Autophagic cell death exists.

The term autophagic cell death (ACD) initially referred to cell death with greatly enhanced autophagy, but is increasingly used to imply a death-mediating role of autophagy, as shown by a protective effect of autophagy inhibition. In addition, many authors require that autophagic cell death must not involve apoptosis or necrosis. Adopting these new and restrictive criteria, and emphasizing their own failure to protect human osteosarcoma cells by autophagy inhibition, the authors of a recent Editor's Corner article in this journal argued for the extreme rarity or nonexistence of autophagic cell death. We here maintain that, even with the more stringent recent criteria, autophagic cell death exists in several situations, some of which were ignored by the Editor's Corner authors. We reject their additional criterion that the autophagy in ACD must be the agent of ultimate cell dismantlement. And we argue that rapidly dividing mammalian cells such as cancer cells are not the most likely situation for finding pure ACD.

Multiple interacting cell death mechanisms in the mediation of excitotoxicity and ischemic brain damage: A challenge for neuroprotection.

There is currently no approved neuroprotective pharmacotherapy for acute conditions such as stroke and cerebral asphyxia. One of the reasons for this may be the multiplicity of cell death mechanisms, because inhibition of a particular mechanism leaves the brain vulnerable to alternative ones. It is therefore essential to understand the different cell death mechanisms and their interactions. We here review the multiple signaling pathways underlying each of the three main morphological types of cell death - apoptosis, autophagic cell death and necrosis - emphasizing their importance in the neuronal death that occurs during cerebral ischemia and hypoxia-ischemia, and we analyze the interactions between the different mechanisms. Finally, we discuss the implications of the multiplicity of cell death mechanisms for the design of neuroprotective strategies.

Classification of cell death: recommendations of the Nomenclature Committee on Cell Death 2009

Different types of cell death are often defined by morphological criteria, without a clear reference to precise biochemical mechanisms. The Nomenclature Committee on Cell Death (NCCD) proposes unified criteria for the definition of cell death and of its different morphologies, while formulating several caveats against the misuse of words and concepts that slow down progress in the area of cell death research. Authors, reviewers and editors of scientific periodicals are invited to abandon expressions like 'percentage apoptosis' and to replace them with more accurate descriptions of the biochemical and cellular parameters that are actually measured. Moreover, at the present stage, it should be accepted that caspase-independent mechanisms can cooperate with (or substitute for) caspases in the execution of lethal signaling pathways and that 'autophagic cell death' is a type of cell death occurring together with (but not necessarily by) autophagic vacuolization. This study details the 2009 recommendations of the NCCD on the use of cell death-related terminology including 'entosis', 'mitotic catastrophe', 'necrosis', 'necroptosis' and 'pyroptosis'.

Cell death and autophagy after severe hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy in term newborns

Introduction: Various studies from hypoxic-ischemic animals haveinvestigated neuroprotection by targeting necrosis and apoptosis with inconclusive results. Three types of cell death have been described: apoptosis, necrosis and more recently, autophagic cell death. While autophagy is a physiological process of degradation of cellular components, excessive autophagy may be involved in cell death. Recent studies showed that inhibition of autophagy is neuroprotective in rodent neonatal models of cerebral ischemia. Furthermore, neonatal hypoxia-ischemia strongly increased neuronal autophagic flux which is linked to cell death in a rat model of perinatal asphyxia. Following our observations in animals, the aim of the present study was to characterize the different neuronal death phenotypes and to clarify whether autophagic cell death could be also involved in neuronal death in the human newborns after perinatal asphyxia. Methods: we selected retrospectively and anonymously all newborns who died in our unit of neonatology between 2004 and 2009, with the following criteria: gestational age >36 weeks, diagnosis of perinatal asphyxia (Apgar <5 at 5 minutes, arterial pH <7.0 at 1 hour of life and encephalopathy Sarnat III) and performed autopsy. The brain of 6 cases in asphyxia group and 6 control cases matching gestational age who died of pulmonary or other malformations were selected. On histological sections of thalamus, frontal cortex and hippocampus, different markers of apoptosis (caspase 3, TUNEL), autophagosomes (LC3-II) and lysosomes (LAMP1, Cathepsin D) were tested by immunohistochemistry. Results: Preliminary studies on markers of apoptosis (TUNEL, caspase 3) and of autophagy (Cathepsin D, LC3II, LAMP1) showed an expected increase of apoptosis, but also an increase of neuronal autophagic flux in the selected areas. The distribution seems to be region specific. Conclusion: This is the first time that autophagic flux linked with cell death is shown in brain of human babies, in association with hypoxicischemic encephalopathy. This work leads to a better understanding of the mechanisms associated with neuronal death following perinatal asphyxia and determines whether autophagy could be a promising therapeutic target.

Neuronal death after perinatal cerebral hypoxia-ischemia: Focus on autophagy-mediated cell death.

Neonatal hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy is a critical cerebral event occurring around birth with high mortality and neurological morbidity associated with long-term invalidating sequelae. In view of the great clinical importance of this condition and the lack of very efficacious neuroprotective strategies, it is urgent to better understand the different cell death mechanisms involved with the ultimate aim of developing new therapeutic approaches. The morphological features of three different cell death types can be observed in models of perinatal cerebral hypoxia-ischemia: necrotic, apoptotic and autophagic cell death. They may be combined in the same dying neuron. In the present review, we discuss the different cell death mechanisms involved in neonatal cerebral hypoxia-ischemia with a special focus on how autophagy may be involved in neuronal death, based: (1) on experimental models of perinatal hypoxia-ischemia and stroke, and (2) on the brains of human neonates who suffered from neonatal hypoxia-ischemia.

Combinative effects of β-Lapachone and APO866 on pancreatic cancer cell death through reactive oxygen species production and PARP-1 activation.

UNLABELLED: Pancreatic cancer (PC) is one of the most lethal human malignancies and a major health problem. Patients diagnosed with PC and treated with conventional approaches have an overall 5-year survival rate of less than 5%. Novel strategies are needed to treat this disease. Herein, we propose a combinatorial strategy that targets two unrelated metabolic enzymes overexpressed in PC cells: NAD(P)H: quinone oxidoreductase-1 (NQO1) and nicotinamide phosphoribosyl transferase (NAMPT) using β-lapachone (BL) and APO866, respectively. We show that BL tremendously enhances the antitumor activity of APO866 on various PC cell lines without affecting normal cells, in a PARP-1 dependent manner. The chemopotentiation of APO866 with BL was characterized by the following: (i) nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD) depletion; (ii) catalase (CAT) degradation; (iii) excessive H2O2 production; (iv) dramatic drop of mitochondrial membrane potential (MMP); and finally (v) autophagic-associated cell death. H2O2 production, loss of MMP and cell death (but not NAD depletion) were abrogated by exogenous supplementation with CAT or pharmacological or genetic inhibition of PARP-1. Our data demonstrates that the combination of a non-lethal dose of BL and low dose of APO866 optimizes significantly cell death on various PC lines over both compounds given separately and open new and promising combination in PC therapy.

The role of raptor in cell death

Selon les statistiques, les maladies cancéreuses sont en augmentation dans les pays en développement ainsi que dans les pays industrialisés. Ceci peut s'expliquer largement par les habitudes alimentaires, le tabagisme, les infections, le manque d'activité physique, la pollution et le stress, entre autres. Ainsi, l'Organisation Mondiale de la Santé (OMS) prévoit une augmentation de la fréquence des cancers avec 15 millions de nouveaux cas par an en 2020. La transformation d'une cellule normale en une cellule cancéreuse se déroule en plusieurs étapes avec, au niveau moléculaire, différentes mutations ciblant des protéines régulant la croissance cellulaire. Un des exemples de protéines qui participent au contrôle des voies cellulaires impliquées lors de la prolifération des cellules sont les complexes de protéines mTORCl et mTORC2 (« mammalian target of rapamycin complex 1 and 2 »). Ces complexes mTORCl et mTORC2 activent des processus anaboliques (la synthèse de protéines et de lipides, le métabolisme énergétique, entre autres) et inhibent en même temps des voies de catabolismes cellulaires (autophagie et synthèse de lysosomes). Ils sont souvent mutés dans de nombreux cas de cancers, c'est pourquoi ils sont la cible de nombreux traitements anti-cancéreux. Pour ces raisons, nous nous sommes intéressés aux mécanismes d'actions moléculaires des drogues qui ciblent les complexes mTORCl et mTORC2. Nous avons ainsi découvert qu'une molécule présente uniquement dans le complexe mTORCl, raptor, était clivée en un fragment plus petit lors du traitement de cellules cancéreuses avec des drogues. Des molécules activées durant la mort cellulaire programmée par apoptose, les caspases, se sont révélées responsables du clivage de raptor. Nous avons ensuite décrit de façon précise les sites de clivage de raptor par les caspases durant la mort cellulaire. Il s'est avéré que le clivage de raptor affaiblissait son interaction avec mTOR au sein du complexe mTORCl, ce qui participe à l'inactivation de mTORCl lors de traitements avec des molécules anti-cancéreuses. Ces résultats nous ont permis de mieux comprendre les mécanismes d'actions de différentes drogues anti-cancéreuses au niveau du complexe mTORCl, ce qui peut être utile pour la synthèse de nouvelles molécules ciblant mTORCl ainsi que pour lutter contre les mécanismes de résistance chimiothérapeutiques. -- La protéine « mammalian target of rapamycin » (mTOR) est une sérine/thréonine kinase qui est hautement conservée des protistes à l'être humain. Deux complexes mTOR existent : le complexe 1 mTOR (mTORCl) et le complexe 2 mTOR (mTORC2). Ils régulent positivement des processus anaboliques (synthèse de protéines et de lipides, le métabolisme énergétique, l'organisation du cytosquelette, la survie cellulaire) et négativement des voies cataboliques (autophagic, biogenèse de lysosomes). Les complexes mTORCl et mTORC2 sont sensibles aux signaux mitogéniques tels que les acides aminés, le glucose, les facteurs de croissance, l'état énergétique (ATP) et les niveaux d'oxygène et induisent des voies de croissance cellulaire essentielles. La voie cellulaire regulée par mTORCl peut être hyperactivée dans de nombreux cancers humains. Puisque plusieurs voies cellulaires convergent et régulent les complexes mTORCl et mTORC2, des mutations dans les kinases en amont peuvent mener à une dérégulation de l'activation de mTOR. Des stratégies thérapeutiques ont été développées pour cibler les complexes mTORCl et mTORC2, ainsi que les kinases en amont qui régulent mTOR. Plusieurs drogues ciblant mTORCl, telles que la rapamycine et la curcumine, affectent l'interaction entre mTOR et un composant spécifique de mTORCl, raptor. Dans cette étude, nous nous sommes intéressés aux mécanismes moléculaires des drogues qui ciblent mTORCl, ainsi que leur effet déstabilisant sur l'interaction entre mTOR et raptor dans des lignées cellulaires de lymphomes. Nous avons démontré que raptor était clivé en un fragment de lOOkDa après traitement avec la rapamycine, la curcumine, l'étoposide, la cisplatine, la staurosporine et le ligand Fas (FasL). Etant donné que ces drogues ont été décrites comme induisant I'apoptose, l'utilisation d'un inhibiteur de caspases (z- VAD-fmk) a révélé que le clivage de raptor, lors de la mort cellulaire, était dépendant des caspases. Des essais caspases in vitro ont permis d'identifier la caspase-6 (ainsi que probablement d'autres caspases) comme étant une protéase impliquée dans le clivage de raptor. La séquence protéique de raptor a montré potentiellement plusieurs sites de clivage de caspases aux extrémités amino-terminale et carboxy-terminale. La mutagénèse a permis d'identifier les sites de clivages de raptor par les caspases comme étant DEAD LTD (acides aminés 17-23) et DDADD (acides aminés 939¬943). De plus, le clivage de raptor corrèle avec l'inhibition de l'activité de mTORCl envers ces substrats (S6K et 4E-BP1). Nous avons aussi observé que le clivage de raptor affaiblissait l'interaction entre mTOR et raptor, ce qui indique que ce clivage est une étape critique dans l'inhibition de mTORCl durant I'apoptose. Pour terminer, la mutagénèse du site de clivage de raptor DDADD a montré une résistance à la mort cellulaire de cellules cancéreuses. Notre travail de recherche a révélé un nouveau mécanisme moléculaire qui module l'organisation et l'activité de mTORCl, ce qui peut être d'un grand intérêt pour les recherches dans le domaine de mTOR ainsi que pour la découverte de molécules ciblant mTORCl. -- The mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) is a serine/threonine protein kinase, which is highly conserved from yeast to humans. Two different mTOR complexes exist: the mTOR complex 1 (mTORCl) and the mTOR complex 2 (mTORC2). They positively regulate anabolic processes (protein and lipid synthesis, energy metabolism, cytoskeleton organization, cell survival) and negatively regulate catabolic pathways (autophagy, lysosome biogenesis). The mTORCl and mTORC2 respond to mitogenic stimuli such as amino acids, glucose, growth factors, energy levels (ATP) and oxygen levels and drive essential cellular growth pathways. The mTORCl pathway can be found hyperactivated in numerous human cancers. As various cellular pathways converge and regulate mTORCl and mTORC2, mutations in upstream protein kinases can lead to a deregulated mTOR activation. Different therapeutic strategies have been developped to target mTORCl, mTORC2, as well as upstream protein kinases regulating mTOR pathways. Various drugs targeting mTORCl, such as rapamycin and curcumin, affect the interaction between mTOR and a specific mTORCl component, raptor. In this study, we investigated the molecular mechanisms of drugs targeting mTORCl, as well as their destabilizing effect on the mTOR-raptor interaction in lymphoma cell lines. We demonstrated that raptor was processed into a lOOkDa fragment after treatment with rapamycin, curcumin, etoposide, cisplatin, staurosporine and FasL. As these drugs were reported to induce apoptosis, the use of a pan-caspase inhibitor (z-VAD-fmk) revealed that the cleavage of raptor under cell death was caspase-dependent. In vitro caspase assays were performed to identify caspases-6 (and probably other caspases) as an important cysteine protease implicated in the cleavage of raptor. Analysis of raptor protein sequence showed several putative caspase-specific cleavage sites at the N-terminal and the C-terminal ends. Mutagenesis studies allowed us to identify the DEADLTD (amino acids 17-23) and the DDADD (amino acids 939-943) as the caspase-dependent cleavage residues of raptor. Furthermore, the cleavage of raptor correlated with inhibition of mTORCl activity towards its specific targets (4E-BP1 and S6K). We also highlighted that raptor processing weakened the interaction between mTOR and raptor, indicating that raptor cleavage is a critical step in the mTORCl inhibition process during apoptosis. Finally, mutagenesis of raptor C-terminal cleavage site (DDADD) conferred resistance to the chemotherapeutic-mediated cell death cascade of cancer cell. Our research work highlighted a new molecular mechanism modulating mTORCl organization and activity, which can be of great interest in the mTOR field research and for designing drugs trageting mTORCl.

NEUROPATHOPHYSIOLOGICAL MECHANISMS IN GLUTARIC ACIDURIA TYPE I: 3-HYDROXYGLUTARIC ACID LEADS TO AMMONIA INCREASE AND NON-APOPTOTIC CELL DEATH

A 3D in vitro model of rat organotypic brain cell cultures in aggregates was used to investigate neurotoxicity mechanisms in glutaric aciduria type I (GA-I). 1 mM glutarate (GA) or 3-hydroxyglutarate (3OHGA) were repeatedly added to the culture media at two different time points. In cultures treated with 3OHGA, we observed an increase in lactate in the medium, pointing to a possible inhibition of Krebs cycle and respiratory chain. We further observed that 3OHGA and to a lesser extend GA induced an increase in ammonia production with concomitant decrease of glutamine concentrations, which may suggest an inhibition of the astrocytic enzyme glutamine synthetase. These previously unreported findings may uncover a pathogenic mechanism in this disease which has deleterious effects on early stages of brain development. By immunohistochemistry we showed that 3OHGA increased non-apoptotic cell death. On the cellular level, 3OHGA and to a lesser extend GA led to cell swelling and loss of astrocytic fibers whereas a loss of oligodendrocytes was only observed for 3OHGA. We conclude that 3OHGAwas the most toxic metabolite in our model for GA-I. 3OHGA induced deleterious effects on glial cells, an increase of ammonia production, and resulted in accentuated cell death of non-apoptotic origin.

Ammonium accumulation and cell death in a rat 3D brain cell model of glutaric aciduria type I.

Glutaric aciduria type I (glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency) is an inborn error of metabolism that usually manifests in infancy by an acute encephalopathic crisis and often results in permanent motor handicap. Biochemical hallmarks of this disease are elevated levels of glutarate and 3-hydroxyglutarate in blood and urine. The neuropathology of this disease is still poorly understood, as low lysine diet and carnitine supplementation do not always prevent brain damage, even in early-treated patients. We used a 3D in vitro model of rat organotypic brain cell cultures in aggregates to mimic glutaric aciduria type I by repeated administration of 1 mM glutarate or 3-hydroxyglutarate at two time points representing different developmental stages. Both metabolites were deleterious for the developing brain cells, with 3-hydroxyglutarate being the most toxic metabolite in our model. Astrocytes were the cells most strongly affected by metabolite exposure. In culture medium, we observed an up to 11-fold increase of ammonium in the culture medium with a concomitant decrease of glutamine. We further observed an increase in lactate and a concomitant decrease in glucose. Exposure to 3-hydroxyglutarate led to a significantly increased cell death rate. Thus, we propose a three step model for brain damage in glutaric aciduria type I: (i) 3-OHGA causes the death of astrocytes, (ii) deficiency of the astrocytic enzyme glutamine synthetase leads to intracerebral ammonium accumulation, and (iii) high ammonium triggers secondary death of other brain cells. These unexpected findings need to be further investigated and verified in vivo. They suggest that intracerebral ammonium accumulation might be an important target for the development of more effective treatment strategies to prevent brain damage in patients with glutaric aciduria type I.

Nitrosative stress and corneal transplant endothelial cell death during acute graft rejection.

BACKGROUND: Nitrosative stress takes place in endothelial cells (EC) during corneal acute graft rejection. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the potential role of peroxynitrite on corneal EC death. METHODS: The effect of peroxynitrite was evaluated in vivo. Fifty, 250, and 500 microM in 1.5 microL of the natural or denatured peroxynitrite in 50 microM NaOH, 50 microM NaOH alone, or balanced salt solution were injected into the anterior chamber of rat eyes (n=3/group). Corneal toxic signs after injection were assessed by slit-lamp, in vivo confocal imaging, pachymetry, and EC count. The effect of peroxynitrite was also evaluated on nitrotyrosine and leucocyte elastase inhibitor/LDNase II immunohistochemistry. Human corneas were incubated with peroxynitrite and the effect on EC viability was evaluated. A specific inducible nitric oxide synthase inhibitor (iNOS) was administered systemically in rats undergoing allogeneic corneal graft rejection and the effect on EC was evaluated by EC count. RESULTS: Rat eyes receiving as little as 50 microM peroxynitrite showed a specific dose-dependent toxicity on EC. We observed an intense nitrotyrosine staining of human and rat EC exposed to peroxynitrite associated with leucocyte elastase inhibitor nuclear translocation, a noncaspase dependent apoptosis reaction. Specific inhibition of iNOS generation prevented EC death and enhanced EC survival of the grafted corneas. However, inhibition of iNOS did not have a significant influence on the incidence of graft rejection. CONCLUSION: Nitrosative stress during acute corneal graft rejection in rat eyes induces a noncaspase dependent apoptotic death in EC. Inhibition of nitric oxide production during the corneal graft rejection has protective effects on the corneal EC survival.

TAT-RasGAP317-326-mediated tumor cell death sensitization can occur independently of Bax and Bak.

The increase of cancer specificity and efficacy of anti-tumoral agents are prime strategies to overcome the deleterious side effects associated with anti-cancer treatments. We described earlier a cell-permeable protease-resistant peptide derived from the p120 RasGAP protein, called TAT-RasGAP317-326, as being an efficient tumor-specific sensitizer to apoptosis induced by genotoxins in vitro and in vivo. Bcl-2 family members regulate the intrinsic apoptotic response and as such could be targeted by TAT-RasGAP317-326. Our results indicate that the RasGAP-derived peptide increases cisplatin-induced Bax activation. We found no evidence, using in particular knock-out cells, of an involvement of other Bcl-2 family proteins in the tumor-specific sensitization activity of TAT-RasGAP317-326. The absence of Bax and Bak in mouse embryonic fibroblasts rendered them resistant to cisplatin-induced apoptosis and consequently to the sensitizing action of the RasGAP-derived peptide. Surprisingly, in the HCT116 colon carcinoma cell line, the absence of Bax and Bak did not prevent cisplatin-induced apoptosis and the ability of TAT-RasGAP317-326 to augment this response. Our study also revealed that p53, while required for an efficient genotoxin-induced apoptotic response, is dispensable for the ability of the RasGAP-derived peptide to improve the capacity of genotoxins to decrease long-term survival of cancer cells. Hence, even though genotoxin-induced Bax activity can be increased by TAT-RasGAP317-326, the sensitizing activity of the RasGAP-derived peptide can operate in the absence of a functional mitochondrial intrinsic death pathway.

Enhancement of autophagic flux after neonatal cerebral hypoxia-ischemia and its region-specific relationship to apoptotic mechanisms.

The multiplicity of cell death mechanisms induced by neonatal hypoxia-ischemia makes neuroprotective treatment against neonatal asphyxia more difficult to achieve. Whereas the roles of apoptosis and necrosis in such conditions have been studied intensively, the implication of autophagic cell death has only recently been considered. Here, we used the most clinically relevant rodent model of perinatal asphyxia to investigate the involvement of autophagy in hypoxic-ischemic brain injury. Seven-day-old rats underwent permanent ligation of the right common carotid artery, followed by 2 hours of hypoxia. This condition not only increased autophagosomal abundance (increase in microtubule-associated protein 1 light chain 3-11 level and punctuate labeling) but also lysosomal activities (cathepsin D, acid phosphatase, and beta-N-acetylhexosaminidase) in cortical and hippocampal CA3-damaged neurons at 6 and 24 hours, demonstrating an increase in the autophagic flux. In the cortex, this enhanced autophagy may be related to apoptosis since some neurons presenting a high level of autophagy also expressed apoptotic features, including cleaved caspase-3. On the other hand, enhanced autophagy in CA3 was associated with a more purely autophagic cell death phenotype. In striking contrast to CA3 neurons, those in CA1 presented only a minimal increase in autophagy but strong apoptotic characteristics. These results suggest a role of enhanced autophagy in delayed neuronal death after severe hypoxia-ischemia that is differentially linked to apoptosis according to the cerebral region.

Cathepsin B-like and cell death in the unicellular human pathogen Leishmania.

In several studies reporting cell death (CD) in lower eukaryotes and in the human protozoan parasite Leishmania, proteolytic activity was revealed using pan-caspase substrates or inhibitors such as carbobenzoxy-valyl-alanyl-aspartyl-[O-methyl]-fluoromethylketone (Z-VAD-FMK). However, most of the lower eukaryotes do not encode caspase(s) but MCA, which differs from caspase(s) in its substrate specificity and cannot be accountable for the recognition of Z-VAD-FMK. In the present study, we were interested in identifying which enzyme was capturing the Z-VAD substrate. We show that heat shock (HS) induces Leishmania CD and leads to the intracellular binding of Z-VAD-FMK. We excluded binding and inhibition of Z-VAD-FMK to Leishmania major metacaspase (LmjMCA), and identified cysteine proteinase C (LmjCPC), a cathepsin B-like (CPC) enzyme, as the Z-VAD-FMK binding enzyme. We confirmed the specific interaction of Z-VAD-FMK with CPC by showing that Z-VAD binding is absent in a Leishmania mexicana strain in which the cpc gene was deleted. We also show that parasites exposed to various stress conditions release CPC into a soluble fraction. Finally, we confirmed the role of CPC in Leishmania CD by showing that, when exposed to the oxidizing agent hydrogen peroxide (H(2)O(2)), cpc knockout parasites survived better than wild-type parasites (WT). In conclusion, this study identified CPC as the substrate of Z-VAD-FMK in Leishmania and as a potential additional executioner protease in the CD cascade of Leishmania and possibly in other lower eukaryotes.

Nineteenth century research on cell death.

This paper reviews research on cell death in the 19th C. The first report of cell death was by Vogt in 1842, which was remarkably soon after the establishment of the cell theory by Schleiden and Schwann between 1838 and 1842. Initial studies on cell death, including that of Vogt, focused on its occurrence in metamorphosis (Vogt, 1842; Prévost and Lebert, 1844; Weismann, 1863-1866) or in blatant pathology (Virchow, 1858), but as histological techniques improved it was found to be involved in more subtle roles in numerous situations including endochondral ossification (Stieda, 1872), ovarian follicle atresia (Flemming, 1885), cell turnover (Nissen, 1886), the wholesale loss of a population of sensory neurons in fish (Beard, 1889), and the naturally occurring histogenetic death of myocytes (Felix, 1889) and neurons (Collin, 1906). The current categorization of cell death into about three main morphological types has 19th century roots in that apoptosis was well described by Flemming (1885), who called it chromatolysis, and various authors including Noetzel (1895) proposed a threefold classification. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled "Apoptosis: Four Decades Later".