Relationships of extant lower Brachycera (Diptera): a quantitative synthesis of morphological characters

With over 80 000 described species, Brachycera represent one of the most diverse clades of organisms with a Mesozoic origin. Larvae of the majority of early lineages are detritivores or carnivores. However, Brachycera are ecologically innovative and they now employ a diverse range of feeding strategies. Brachyceran relationships have been the subject of numerous qualitative analyses using morphological characters. These analyses are often based on characters from one or a few character systems and general agreement on relationships has been elusive. In order to understand the evolution of basal brachyceran lineages, 101 discrete morphological characters were scored and compiled into a single data set. Terminals were scored at the family level, and the data set includes characters from larvae, pupae and adults, internal and external morphology, and male and female terminalia. The results show that all infraorders of Brachycera are monophyletic, but there is little evidence for relationships between the infraorders. Stratiomyomorpha, Tabanomorpha, and Xylophagomorpha together form the sister group to Muscomorpha. Xylophagomorpha and Tabanomorpha are sister groups. Within Muscomorpha, the paraphyletic Nemestrinoidea form the two most basal lineages. There is weak evidence for the monophyly of Asiloidea, and Hilarimorphidae appear to be more closely related to Eremoneura than other muscomorphs. Apsilocephalidae, Scenopinidae and Therevidae form a clade of Asiloidea. This phylogenetic evidence is consistent with the contemporaneous differentiation of the main brachyceran lineages in the early Jurassic. The first major radiation of Muscomorpha were asiloids and they may have diversified in response to the radiation of angiosperms in the early Cretaceous.

The adult ventral nerve cord as a phylogenetic character in brachyceran Diptera

Insect ganglia are often composed of fused segmental units or neuromeres. We estimated the evolution of the ventral nerve cord (VNC) in higher Diptera by comparing the patterns of neuromere fusion among 33 families of the Brachycera. Variation within families is uncommon, and VNC architecture does not appear to be influenced by body shape. The outgroup pattern, seen in lower Diptera, is fusion of neuromeres belonging to thoracic segments 1 and 2 (T1 and T2), and fusion of neuromeres derived from T3 and abdominal segment 1 (A1). In the abdomen, neuromeres A7-10 are fused into the terminal abdominal ganglion (TAG). Increased neuromere fusion is a feature of the Brachycera. No brachyceran shows less fusion than the outgroups. We established six pattern elements; (1) fusion of T1 and T2, (2) fusion of T3 and A1, (3) fusion of the T1/T2 andT3/A1 ganglia, (4) increase in the number of neuromeres comprising the TAG, (5) anteriorward fusion of abdominal neuromeres, and (6) the complete fusion of thoracic and abdominal neuromeres into a synganglion. States 1 and 2 are present in the outgroup lower Diptera, and state 3 in the Xylophagomorpha, Stratiomyomorpha, Tabanomorpha and Cyclorrhapha. State 4 is a feature of all Eremoneura. State 5 is present in Cyclorrhapha only, and state 6, fusion into a synganglion, has evolved at least 4 times in the Eremoneura. Synapomorphies are provided for the Cyclorrhapha and Muscoidea, and a grouping of three basal brachyceran infraorders Xylophagomorpha, Stratiomyomorpha and Tabanomorpha. The patterns of fusion suggest that VNC architecture has evolved irreversibly, in accordance with Dollo's law.