Study of tRNA modifying enzymes and codon usage bias in cancer

Recent evidences indicate that tRNA modifications and tRNA modifying enzymes may play important roles in complex human diseases such as cancer, neurological disorders and mitochondrial-linked diseases. We postulate that expression deregulation of tRNA modifying enzymes affects the level of tRNA modifications and, consequently, their function and the translation efficiency of their tRNA corresponding codons. Due to the degeneracy of the genetic code, most amino acids are encoded by two to six synonymous codons. This degeneracy and the biased usage of synonymous codons cause alterations that can span from protein folding to enhanced translation efficiency of a select gene group. In this work, we focused on cancer and performed a meta-analysis study to compare microarray gene expression profiles, reported by previous studies and evaluate the codon usage of different types of cancer where tRNA modifying enzymes were found de-regulated. A total of 36 different tRNA modifying enzymes were found de-regulated in most cancer datasets analyzed. The codon usage analysis revealed a preference for codons ending in AU for the up-regulated genes, while the down-regulated genes show a preference for GC ending codons. Furthermore, a PCA biplot analysis showed this same tendency. We also analyzed the codon usage of the datasets where the CTU2 tRNA modifying enzyme was found deregulated as this enzyme affects the wobble position (position 34) of specific tRNAs. Our data points to a distinct codon usage pattern between up and downregulated genes in cancer, which might be caused by the deregulation of specific tRNA modifying enzymes. This codon usage bias may augment the transcription and translation efficiency of some genes that otherwise, in a normal situation, would be translated less efficiently.

Molecular reconstruction of a genetic code alteration

The genetic code establishes the rules that govern gene translation into proteins. It was established more than 3.5 billion years ago and it is one of the most conserved features of life. Despite this, several alterations to the standard genetic code have been discovered in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes, namely in the fungal CTG clade where a unique seryl transfer RNA (tRNACAG Ser) decodes leucine CUG codons as serine. This tRNACAG Ser appeared 272±25 million years ago through insertion of an adenosine in the middle position of the anticodon of a tRNACGA Ser gene, which changed its anticodon from 5´-CGA-3´ to 5´-CAG-3´. This most dramatic genetic event restructured the proteome of the CTG clade species, but it is not yet clear how and why such deleterious genetic event was selected and became fixed in those fungal genomes. In this study we have attempted to shed new light on the evolution of this fungal genetic code alteration by reconstructing its evolutionary pathway in vivo in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. For this, we have expressed wild type and mutant versions of the C. albicans tRNACGA Ser gene into S. cerevisiae and evaluated the impact of the mutant tRNACGA Ser on fitness, tRNA stability, translation efficiency and aminoacylation kinetics. Our data demonstrate that these mutants are expressed and misincorporate Ser at CUGs, but their expression is repressed through an unknown molecular mechanism. We further demonstrate, using in vivo forced evolution methodologies, that the tRNACAG Ser can be easily inactivated through natural mutations that prevent its recognition by the seryl-tRNA synthetase. The overall data show that repression of expression of the mistranslating tRNACAG Ser played a critical role on the evolution of CUG reassignment from Leu to Ser. In order to better understand the evolution of natural genetic code alterations, we have also engineered partial reassignment of various codons in yeast. The data confirmed that genetic code ambiguity affects fitness, induces protein aggregation, interferes with the cell cycle and results in nuclear and morphologic alterations, genome instability and gene expression deregulation. Interestingly, it also generates phenotypic variability and phenotypes that confer growth advantages in certain environmental conditions. This study provides strong evidence for direct and critical roles of the environment on the evolution of genetic code alterations.

Cellular responses to genome mistranslation

Low level protein synthesis errors can have profound effects on normal cell physiology and disease development, namely neurodegeneration, cancer and aging. The biology of errors introduced into proteins during mRNA translation, herein referred as mistranslation, is not yet fully understood. In order to shed new light into this biological phenomenon, we have engineered constitutive codon misreading in S. cerevisiae, using a mutant tRNA that misreads leucine CUG codons as serine, representing a 240 fold increase in mRNA translational error relative to typical physiological error (0.0001%). Our studies show that mistranslation induces autophagic activity, increases accumulation of insoluble proteins, production of reactive oxygen species, and morphological disruption of the mitochondrial network. Mistranslation also up-regulates the expression of the longevity gene PNC1, which is a regulator of Sir2p deacetylase activity. We show here that both PNC1 and SIR2 are involved in the regulation of autophagy induced by mistranslation, but not by starvation-induced autophagy. Mistranslation leads to P-body but not stress-granule assembly, down-regulates the expression of ribosomal protein genes and increases slightly the selective degradation of ribosomes (ribophagy). The study also indicates that yeast cells are much more resistant to mistranslation than expected and highlights the importance of autophagy in the cellular response to mistranslation. Morpho-functional alterations of the mitochondrial network are the most visible phenotype of mistranslation. Since most of the basic cellular processes are conserved between yeast and humans, this study reinforces the importance of yeast as a model system to study mistranslation and suggests that oxidative stress and accumulation of misfolded proteins arising from aberrant protein synthesis are important causes of the cellular degeneration observed in human diseases associated to mRNA mistranslation.

The role of environmental stress on protein synthesis fidelity

Estudos recentes estabelecem uma ligação entre erros na tradução do mRNA e cancro, envelhecimento e neurodegeneração. RNAs de transferência mutantes que introduzem aminoácidos em locais errados nas proteínas aumentam a produção de espécies reactivas de oxigénio e a expressão de genes que regulam autofagia, ribofagia, degradação de proteínas não-funcionais e protecção contra o stress oxidativo. Erros na tradução do mRNA estão portanto relacionados com stress proteotóxico. Sabe-se agora que o mecanismo de toxicidade do crómio está associado à diminuição da fidelidade de tradução e à agregação de proteínas com malformações que destabilizam a sua estrutura terciária. Desta forma, é possível que os efeitos do stress ambiental ao nível da degeneração celular possam estar relacionados com a alteração da integridade da maquinaria da tradução. Neste estudo procedeu-se a uma avaliação alargada do impacto do stress ambiental na fidelidade da síntese de proteínas, utilizando S. cerevisiae como um sistema modelo. Para isso recorreu-se a repórteres policistrónicos de luciferase que permitiram quantificar especificamente a supressão de codões de terminação e o erro na leitura do codão AUG em células exposta a concentações não letais de metais pesados, etanol, cafeína e H2O2. Os resultados sugerem que a maquinaria de tradução é na generalidade muito resistente ao stress ambiental, devido a uma conjugação de mecanismos de homeostase que muito eficientemente antagonizam o impacto negativo dos erros de tradução. A nossa abordagem quantitativa permitiu-nos a identificar genes regulados por uma resposta programada ao stress ambiental que são também essenciais para mitigar a ocorrência de erros de tradução, nomeadamente, HSP12, HSP104 e RPN4. A exposição prolongada ao stress ambiental conduz à saturação dos mecanismos de homeostase, contribuindo para a acumulação de proteínas contendo erros de tradução e diminuindo a disponibilidade de proteínas funcionais directamente envolvidas na manutenção da fidelidade de tradução e integridade celular. Ao contrário de outras Hsps, a Hsp12p adopta normalmente uma localização membranar em condições de stress, que pode modular a fluidez e estabilidade membranar, sugerindo que a membrana plasmática é um alvo preferencial da perda de fidelidade da tradução. Para melhor compreender as respostas celulares aos erros de tradução, células contendo deleções em genes codificadores das Hsps foram transformadas com tRNAs mutantes que introduzem alterações no proteoma. Os nossos resultados demonstram que para além da resposta geral ao stress, estes tRNAs induzem alterações a nível do metabolismo celular e um aumento de aminoacilação com Metionina em vários tRNAs, sugerindo um mecanismo de protecção contra espécies reactivas de oxigénio. Em conclusão, este estudo sugere um papel para os erros de tradução na gestão de recursos energéticos e na adaptação das células a ambientes desfavoráveis.

Phenotypic consequences of genome mistranslation in Candida albicans

Várias espécies do género Candida traduzem o codão CUG de leucine como serina. Em C. albicans este codão é traduzido pelo tRNACAG Ser de serina que é reconhecido por leucil- e seril-tRNA sintetases (LeuRS e SerRS), permitindo a incorporação de leucina ou serina em posições com CUG. Em condições padrão de crescimento os codões CUG é incorporam 3% de leucina e 97% de serina, no entanto estes valores são flexíveis uma vez que a incorporação de serina pode variar entre 0.6% e 5% em resposta a condições de stress. Estudos anteriores realizados in vivo em Escherichia coli sugeriram que a ambiguidade em codões CUG é regulada pela SerRS. De facto, o gene da SerRS de C. albicans tem um codão CUG na posição 197 (Ser197) cuja descodificação ambígua resulta na produção de duas isoformas de SerRS. A isoforma SerRS_Leu197 é mais ativa, apesar de menos estável, que a isoforma SerRS_Ser197, suportando a ideia da existência de um feedback loop negativo, envolvendo estas duas isoformas de SerRS, a enzima LeuRS e o tRNACAG Ser, que mantem os níveis de incorporação de leucina no codões CUG baixos. Nesta tese demonstramos que tal mecanismo não é operacional nas células de C. albicans. De facto, os níveis de incorporação de leucina em codões CUG flutuam drasticamente em resposta a alterações ambientais. Por exemplo, a incorporação de leucina pode chegar a níveis de 49.33% na presença de macrófagos e anfotericina B, mostrando a notória tolerância de C. albicans à ambiguidade. Para compreender a relevância biológica da ambiguidade do código genético em C. albicans construímos estirpes que incorporam serina em vários codões. Apesar da taxa crescimento ter sido negativamente afetada em condições padrão de crescimento, as estirpes construídas crescem favoravelmente em várias condições de stresse, sugerindo que a ambiguidade desempenha um papel importante na adaptação a novos nichos ecológicos. O transcriptoma das estirpes construídas de C. albicans e Saccharomyces. cerevisiae mostram que as leveduras respondem à ambiguidade dos codões de modo distinto. A ambiguidade induziu uma desregulação moderada da expressão génica de C. albicans, mas ativou uma resposta comum ao stresse em S. cerevisiae. O único processo celular que foi induzido na maioria das estirpes foi a oxidação redução. De salientar, que enriquecimento em elementos cis de fatores de transcrição que regulam a resposta à ambiguidade em ambas as leveduras foi distinta, sugerindo que ambas respondem ao stresse de modo diferente. Na globalidade, o nosso estudo aprofunda o conhecimento da elevada tolerância à ambiguidade de codões em C. albicans. Os resultados sugerem que este fungo usa a ambiguidade do codão CUG durante infeção, possivelmente para modular a sua interação com o hospedeiro e a resposta a drogas antifúngicas.

Characterization of proteotoxic stress in zebrafish

A fidelidade da síntese proteica é fundamental para a estabilidade do proteoma e para a homeostasia celular. Em condições fisiológicas normais as células têm uma taxa de erro basal associada e esta muitas vezes aumenta com o envelhecimento e doença. Problemas na síntese das proteínas estão associados a várias doenças humanas e aos processos de envelhecimento. De facto, a incorporação de erros nas proteínas devido a tRNAs carregados pelas aminoacil-tRNA sintetases com o amino ácido errado causa doenças neurodegenerativas em humanos e ratos. Ainda não é claro como é que estas doenças se desenvolvem e se são uma consequência directa da disrupção do proteoma ou se são o resultado da toxicidade produzida pela acúmulação de proteínas mal traduzidas ao nível do ribossoma. Para elucidar como é que as células eucarióticas lidam com proteínas aberrantes e agregados proteicos (stress proteotóxico) desenvolvemos uma estratégia para destabilizar o proteoma. Para isso estabelecemos um sistema de erros de tradução em embriões de peixe zebra que assenta em tRNAs mutantes capazes de incorporar erradamente serina nas proteínas. As proteínas produzidas neste sistema despoletam as vias de resposta ao stress, nomeadamente a via da ubiquitina-proteassoma (UPP – “ubiquitin protesome pathway”) e a via do retículo endoplasmático (UPR – “unfolded protein response”). O stress proteotóxico gerado pelos erros de tradução altera a expressão génica e perfis de expressão de miRNAs, o desenvolvimento embrionário e viabilidade, aumenta a produção de espécies reactivas de oxigénio (ROS), leva ainda à acumulação de agregados proteicos e à disfunção mitocondrial. As malformações embrionárias e fenótipos de viabilidade que observámos foram revertidos por antioxidantes, o que sugere que os ROS desempenham papéis importantes nos fenótipos degenerativos celulares induzidos pela produção de proteínas aberrantes e agregação proteica. Estabelecemos ainda uma linha de peixe zebra transgénica para o estudo do stress proteotóxico. Este trabalho mostra que a destabilização do proteoma em embriões de peixe zebra com tRNAs mutantes é uma boa metodologia para estudar a biologia do stress proteotóxico visto que permite a agregação controlada do proteoma, mimetizando os processos de agregação de proteínas que ocorrem naturalmente durante o envelhecimento e em doenças conformacionais humanas.

Molecular genomics of a genetic code alteration

The genetic code is not universal. Alterations to its standard form have been discovered in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes and demolished the dogma of an immutable code. For instance, several Candida species translate the standard leucine CUG codon as serine. In the case of the human pathogen Candida albicans, a serine tRNA (tRNACAGSer) incorporates in vivo 97% of serine and 3% of leucine in proteins at CUG sites. Such ambiguity is flexible and the level of leucine incorporation increases significantly in response to environmental stress. To elucidate the function of such ambiguity and clarify whether the identity of the CUG codon could be reverted from serine back to leucine, we have developed a forced evolution strategy to increase leucine incorporation at CUGs and a fluorescent reporter system to monitor such incorporation in vivo. Leucine misincorporation increased from 3% up to nearly 100%, reverting CUG identity from serine back to leucine. Growth assays showed that increasing leucine incorporation produced impressive arrays of phenotypes of high adaptive potential. In particular, strains with high levels of leucine misincorporation exhibited novel phenotypes and high level of tolerance to antifungals. Whole genome re-sequencing revealed that increasing levels of leucine incorporation were associated with accumulation of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and loss of heterozygozity (LOH) in the higher misincorporating strains. SNPs accumulated preferentially in genes involved in cell adhesion, filamentous growth and biofilm formation, indicating that C. albicans uses its natural CUG ambiguity to increase genetic diversity in pathogenesis and drug resistance related processes. The overall data provided evidence for unantecipated flexibility of the C. albicans genetic code and highlighted new roles of codon ambiguity on the evolution of genetic and phenotypic diversity.

Codon ambiguities as a mechanism to alter the genetic code in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Although the genetic code is generally viewed as immutable, alterations to its standard form occur in the three domains of life. A remarkable alteration to the standard genetic code occurs in many fungi of the Saccharomycotina CTG clade where the Leucine CUG codon has been reassigned to Serine by a novel transfer RNA (Ser-tRNACAG). The host laboratory made a major breakthrough by reversing this atypical genetic code alteration in the human pathogen Candida albicans using a combination of tRNA engineering, gene recombination and forced evolution. These results raised the hypothesis that synthetic codon ambiguities combined with experimental evolution may release codons from their frozen state. In this thesis we tested this hypothesis using S. cerevisiae as a model system. We generated ambiguity at specific codons in a two-step approach, involving deletion of tRNA genes followed by expression of non-cognate tRNAs that are able to compensate the deleted tRNA. Driven by the notion that rare codons are more susceptible to reassignment than those that are frequently used, we used two deletion strains where there is no cognate tRNA to decode the rare CUC-Leu codon and AGG-Arg codon. We exploited the vulnerability of the latter by engineering mutant tRNAs that misincorporate Ser at these sites. These recombinant strains were evolved over time using experimental evolution. Although there was a strong negative impact on the growth rate of strains expressing mutant tRNAs at high level, such expression at low level had little effect on cell fitness. We found that not only codon ambiguity, but also destabilization of the endogenous tRNA pool has a strong negative impact in growth rate. After evolution, strains expressing the mutant tRNA at high level recovered significantly in several growth parameters, showing that these strains adapt and exhibit higher tolerance to codon ambiguity. A fluorescent reporter system allowing the monitoring of Ser misincorporation showed that serine was indeed incorporated and possibly codon reassignment was achieved. Beside the overall negative consequences of codon ambiguity, we demonstrated that codons that tolerate the loss of their cognate tRNA can also tolerate high Ser misincorporation. This raises the hypothesis that these codons can be reassigned to standard and eventually to new amino acids for the production of proteins with novel properties, contributing to the field of synthetic biology and biotechnology.

Identification of molecules and pathways regulating mistranslation in Candida albicans

Candida albicans is the major fungal pathogen in humans, causing diseases ranging from mild skin infections to severe systemic infections in immunocompromised individuals. The pathogenic nature of this organism is mostly due to its capacity to proliferate in numerous body sites and to its ability to adapt to drastic changes in the environment. Candida albicans exhibit a unique translational system, decoding the leucine-CUG codon ambiguously as leucine (3% of codons) and serine (97%) using a hybrid serine tRNA (tRNACAGSer). This tRNACAGSer is aminoacylated by two aminoacyl tRNA synthetases (aaRSs): leucyl-tRNA synthetase (LeuRS) and seryl-tRNA synthetase (SerRS). Previous studies showed that exposure of C. albicans to macrophages, oxidative, pH stress and antifungals increases Leu misincorporation levels from 3% to 15%, suggesting that C. albicans has the ability to regulate mistranslation levels in response to host defenses, antifungals and environmental stresses. Therefore, the hypothesis tested in this work is that Leu and Ser misincorporation at CUG codons is dependent upon competition between the LeuRS and SerRS for the tRNACAGSer. To test this hypothesis, levels of the SerRS and LeuRS were indirectly quantified under different physiological conditions, using a fluorescent reporter system that measures the activity of the respective promoters. Results suggest that an increase in Leu misincorporation at CUG codons is associated with an increase in LeuRS expression, with levels of SerRS being maintained. In the second part of the work, the objective was to identify putative regulators of SerRS and LeuRS expression. To accomplish this goal, C. albicans strains from a transcription factor knock-out collection were transformed with the fluorescent reporter system and expression of both aaRSs was quantified. Alterations in the LeuRS/SerRS expression of mutant strains compared to wild type strain allowed the identification of 5 transcription factors as possible regulators of expression of LeuRS and SerRS: ASH1, HAP2, HAP3, RTG3 and STB5. Globally, this work provides the first step to elucidate the molecular mechanism of regulation of mistranslation in C. albicans.

Saccharomycotin transcriptomics by next-generation sequencing

The non-standard decoding of the CUG codon in Candida cylindracea raises a number of questions about the evolutionary process of this organism and other species Candida clade for which the codon is ambiguous. In order to find some answers we studied the transcriptome of C. cylindracea, comparing its behavior with that of Saccharomyces cerevisiae (standard decoder) and Candida albicans (ambiguous decoder). The transcriptome characterization was performed using RNA-seq. This approach has several advantages over microarrays and its application is booming. TopHat and Cufflinks were the software used to build the protocol that allowed for gene quantification. About 95% of the reads were mapped on the genome. 3693 genes were analyzed, of which 1338 had a non-standard start codon (TTG/CTG) and the percentage of expressed genes was 99.4%. Most genes have intermediate levels of expression, some have little or no expression and a minority is highly expressed. The distribution profile of the CUG between the three species is different, but it can be significantly associated to gene expression levels: genes with fewer CUGs are the most highly expressed. However, CUG content is not related to the conservation level: more and less conserved genes have, on average, an equal number of CUGs. The most conserved genes are the most expressed. The lipase genes corroborate the results obtained for most genes of C. cylindracea since they are very rich in CUGs and nothing conserved. The reduced amount of CUG codons that was observed in highly expressed genes may be due, possibly, to an insufficient number of tRNA genes to cope with more CUGs without compromising translational efficiency. From the enrichment analysis, it was confirmed that the most conserved genes are associated with basic functions such as translation, pathogenesis and metabolism. From this set, genes with more or less CUGs seem to have different functions. The key issues on the evolutionary phenomenon remain unclear. However, the results are consistent with previous observations and shows a variety of conclusions that in future analyzes should be taken into consideration, since it was the first time that such a study was conducted.