Human CD8(+) T cells engineered with supraphysiological TCRs are functionally inhibited via PD-1 and SHP-1 phosphatase

Purpose/Objective: Protective CD8+ T cell responses rely on TCRdependent recognition of immunogenic peptides presented by MHC I. Cytolytic T lymphocytes directed against self/tumor antigens express TCRs of lower affinity/avidity than pathogen-derived T lymphocytes and elicit less protective immune responses due to mechanisms of central and peripheral tolerance. Anti-tumor T cell reactivity can be improved by increasing the TCR-pMHC affinity within physiological limits, while intriguingly further increase in the supraphysiological range (KD < 1 lM) leads to drastic functional declines. We aim at identifying the molecular mechanisms underlying the loss of T cell responsiveness associated with supraphysiological TCRpMHC affinities in order to improve effectiveness of TCR-engineered T cells used in adoptive cell transfer (ACT) cancer immunotherapy. Materials and methods: Using a panel of human CD8+ T cells engineered with TCRs of incremental affinity for the HLA-A2-resticted tumor cancer testis antigen NY-ESO-1, we performed comparative gene expression microarray and TCR-mediated signaling analysis together with membrane receptors level analysis. Results: As compared to cells expressing TCR affinities generating optimal function (KD from 5to 1 lM), those with supraphysiological affinity (KD from 1 lM to 15 nM) had an overall reduced expression of genes implied in signaling, cell activation and proliferation, and showed impaired proximal and distal TCR signaling capacity. This correlated with a decline in surface expression of CD8b, CD28 and activatory TNFR superfamily members. Importantly, expression of inhibitory receptor PD-1 and SHP-1 phosphatase was upregulated in a TCR affinity-dependent manner. Consequently, PD-L1 and SHP-1 blockade restored the function of T cells with high TCRs affinity. Moreover, SHP-1 inhibition also augmented functional efficacy of T cells with TCRs of optimal affinity. Conclusions: Our findings indicate that TCR affinity-associated regulatory mechanisms control T cells responsiveness at various levels to limit potential auto-reactive cytotoxic effects. They also support the development of ACT therapies combined with blockade of inhibitory molecules such as SHP-1 to enhance effectiveness of T cell immunotherapy.