Initial dilemmas in IST research: design science and design research, a clarification of concepts

The inter-disciplinarity of information systems, applied discipline and activity of design, and the study from different paradigms perspectives explains the diversity of problems addressed. The context is broad and includes important issues beyond technology, as the application, use, effectiveness, efficiency and their organizational and social impacts. In design science, the research interest is in contributing to the improvement of the processes of the design activity itself. The relevance of research in design science is associated with the result obtained for the improvement of living conditions in organizational, inter-organizational and Society contexts. In the research whose results are artifacts, the adoption of design research as a process of research is crucial to ensure discipline, rigor and transparency. Based on a literature review, this paper clarifies the terms of design science and design research. This is the main motivation for presenting this paper, determinant for the phase in research in technologies and information systems which are the three research projects presented. As a result the three projects are discussed in relation to the concepts of design science and design research.

Interpretative research in information systems: two qualitative research design projects

In a scientific research project is important to define the underlying philosophical orientation of the project, because this will influence the choices made in respect of scientific methods used, as well as the way they will be applied. It is crucial, therefore, that the philosophy and research design strategy are consistent with each other. These questions become even more relevant in qualitative research. Historically, the interpretive research philosophy is more associated to the scientific areas of social sciences and humanities where the subjectivity inherent to human intervention is more explicitly defined. Information systems field are, primarily, trapped in computer science field, though it also integrates issues related with management and organizations field. This shift from a purely technological guidance for the consideration of the problems of management and organizations has fostered the rise of research projects according to the interpretive philosophy and using qualitative methods. This paper explores the importance of alignment between the epistemological orientation and research design strategy, in qualitative research projects. As a result, it is presented two PhD projects, with different research design strategies, that are being developed in the technology and information systems field, in the light of the interpretive paradigm.

Post-MAPS: An interactive acquisition platform for gastroenterology

Post-MAPS is a web platform that collects gastroenterological exam data from several european hospital centers, to be used in future clinical studies and was developed in partnership with experts from the gastroenterological area and information technology (IT) technicians. However, although functional, this platform has some issues that are crucial for its functioning, and can render user interaction unpleasant and exhaustive. Accordingly, we proposed the development of a new web platform, in which we aimed for an improvement in terms of usability, data uni cation and interoperability. Therefore, it was necessary to identify and study different ways of acquiring clinical data and review some of the existing clinical databases in order to understand how they work and what type of data they store, as well as their impact and contribution to clinical knowledge. Closely linked to the data model is the ability to share data with other systems, so, we also studied the concept of interoperability and analyzed some of the most widely used international standards, such as DICOM, HL7 and openEHR. As one of the primary objectives of this project was to achieve a better level of usability, practices related to Human Computer-Interaction, such as requirement analysis, creation of conceptual models, prototyping, and evaluation were also studied. Before we began the development, we conducted an analysis of the previous platform, from a functional point of view, which allowed us to gather not only a list of architectural and interface issues, but also a list of improvement opportunities. It was also performed a small preliminary study in order to evaluate the platform's usability, where we were able to realize that perceived usability is different between users, and that, in some aspects, varies according to their location, age and years of experience. Based on the information gathered during the platform's analysis and in the conclusions of the preliminary study, a new platform was developed, prepared for all potential users, from the inexperienced to the most comfortable with technology. It presents major improvements in terms of usability, also providing several new features that simplify the users' work, improving their interaction with the system, making their experience more enjoyable.

Contributos das TIC para as Necessidades Educativas Especiais - Treino da Perceção Visual

As novas tecnologias de informação e comunicação vêm introduzir novas abordagens e orientações nas relações das pessoas no mundo global, ao mesmo tempo que vêm redefinir paradigmas diversos em várias áreas disciplinares, nomeadamente nas áreas da saúde e da educação. A massificação das tecnologias vem assim aproximar a informação e o conhecimento das pessoas e a sua utilização no apoio aos processos de ensino e de aprendizagem dos alunos com necessidades educativas especiais e dificuldades de aprendizagem específicas tem vindo a ser discutida cada vez mais com uma maior relevância. Pretende-se através da presente dissertação contribuir com soluções que apoiem a desmaterialização dos processos e desburocratização dos relacionamentos entres os diversos intervenientes num processo de terapia de uma criança. Apesar de poder ser extensível a outros cenários, o projeto desenvolvido aplica-se ao caso concreto de crianças com necessidades educativas especiais e dificuldades de aprendizagem específicas, motivadas por dificuldades de perceção visual, que obrigam, além da adoção de programas de treino, como jogos interativos, a um acompanhamento integrado de todos os intervenientes na sua terapia: terapeutas, professores, pais e educadores, assistentes sociais entre outros, tornando-se fundamental a utilização de uma plataforma universal que permita a troca e sistematização de informações. Inicialmente foi necessário um enquadramento desta temática por via da leitura, pesquisa e reuniões com elementos ligados a diferentes áreas que intervém no tratamento de necessidades educativas especiais. Depois de uma pesquisa bibliográfica inicial sobre as dimensões a explorar, recolheu-se informação sobre estudos e projetos desenvolvidos para apoiar esta área, e desenvolveu-se um projeto destinado a contribuir para o trabalho positivo de todos os profissionais que se dedicam à terapia/tratamento das crianças com necessidades educativas especiais, particularmente derivadas de dificuldades de perceção visual. Posteriormente, realizou-se a avaliação do protótipo de forma a validar o real contributo do sistema na melhoria da comunicação e partilha de informação entre todos os intervenientes no processo de terapia de crianças com necessidades educativas especiais e da utilização das tecnologias interativas no treino da perceção visual. Com vista a uma futura implementação de um recurso educativo deste âmbito, foram também recolhidos os pontos negativos e sugestões de melhoria a incorporar. Em suma, este trabalho valida os contributos das TIC, e deste sistema em particular, na relação dos intervenientes num processo de terapia interdisciplinar e no treino da perceção visual.