal bone texture as measured by lumbar spine TBS, and a lower TBS was associated with incident fractures in recipients. INTRODUCTION: Trabecular bone score (TBS) is a texture measure derived from dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) lumbar spine images, providing information independent of bone mineral density. We assessed characteristics associated with TBS and fracture outcomes in kidney transplant recipients. METHODS: We included 327 kidney transplant recipients from Manitoba, Canada, who received a post-transplant DXA (median 106 days post-transplant). We matched each kidney transplant recipient (mean age 45 years, 39 % men) to three controls from the general population (matched on age, sex, and DXA date). Lumbar spine (L1-L4) DXA images were used to derive TBS. Non-traumatic incident fracture (excluding hand, foot, and craniofacial) (n = 31) was assessed during a mean follow-up of 6.6 years. We used multivariable linear regression models to test predictors of TBS, and multivariable Cox proportional hazard regression was used to estimate hazard ratios (HRs) per standard deviation decrease in TBS to express the gradient of risk. RESULTS: Compared to the general population, kidney transplant recipients had a significantly lower lumbar spine TBS (1.365 ± 0.129 versus 1.406 ± 0.125, P < 0.001). Multivariable linear regression revealed that receipt of a kidney transplant was associated with a significantly lower mean TBS compared to controls (-0.0369, 95 % confidence interval [95 % CI] -0.0537 to -0.0202). TBS was associated with fractures independent of the Fracture Risk Assessment score including BMD (adjusted HR per standard deviation decrease in TBS 1.64, 95 % CI 1.15-2.36). CONCLUSION: Kidney transplant recipients had abnormal bone texture as assessed by TBS and a lower lumbar spine TBS was associated with fractures in recipients.

Primary isolated aortic valve surgery in octogenarians.

We reviewed our surgery registry, to identify predictive risk factors for operative results, and to analyse the long-term survival outcome in octogenarians operated for primary isolated aortic valve replacement (AVR). A total of 124 consecutive octogenarians underwent open AVR from January 1990 to December 2005. Combined procedures and redo surgery were excluded. Selected variables were studied as risk factors for hospital mortality and early neurological events. A follow-up (FU; mean FU time: 77 months) was obtained (90% complete), and Kaplan-Meier plots were used to determine survival rates. The mean age was 82+/-2.2 (range: 80-90 years; 63% females). Of the group, four patients (3%) required urgent procedures, 10 (8%) had a previous myocardial infarction, six (5%) had a previous coronary angioplasty and stenting, 13 patients (10%) suffered from angina and 59 (48%) were in the New York Heart Association (NYHA) class III-IV. We identified 114 (92%) degenerative stenosis, six (5%) post-rheumatic stenosis and four (3%) active endocarditis. The predicted mortality calculated by logistic European System for Cardiac Operative Risk Evaluation (EuroSCORE) was 12.6+/-5.7%, and the observed hospital mortality was 5.6%. Causes of death included severe cardiac failure (four patients), multi-organ failure (two) and sepsis (one). Complications were transitory neurological events in three patients (2%), short-term haemodialysis in three (2%), atrial fibrillation in 60 (48%) and six patients were re-operated for bleeding. Atrio-ventricular block, myocardial infarction or permanent stroke was not detected. The age at surgery and the postoperative renal failure were predictors for hospital mortality (p value <0.05), whereas we did not find predictors for neurological events. The mean FU time was 77 months (6.5 years) and the mean age of surviving patients was 87+/-4 years (81-95 years). The actuarial survival estimates at 5 and 10 years were 88% and 50%, respectively. Our experience shows good short-term results after primary isolated standard AVR in patients more than 80 years of age. The FU suggests that aortic valve surgery in octogenarians guarantees satisfactory long-term survival rates and a good quality of life, free from cardiac re-operations. In the era of catheter-based aortic valve implantation, open-heart surgery for AVR remains the standard of care for healthy octogenarians.

Host innate immune responses to microbial pathogens.

Sepsis is among the leading causes of death worldwide and its incidence is increasing. Defined as the host response to infection, sepsis is a clinical syndrome considered to be the expression of a dysregulated immune reaction induced by danger signals that may lead to organ failure and death. Remarkable progresses have been made in our understanding of the molecular basis of host defenses in recent years. The host defense response is initiated by innate immune sensors of danger signals designated under the collective name of pattern-recognition receptors. Members of the family of microbial sensors include the complement system, the Toll-like receptors, the nucleotide-binding oligomerization domainlike receptors, the RIG-I-like helicases and the C-type lectin receptors. Ligand-activated pattern-recognition receptors kick off a cascade of intracellular events resulting in the expression of co-stimulatory molecules and release of effector molecules playing a fundamental role in the initiation of the innate and adaptive immune responses. Fine tuning of proinflammatory and anti-inflammatory reactions is critical for keeping the innate immune response in check. Overwhelming or dysregulated responses induced by infectious stimuli may have dramatic consequences for the host as shown by the profound derangements observed in sepsis. Unfortunately, translational research approaches aimed at the development of therapies targeting newly identified innate immune pathways have not held their promises. Indeed, all recent clinical investigations of adjunctive anti-sepsis treatments had little, if any, impact on morbidity and all-cause mortality of sepsis. Dissecting the mechanisms underlying the transition from infection to sepsis is essential for solving the sepsis enigma. Important components of the puzzle have already been identified, but the hunt must go on in the laboratory and at the bedside.

Phase II study of weekly plitidepsin as second-line therapy for small cell lung cancer.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the antitumor activity and safety profile of plitidepsin administered as a 1h weekly intravenous (i.v.) infusion of 3.2mg/m(2) to patients with small cell lung cancer (SCLC) who relapsed or progressed after one line of chemotherapy. PATIENTS AND METHODS: This was a multicenter, open-label, single-arm, exploratory, phase II clinical trial. Treatment lasted until disease progression, unacceptable toxicity, patient refusal or treatment delay for >2 weeks. Objective response rate (primary efficacy endpoint) was evaluated according to response evaluation criteria in solid tumors (RECIST). The rate of stable disease (SD) lasting for at least 6 months and time-to-event variables were secondary endpoints of efficacy. Toxicity was assessed using National Cancer Institute Common Toxicity Criteria (NCI-CTC) version 2.0. RESULTS: Twenty pretreated SCLC patients (median age, 60 years) with extensive (n=13) or limited-stage disease (n=7) received a total of 24 treatment cycles (median, one cycle per patient; range, 1-2). Objective tumor responses were not observed and only one of the 17 evaluable patients had SD. With a median follow-up of 11.8 months, the progression-free survival and the median overall survival were 1.3 months and 4.8 months, respectively. The most troubling or common toxicities were fatigue, muscle weakness, lymphopenia, anemia (no patients showed neutropenia), and asymptomatic, non-cumulative increase of transaminases levels and alkaline phosphatase. CONCLUSION: This clinical trial shows that a cycle of 1h weekly i.v. infusion of plitidepsin (3.2mg/m(2)) was generally well tolerated other than fatigue and muscle weakness in patients with pretreated SCLC. One patient died due to multi-organ failure. The absence of antitumor activity found here precludes further studies of this plitidepsin schedule as second-line single-agent treatment of SCLC.

In-situ revascularisation for secondary aorto-enteric fistulae: the success of silver-coated Dacron is closely linked to a suitable bowel repair.

OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this study was to assess short- and mid-term results of in-situ revascularisation (ISR) using silver-coated Dacron prostheses and bowel repair for management of secondary aorto-enteric fistulae (SAEF). DESIGN: Single-centre retrospective chart review. MATERIAL AND METHODS: This study includes all the patients treated by ISR using silver-coated Dacron for SAEF between 2006 and 2010. Primary end points were mortality and survival rates. Secondary end points were reinfection-free survival and secondary patency rates. RESULTS: Eighteen male patients with SAEF with a median age of 64 years were operated by ISR using silver-coated Dacron during the study period without operative death. The 30-day mortality was 22% and the in-hospital mortality rate was 39%. Indeed, during hospitalisation, a duodenal leak was observed in four patients including three who died. Four others patients died due to multi-system organ failure. Median follow-up was 16 months (range 1-66). The survival rate at 12 months was 55%. One duodenal leak was observed leading to death. The reinfection-free survival and the secondary patency rates at 12 months were 60% and 89%, respectively. CONCLUSION: In-situ revascularisation with silver-coated Dacron provides acceptable results in terms of mortality. This treatment may be useful for simple vascular reconstruction and allow greater attention to bowel repair that is a determinant in short- and mid-term survival.

Ten years of lung transplantation in Switzerland: results of the Swiss Lung Transplant Registry.

Lung transplantation has evolved from an experimental procedure to a viable therapeutic option in many countries. In Switzerland, the first lung transplant was performed in November 1992, more than ten years after the first successful procedure world-wide. Thenceforward, a prospective national lung transplant registry was established, principally to enable quality control. The data of all patients transplanted in the two Swiss Lung Transplant centres Zurich University Hospital and Centre de Romandie (Geneva-Lausanne) were analysed. In 10 years 242 lung transplants have been performed. Underlying lung diseases were cystic fibrosis including bronchiectasis (32%), emphysema (32%), parenchymal disorders (19%), pulmonary hypertension (11%) and lymphangioleiomyomatosis (3%). There were only 3% redo procedures. The 1, 5 and 9 year survival rates were 77% (95% CI 72-82), 64% (95% CI 57-71) and 56% (95% CI 45-67), respectively. The 5 year survival rate of patients transplanted since 1998 was 72% (95% CI 64-80). Multivariate Cox regression analysis revealed that survival was significantly better in this group compared to those transplanted before 1998 (HR 0.44, 0.26-0.75). Patients aged 60 years and older (HR 5.67, 95% CI 2.50-12.89) and those with pulmonary hypertension (HR 2.01, 95% CI 1.10-3.65) had a significantly worse prognosis The most frequent causes of death were infections (29%), bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome (25%) and multiple organ failure (14%). The 10-year Swiss experience of lung transplantation compares favourably with the international data. The best results are obtained in cystic fibrosis, pulmonary emphysema and parenchymal disorders.

The Swiss Systemic lupus erythematosus Cohort Study (SSCS) - cross-sectional analysis of clinical characteristics and treatments across different medical disciplines in Switzerland.

OBJECTIVES: To describe disease characteristics and treatment modalities in a multidisciplinary cohort of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) patients in Switzerland. METHODS: Cross-sectional analysis of 255 patients included in the Swiss SLE Cohort and coming from centres specialised in Clinical Immunology, Internal Medicine, Nephrology and Rheumatology. Clinical data were collected with a standardised form. Disease activity was assessed using the Safety of Estrogens in Lupus Erythematosus National Assessment-SLE Disease Activity Index (SELENA-SLEDAI), an integer physician's global assessment score (PGA) ranging from 0 (inactive) to 3 (very active disease) and the erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR). The relationship between SLE treatment and activity was assessed by propensity score methods using a mixed-effect logistic regression with a random effect on the contributing centre. RESULTS: Of the 255 patients, 82% were women and 82% were of European ancestry. The mean age at enrolment was 44.8 years and the median SLE duration was 5.2 years. Patients from Rheumatology had a significantly later disease onset. Renal disease was reported in 44% of patients. PGA showed active disease in 49% of patients, median SLEDAI was 4 and median ESR was 14 millimetre/first hour. Prescription rates of anti-malarial drugs ranged from 3% by nephrologists to 76% by rheumatologists. Patients regularly using anti-malarial drugs had significantly lower SELENA-SLEDAI scores and ESR values. CONCLUSION: In our cohort, patients in Rheumatology had a significantly later SLE onset than those in Nephrology. Anti-malarial drugs were mostly prescribed by rheumatologists and internists and less frequently by nephrologists, and appeared to be associated with less active SLE.

Bacterial flagellin elicits innate immune defenses and cardiac dysfunction in vivo

Résumé Les agents pathogènes responsables d'infection entraînent chez l'hôte deux types de réponses immunes, la première, non spécifique, dite immunité innée, la seconde, spécifique à l'agent concerné, dite immunité adaptative. L'immunité innée, qui représente la première ligne de défense contre les pathogènes, est liée à la reconnaissance par les cellules de l'hôte de structures moléculaires propres aux micro-organismes (« Pathogen-Associated Molecular Patterns », PAMPs), grâce à des récepteurs membranaires et cytoplasmiques (« Pattern Recognition Receptors », PRRs) identifiant de manière spécifique ces motifs moléculaires. Les récepteurs membranaires impliqués dans ce processus sont dénommés toll-like récepteurs, ou TLRS. Lorsqu'ils sont activés par leur ligand spécifique, ces récepteurs activent des voies de signalisation intracellulaires initiant la réponse inflammatoire non spécifique et visant à éradiquer l'agent pathogène. Les deux voies de signalisation impliquées dans ce processus sont la voie des « Mitogen-Activated Protein Kinases » (MAPKs) et celle du « Nuclear Factor kappaB » (NF-κB), dont l'activation entraîne in fine l'expression de protéines de l'inflammation dénommées cytokines, ainsi que certaines enzymes produisant divers autres médiateurs inflammatoires. Dans certaines situations, cette réponse immune peut être amplifiée de manière inadéquate, entraînant chez l'hôte une réaction inflammatoire systémique exagérée, appelée sepsis. Le sepsis peut se compliquer de dysfonctions d'organes multiples (sepsis sévère), et dans sa forme la plus grave, d'un collapsus cardiovasculaire, définissant le choc septique. La défaillance circulatoire du choc septique touche les vaisseaux sanguins d'une part, le coeur d'autre part, réalisant un tableau de «dysfonction cardiaque septique », dont on connaît mal les mécanismes pathogéniques. Les bactéries à Gram négatif peuvent déclencher de tels phénomènes, notamment en libérant de l'endotoxine, qui active les voies de l'immunité innée par son interaction avec un toll récepteur, le TLR4. Outre l'endotoxine, la plupart des bactéries à Gram négatif relâchent également dans leur environnement une protéine, la flagelline, qui est le constituant majeur du flagelle bactérien, organelle assurant la mobilité de ces micro-organismes. Des données récentes ont indiqué que la flagelline active, dans certaines cellules, les voies de l'immunité innée en se liant au récepteur TLRS. On ne connaît toutefois pas les conséquences de l'interaction flagelline-TLRS sur le développement de l'inflammation et des dysfonctions d'organes au cours du sepsis. Nous avons par conséquent élaboré le présent travail en formulant l'hypothèse que la flagelline pourrait déclencher une telle inflammation et représenter ainsi un médiateur potentiel de la dysfonction d'organes au cours du sepsis à Gram négatif, en nous intéressant plus particulièrement àl'inflammation et à la dysfonction cardiaque. Dans la première partie de ce travail, nous avons étudié les effets de la flagelline sur l'activation du NF-κB et des MAPKs, et sur l'expression de cytokines inflammatoires au niveau du myocarde in vitro (cardiomyocytes en culture) et in vivo (injection de flagelline recombinante à des souris). Nous avons observé tout d'abord que le récepteur TLRS est fortement exprimé au niveau du myocarde. Nous avons ensuite démontré que la flagelline active la voie du NF-κB et des MAP kinases (p38 et JNK), stimule la production de cytokines et de chemokines inflammatoires in vitro et in vivo, et entraîne l'activation de polynucléaires neutrophiles dans le tissu cardiaque in vivo. Finalement, au plan fonctionnel, nous avons pu montrer que la flagelline entraîne une dilatation et une réduction aiguë de la contractilité du ventricule gauche chez la souris, reproduisant les caractéristiques de la dysfonction cardiaque septique. Dans la deuxième partie, nous avons déterminé la distribution du récepteur TLRS dans les autres organes majeurs de la souris (poumon, foie, intestin et rein}, et avons caractérisé dans ces organes l'effet de la flagelline sur l'activation du NF-κB et des MAPKs, l'expression de cytokines, et l'induction de l'apoptose. Nous avons démontré que le TLRS est exprimé de façon constitutive dans ces organes, et que l'injection de flagelline y déclenche les cascades de l'immunité innée et de processus apoptotiques. Finalement, nous avons également déterminé que la flagelline entraîne une augmentation significative de multiples cytokines dans le plasma une à six heures après son injection. En résumé, nos données démontrent que la flagelline bactérienne (a) entraîne une inflammation et une dysfonction importantes du myocarde et (b) active de manière très significative les mécanismes d'immunité innée dans les principaux organes et entraîne une réponse inflammatoire systémique. Par conséquent, la flagelline peut représenter un médiateur puissant de l'inflammation et de la dysfonction d'organes, notamment du coeur, au cours du choc septique déclenché par les bactéries à Gram négatif. Summary Pathogenic microorganisms trigger two kinds of immune responses in the host. The first one is immediate and non-specific and is termed innate immunity, whereas the second one, specifically targeted at the invading agent, is termed adaptative immunity. Innate immunity, which represents the first line of defense against invading pathogens, confers the host the ability to recognize molecular structures common to many microbial pathogens, ("Pathogen-Associated Molecular Patterns", PAMPs), through cytosolic or membrane-associated receptors ("Pattern Recognition Receptors", PRRs), the latter being represented by a family of receptors termed "toll-like receptors or TLRs". Once activated by the binding of their specific ligand, these receptors activate intracellular signaling pathways, which initiate the non-specific inflammatory response aimed at eradicating the pathogens. The two pathways implicated in this process are the mitogen-activated protein kinases (MAPK) and the nuclear factor kappa B (NF-κB) signaling pathways, whose activation elicit in fine the expression of inflammatory proteins termed cytokines, as well as various enzymes producing a wealth of additional inflammatory mediators. In some circumstances, the innate immune response can become amplified and dysregulated, triggering an overwhelming systemic inflammatory response in the host, identified as sepsis. Sepsis can be associated with multiple organ dysfunction (severe sepsis), and in its most severe form, with cardiovascular collapse, defming septic shock. The cardiovascular failure associated with septic shock affects blood vessels as well as the heart, resulting in a particular form of acute heart failure termed "septic cardiac dysfunction ", whose pathogenic mechanisms remain partly undefined. Gram-negative bacteria can initiate such phenomena, notably by releasing lipopolysaccharide (LPS), which activates innate immune signaling by interacting with its specific toll receptor, the TLR4. Besides LPS, most Gram-negative bacteria also release flagellin into their environment, which is the main structural protein of the bacterial flagellum, an appendage extending from the outer bacterial membrane, responsible for the motility of the microorganism. Recent data indicated that flagellin activate immune responses upon binding to its receptor, TLRS, in various cell types. However, the role of flagellin/TLRS interaction in the development of inflammation and organ dysfunction during sepsis is not known. Therefore, we designed the present work to address the hypothesis that flagellin might trigger such inflammatory responses and thus represent a potential mediator of organ dysfunction during Gram-negative sepsis, with a particular emphasis on cardiac inflammation and contractile dysfunction. In the first part of this work, we investigated the effects of flagellin on NF-κB and MAPK activation and the generation of pro-inflammatory mediators within the heart in vitro (cultured cardiomyocytes) and in vivo (injection of recombinant flagellin into mice). We first observed that TLRS protein is strongly expressed by the myocardium. We then demonstrated that flagellin activates NF-κB and MAP kinases (p38 and JNK), upregulates the transcription of pro-inflammatory cytokines and chemokines in vitro and in vivo, and stimulates the activation of polymorphonuclear neutrophils within the heart in vivo. Finally, we demonstrated that flagellin triggers acute cardiac dilation, and a significant reduction of left ventricular contractility, mimicking characteristics of clinical septic cardiac dysfunction. In the second part, we determined the TLRS distribution in other mice major organs (lung, liver, gut and kidney) and we characterized in these organs the effects of flagellin on NF-κB and MAPK activation, on the expression of pro-inflammatory çytokines, and on the induction of apoptosis. We demonstrated that TLRS protein is constitutively expressed and that flagellin activates prototypical innate immune responses and pro-apoptotic pathways in all these organs. Finally, we also observed that flagellin induces a significant increase of multiple cytokines in the plasma from 1 to 6 hours after its intravenous administration. Altogether, these data provide evidence that bacterial flagellin (a) triggers an important inflammatory response and an acute dysfunction of the myocardium, and (b) significantly activates the mechanisms of innate immunity in most major organs and elicits a systemic inflammatory response. In consequence, flagellin may represent a potent mediator of inflammation and multiple organ failure, notably cardiac dysfunction, during Gram-negative septic shock.

Can oxidative damage be treated nutritionally?

BACKGROUND & AIMS: Nutrition and dietary patterns have been shown to have direct impact on health of the population and of selected patient groups. The beneficial effects have been attributed to the reduction of oxidative damage caused by the normal or excessive free radical production. The papers aims at collecting evidence of successful supplementation strategies. METHODS: Review of the literature reporting on antioxidant supplementation trials in the general population and critically ill patients. RESULTS: Antioxidant vitamin and trace element intakes have been shown to be particularly important in the prevention of cancer, cardiovascular diseases, age related ocular diseases and in aging. In animal models, targeted interventions have been associated with reduction of tissue destruction is brain and myocardium ischemia-reperfusion models. In the critically ill antioxidant supplements have resulted in reduction of organ failure and of infectious complications. CONCLUSIONS: Antioxidant micronutrients have beneficial effects in defined models and pathologies, in the general population and in critical illness: ongoing research encourages this supportive therapeutic approach. Further research is required to determined the optimal micronutrient combinations and the doses required according to timing of intervention.

Fat embolism syndrome after combined aesthetic surgery.

Fat embolism syndrome is a rare complication that develops after extended soft tissue disruption by liposuction, in particular if combined with time consuming, multiple procedures. Early signs are non-specific and often not considered, so that diagnosis and correct management may be delayed. We report a case in which liposuction combined with other aesthetic surgical procedures caused a fat embolism syndrome in a 46-year-old woman, which was followed by multiple organ failure and the development of sepsis with perimammary abscesses. Extended liposuction of the abdomen and thighs, bilateral augmentation mammaplasty, and stripping of both greater saphenous veins were combined.

Suivi thérapeutique des médicaments (I). Les principes [Principles of therapeutic drug monitoring]

Requesting a blood level measurement of a drug is part of the global approach known as "Therapeutic Drug Monitoring". Diverse situations require this monitoring approach, such as inadequate response to treatment or organ failure. Every drug however does not possess all the characteristics for a TDM program. The therapeutic range of a TDM drug has indeed to be narrow and its interindividual pharmacokinetic variability to be wide. As the development of new drugs is currently slowing down, the precise management of existing treatments certainly deserves progress, but needs however to be applied rationally, starting from a valid indication to blood sampling, and ending with a sound dosage adaptation decision.

Growth arrest-specific gene 6 (GAS6) as an intra-hospital mortality predictor for patients in septic shock

Aim: Gas6 is known to be elevated in sepsis, correlating with the severity of infection and organ failure. We aimed to investigate the performance of Gas6 plasma levels at admission to predict the risk of mortality in a cohort of septic patients.Methods: We used prospectively collected data and plasma samples from the 'Sepsis Cohorte Romande'. Gas6 level was measured by ELISA at admission and expressed in percentage relative to its level in a pool of normal plasma.Results: Non-survivors (n = 19) presented higher Gas6 levels than survivors (n = 78; median 287% vs. 158%, IQR 182 and 119 respectively; P = 0.0003). Gas6 correlated positively with different cytokine and was the best mortality predictor, as shown by the ROC curves area (Fig. 1). In patients with septic shock (n = 67), using 249% as a cut-off value, Gas6 measurement had a specificity of 81% and a sensitivity of 68% for predicting mortality. ROC curve area was 0.76. Positive and negative predictive values were 59% and 87%, respectively.Conclusion: Thus, Gas6 plasma level at admission might be a useful tool to predict mortality in patients with septic shock. Nevertheless, independent association of Gas6 level with mortality still needs to be assessed. Although Gas6 hold promise as an early sepsis marker, its precise implication in sepsis remains to be elucidated.

Adrenal crisis presenting as hypoglycemic coma.

An 18-month-old male infant presented with hypoglycemic coma and clinical signs of bronchopneumonia. He was suspected of suffering from septic shock. The patient progressed to irreversible multiple organ failure before the diagnosis of adrenal crisis was established. Plasma levels of ACTH and cortisol remained undetectable. Renin and aldosterone were normal. An autopsy failed to demonstrate any adrenal gland cortical tissue. Immunohistochemical staining demonstrated the presence of all pituitary hormones except ACTH, establishing the diagnosis of isolated ACTH deficiency. Intensive care clinicians should consider adrenal crisis in non-diabetic children with hypoglycemia and rapid circulatory deterioration.

Acceptance of inflammatory bowel disease treatment recommendations based on appropriateness ratings : do practicing gastroenterologists agree with experts?

BACKGROUND: Appropriateness criteria for the treatment of Crohn's disease (CD) and ulcerative colitis (UC) have been developed by experts' panels. Little is known about the acceptance of such recommendations by care providers. The aim was to explore how treatment decisions of practicing gastroenterologists differ from experts using a vignette case study and a focus group. METHODS: Seventeen clinical vignettes were drawn from clinical indications evaluated by the expert panel. A vignette case questionnaire asking for treatment options in 9-10 clinical situations was submitted to 26 practicing gastroenterologists. For each vignette case, practitioners' answers on treatments deemed appropriate were compared to panel decisions. Qualitative analysis was made based on focus group discussion to explore acceptance and divergence reasons. RESULTS: 239 clinical vignettes were completed, 98 for CD and 141 for UC. Divergence between proposed treatments and results from panels was more frequent for CD (34%) than for UC (27%). Among UC clinical vignettes, the main divergences with the panel were linked to 5-ASA failure assessment and to situations where stopping treatment was the main decision. For CD, the care provider propositions diverged with the panel in mild-to-moderate active disease, where practitioners were more prone to an accelerated step up than the panel's recommendations. CONCLUSIONS: In about one third of vignettes cases, IBD treatment propositions made by practicing gastroenterologists diverged as compared to expert recommendations. Practicing gastroenterologists may experience difficulties in applying recommendations in daily practice.