Assessing Fracture Connectivity using Stable and Clumped Isotope Geochemistry of Calcite Cements

Understanding flow path connectivity within a geothermal reservoir is a critical component for efficiently producing sustained flow rates of hot fluids from the subsurface. I present a new approach for characterizing subsurface fracture connectivity that combines petrographic and cold cathodoluminescence (CL) microscopy with stable isotope analysis (δ18O and δ13C) and clumped isotope (Δ47) thermometry of fracture-filling calcite cements from a geothermal reservoir in northern Nevada. Calcite cement samples were derived from both drill cuttings and core samples taken at various depths from wells within the geothermal field. CL microscopy of some fracture filling cements shows banding parallel to the fracture walls as well as brecciation, indicating that the cements are related to fracture opening and fault slip. Variations in trace element composition indicated by the luminescence patterns reflect variations in the composition and source of fluids moving through the fractures as they opened episodically. Calcite δ13C and δ18O results also show significant variation among the sampled cements, reflecting multiple generations of fluids and fracture connectivity. Clumped isotope analyses performed on a subset of the cements analyzed for conventional δ18O and δ13C mostly show calcite growth temperatures around 150°C—above the current ambient rock temperature, which indicates a common temperature trend for the geothermal reservoir. However, calcite cements sampled along faults located within the well field showed both cold (18.7°C) and hot (226.1°C) temperatures. The anomalously cool temperature found along the fault, using estimates from clumped isotope thermometry, suggests a possible connection to surface waters for the geothermal source fluids for this system. This information may indicate that some of the faults within the well field are transporting meteoric water from the surface to be heated at depth, which then is circulated through a complex network of fractures and other faults.

An isotopic analysis of geothermal brine and calcite scaling from the Blue Mountain geothermal field, Winnemucca, Nevada

Understanding, and controlling, the conditions under which calcite precipitates within geothermal energy production systems is a key step in maintaining production efficiency. In this study, I apply methods of bulk and clumped isotope thermometry to an operating geothermal energy facility in northern Nevada to see how those methods can better inform the facility owner, AltaRock Energy, Inc., about the occurrence of calcite scale in their power plant. I have taken water samples from five production wells, the combined generator effluent, shallow cold-water wells, monitoring wells, and surface water. I also collected calcite scale samples from within the production system. Water samples were analyzed for stable oxygen isotope composition (d18O). Calcite samples were analyzed for stable oxygen and carbon (d13C) composition, and clumped isotope composition (D47). With two exceptions, the water compositions are very similar, likely indicating common origin and a well-mixed hydrothermal system. The calcite samples are likewise similar to one another. Apparent temperatures calculated from d18O values of water and calcite are lower than those recorded for the system. Apparent temperatures calculated from D47 are several degrees higher than the recorded well temperatures. The lower temperatures from the bulk isotope data are consistent with temperatures that could be expected during a de-pressurization of the production system, which would cause boiling in the pipes, a reduction in system temperature, and rapid precipitation of calcite scale. However, the high apparent temperature indicated by the D47 data suggests that the calcite is depleted in clumped isotopes given the known temperature of the system, which is inconsistent with this hypothesis. This depletion could instead result from disequilibrium isotopic fractionation during the aforementioned boil events, which would make both the apparent d18O-based and D47-based temperatures unrepresentative of the actual water temperature. This research can help improve our understanding of how isotopic analyses can better inform us about the movement of water through geothermal systems of the past and how it now moves through modern systems. Increased understanding of water movement in these systems could potentially allow for more efficient utilization of geothermal energy as a renewable resource.