131 resultados para Lingüística aplicada
Resumo:
The purpose of this article is to treat a currently much debated issue, the effects of age on second language learning. To do so, we contrast data collected by our research team from over one thousand seven hundred young and adult learners with four popular beliefs or generalizations, which, while deeply rooted in this society, are not always corroborated by our data.Two of these generalizations about Second Language Acquisition (languages spoken in the social context) seem to be widely accepted: a) older children, adolescents and adults are quicker and more efficient at the first stages of learning than are younger learners; b) in a natural context children with an early start are more liable to attain higher levels of proficiency. However, in the context of Foreign Language Acquisition, the context in which we collect the data, this second generalization is difficult to verify due to the low number of instructional hours (a maximum of some 800 hours) and the lower levels of language exposure time provided. The design of our research project has allowed us to study differences observed with respect to the age of onset (ranging from 2 to 18+), but in this article we focus on students who began English instruction at the age of 8 (LOGSE Educational System) and those who began at the age of 11 (EGB). We have collected data from both groups after a period of 200 (Time 1) and 416 instructional hours (Time 2), and we are currently collecting data after a period of 726 instructional hours (Time 3). We have designed and administered a variety of tests: tests on English production and reception, both oral and written, and within both academic and communicative oriented approaches, on the learners' L1 (Spanish and Catalan), as well as a questionnaire eliciting personal and sociolinguistic information. The questions we address and the relevant empirical evidence are as follows: 1. "For young children, learning languages is a game. They enjoy it more than adults."Our data demonstrate that the situation is not quite so. Firstly, both at the levels of Primary and Secondary education (ranging from 70.5% in 11-year-olds to 89% in 14-year-olds) students have a positive attitude towards learning English. Secondly, there is a difference between the two groups with respect to the factors they cite as responsible for their motivation to learn English: the younger students cite intrinsic factors, such as the games they play, the methodology used and the teacher, whereas the older students cite extrinsic factors, such as the role of their knowledge of English in the achievement of their future professional goals. 2 ."Young children have more resources to learn languages." Here our data suggest just the opposite. The ability to employ learning strategies (actions or steps used) increases with age. Older learners' strategies are more varied and cognitively more complex. In contrast, younger learners depend more on their interlocutor and external resources and therefore have a lower level of autonomy in their learning. 3. "Young children don't talk much but understand a lot"This third generalization does seem to be confirmed, at least to a certain extent, by our data in relation to the analysis of differences due to the age factor and productive use of the target language. As seen above, the comparably slower progress of the younger learners is confirmed. Our analysis of interpersonal receptive abilities demonstrates as well the advantage of the older learners. Nevertheless, with respect to passive receptive activities (for example, simple recognition of words or sentences) no great differences are observed. Statistical analyses suggest that in this test, in contrast to the others analyzed, the dominance of the subjects' L1s (reflecting a cognitive capacity that grows with age) has no significant influence on the learning process. 4. "The sooner they begin, the better their results will be in written language"This is not either completely confirmed in our research. First of all, we perceive that certain compensatory strategies disappear only with age, but not with the number of instructional hours. Secondly, given an identical number of instructional hours, the older subjects obtain better results. With respect to our analysis of data from subjects of the same age (12 years old) but with a different number of instructional hours (200 and 416 respectively, as they began at the ages of 11 and 8), we observe that those who began earlier excel only in the area of lexical fluency. In conclusion, the superior rate of older learners appears to be due to their higher level of cognitive development, a factor which allows them to benefit more from formal or explicit instruction in the school context. Younger learners, however, do not benefit from the quantity and quality of linguistic exposure typical of a natural acquisition context in which they would be allowed to make use of implicit learning abilities. It seems clear, then, that the initiative in this country to begin foreign language instruction earlier will have positive effects only if it occurs in combination with either higher levels of exposure time to the foreign language, or, alternatively, with its use as the language of instruction in other areas of the curriculum.
Resumo:
La comedia Pigmalión, que Bernard Shaw escribió en 1912 y estrenó al año siguiente, es una proclamación artística de la lingüística. A pesar de la popularidad de la obra, es un acontecimiento que se conoce como una anécdota extravagante. El extraordinario mérito de Pigmalión ha pasado desapercibido para la historia de la lingüística. Su mérito estriba en la calidad teatral, la capacidad prospectiva de Shaw y la intención social de su mensaje. Shaw anuncia la utilidad de la lingüística en facetas que, décadas después, se conocerán como sociolingüística, planificación lingüística y logopedia. Por otra parte, se ha relacionado de modo simplista el personaje del profesor Higgins al fonetista H. Sweet. The play Pygmalion, that Bernard Shaw wrote in 1912 and released the following year, is an artistic proclamation of Linguistics. Despite the popularity of the play, this event is known as an extravagant story. The History of Linguistics does not recognize the extraordinary merit of Pygmalion. Its merit lays in the theatrical quality ant the social intention of the message. Shaw announces the usefulness of Linguistics in facets that will be known as Sociolinguistics, Language Planning and Speech Therapy. And furthermore, in a simplistic way, the character of Professor Higgins has been linked to the phonetician H. Sweet.
Resumo:
Segons els estudis existents, en general, els joves són la franja més capacitada per utilitzar el català en tots els àmbits i contextos, però, en conjunt, són els que menys el fan servir. En l"àmbit metropolità, on resideix la majoria de la població de Catalunya, l"ús del català per part dels joves és encara més baix. Alhora, se sap que l"assoliment de la competència de l"expressió oral en català al final del primer cicle de l"ESo no és pas general, per la qual cosa tot sembla indicar que el model escolar actual no té gaire influència en els usos lingüístics més individualitzats. En el marc d"aquesta situació, el Govern de la Generalitat de Catalunya va encarregar al Consell Social de la Llengua Catalana un informe sobre les possibles mesures a prendre per tal d"intervenir-hi i potenciar més l"ús de la llengua. Les conclusions del Consell assenyalen que caldria actuar preferentment sobre els hàbits d"ús intergrupals i socials a través de la formació sociolingüística dels mestres i professors en general, i tot transformant els centres escolars que ho necessitin per la seva composició demolingüística en institucions molt conscients del seu paper en el desenvolupament eficaç d"una L2 (llengua segona). Igualment, es recomana que les polítiques lingüístiques no ignorin el pla cognitivoemotiu dels individus i que s"acompanyin de discursos legitimadors integradors. Per tal d"augmentar la percepció d"utilitat i funcionalitat del català, és imprescindible aconseguir que es converteixi en la llengua laboral més habitual, fet pel qual la intervenció sobre el món socioeconòmic té la màxima importància. En paral·lel, el Govern ha de procurar incidir en tot l"àmbit ludicomediàtic juvenil, ja que és una generació plenament integrada en aquest univers tecnològic.
Resumo:
Los manuales de historia de la lingüística tratan del mito bíblico de Babel y del nacimiento de la gramática en Alejandría de manos de Dionisio de Tracia. Estos pasajes de la historia, que corresponden a épocas diferentes, remiten a dos problemas fundamentales de la lingüística: por una parte, el origen del lenguaje y la diversidad lingüística; por la otra, la invención de la gramática como instrumento para la edición de textos y para el conocimiento formal de la lengua. Pese a las diferencias, Babel y la biblioteca de Alejandría tienen en común una naturaleza mítica. Sus relatos contienen elementos de la ficción y de la realidad que suelen pasar desapercibidos. El artículo señala estos elementos y establece ciertas afinidades entre Babel y la biblioteca, de suerte que articulados componen un ciclo narrativo. // Abstract.- Babel and the Library, the myth masks in Linguistics. History textbooks of linguistics explain the biblical myth of Babel and the birth of grammar in Alexandria at the hands of Dionysius Thrax. These passages of history, which correspond to different times, refer to two fundamental problems of linguistics: first, the origin of language and linguistic diversity and on the other, the invention of grammar as a tool for text editing and formal knowledge of the language. Despite the differences, Babel and the library of Alexandria share a mythical nature. These stories contain elements of fiction and reality that often go unnoticed. The article points out these elements and establishes affinities between Babel and the library, so that it should be considered as a narrative cycle. Keywords: Babel, Library of Alexandria, myth, story, grammar, institution, Dionysius Thrax.
Resumo:
En aquest article reflexionem sobre el monopoli de les llengües "majoritàries" en l'àmbit de les tecnologies lingüístiques. Analitzem, així mateix, com les llengües minoritàries poden afrontar aquest desafiament i examinem el cas de l'èuscar. Un cop estudiat el desenvolupament de l'èuscar en el camp de les tecnologies lingüístiques, analitzem fins a quin punt aquestes tecnologies poden ajudar el procés de normalització de la llengua.
Resumo:
Mitjançant una metodologia qualitativa basada en entrevistes obertes en profunditat, l'article pretén mostrar exemples de projecció de representacions lingüístiques de parlants provinents d'altres àrees lingüístiques sobre la situació sociolingüística del català. S'observen diferents aspectes d'aquestes representacions i es constata que hi ha nombrosos fenòmens de reinterpretació de la pròpia llengua i de la situació sociolingüística d'origen a partir de l'experiència amb el català. Així mateix, es veu com les llengües com el català, amb capacitat identitària, es constitueixen en elements clau tant d'integració en una nova comunitat com de valoració de la pròpia herència cultural i lingüística, especialment en els casos de llengües minoritzades.
Resumo:
Mitjançant una metodologia qualitativa basada en entrevistes obertes en profunditat, l'article pretén mostrar exemples de projecció de representacions lingüístiques de parlants provinents d'altres àrees lingüístiques sobre la situació sociolingüística del català. S'observen diferents aspectes d'aquestes representacions i es constata que hi ha nombrosos fenòmens de reinterpretació de la pròpia llengua i de la situació sociolingüística d'origen a partir de l'experiència amb el català. Així mateix, es veu com les llengües com el català, amb capacitat identitària, es constitueixen en elements clau tant d'integració en una nova comunitat com de valoració de la pròpia herència cultural i lingüística, especialment en els casos de llengües minoritzades.
Resumo:
Des la perspectiva sociològica, dos són els punts clau a destacar: la importància d'entendre la realitat lingüística separadament pels catalanoparlants i els castellanoparlants; i la importància, malgrat la dificultat, d'actuar sobre l'ús de la llengua en el marc social, cultural, polític i legal que tenim
Resumo:
Aquest treball és l'anàlisi lingüística diacrònica d'un procés judicial sobre proxenetisme celebrat entre el mes de desembre de 1403 i el mes d'abril de 1404 a Binissalem (Mallorca). L'interès per la llengua no literària dels textos catalans medievals n'és el seu l'origen. L'estudi que presentam s'ha dividit en diferents seccions en què analitzam els nivells lingüístics (grafies i fonètica, morfosintaxi i lèxic). Els resultats aconseguits ens han permès confirmar i aportar més informació sobre l'estat de la llengua a la Mallorca medieval, entre els quals destacam alguns trets innovadors que detallam a l'anàlisi
Resumo:
The purpose of this article is to treat a currently much debated issue, the effects of age on second language learning. To do so, we contrast data collected by our research team from over one thousand seven hundred young and adult learners with four popular beliefs or generalizations, which, while deeply rooted in this society, are not always corroborated by our data.Two of these generalizations about Second Language Acquisition (languages spoken in the social context) seem to be widely accepted: a) older children, adolescents and adults are quicker and more efficient at the first stages of learning than are younger learners; b) in a natural context children with an early start are more liable to attain higher levels of proficiency. However, in the context of Foreign Language Acquisition, the context in which we collect the data, this second generalization is difficult to verify due to the low number of instructional hours (a maximum of some 800 hours) and the lower levels of language exposure time provided. The design of our research project has allowed us to study differences observed with respect to the age of onset (ranging from 2 to 18+), but in this article we focus on students who began English instruction at the age of 8 (LOGSE Educational System) and those who began at the age of 11 (EGB). We have collected data from both groups after a period of 200 (Time 1) and 416 instructional hours (Time 2), and we are currently collecting data after a period of 726 instructional hours (Time 3). We have designed and administered a variety of tests: tests on English production and reception, both oral and written, and within both academic and communicative oriented approaches, on the learners' L1 (Spanish and Catalan), as well as a questionnaire eliciting personal and sociolinguistic information. The questions we address and the relevant empirical evidence are as follows: 1. "For young children, learning languages is a game. They enjoy it more than adults."Our data demonstrate that the situation is not quite so. Firstly, both at the levels of Primary and Secondary education (ranging from 70.5% in 11-year-olds to 89% in 14-year-olds) students have a positive attitude towards learning English. Secondly, there is a difference between the two groups with respect to the factors they cite as responsible for their motivation to learn English: the younger students cite intrinsic factors, such as the games they play, the methodology used and the teacher, whereas the older students cite extrinsic factors, such as the role of their knowledge of English in the achievement of their future professional goals. 2 ."Young children have more resources to learn languages." Here our data suggest just the opposite. The ability to employ learning strategies (actions or steps used) increases with age. Older learners' strategies are more varied and cognitively more complex. In contrast, younger learners depend more on their interlocutor and external resources and therefore have a lower level of autonomy in their learning. 3. "Young children don't talk much but understand a lot"This third generalization does seem to be confirmed, at least to a certain extent, by our data in relation to the analysis of differences due to the age factor and productive use of the target language. As seen above, the comparably slower progress of the younger learners is confirmed. Our analysis of interpersonal receptive abilities demonstrates as well the advantage of the older learners. Nevertheless, with respect to passive receptive activities (for example, simple recognition of words or sentences) no great differences are observed. Statistical analyses suggest that in this test, in contrast to the others analyzed, the dominance of the subjects' L1s (reflecting a cognitive capacity that grows with age) has no significant influence on the learning process. 4. "The sooner they begin, the better their results will be in written language"This is not either completely confirmed in our research. First of all, we perceive that certain compensatory strategies disappear only with age, but not with the number of instructional hours. Secondly, given an identical number of instructional hours, the older subjects obtain better results. With respect to our analysis of data from subjects of the same age (12 years old) but with a different number of instructional hours (200 and 416 respectively, as they began at the ages of 11 and 8), we observe that those who began earlier excel only in the area of lexical fluency. In conclusion, the superior rate of older learners appears to be due to their higher level of cognitive development, a factor which allows them to benefit more from formal or explicit instruction in the school context. Younger learners, however, do not benefit from the quantity and quality of linguistic exposure typical of a natural acquisition context in which they would be allowed to make use of implicit learning abilities. It seems clear, then, that the initiative in this country to begin foreign language instruction earlier will have positive effects only if it occurs in combination with either higher levels of exposure time to the foreign language, or, alternatively, with its use as the language of instruction in other areas of the curriculum.
Resumo:
The purpose of this article is to treat a currently much debated issue, the effects of age on second language learning. To do so, we contrast data collected by our research team from over one thousand seven hundred young and adult learners with four popular beliefs or generalizations, which, while deeply rooted in this society, are not always corroborated by our data.Two of these generalizations about Second Language Acquisition (languages spoken in the social context) seem to be widely accepted: a) older children, adolescents and adults are quicker and more efficient at the first stages of learning than are younger learners; b) in a natural context children with an early start are more liable to attain higher levels of proficiency. However, in the context of Foreign Language Acquisition, the context in which we collect the data, this second generalization is difficult to verify due to the low number of instructional hours (a maximum of some 800 hours) and the lower levels of language exposure time provided. The design of our research project has allowed us to study differences observed with respect to the age of onset (ranging from 2 to 18+), but in this article we focus on students who began English instruction at the age of 8 (LOGSE Educational System) and those who began at the age of 11 (EGB). We have collected data from both groups after a period of 200 (Time 1) and 416 instructional hours (Time 2), and we are currently collecting data after a period of 726 instructional hours (Time 3). We have designed and administered a variety of tests: tests on English production and reception, both oral and written, and within both academic and communicative oriented approaches, on the learners' L1 (Spanish and Catalan), as well as a questionnaire eliciting personal and sociolinguistic information. The questions we address and the relevant empirical evidence are as follows: 1. "For young children, learning languages is a game. They enjoy it more than adults."Our data demonstrate that the situation is not quite so. Firstly, both at the levels of Primary and Secondary education (ranging from 70.5% in 11-year-olds to 89% in 14-year-olds) students have a positive attitude towards learning English. Secondly, there is a difference between the two groups with respect to the factors they cite as responsible for their motivation to learn English: the younger students cite intrinsic factors, such as the games they play, the methodology used and the teacher, whereas the older students cite extrinsic factors, such as the role of their knowledge of English in the achievement of their future professional goals. 2 ."Young children have more resources to learn languages." Here our data suggest just the opposite. The ability to employ learning strategies (actions or steps used) increases with age. Older learners' strategies are more varied and cognitively more complex. In contrast, younger learners depend more on their interlocutor and external resources and therefore have a lower level of autonomy in their learning. 3. "Young children don't talk much but understand a lot"This third generalization does seem to be confirmed, at least to a certain extent, by our data in relation to the analysis of differences due to the age factor and productive use of the target language. As seen above, the comparably slower progress of the younger learners is confirmed. Our analysis of interpersonal receptive abilities demonstrates as well the advantage of the older learners. Nevertheless, with respect to passive receptive activities (for example, simple recognition of words or sentences) no great differences are observed. Statistical analyses suggest that in this test, in contrast to the others analyzed, the dominance of the subjects' L1s (reflecting a cognitive capacity that grows with age) has no significant influence on the learning process. 4. "The sooner they begin, the better their results will be in written language"This is not either completely confirmed in our research. First of all, we perceive that certain compensatory strategies disappear only with age, but not with the number of instructional hours. Secondly, given an identical number of instructional hours, the older subjects obtain better results. With respect to our analysis of data from subjects of the same age (12 years old) but with a different number of instructional hours (200 and 416 respectively, as they began at the ages of 11 and 8), we observe that those who began earlier excel only in the area of lexical fluency. In conclusion, the superior rate of older learners appears to be due to their higher level of cognitive development, a factor which allows them to benefit more from formal or explicit instruction in the school context. Younger learners, however, do not benefit from the quantity and quality of linguistic exposure typical of a natural acquisition context in which they would be allowed to make use of implicit learning abilities. It seems clear, then, that the initiative in this country to begin foreign language instruction earlier will have positive effects only if it occurs in combination with either higher levels of exposure time to the foreign language, or, alternatively, with its use as the language of instruction in other areas of the curriculum.
Resumo:
Tot i que la creixent amenaça de les plantes exòtiques invasores en els espais naturals és un fet evident, aquest problema és gairebé desconegut a la Vall d'Alinyà. Es van estudiar set punts de mostreig associats a quatre tipologies d'hàbitat per esbrinar la distribució de les plantes invasores en la Vall d'Alinyà, així com canvis recents en la seva composició, abundància i en el rang de distribució a partir de fonts bibliogràfiques. Es va desenvolupar un índex per quantificar la problemàtica de les invasions de flora exòtica en els diferents hàbitats estudiats. Els focus d'invasió van resultar estar associats a zones pertorbades, nuclis de població i baixes altituds. El canvi climàtic i els canvis en els usos del sòl podrien estar jugant un paper essencial en l'aparició de noves plantes invasores i en l'increment tant de l'abundància com de la cota altitudinal dels nivells més grans d'invasió. Tot i que la problemàtica associada a les plantes invasores en la Vall d'Alinyà és generalment baixa, algunes espècies com Senecio inaequidens representen una amenaça per a l'espai, motiu pel qual es proposa un pla de gestió per a la flora invasora.
Resumo:
El documento de trabajo contiene descripción y documentación de cómo trabajar películas en el aula de lengua y literatura en la etapa de educación primaria y secundaria. El cine es la maquinaria más formidable de desplegar emociones y conectarnos con el mundo, con las personas, con la vida. Desde que nació la “pantalla fascinadora” a finales del siglo XIX, el cine ha ido evolucionando y transformándose adoptando distintas formas. Pero a pesar de ello, su fuerza comunicativa y motivadora sigue siendo fascinante, desbordante, mágica.Cada vez son más son compartidas las grandes contribuciones pedagógicas del uso del cine en clase para promover conocimientos interdisciplinarios, contextualizar contenidos de enseñanza, favorecer la identificación sujeto-objeto, recuperar el carácter documental que el cine posee desde sus inicios, ahondar en el enfoque comunicativo que proporciona para el aprendizaje de lenguas extranjeras, el acercamiento a la literatura, establecer y reconocer relaciones intertextuales con otros textos y para educar en el goce artístico-lúdico. A todas estas contribuciones pedagógicas tenemos que añadir que en la pantalla conviven varios lenguajes: el verbal, el no verbal y el audiovisual, fundamentales para el desarrollo del intelecto humano. La multimodalidad es inherente al lenguaje cinematográfico, y tenemos que saber leer e interpretar los mensajes en distintos códigos. Desde Cinescola defendemos la necesidad de desarrollar la alfabetización múltiple (Unión Europea, 2012), que tanto engloba las competencias de lectura como de escritura para la comprensión, utilización y evaluación crítica de diferentes formas de información y textos. En esta línea, presentaremos propuestas didácticas experimentadas para educación primaria y secundaria que fomentan la comprensión tanto del lenguaje verbal como el audiovisual. Sustentadas en el proceso de recepción lectora y sus distintas fases, se apoyan en dos estrategias clave para la fase de comprensión e interpretación: la estrategia de comparación de textos breves (cinematográfico, literario, narrativo, ilustrado, etc.) y la estrategia de traducción de textos (por ejemplo, explicar con imágenes un fragmento escrito, narrar de forma oral o escrita una secuencia fílmica, etc.). Con ello, contribuimos de forma clara al desarrollo de la competencia comunicativa lingüística y la audiovisual a partir del cine. En nuestra pantalla proyectaremos secuencias de las películas Smoke (Wang, 1995); Akeelah and the Bee (Doug Atchinson, 2006); El pequeño vampiro (Edel, 2000); Mis tardes con Margueritte (Becker, 2010); junto con la novela El cine de Claudia (Breu, 2014) para aprender cine a través de una novela.
Resumo:
El documento de trabajo contiene descripción y documentación de cómo trabajar películas en el aula de lengua y literatura en la etapa de educación primaria y secundaria. El cine es la maquinaria más formidable de desplegar emociones y conectarnos con el mundo, con las personas, con la vida. Desde que nació la “pantalla fascinadora” a finales del siglo XIX, el cine ha ido evolucionando y transformándose adoptando distintas formas. Pero a pesar de ello, su fuerza comunicativa y motivadora sigue siendo fascinante, desbordante, mágica.Cada vez son más son compartidas las grandes contribuciones pedagógicas del uso del cine en clase para promover conocimientos interdisciplinarios, contextualizar contenidos de enseñanza, favorecer la identificación sujeto-objeto, recuperar el carácter documental que el cine posee desde sus inicios, ahondar en el enfoque comunicativo que proporciona para el aprendizaje de lenguas extranjeras, el acercamiento a la literatura, establecer y reconocer relaciones intertextuales con otros textos y para educar en el goce artístico-lúdico. A todas estas contribuciones pedagógicas tenemos que añadir que en la pantalla conviven varios lenguajes: el verbal, el no verbal y el audiovisual, fundamentales para el desarrollo del intelecto humano. La multimodalidad es inherente al lenguaje cinematográfico, y tenemos que saber leer e interpretar los mensajes en distintos códigos. Desde Cinescola defendemos la necesidad de desarrollar la alfabetización múltiple (Unión Europea, 2012), que tanto engloba las competencias de lectura como de escritura para la comprensión, utilización y evaluación crítica de diferentes formas de información y textos. En esta línea, presentaremos propuestas didácticas experimentadas para educación primaria y secundaria que fomentan la comprensión tanto del lenguaje verbal como el audiovisual. Sustentadas en el proceso de recepción lectora y sus distintas fases, se apoyan en dos estrategias clave para la fase de comprensión e interpretación: la estrategia de comparación de textos breves (cinematográfico, literario, narrativo, ilustrado, etc.) y la estrategia de traducción de textos (por ejemplo, explicar con imágenes un fragmento escrito, narrar de forma oral o escrita una secuencia fílmica, etc.). Con ello, contribuimos de forma clara al desarrollo de la competencia comunicativa lingüística y la audiovisual a partir del cine. En nuestra pantalla proyectaremos secuencias de las películas Smoke (Wang, 1995); Akeelah and the Bee (Doug Atchinson, 2006); El pequeño vampiro (Edel, 2000); Mis tardes con Margueritte (Becker, 2010); junto con la novela El cine de Claudia (Breu, 2014) para aprender cine a través de una novela.
Resumo:
L"article presenta l"entorn històric de les gramàtiques universals del segle xvii. Descriu el moviment cultural de l"abadia de Port-Royal, en els vessants religiós, polític, pedagògic i científic. Analitza els principis de la Grammaire générales et raisonne d"Antonie Arnauld i Claude Lancelot. Considera la relació de la gramàtica amb la Logique d"A. Aranuld i Pierre. Nicole. I examina la recepció que ha tingut la gramàtica de Port-Royal a la història de la Lingüística, en especial a partir de la tesi de Noam Chomsky sobre la lingüística cartesiana. La controvertida postura de Chomsky, rebutjada per la crítica, instrueix sobre els processos de construcció de la historiografia