Reflections on the centrality of power in medical sociology: an empirical test and theoretical elaboration

This paper explores the contemporary relevance of sociological theorisations centred on medical power, including the medical dominance and deprofessionalisation theses. To achieve this it examines two issues that have been tentatively linked to the relative decline of the power and autonomy of biomedicine - complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) and the Internet-informed patient. Drawing on these two different but interconnected social phenomena, this paper reflects on the potential limitations of power-based theorisations of the medical profession and its relationship to patients and other non-biomedically situated professional groups. It is argued that power-based conceptual schemas may not adequately reflect the non-linear and complex strategic adaptations that are occurring among professional groups.

Neurobiological alterations in the human alcoholic brain: effect of genotype

Long-term alcohol abuse by human subjects leads to selective brain damage that is restricted in extent and variable in severity. Within the cerebral cortex, neuronal loss is most marked in the superior frontal cortex and relatively mild in motor cortex. Cirrhotic alcoholics and subjects with alcohol-related Wernicke-Korsakoff syndrome show more severe and more extensive damage than do uncomplicated cases. Accumulating evidence suggests that the likelihood of developing alcohol dependency is associated with one or more genetic markers. In previous work we showed that GABAA receptor functionality, and the subunit isoform expression that underlies this, differed in region- and disease-specific ways between alcoholics and controls. By contrast, glutamate receptor (NMDA, KA, AMPA) differences were muted or absent. Here we asked if genotype differentiated the form, pharmacology, or expression of glutamate and GABA receptors in pathologically vulnerable and spared cortical regions, with a view to determining whether such subject factors might influence the severity of alcohol-induced brain damage. Cerebrocortical tissue was obtained at autopsy under informed, written consent from uncomplicated and alcoholic-cirrhotic Caucasian (predominantly Anglo-Celtic) cases, together with matched controls and cases with cirrhosis of non-alcoholic origin. All subjects had pathological confirmation of liver and brain diagnosis; none had been polydrug abusers. Samples were processed for synaptic membrane receptor binding, mRNA analysis by quantitative RT-PCR, and protein analysis by Western blot. Genotyping was performed by PCR methods, in the main using published primers. Several genetic markers differentiated between our alcoholic and control subjects, including the GABAA receptor 2 subunit (GABB2) gene ( 2 (3) 10.329, P 0.01), the dopamine D2 receptor B1 (DRD2B) allele ( 2 (3) 10.109, P 0.01) and a subset of the alcohol dehydrogenase-3 (ADH3) alleles ( 2 (2) 4.730, P 0.05). Although neither the type-2 glutamate transporter (EAAT2) nor the serotonin transporter (5HTT) genes were significantly associated with alcoholism, only EAAT2 heterozygotes showed a significant association between ADH3 genotype and alcoholism ( 2 (3) 7.475, P 0.05). Other interactions between genotypes were also observed. DRD2A, DRD2B, GABB2, EAAT2 and 5HTT genotypes did not divide alcoholic cases and controls on NMDA receptor parameters, although in combined subjects there was a significant DRD2B X Area Interaction with glutamateNMDA receptor efficacy (F(1,57) 4.67; P 0.05), measured as the extent of glutamate-enhanced MK801 binding. In contrast, there was a significant Case-group X ADH3 X Area Interaction with glutamateNMDA receptor efficacy (F(3,57) 2.97; P 0.05). When GABAA receptor subunit isoform expression was examined, significant Case-group X Genotype X Area X Isoform interactions were found for EAAT2 with subunit mRNA (F(1,37) 4.22; P0.05), for GABB2 with isoform protein (F(1,37) 5.69; P 0.05), and for DRD2B with isoform protein (F(2,34)5.69; P0.05). The results suggest that subjects’ genetic makeup may modulate the effectiveness of amino acid-mediated transmission in different cortical regions, and thereby influence neuronal vulnerability to excitotoxicity.

Microarray and proteomic analysis of the human alcoholic brain

The superior frontal cortex (SFC) is selectively damaged in chronic alcohol abuse, with localized neuronal loss and tissue atrophy. Regions such as motor cortex show little neuronal loss except in severe co-morbidity (liver cirrhosis or WKS). Altered gene expression was found in microarray comparisons of alcoholic and control SFC samples [1]. We used Western blots and proteomic analysis to identify the proteins that also show differential expression. Tissue was obtained at autopsy under informed, written consent from uncomplicated alcoholics and age- and sex-matched controls. Alcoholics had consumed 80 g ethanol/day chronically (often, 200 g/day for 20 y). Controls either abstained or were social drinkers ( 20 g/day). All subjects had pathological confirmation of liver and brain diagnosis; none had been polydrug abusers. Samples were homogenized in water and clarified by brief centrifugation (1000g, 3 min) before storage at –80°C. For proteomics the thawed suspensions were centrifuged (15000g, 50 min) to prepare soluble fractions. Aliquots were pooled from SFC samples from the 5 chronic alcoholics and 5 matched controls used in the previous microarray study [1]. 2-Dimensional electrophoresis was performed in triplicate using 18 cm format pH 4–7 and pH 6–11 immobilized pH gradients for firstdimension isoelectric focusing. Following second-dimension SDS-PAGE the proteins were fluorescently stained and the images collected by densitometry. 182 proteins differed by 2-fold between cases and controls. 141 showed lower expression in alcoholics, 33 higher, and 8 were new or had disappeared. To date 63 proteins have been identified using MALDI-MS and MS-MS. Western blots were performed on uncentrifuged individual samples from 76 subjects (controls, uncomplicated alcoholics and cirrhotic alcoholics). A common standard was run on every gel. After transfer, immunolabeling, and densitometry, the intensities of the unknown bands were compared to those of the standards. We focused on proteins from transcripts that showed clear differences in a series of microarray studies, classified into common sets including Regulators of G-protein Signaling and Myelin-associated proteins. The preponderantly lower level of differentially expressed proteins in alcoholics parallels the microarray mRNA analysis in the same samples. We found that mRNA and protein expression do not frequently correspond; this may help identify pathogenic processes acting at the level of transcription, translation, or post-translationally.

The use of complementary and alternative therapies by patients with cancer

The aim of this research was to assess the prevalence and predictors of complementary and alternative therapy (CAT) use among cancer patients in Australia. A total of 1492 cancer patients attending nine major public cancer treatment centers in New South Wales, Australia, were asked to complete the Supportive Care Needs Survey. Of the 1354 consenting patients, 888 (65%) returned a completed survey. This article reports the secondary analyses of the survey data, specifically focusing on CAT use. For all cancers, 17.1% of patients were using at least one CAT. The two main demographic characteristics of CAT users were gender and age, where females were more likely to use CAT than males and that CAT use declined as age increased. Time since diagnosis was identified as the only significant clinical predictor of CAT use, where CAT use increased with time until 5 years since diagnosis. Our research shows that herbal treatments and naturopathy are the most popular CAT used by cancer patients (constituting over 30% of all CAT use recorded). The use of CAT among cancer patients is a significant issue in cancer care, especially considering the potential interactions between CAT and conventional medicines. Given that many cancer patients may not be aware of potential risks associated with these interactions it is important that oncologists and others involved in cancer patient care are informed about CAT and its use amongst their patients.

Bimanual aiming and overt attention: one law for two hands

Reaching to interact with an object requires a compromise between the speed of the limb movement and the required end-point accuracy. The time it takes one hand to move to a target in a simple aiming task can be predicted reliably from Fitts' law, which states that movement time is a function of a combined measure of amplitude and accuracy constraints (the index of difficulty, ID). It has been assumed previously that Fitts' law is violated in bimanual aiming movements to targets of unequal ID. We present data from two experiments to show that this assumption is incorrect: if the attention demands of a bimanual aiming task are constant then the movements are well described by a Fitts' law relationship. Movement time therefore depends not only on ID but on other task conditions, which is a basic feature of Fitts' law. In a third experiment we show that eye movements are an important determinant of the attention demands in a bimanual aiming task. The results from the third experiment extend the findings of the first two experiments and show that bimanual aiming often relies on the strategic co-ordination of separate actions into a seamless behaviour. A number of the task specific strategies employed by the adult human nervous system were elucidated in the third experiment. The general strategic pattern observed in the hand trajectories was reflected by the pattern of eye movements recorded during the experiment. The results from all three experiments demonstrate that eye movements must be considered as an important constraint in bimanual aiming tasks.

Popper and his Commentators on the Discovery of Neptune: a close shave for the Law of Gravitation?

Knowledge of residual perturbations in the orbit of Uranus in the early 1840s did not lead to the refutation of Newton's law of gravitation but instead to the discovery of Neptune in 1846. Karl Popper asserts that this case is atypical of science and that the law of gravitation was at least prima facie falsified by these perturbations. I argue that these assertions are the product of a false, a priori methodological position I call, 'Weak Popperian Falsificationism' (WPF). Further, on the evidence the law was not prima facie false and was not generally considered so by astronomers at the time. Many of Popper's commentators (Kuhn, Lakatos, Feyerabend and others) presuppose WPF and their views on this case and its implications for scientific rationality and method suffer from this same defect.

Knowing your allies: Medical education and interprofessional exposure

Collaborative, team-based, interprofessional approaches to patient management are becoming increasingly recognized as beneficial to health outcomes. This project aimed to develop interprofessional skills among 134 third year medical students that were of clinical educational value to the students, and through activities that directly benefited the rural health professionals in their daily work. Placements were undertaken during a six week rural clinical attachment, mainly throughout South-West Queensland. Pre- and post-placement self-report questionnaires completed by both students and health professionals were used to evaluate the project. Results showed that over 80% of the health professional group reported the medical student placements were useful. Similarly, almost 80% of medical students reported positive changes in their attitude to other health professionals from the placement, and 91% indicated they had derived clinical educational benefit from their interprofessional activity. Despite difficulties due to poor communication between the various parties involved, the project proved successful in improving medical students' skills, knowledge and perceptions concerning interprofessional practice, through a placement and educational project which delivered practical benefits to rural health professionals and rural communities.

A shift from passive teaching at medical conferences to more interactive methods improves physician learning

Conferences that deliver interactive sessions designed to enhance physician participation, such as role play, small discussion groups, workshops, hands-on training, problem- or case-based learning and individualised training sessions, are effective for physician education.