Evaluation of NHMRC funded research completed in 1992, 1997 and 2003: gains in knowledge, health and wealth

Objective: To report on strategies for, and outcomes of, evaluation of knowledge (publications), health and wealth (commercial) gains from medical research funded by the Australian Government through the National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC). Design and methods: End-of-grant reports submitted by researchers within 6 months of completion of NHMRC funded project grants which terminated in 2003 were used to capture self-reported publication number, health and wealth gains. Self-reported gains were also examined in retrospective surveys of grants completed in 1992 and 1997 and awards primarily supporting people (“people awards”) held between 1992 and 2002. Results: The response rate for the 1992 sample was too low for meaningful analysis. The mean number of publications per grant in the basic biomedical, clinical and health services research areas was very similar in 1997 and 2003. The publication output for population health was somewhat higher in the 2003 than in the 1997 analysis. For grants completed in 1997, 24% (31/131) affected clinical practice; 14% (18/131) public health practice; 9% (12/131) health policy; and 41% (54/131) had commercial potential with 20% (26/131) resulting in patents. Most respondents (89%) agreed that NHMRC people awards improved their career prospects. Interpretation is limited by the relatively low response rates (50% or less). Conclusions: A mechanism has been developed for ongoing assessment of NHMRC funded research. This process will improve accountability to the community and to government, and refine current funding mechanisms to most efficiently deliver health and economic returns for Australia.

Detection of elevated protein modification in human cerebellum in alcoholic cerebellar degeneration

Modification of proteins by reactive ethanol metabolites has been known for some time to occur in the liver, the main site of ethanol metabolism. In more recent studies of laboratory animals, similar modifications have been detected in organs with lesser ability to metabolize ethanol, such as skeletal and cardiac muscle and brain. Such modification may alter protein function or form a neoantigen, making it a target for immune attack. We now report an analysis of protein modification derived from ethanol metabolites in human brain tissue by ELISA using adduct-specific antibodies. We obtained autopsy cerebellum samples from 10 alcoholic cerebellar degeneration cases and 10 matched controls under informed written consent from the next of kin and clearance from the UQ Human Ethics Committee. Elevated levels of protein modifications derived from acetaldehyde (unreduced-acetaldehyde and acetaldehyde-advanced glycation end-product adducts), from malondialdehyde (malondialdehyde adducts) and from combined adducts (malondialdehydeacetaldehyde (MAA) adducts) were detected in alcoholic cerebellar degeneration samples when compared to controls. Other adduct types found in liver samples, such as reduced-acetaldehyde and those derived from hydroxyethyl radicals, were not detected in brain samples. This may reflect the different routes of ethanol metabolism in the two tissues. This is the first report of elevated protein modification in alcoholic cerebellar degeneration, and suggests that such modification may play a role in the pathogenesis of brain injury. Supported by NIAAA under grant NIH AA12404 and the NHMRC (Australia) under grant #981723.

Cytokine-specific Gene-knockout Studies in Oropharyngeal Candidiasis

Oropharyngeal candidiasis is a common clinical problem encountered in patients with defects in innate or cell-mediated immunity. We have previously shown that recovery from chronic oropharyngeal candidiasis is dependent on CD4+ T-cell augmentation of neutrophil and macrophage candidacidal activity, and that the immune response is characterised by the production of cytokines such as IL-12 and IFN-gamma by cells in the local draining lymph nodes, and by the expression of TNF-alpha in the oral tissues. Objective: The purpose of this study was to elaborate on the role of these cytokines in recovery from oropharyngeal candidiasis, by using cytokine-specific gene-knockout mice. Methods: These mice are created by targeted gene mutation (tm1) of embryonic stem (ES) cells microinjected into host embryos. IL-4, IL-10, IL-12, IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha knockout mice, and appropriate controls, were infected orally with 108 viable C. albicans yeasts. The infection was quantified by swabbing the oral cavity and plating on Sabouraud's agar. Results: Tnftm1mice developed an acute severe infection characterized by an increased fungal load in the early stages of infection, but cleared the yeast within the same time frame as control mice (21 days). On the other hand, Il12btm1 mice developed a chronic oropharyngeal infection (120 days) similar to that seen in T-cell deficient (Foxn1nu/Foxn1nu) mutant mice. There was no significant difference between Il4tm1, Il10tm1, and Ifngtm1 mice and their respective controls. Conclusions: Tnftm1 mice may be rendered more susceptible through impaired recruitment of phagocytic cells, and/or impaired killing of C. albicans, whereas Il12btm1 mice may not be capable of activating naïve T-cells or inducing an appropriate cellular immune response. Supported by NHMRC and ADRF.