The role of the efflux mechanisms in multidrug resistance in Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Abstract The emergence of multi and extensively drug resistant tuberculosis (MDRTB and XDRTB) has increased the concern of public health authorities around the world. The World Health Organization has defined MDRTB as tuberculosis (TB) caused by organisms resistant to at least isoniazid and rifampicin, the main first-line drugs used in TB therapy, whereas XDRTB refers to TB resistant not only to isoniazid and rifampicin, but also to a fluoroquinolone and to at least one of the three injectable second-line drugs, kanamycin, amikacin and capreomycin. Resistance in Mycobacterium tuberculosis is mainly due to the occurrence of spontaneous mutations and followed by selection of mutants by subsequent treatment. However, some resistant clinical isolates do not present mutations in any genes associated with resistance to a given antibiotic, which suggests that other mechanism(s) are involved in the development of drug resistance, namely the presence of efflux pump systems that extrude the drug to the exterior of the cell, preventing access to its target. Increased efflux activity can occur in response to prolonged exposure to subinhibitory concentrations of anti-TB drugs, a situation that may result from inadequate TB therapy. The inhibition of efflux activity with a non-antibiotic inhibitor may restore activity of an antibiotic subject to efflux and thus provide a way to enhance the activity of current anti-TB drugs. The work described in this thesis foccus on the study of efflux mechanisms in the development of multidrug resistance in M. tuberculosis and how phenotypic resistance, mediated by efflux pumps, correlates with genetic resistance. In order to accomplish this goal, several experimental protocols were developed using biological models such as Escherichia coli, the fast growing mycobacteria Mycobacterium smegmatis, and Mycobacterium avium, before their application to M. tuberculosis. This approach allowed the study of the mechanisms that result in the physiological adaptation of E. coli to subinhibitory concentrations of tetracycline (Chapter II), the development of a fluorometric method that allows the detection and quantification of efflux of ethidium bromide (Chapter III), the characterization of the ethidium bromide transport in M. smegmatis (Chapter IV) and the contribution of efflux activity to macrolide resistance in Mycobacterium avium complex (Chapter V). Finally, the methods developed allowed the study of the role of efflux pumps in M. tuberculosis strains induced to isoniazid resistance (Chapter VI). By this manner, in Chapter II it was possible to observe that the physiological adaptation of E. coli to tetracycline results from an interplay between events at the genetic level and protein folding that decrease permeability of the cell envelope and increase efflux pump activity. Furthermore, Chapter III describes the development of a semi-automated fluorometric method that allowed the correlation of this efflux activity with the transport kinetics of ethidium bromide (a known efflux pump substrate) in E. coli and the identification of efflux inhibitors. Concerning M. smegmatis, we have compared the wild-type M. smegmatis mc2155 with knockout mutants for LfrA and MspA for their ability to transport ethidium bromide. The results presented in Chapter IV showed that MspA, the major porin in M. smegmatis, plays an important role in the entrance of ethidium bromide and antibiotics into the cell and that efflux via the LfrA pump is involved in low-level resistance to these compounds in M. smegmatis. Chapter V describes the study of the contribution of efflux pumps to macrolide resistance in clinical M. avium complex isolates. It was demonstrated that resistance to clarithromycin was significantly reduced in the presence of efflux inhibitors such as thioridazine, chlorpromazine and verapamil. These same inhibitors decreased efflux of ethidium bromide and increased the retention of [14C]-erythromycin in these isolates. Finaly, the methods developed with the experimental models mentioned above allowed the study of the role of efflux pumps on M. tuberculosis strains induced to isoniazid resistance. This is described in Chapter VI of this Thesis, where it is demonstrated that induced resistance to isoniazid does not involve mutations in any of the genes known to be associated with isoniazid resistance, but an efflux system that is sensitive to efflux inhibitors. These inhibitors decreased the efflux of ethidium bromide and also reduced the minimum inhibitory concentration of isoniazid in these strains. Moreover, expression analysis showed overexpression of genes that code for efflux pumps in the induced strains relatively to the non-induced parental strains. In conclusion, the work described in this thesis demonstrates that efflux pumps play an important role in the development of drug resistance, namely in mycobacteria. A strategy to overcome efflux-mediated resistance may consist on the use of compounds that inhibit efflux activity, restoring the activity of antimicrobials that are efflux pump substrates, a useful approach particularly in TB where the most effective treatment regimens are becoming uneffective due to the increase of MDRTB/XDRTB.

The inhibitory activity of synthetic compounds and ions against transporters of multi-drug resistant bacteria

RESUMO: Sessenta e três derivados de hidantoína foram utilizados para avaliar possíveis efeitos de modulação na actividade das bombas de efluxo (BE) na Salmonella NCTC 13349 utilizando um método fluorimétrico semi-automático. Nenhum dos compostos apresentaram actividade anti-bacteriana até concentrações de 240 mg/L. Entre todos os compostos, SZ-7 demonstrou possuir propriedades de modulação de effluxo na presença de glucose. Para testar esta actividade, estirpes de Salmonella resistentes à ciprofloxacina, induzidas a elevados níveis de resistência com sobre-expressão de BE, foram expostas ao SZ-7. Este derivado afectou a susceptibilidade das estirpes à ciprofloxacina. Uma vez que os 63 compostos estudados apresentaram pouco efeito inibitório /cumulativo, apesar de serem conhecidos pelos seus efeitos moduladores de BE-dependentes de iões em eucariotas, foi questionado o papel dos iões na regulação de BE bacterianas, que poderão influenciar a eficácia de novos compostos. Para este estudo, utilizamos a Escherichia coli AG100 como modelo, devido ao extenso conhecimento no que respeita a estrutura e actividade das BE. Devido à importância de iões de cálcio (Ca2+) nos canais de transporte membranar e na actividade de ATPases, a sua actividade na modulação do efluxo foi investigada. De resultados anteriormente obtidos concluiu-se que a pH 5 o efluxo é independente de energia metabólica; contudo, a pH 8 é absolutamente dependente, sendo que o Ca2+ é indispensável para manter a actividade das ATPases bacterianas. A acumulação/effluxo de EtBr pela E. coli AG100 foi determinada na presença/ausência de Ca2+, clorpromazina (inibidor de ligação de Ca2+ a proteínas), e ácido etilenodiamino tetra-acético (quelante de Ca2+). Acumulação/effluxo aumentou a pH 8, contudo o Ca2+ reverte estes efeitos evidenciando a sua importância no funcionamento das BE bacterianas. Em resumo este trabalho colocou em evidência que muitos aspectos bioquímicos e bioenergéticos devem ser tomados em consideração no estudo da resistência bacteriana mediada por BE.------- ABSTRACT: Sixty-three hydantoin derivatives were evaluated for their modulating effects on efflux pump (EP) activity of Salmonella NCTC 13349 utilizing a semi-automatic fluorometric method. None of the compounds presented antibacterial activities at concentrations as high as 240 mg/L. Among all compounds, SZ-7 showed possible efflux modulating activity in the presence of glucose, indicative of a potential EP inhibitor. To verify its potential effects, ciprofloxacin-resistant Salmonella strains, induced to high level resistance with over-expressing EPs, were exposed to SZ-7. This derivative affected the susceptibility of the ciprofloxacin-resistant strains. Since the 63 compounds studied had very low inhibitory/accumulative effects, even though their known for being efficient in modulating ion-driven eukaryotic EPs, we questioned whether ions had a leading role in regulating bacterial EPs, influencing the effectiveness of new compounds. For this study we used Escherichia coli AG100 as a model, due to the extensive knowledge on its EPs structure and activity. Owing the importance of calcium ions (Ca2+) for membrane transport channels and activity of ATPases, the role of Ca2+ was investigated. From previous results we concluded that at pH 5 efflux is independent of metabolic energy; however, at pH 8 it is entirely dependent of metabolic energy and the Ca2+ ions are essential to maintain the activity of bacterial ATPases. Accumulation and efflux of ethidium bromide (EtBr) by E. coli AG100 was determined in the presence and absence of Ca2+, chlorpromazine (inhibitor of Ca2+-binding to proteins), and ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (Ca2+ chelator). Accumulation of EtBr increased at pH 8; however Ca2+ reversed these effects providing information as to the importance of this ion in the regulation of bacterial EP systems. Overall this work puts in evidence that many biochemical and bioenergetic aspects related to the strains physiology need to be taken into consideration in bacterial drug resistance mediated by EPs.

A contribuição das bombas de efluxo QacA e Smr para a multirresistência em Staphylococcus aureus

RESUMO: O efluxo de compostos antimicrobianos é um mecanismo importante na multirresistência em bactérias. Bombas de efluxo codificadas em plasmídeos, como a QacA e a Smr, estão implicadas na susceptibilidade reduzida a biocidas, geralmente utilizados na prevenção e controlo de infecções nosocomiais, incluindo as causadas por estirpes de Staphylococcus aureus resistentes à meticilina (MRSA). Neste trabalho pretendeu-se avaliar a relevância de QacA e Smr no perfil de susceptibilidade dos isolados clínicos MRSA SM39 e SM52, que transportam os plasmídeos pSM39 e pSM52 com os determinantes qacA e smr, respectivamente. A actividade de efluxo das estirpes SM39 e SM39 curada (sem pSM39) e das estirpes SM52 e RN4220:pSM52 (estirpe susceptível RN4220 transformada com pSM52) foi caracterizada por: (1) determinação da concentração mínima inibitória (CMI) de biocidas, corantes e antibióticos, na ausência e presença dos inibidores de efluxo tioridazina, clorpromazina, verapamil e reserpina; e (2) fluorometria em tempo-real. A determinação de CMIs demonstrou que a actividade de efluxo mediada por QacA e Smr está envolvida na susceptibilidade reduzida aos biocidas e corantes testados, que incluíram o brometo de hexadeciltrimetilamónio, a cetrimida, o cloreto de benzalcónio, a berberina, o cloreto de dequalínio, a pentamidina e o brometo de etídeo. Os ensaios fluorométricos confirmaram a elevada actividade de efluxo presente nas estirpes com os genes qacA ou smr. A determinação de CMIs para antibióticos β-lactâmicos em conjunto com o teste da nitrocefina revelou a presença simultânea do gene qacA e de uma β-lactamase no plasmídeo pSM39. Este trabalho evidencia a importância das bombas de efluxo QacA e Smr na resistência a biocidas em estirpes MRSA e na sobrevivência destas estirpes em ambiente hospitalar e na comunidade, para além de destacar a questão da potencial co-resistência entre biocidas e antibióticos.--------------- ABSTRACT: Drug efflux has become an important cause of multidrug resistance (MDR) in bacteria. Plasmid-encoded MDR efflux pumps, such as QacA and Smr, are implicated in reduced susceptibility to biocides, generally used in the prevention and control of nosocomial infections, including the ones caused by methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA). In this work, we aimed to evaluate the relevance of QacA and Smr to the susceptibility profile of the clinical MRSA isolates SM39 and SM52, which harbor the plasmids pSM39 and pSM52 that carry the determinants qacA and smr, respectively. Efflux activity of strain SM39 and its plasmid-free counterpart, SM39 cured, SM52 and RN4220:pSM52 (susceptible strain RN4220 transformed with pSM52) was characterized by: (1) determination of minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) of biocides, dyes and antibiotics, in the absence and presence of the efflux inhibitors thioridazine, chlorpromazine, verapamil and reserpine; and (2) real-time fluorometry. MIC determination showed that QacA and Smr mediated efflux was involved in the reduced susceptibility profile to the biocides and dyes tested, which included hexadecyltrymethylammonium bromide, cetrimide, benzalkonium chloride, berberine, dequalinium chloride, pentamidine and ethidium bromide. Fluorometric assays confirmed the higher efflux activity present in strains harboring qacA or smr genes. Moreover, MIC determination for β-lactam antibiotics together with the nitrocefin test confirmed the presence of a β-lactamase in the plasmid carried by SM39 strain, pSM39. This work highlights the relevance of QacA and Smr to the biocide resistance in MRSA strains, and consequently to their survival and maintenance in the hospital environment and in the community. Furthermore, the presence of a β-lactamase and qacA determinants in the the same plasmid reinforces the question of the potencial biocide/antibiotic co-resistance in MRSA strains.