Biophysical requirements of power-supply systems: nuclear energy and fossil energy

The report presents a grammar capable of analyzing the process of production of electricity in modular elements for different power-supply systems, defined using semantic and formal categories. In this way it becomes possible to individuate similarities and differences in the process of production of electricity, and then measure and compare “apples” with “apples” and “oranges” with “oranges”. For instance, when comparing the various unit operations of the process of production of electricity with nuclear energy to the analogous unit operations of the process of production of fossil energy, we see that the various phases of the process are the same. The only difference is related to characteristics of the process associated with the generation of heat which are completely different in the two systems. As a matter of facts, the performance of the production of electricity from nuclear energy can be studied, by comparing the biophysical costs associated with the different unit operations taking place in nuclear and fossil power plants when generating process heat or net electricity. By adopting this approach, it becomes possible to compare the performance of the two power-supply systems by comparing their relative biophysical requirements for the phases that both nuclear energy power plants and fossil energy power plants have in common: (i) mining; (ii) refining/enriching; (iii) generating heat/electricity; (iv) handling the pollution/radioactive wastes. This report presents the evaluation of the biophysical requirements for the two powersupply systems: nuclear energy and fossil energy. In particular, the report focuses on the following requirements: (i) electricity; (ii) fossil-fuels, (iii) labor; and (iv) materials.

Assessing the viability of power-supply systems: a tentative protocol

This Technical Report presents a tentative protocol used to assess the viability of powersupply systems. The viability of power-supply systems can be assessed by looking at the production factors (e.g. paid labor, power capacity, fossil-fuels) – needed for the system to operate and maintain itself – in relation to the internal constraints set by the energetic metabolism of societies. In fact, by using this protocol it becomes possible to link assessments of technical coefficients performed at the level of the power-supply systems with assessments of benchmark values performed at the societal level throughout the relevant different sectors. In particular, the example provided here in the case of France for the year 2009 makes it possible to see that in fact nuclear energy is not viable in terms of labor requirements (both direct and indirect inputs) as well as in terms of requirements of power capacity, especially when including reprocessing operations.

Informe d'Autors UOC a ISI Web of Knowledge. Gener 2007

UOC

Informe d'Autors UOC a ISI Web of Knowledge. Octubre 2007

Informe sobre les publicacions de recerca de la UOC introduides a ISI Web of Knowledge durant

Informe d'Autors UOC a ISI Web of Knowledge. Novembre 2007

Informe sobre les publicacions de recerca de la UOC introduides a ISI Web of Knowledge durant

Informe d'Autors UOC a ISI Web of Knowledge. Desembre 2007

UOC

Informe d'Autors UOC a ISI Web of Knowledge. Gener-Febrer 2008

UOC

Informe d'Autors UOC a ISI Web of Knowledge. Març-Abril 2008

UOC

Informe d'Autors UOC a ISI Web of Knowledge. Maig-Juny 2008

UOC

Informe d'Autors UOC a ISI Web of Knowledge. Juliol-Agost 2008

UOC

Informe d'Autors UOC a ISI Web of Knowledge. Setembre 2008

UOC

Informe d'Autors UOC a ISI Web of Knowledge. Octubre-Novembre 2008

UOC

Informe d'Autors UOC a ISI Web of Knowledge. Desembre 2008

UOC

Informe d'Autors UOC a ISI Web of Knowledge. Febrer 2007

Informe sobre les publicacions de recerca de la UOC introduides a ISI Web of Knowledge durant el febrer de 2007.