Multicriteria decision making: a case study in the automobile industry

Multi-criteria decision analysis(MCDA) has been one of the fastest-growing areas of operations research during the last decades. The academic attention devoted to MCDA motivated the development of a great variety of approaches and methods within the field. These methods distinguish themselves in terms of procedures, theoretical assumptions and type of decision addressed. This diversity poses challenges to the process of selecting the most suited method for a specific real-world decision problem. In this paper we present a case study in a real-world decision problem arising in the painting sector of an automobile plant. We tackle the problem by resorting to the well-known AHP method and to the MCDA method proposed by Pereira and Fontes (2012) (MMASSI). By relying on two, rather than one, MCDA methods we expect to improve the confidence and robustness of the obtained results. The contributions of this paper are twofold: first, we intend to investigate the contrasts and similarities of the results obtained by distinct MCDA approaches (AHP and MMASSI); secondly, we expect to enrich the literature of the field with a real-world MCDA case study on a complex decision making problem since there is a paucity of applied research work addressing real decision problems faced by organizations.

Multicriteria decision making: a case study in the automobile industry

Multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) has been one of the fastest-growing areas of operations research during the last decades. The academic attention devoted to MCDA motivated the development of a great variety of approaches and methods within the field. These methods distinguish themselves in terms of procedures, theoretical assumptions and type of decision addressed. This diversity poses challenges to the process of selecting the most suited method for a specific real-world decision problem. In this paper we present a case study in a real-world decision problem arising in the painting sector of an automobile plant. We tackle the problem by resorting to the well-known AHP method and to the MCDA method proposed by Pereira and Fontes (2012) (MMASSI). By relying on two, rather than one, MCDA methods we expect to improve the confidence and robustness of the obtained results. The contributions of this paper are twofold: first, we intend to investigate the contrasts and similarities of the results obtained by distinct MCDA approaches (AHP and MMASSI); secondly, we expect to enrich the literature of the field with a real-world MCDA case study on a complex decision making problem since there is a paucity of applied research work addressing real decision problems faced by organizations.

MCDA applied to performance appraisal of short-haul truck drivers: a case study in a portuguese trucking company

Performance appraisal increasingly assumes a more important role in any organizational environment. In the trucking industry, drivers are the company's image and for this reason it is important to develop and increase their performance and commitment to the company's goals. This paper aims to create a performance appraisal model for trucking drivers, based on a multi-criteria decision aid methodology. The PROMETHEE and MMASSI methodologies were adapted using the criteria used for performance appraisal by the trucking company studied. The appraisal involved all the truck drivers, their supervisors and the company's Managing Director. The final output is a ranking of the drivers, based on their performance, for each one of the scenarios used. The results are to be used as a decision-making tool to allocate drivers to the domestic haul service.

Maximizing the Social Welfare of Virtual Power Players Operation in Case of Excessive Wind Power

The integration of growing amounts of distributed generation in power systems, namely at distribution networks level, has been fostered by energy policies in several countries around the world, including in Europe. This intensive integration of distributed, non-dispatchable, and natural sources based generation (including wind power) has caused several changes in the operation and planning of power systems and of electricity markets. Sometimes the available non-dispatchable generation is higher than the demand. This generation must be used; otherwise it is wasted if not stored or used to supply additional demand. New policies and market rules, as well as new players, are needed in order to competitively integrate all the resources. The methodology proposed in this paper aims at the maximization of the social welfare in a distribution network operated by a virtual power player that aggregates and manages the available energy resources. When facing a situation of excessive non-dispatchable generation, including wind power, real time pricing is applied in order to induce the increase of consumption so that wind curtailment is minimized. This method is especially useful when actual and day-ahead resources forecast differ significantly. The distribution network characteristics and concerns are addressed by including the network constraints in the optimization model. The proposed methodology has been implemented in GAMS optimization tool and its application is illustrated in this paper using a real 937-bus distribution network with 20.310 consumers and 548 distributed generators, some of them non-dispatchable and with must take contracts. The implemented scenario corresponds to a real day in Portuguese power system.

Definition of Distribution Network Tariffs Considering Distribution Generation and Demand Response

The use of distribution networks in the current scenario of high penetration of Distributed Generation (DG) is a problem of great importance. In the competitive environment of electricity markets and smart grids, Demand Response (DR) is also gaining notable impact with several benefits for the whole system. The work presented in this paper comprises a methodology able to define the cost allocation in distribution networks considering large integration of DG and DR resources. The proposed methodology is divided into three phases and it is based on an AC Optimal Power Flow (OPF) including the determination of topological distribution factors, and consequent application of the MW-mile method. The application of the proposed tariffs definition methodology is illustrated in a distribution network with 33 buses, 66 DG units, and 32 consumers with DR capacity.

Realistic Traffic Scenarios Using a Census Methodology: Vila Real Case Study

This paper presents the first phase of the redevelopment of the Electric Vehicle Scenario Simulator (EVeSSi) tool. A new methodology to generate traffic demand scenarios for the Simulation of Urban MObility (SUMO) tool for urban traffic simulation is described. This methodology is based on a Portugal census database to generate a synthetic population for a given area under study. A realistic case study of a Portuguese city, Vila Real, is assessed. For this area the road network was created along with a synthetic population and public transport. The traffic results were obtained and an electric buses fleet was evaluated assuming that the actual fleet would be replaced in a near future. The energy requirements to charge the electric fleet overnight were estimated in order to evaluate the impacts that it would cause in the local electricity network.

A Communication and Resources Management Scheme to Support the Smart Grid Integration of Multiplayers Access to Resources Information

The increasing and intensive integration of distributed energy resources into distribution systems requires adequate methodologies to ensure a secure operation according to the smart grid paradigm. In this context, SCADA (Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition) systems are an essential infrastructure. This paper presents a conceptual design of a communication and resources management scheme based on an intelligent SCADA with a decentralized, flexible, and intelligent approach, adaptive to the context (context awareness). The methodology is used to support the energy resource management considering all the involved costs, power flows, and electricity prices leading to the network reconfiguration. The methodology also addresses the definition of the information access permissions of each player to each resource. The paper includes a 33-bus network used in a case study that considers an intensive use of distributed energy resources in five distinct implemented operation contexts.

Quantum-based Particle Swarm Optimization Application to Studies of Aggregated Consumption Shifting and Generation Scheduling in Smart Grids

Demand response programs and models have been developed and implemented for an improved performance of electricity markets, taking full advantage of smart grids. Studying and addressing the consumers’ flexibility and network operation scenarios makes possible to design improved demand response models and programs. The methodology proposed in the present paper aims to address the definition of demand response programs that consider the demand shifting between periods, regarding the occurrence of multi-period demand response events. The optimization model focuses on minimizing the network and resources operation costs for a Virtual Power Player. Quantum Particle Swarm Optimization has been used in order to obtain the solutions for the optimization model that is applied to a large set of operation scenarios. The implemented case study illustrates the use of the proposed methodology to support the decisions of the Virtual Power Player in what concerns the duration of each demand response event.

Estudo comparativo da utilização do biodiesel produzido a partir de óleos alimentares usados e do gasóleo numa frota industrial

A definição de teores mínimos de incorporação de biocombustíveis, constitui objeto de discussão entre grupos pro-desenvolvimento e ambientalistas. Esses últimos argumentam que as consequências da utilização desta fonte energética ainda são desconhecidas. Além disso, alegam que a produção de biocombustíveis é, em parte, responsável pelo aumento no preço dos alimentos, encoraja a conversão de florestas em monoculturas e conduz à exploração de trabalhadores em países em desenvolvimento (PEDs). Para responder à dependência energética dos combustíveis de origem fóssil, e ajudar a reduzir as emissões de gases com efeito de estufa, sobretudo no sector dos transportes, o biodiesel produzido a partir de óleos alimentares usados têm sido apontado como uma “solução verde” capaz de minimizar o problema das alterações climáticas e valorizar um resíduo, e simultaneamente conferir ao setor energético um pouco mais de independência. De forma a desmistificar e clarificar um pouco estas premissas, a presente dissertação pretende fazer um estudo de avaliação do impacto da utilização do biodiesel, nomeadamente no que diz respeito às emissões gasosas. Posteriormente realizou-se, tomando como referência uma pequena frota industrial existente, uma análise comparativa dos consumos e emissões dos principais poluentes decorrentes da utilização do biodiesel em diferentes percentagens de incorporação no gasóleo, comparativamente ao gasóleo puro. O trabalho culmina com uma abordagem técnica sobre o comportamento de um veículo equipado com um motor de ignição por compressão, utilizando como biocombustível o biodiesel.

Análise dos sistemas termo-solares de produção de energia eléctrica

Actualmente a humanidade depara-se com um dos grandes desafios que é o de efectivar a transição para um futuro sustentável. Logo, o sector da energia tem um papel chave neste processo de transição, com principal destaque para a energia solar, tendo em conta que é uma das fontes de energias renováveis mais promissoras, podendo no médiolongo prazo, tornar-se uma das principais fontes de energia no panorama energético dos países. A energia solar térmica de concentração (CSP), apesar não ser ainda conhecida em Portugal, possui um potencial relevante em regiões específicas do nosso território. Logo, o objectivo deste trabalho é efectuar uma análise detalhada dos sistemas solares de concentração para produção de energia eléctrica, abordando temas, tais como, o potencial da energia solar, a definição do processo de concentração solar, a descrição das tecnologias existentes, o estado da arte do CSP, mercado CSP no mundo, e por último, a análise da viabilidade técnico-económica da instalação de uma central tipo torre solar de 20 MW, em Portugal. Para que este objectivo fosse exequível, recorreu-se à utilização de um software de simulação termodinâmica de centrais CSP, denominado por Solar Advisor Model (SAM). O caso prático foi desenvolvido para a cidade de Faro, onde foram simuladas quatro configurações distintas para uma central do tipo torre solar de 20 MW. Foram apresentados resultados, focando a desempenho diário e anual da central. Foi efectuada uma análise para avaliação da influência da variabilidade dos parâmetros, localização geográfica, múltiplo solar, capacidade de armazenamento de calor e fracção de hibridização sobre o custo nivelado da energia (LCOE), o factor de capacidade e a produção anual de energia. Conjuntamente, é apresentada uma análise de sensibilidade, com a finalidade de averiguar quais os parâmetros que influenciam de forma mais predominante o valor do LCOE. Por último, é apresentada uma análise de viabilidade económica de um investimento deste tipo.

Comparison of different methods for work accidents investigation in hospitals: A Portuguese case study

BACKGROUND: The hospital environment has many occupational health risks that predispose healthcare workers to various kinds of work accidents. OBJECTIVE: This study aims to compare different methods for work accidents investigation and to verify their suitability in hospital environment. METHODS: For this purpose, we selected three types of accidents that were related with needle stick, worker fall and inadequate effort/movement during the mobilization of patients. A total of thirty accidents were analysed with six different work accidents investigation methods. RESULTS: The results showed that organizational factors were the group of causes which had the greatest impact in the three types of work accidents. CONCLUSIONS: The methods selected to be compared in this paper are applicable and appropriate for the work accidents investigation in hospitals. However, the Registration, Research and Analysis of Work Accidents method (RIAAT) showed to be an optimal technique to use in this context.

Análise da eficácia da aplicação da Metodologia FMEA do Processo: Caso de estudo numa empresa certificada

Num mercado globalizado, a procura contínua de vantagens competitivas é um fator crucial para o sucesso das organizações. A melhoria contínua dos processos é uma abordagem usual, uma vez que os resultados destas melhorias vão se traduzir diretamente na qualidade dos produtos. Neste contexto, a metodologia Failure Mode Effect Analysis (FMEA) é muito utilizada, especialmente pelas suas características proactivas, que permitem a identificação e a prevenção de erros do processo. Assim, quanto mais eficaz for a aplicação desta ferramenta, mais benefícios terá a organização. Assim, quando é utilizado com eficácia, o FMEA de Processo, além de ser um método poderoso na análise do processo, permite a melhoria contínua e a redução dos custos [1] . Este trabalho de dissertação teve como objetivo avaliar a eficácia da utilização da ferramenta do FMEA de processo numa organização certificada segundo a norma ISO/TS16949. A metodologia proposta passa pela análise de dados reais, ou seja, comparar as falhas verificadas no mercado com as falhas que tinham sido identificadas no FMEA. Assim, ao analisar o nível de falhas identificadas e não identificadas durante o FMEA e a projeção dessas falhas no mercado, consegue-se determinar se o FMEA foi mais ou menos eficaz, e ainda, identificar fatores que condicionam a melhor utilização da mesma. Este estudo, está organizado em três fases, a primeira apresenta a metodologia proposta , com a definição de um fluxograma do processo de avaliação e as métricas usadas, a segunda fase a aplicação do modelo proposto a dois casos de estudo, e uma última fase, que consiste na análise comparativa, individual e global, que visa, além de comparar esultados, identificar pontos fracos durante a execução do FMEA. Os resultados do caso de estudo indicam que a ferramenta do FMEA tem sido usada com eficácia, pois consegue-se identificar uma quantidade significativa de falhas potenciais e evitá-las. No entanto, existem ainda falhas que não foram identificadas no FMEA e que apareceram no cliente, e ainda, algumas falhas que foram identificadas e apareceram no cliente. As falhas traduzem-se em má qualidade e custos para o negócio, pelo que são propostas ações de melhoria. Pode-se concluir que uma boa utilização do FMEA pode ser um fator importante para a qualidade do serviço ao cliente, e ainda, com impacto dos custos.

Strategies to assess web resources credibility: results of a case study in primary and secondary schools from Portugal

In this paper, three approaches for the assessment of credibility in a web environment will be presented, namely the checklists model, the cognitive authority model and the contextual model. This theoretical framework was used to conduct a study about the assessment of web resources credibility among a sample of 195 students, from elementary and secondary schools in a municipality in Oporto district (Portugal). The practices that young people and children claim to use regarding the use of criteria for web resources selection will be presented. In addition, these results will be discussed and compared with the perceptions that these respondents have demonstrated for the use of criteria to establish or assess authorship, originality, or information resources structure. These results will be also discussed and compared with the perceptions that these respondents have demonstrated for the elements that make up each of these criteria.

Introducing numerical analysis tools in engineering: a Scilab user case in electronics course

Software tools in education became popular since the widespread of personal computers. Engineering courses lead the way in this development and these tools became almost a standard. Engineering graduates are familiar with numerical analysis tools but also with simulators (e.g. electronic circuits), computer assisted design tools and others, depending on the degree. One of the main problems with these tools is when and how to start use them so that they can be beneficial to students and not mere substitutes for potentially difficult calculations or design. In this paper a software tool to be used by first year students in electronics/electricity courses is presented. The growing acknowledgement and acceptance of open source software lead to the choice of an open source software tool – Scilab, which is a numerical analysis tool – to develop a toolbox. The toolbox was developed to be used as standalone or integrated in an e-learning platform. The e-learning platform used was Moodle. The first approach was to assess the mathematical skills necessary to solve all the problems related to electronics and electricity courses. Analysing the existing circuit simulators software tools, it is clear that even though they are very helpful by showing the end result they are not so effective in the process of the students studying and self learning since they show results but not intermediate steps which are crucial in problems that involve derivatives or integrals. Also, they are not very effective in obtaining graphical results that could be used to elaborate reports and for an overall better comprehension of the results. The developed tool was based on the numerical analysis software Scilab and is a toolbox that gives their users the opportunity to obtain the end results of a circuit analysis but also the expressions obtained when derivative and integrals calculations, plot signals, obtain vector diagrams, etc. The toolbox runs entirely in the Moodle web platform and provides the same results as the standalone application. The students can use the toolbox through the web platform (in computers where they don't have installation privileges) or in their personal computers by installing both the Scilab software and the toolbox. This approach was designed for first year students from all engineering degrees that have electronics/electricity courses in their curricula.