Dual paths to performance: the impact of global pressures on MNC subsidiary conduct and performance

Over the last decade, the international business literature has placed ever-greater emphasis on the role that learning and innovation play in determining multinational and multinational subsidiary performance. The present research seeks to understand the organizational paths leading to such desirable outcomes as greater learning, increased innovation and improved performance. Using a model tested with data collected through a survey of managers in subsidiaries of multinational firms, we find dual, independent paths to improved performance - one through networking and inter-unit learning and the other through subsidiary autonomy and innovation. A particular feature of these findings is that they can be shown to be robust after controlling for a wide range of environmental pressures and firm and industry factors. However, in the absence of environmental controls the dual path finding is rejected. These conflicting findings support the imperative to test models that include a diverse range of environmental pressures so that the true effects of organizational factors on learning, innovation and performance can be identified.

Contribution of MNCs to subsidiary stakeholders

The international business literature has evolved from addressing the question of how MNCs are more efficient organizations for exploiting innovations globally – to the issue of how MNCs are more effective in creating new products, processes and technologies worldwide. However, the question of how MNCs contribute to, and share benefits with, the host country stakeholders has received little attention in the literature. Our research shows that the contribution of MNCs to the subsidiary company and country stakeholders in the form of R&D, exports and royalty earnings is significantly less than expected. Insufficient compensation to local subsidiary stakeholders may undermine the motivation of subsidiary managers to discover new sources of advantage for the MNC. It may also discourage subsidiary country governments from offering incentives to MNCs for inward FDI.