The effect of manufacture and assembly joining methods on stiffened panel performance

This paper describes the simulation of representative aircraft wing stiffened panels under axial compression loading, to determine the effects of varying the manufacturing shape and assembly joining methods on stiffened panel performance. T-stiffened and Z-stiffened panels are modelled in Abaqus simulating integral, co-cured and mechanically fastened joints. The panels are subject to an edge compressive displacement along the stiffener axis until failure and the ultimate failure load and buckling performance is assessed for each. Integral panels consistently offer the highest performance. Co-cured panels demonstrate reduced performance (3-5% reduction in ultimate load relative to integral) caused by localised cohesive failure and skin-stiffener separation. The mechanically fastened panels are consistently the weakest joint (19-25% reduction in ultimate load relative to integral) caused primarily by inter-rivet buckling between fasteners