Long-Term Evaluation of Recurrence after Photodynamic Therapy with Topical Methyl Aminolevulinate for Non-Melanoma Skin Cancer: a Hospital-Based Study

Introduction & Objectives: Several factors may influence the decision to pursue nonsurgical modalities for the treatment of non-melanoma skin cancer. Topical photodynamic therapy (PDT) is a non-invasive alternative treatment reported to have a high efficacy when using standardized protocols in Bowen’s disease (BD), superficial basal cell carcinoma (BCC) and in thin nodular BCC. However, long-term recurrence studies are lacking. The aim of this study was to evaluate the long-term efficacy of PDT with topical methylaminolevulinate (MAL) for the treatment of BD and BCC in a dermato-oncology department. Materials & Methods: All patients with the diagnosis of BD or BCC, treated with MAL-PDT from the years 2004 to 2008, were enrolled. Treatment protocol included two MAL-PDT sessions one week apart repeated at three months when incomplete response, using a red light dose of 37-40 J/cm2 and an exposure time of 8’20’’. Clinical records were retrospectively reviewed, and data regarding age, sex, tumour location, size, treatment outcomes and recurrence were registered. Descriptive analysis was performed using chi square tests, followed by survival analysis with the Kaplan-Meier and Cox regression models. Results: Sixty-eight patients (median age 71.0 years, P25;P75=30;92) with a total of 78 tumours (31 BD, 45 superficial BCC, 2 nodular BCC) and a median tumour size of 5 cm2 were treated. Overall, the median follow-up period was 43.5 months (P25;P75=0;100), and a total recurrence rate of 33.8% was observed (24.4 % for BCC vs. 45.2% for BD). Estimated recurrence rates for BCC and BD were 5.0% vs. 7.4% at 6 months, 23.4% vs. 27.9% at 12 months, and 30.0% vs. 72.4% at 60 months. Both age and diagnosis were independent prognostic factors for recurrence, with significantly higher estimated recurrence rates in patients with BD (p=0.0036) or younger than 58 years old (p=0.039). The risk of recurrence (hazard ratio) was 2.4 times higher in patients with BD compared to superficial BCC (95% CI:1.1-5.3; p=0.033), and 2.8 times higher in patients younger than 58 years old (95% CI:1.2-6.5; p=0.02). Conclusions: In the studied population, estimated recurrence rates are higher than those expected from available literature, possibly due to a longer follow-up period. To the authors’ knowledge there is only one other study with a similar follow-up period, regarding BCC solely. BD, as an in situ squamous cell carcinoma, has a higher tendency to recur than superficial BCC. Despite greater cosmesis, PDT might no be the best treatment option for young patients considering their higher risk of recurrence.

Recidiva de Cancro Cutâneo Não-Melanoma após Terapêutica Fotodinâmica num Serviço de Dermatologia

Introdução: São escassos os estudos de eficácia a longo prazo da terapêutica fotodinâmica(TFD) no tratamento da doença de Bowen (DB) e do carcinoma basocelular (CBC). Objectivos: Determinar a eficácia a longo prazo da TFD com metilaminolevulinato (MAL) no tratamento da DB e do CBC pela análise de recidiva. Material e método: Foram analisados retrospectivamente os processos clínicos de doentes com o diagnóstico de DB ou CBC tratados com TFD-MAL num serviço de Dermato- Oncologia entre 2004 e 2008. Foi efectuada a análise descritiva dos dados pelo teste do chiquadrado, seguida da análise de sobrevivência pelos métodos de Kaplan-Meier e regressão de Cox. Resultados: Foram tratados 68 doentes (mediana etária 71 anos, P25;P75=30;92) com um total de 78 tumores (31 DB, 45 CBC superficiais, 2 CBC nodulares finos). No período de seguimento efectuado (mediana 43,5 meses, P25;P75=0;100) observou-se uma taxa de recidiva de 25% no CBC e 45,2% na DB. As taxas de recidiva estimadas para os CBC e DB foram de 5,0% vs. 7,4% aos 6 meses, 23,4% vs. 27,9% aos 12 meses e de 30,0% vs. 72,4% aos 60 meses. Idade e diagnóstico constituíram factores independentes de prognóstico, com taxas de recidiva significativamente maiores nos doentes com DB (p=0,0036) ou com menos de 58 anos (p=0,039). De modo semelhante, o risco de recidiva foi 2,4 vezes superior nos doentes com DB face àqueles com CBC (p=0,033) e 2,8 vezes maior em doentes com menos de 58 anos (p=0,02). Conclusões: Na população estudada, a taxa de recidiva foi superior àquela encontrada na literatura. A TFD pode não ser a melhor opção para o tratamento do cancro cutâneo nãomelanoma em doentes mais jovens, em particular na doença de Bowen. Apesar do melhor resultado cosmético, o risco de recidiva deve ser equacionado e a escolha terapêutica deve ser ponderada caso a caso.

Long-Term Recurrence of Nonmelanoma Skin Cancer after Topical Methylaminolevulinate Photodynamic Therapy in a Dermato-Oncology Department

BACKGROUND: Most available studies on the efficacy of topical photodynamic therapy focus on short-to medium-term results. Long-term data are scarce. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the long-term efficacy of photodynamic therapy with topical methylaminolevulinate to treat Bowen's disease and basal cell carcinoma in the clinical practice setting of a dermato-oncology department. METHODS: The study included patients diagnosed with Bowen's disease or basal cell carcinoma, and who received photodynamic therapy from 2004 to 2008. Treatment protocol and clinical follow-up were standardized. The primary endpoint was clinically observed recurrence in a previous photodynamic therapy-treated area. Descriptive and survival analyses were performed. RESULTS: A total of 31 Bowen's disease lesions and 44 superficial basal cell carcinoma were treated, with a median follow-up of 43.5 months. Recurrence was observed in 14 Bowen's disease lesions (53.8%) and in 11 superficial basal cell carcinoma (33.3%). Significantly higher estimates for recurrence rates were found in patients with Bowen's disease (p=0.0036) or those aged under 58 years (p=0.039). The risk of recurrence was higher in patients with Bowen's disease than in those with superficial basal cell carcinoma and younger patients. CONCLUSIONS: Recurrence should be considered when choosing to treat non-melanoma skin cancer with photodynamic therapy. Younger age and Bowen's disease were independent predictors for long-term recurrence, suggesting the need to establish an extended period of follow-up for this subset of patients.