The estimation of the return on firms’ investments – as to ISO 9001

The aim of this paper was to estimate the return on investment in QMS (quality management systems) certification undertaken in Portuguese firms, according to the ISO 9000 series. A total of 426 certified Portuguese firms were surveyed. The response rate was 61.03 percent. The different payback periods were validated through statistical analysis and the relationship between expected and perceived payback periods was discussed. This study suggests that a firm’s sector of activity, size and degree of internationalization are related to the length of the investment in QMS certification recovery period. Furthermore, our findings suggest, that the time taken to obtain the certification is not directly related to the economic component of the certification. The majority of Portuguese firms (58.9%) took up to three years to recoup their investment and 35.5% of companies said they had not yet recovered the initial investment made. The recoup of investment was measured by the increase in the number of customers and consequent volume of deliveries, improved profitability and productivity of the company, improvement of competitive position and performance (cost savings), reduction in the number of external complaints and internal defects/scrap, achievement of some important clientele, among others. We compared our work to similar studies undertaken in other countries. This paper provides a contribution to the research related to the return on investment for costs related to the certification QMS according to ISO 9000. This paper provides a valuable contribution to the field and is one of the first studies to undertake this type of analysis in Portugal.

Certification and integration of management systems: the experience of Portuguese small and medium enterprises

The purpose of this study was to characterize the situation of Portuguese Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) concerning the certification of their Quality Management Systems (QMS), Environmental Management Systems (EMS) and Occupational Health and Safety Management Systems (OHSMS), in their individually form, to identify benefits, drawbacks and difficulties associated with the certification process and to characterize the level of integration that has been achieved. This research was based on a survey carried out by the research team; it was administered to 46 Portuguese SMEs. Our sample comprised 20 firms (43%) from the Trade/Services activity sector, 17 (37%) from the Industrial sector, 5 (11%) from the Electricity/Telecommunications sector and 4 (9%) from the Construction area. All SMEs surveyed were certified according to the ISO 9001 (100%), a quarter of firms were certified according to the ISO 14001 (26.1%) and a few certified by OHSAS 18001 (15.2%). We undertook a multivariate cluster analysis, which enabled grouping variables into homogeneous groups or one or more common characteristics of the SMEs participating in the study. Results show that the main benefits that Portuguese SMEs have gained from the referred certifications have been, among others, an improvement of both their internal organization and external image. We also present the main difficulties in achieving certification. Overall, 7 of the Portuguese SMEs examined indicated that the main benefits of the IMS implementation management included costs reduction, increased employee training and easier compliance of legislation. The respective drawbacks and difficulties are also presented. Finally, we presented the main integrated items in the certified Portuguese SMEs we examined.

A divulgação da política da segurança e saúde do trabalho, no website das empresas portuguesas certificadas, no âmbito da qualidade (ISO 9001), ambiente (ISO 14001), segurança e saúde do trabalho (OHSAS 18001/NP 4397)

A Internet é um meio privilegiado de comunicação, no qual a informação não conhece fronteiras, e a sua divulgação toma uma dimensão universal. No mundo empresarial a comunicação é hoje tida, como o elemento fulcral dos processos de negócio, em que interação com as partes interessadas, pode ser traduzida em termos do seu expoente máximo pelo website da empresa. Grande parte da informação hoje divulgada à sociedade pela empresa, tem por objetivo demonstrar a «transparência» dos processos da organização, promovendo assim o seu escrutínio público. A investigação visou a análise exploratória dos websites de 422 empresas que se encontravam certificadas no ano 2011, no âmbito dos sistemas de gestão da qualidade (ISO 9001), ambiente (ISO 14001), segurança e saúde do trabalho (OHSAS 18001/NP 4397). O objeto de estudo visou determinar a percentagem de empresas que recorre ao website, para disponibilizar a Política da Segurança e Saúde do Trabalho (PSST), às partes interessadas (stakeholders), no cumprimento da alínea g) do requisito normativo 4.2 dos referenciais OHSAS 18001/NP 4397, bem como compreender a extensão ao website do requisito 4.4.3.1 (comunicação) no âmbito da divulgação da PSST.

Motivation and Benefits of Implementation and Certification according ISO 9001 – the Portuguese Experience

The aim of the research is to analyze the different aspects associated with the motivation and benefits of certified ISO 9001 companies in Portugal. A total of 426 certified Portuguese companies were surveyed. The response rate was equal to 61.03 percent. Our results suggest that the main motivation for certification were “improvement of quality”, “improvement of company image”, “marketing advantage”, “give empowerment to workers / capturing workers knowledge” and “cost reduction”. The main benefits that Portuguese companies have gained from the referred certification have been, among others, the improvement of “procedures”, beneficial effect on the “company’s image”, the improvement of quality products/services, increase of the “customer satisfaction”, improvement of “on-time delivery”; improvement the “morale” of workers’ increase in productivity and decrease of “production costs”, among others. The surveyed firms belong only to the Minho region of the north of Portugal. This paper aims to provide a contribution to the research related to the motivation and benefits associated to the quality management systems. The selection of the motives and benefits were validated through statistical analysis and the relationship between expected and perceived benefits was discussed.

Contributos para a revisão da Norma ISO 9001:2008 na perspetiva de uma aproximação à realidade organizacional

Este trabalho de investigação pretende dar o seu contributo para a renovação da norma ISO 9001:2008, na perspetiva de uma maior aproximação à realidade organizacional, através da análise da perceção dos especialistas/profissionais da qualidade. Numa primeira fase foi realizada uma abordagem ao estado da arte, relativamente ao conceito qualidade, à organização International Organization for Standardization (ISO), ao processo de alteração da norma, ao referencial normativo ISO 9001:2008, ao comportamento ao nível mundial da certificação segundo a norma ISO 9001:2008 e finalmente ao processo de preparação da revisão da norma ISO 9001:2008 a ser divulgada em 2015, cuja publicação na versão final, está prevista para novembro de 2015. Com a finalidade de apurar as opiniões/sugestões dos especialistas da área realizou-se um questionário que foi colocado online nas principais redes sociais e também enviado para alguns auditores, consultores, gestores/técnicos da qualidade e gestores de topo. Participaram 60 profissionais. Após da recolha dos dados, estes foram tratados através da utilização do software statistical package for the social sciences (SPSS). Os resultados obtidos demonstraram que a perceção dos profissionais vai de encontro às alterações que já estão propostas para a nova norma ISO 9001:2015. Das alterações sugeridas é de realçar, uma maior adequação da norma às diversas áreas de negócio, maior exigência nos aspetos ligados às organizações, adequação de conceitos e objetivos, compatibilidade com outros referenciais, complementar áreas como segurança, finanças e/ou responsabilidade social e maior envolvimento das organizações no processo de renovação da norma. No que concerne às expetativas, os profissionais esperam que a nova norma ISO 9001:2015 venha facilitar a integração e compreensão dos vários sistemas, maior adequação e credibilização junto das organizações e uma melhoria generalizada. Desta forma com o presente trabalho, espera-se ter contribuído para a clarificação das dificuldades sentidas na adequação do atual referencial à realidade organizacional. Assim como dar um contributo para futura apresentação aos responsáveis pelo acompanhamento da atividade normativa em Portugal (comité técnico CT80).

Implementing and certifying ISO 14001 in Portugal: motives, difficulties and benefits after ISO 9001 certification

The purpose of this study is to characterise the environmental management systems (EMS) certification process (International Organization for Standardization (ISO) 14001) in Portuguese small and medium enterprises (SMEs) following quality management system (QMS) certification (ISO 9001). The study is based on a sample from Portuguese SMEs which characterise the local reality in terms of companies certified in accordance with ISO 14001 after ISO 9001 certification. Some Portuguese SMEs have the EMS implemented but not certified, mainly given the lack of investment support and because it is considered merely a form of marketing. As such, they do not feel motivated to certificate an EMS in the company since they consider that it is a form of advertising and not a way to protect the environment. Nonetheless, it is already evident form other Portuguese SMEs that gained EMS certification that gains supersede marketing benefits and allow for evermore enduring benefits such as prevention of environmental risks, environment protection, improved company image, compliance with legislation and efficient use of natural resources. This paper also presented the main difficulties in achieving an EMS certification, including high certification costs, human resources, motivation issues and difficulties in changing the company’s culture.