Sporting Justice: An Arbitrator's Perspective

Drawing on my experience of a number of sports dispute resolution tribunals in the UK and Ireland (such as Sports Resolutions UK; Just Sport Ireland; the Football Association of Ireland’s Disciplinary Panel and the Gaelic Athletic Association’s Dispute Resolution Authority) I intend to use this paper to review the legal arguments typically made in sports-related arbitrations. These points of interest can be summarised as a series of three questions: the fairness question; the liability question; the penalty question.

In answer to the fairness question, the aim is to give a brief outline on best practice in establishing a "fair" sports disciplinary tribunal. The answer, I believe, is always twofold in nature: first, and to paraphrase Lord Steyn in R v Secretary of State For The Home Department, Ex Parte Daly [2001] UKHL 26 at [28] "in law, context is everything" – translated into the present matter, this means that in sports disciplinary cases, the more serious the charges against the individual (in terms of reputational damage, economic impact and/or length of sanction); the more tightly wrapped the procedural safeguards surrounding any subsequent disciplinary hearing must be. A fair disciplinary system will be discussed in the context of the principles laid down in Article 8 of the World Anti-Doping Code which, in effect, acts as sport’s Article 6 of the ECHR on a right to a fair trial.

Following on from the above, in the 60 or so sports arbitrations that I have heard, there are two further points of interest. First, the claim before the arbitral panel will often be framed in an argument that, for various reasons of substantive and procedural irregularity, the sanction imposed on the appellant should be quashed ("the liability"). Second, and in alternative, that the sanction imposed was wholly disproportionate ("the penalty").

The liability issue usually breaks down into two further questions. First, what is the nature of the legal duty upon a sports body in exercising its disciplinary remit? Second, to what extent does a de novo hearing on appeal cure any apparent defects in a hearing of first instance? The first issue often results in an arbitral panel debating the contra preferentum approach to the interpretation of a contested rule i.e., the sports body’s rules in question are so ambiguous that they should be interpreted in a manner to the detriment of the rule maker and in favour of the appellant. On the second matter, it now appears to be a general principle of sports law, administrative law and even human rights law that even if a violation of the principles of natural justice takes place at the first instance stage of a disciplinary process, they may be cured on de novo appeal. Authority for this approach can be found at the Court of Arbitration for Sport and in particular in CAS 2009/A/1920 FK Pobeda, Aleksandar Zabrcanec, Nikolce Zdraveski v UEFA at para 87.

The question on proportionality asks what, aside from precedent found within the decisions of the sports body in question, are the general legal principles against which a sanction by a sports disciplinary body can be benchmarked in order to ascertain whether it is disproportionate in length or even irrational in nature?

On the matter of (dis)proportionality of sanction, the debate is usually guided by the authority in Bradley v the Jockey Club [2004] EWHC 2164 (QB) and affirmed at [2005] EWCA Civ 1056. The Bradley principles on proportionality of sports-specific sanctions, recently cited with approval at the Court of Arbitration for Sport, will be examined in this presentation.

Finally, an interesting application of many of the above principles (and others such as the appropriate standard of proof in sports disciplinary procedures) can be made to recent match-fixing or corruption related hearings held by the British Horse Racing Authority, the integrity units of snooker and tennis, and at the Court of Arbitration for Sport.

Academic selection and Northern Ireland

An overview of research and public policy debate on academic selection in Northern Ireland. The chapter examines the outcomes of the major investigation of the effects of the selective system of secondary education published in 2000, including a consideration of comparative evidence collected in Scotland. The paper outlines the debate which followed the publication of the Burns Report and presents the current state of play in policy and practice.

A Pilot Study of Reciprocal Peer Tutoring in Irish Medium Schools

A pilot study to investigate the effects of mathematics peer tutoring in Irish medium primary schools was undertaken. Five schools and 90 students took part in the pilot. Materials and resources that had previously been shown to work in English medium Scottish schools were translated into Irish by CCEA. Irish medium teachers attended three professional development days. Teachers implemented the peer tutoring techniques during mathematics lessons during a period of 16 weeks. Changes in attainment were measures with an Irish translation of the Scottish Survey of Achievement Mathematics Test. Results were positive. Student attainment was significantly raised during the 16-week implementation period by over one standard deviation. This equated to one-year’s worth of mathematics development during this time period. Results must be treated with caution. No control group was used in the pilot study. However, results are very promising and indicate that reciprocal role peer tutoring may be a useful pedagogy in Irish medium education. Further work would be required to establish this definitively.

Social Risk of Public Spending Cuts in Scotland: Local Authority Experiences

This paper relates to work supported by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation which examines the way Scottish Local Authorities have approached budget cuts (Asenova, et. al., 2013). Starting with a discussion of notions of social risk, we discuss the heightened challenges faced by local authorities. We note that the literature on public sector innovation predict such pressures would cause local authorities to engage in short term decision making and adopt a static coping approach to risk mitigation which is likely to stifle innovation and obstruct the creation of more coherent and resilient localities. Although we find this to have happened in some areas, we discuss two cases where these challenges have promoted innovative and inclusive approaches to service re-design and delivery.

What Have We Learned...

Presentation on the outworkings of the selective system of secondary education in Northern Ireland and a commentary on themes emerging on the conference held to mark the 50th anniversary of comprehensive schooling in Scotland. The two main challenges identified were: (1) how to deal with the consequence that not all children arrive in school with the same experiences or support, that is, dealing with the consequences of social disadvantage; and (2) not all post-school outcomes are seen to have the same value, so post-compulsory schooling risks becoming a selective mechanism for entry to more desirable outcomes

Glucagon-like peptide-1 based therapies as a novel approach for chronic heart failure

Glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) is an endogenous peptide hormone whose metabolic effects have been exploited for glycaemic control in diabetes, but which also exerts important cardiovascular actions. We have recently reported that the GLP-1 mimetic, exendin-4, exerts clear benefits post-myocardial infarction via specific effects on extracellular matrix remodelling which is dysregulated in the diabetic heart (Robinson E et al, Basic Res Cardiol 2015; 110: 20), and have now shown similar cardioprotective actions in experimental diabetes, which are mediated via direct effects on infiltrating macrophages (Tate M et al, Basic Res Cardiol 2016; 111: 1). Taken together with the apparent complexity of GLP-1 signalling and disappointing results of recent cardiovascular trials, our work strongly suggests that selective targeting of GLP-1 may be required in order to realise therapeutic benefit for both diabetic and non-diabetic heart failure patients. This is particularly important given the epidemic increase in the incidence of diabetes which is associated with a markedly enhanced susceptibility to cardiovascular stress.

Chronic PEGylated obestatin treatment prevents the onset of high fat diet-induced hypertension and endothelial dysfunction in the absence of metabolic actions

Background: Obestatin is a gastrointestinal peptide with established metabolic actions and emerging vascular effects which involve activation of NO signalling. The aim of this study was to investigate effects of a recently-characterised stable analogue, PEGylated obestatin (PEG-OB), in the setting of diet-induced obesity which is associated with both metabolic and vascular dysfunction. Methods: Male Sprague Dawley rats (6 weeks; n=8) were maintained on standard (SD) or high fat (HF) diet (60% fat) for 8 weeks with once-daily injection of either PEG-OB (50nmol/kg/day) or saline from 2 weeks. Results: HF feeding for 8 weeks resulted in marked body weight gain which was not affected by chronic PEG-OB treatment (HF saline, 175.0±12.2; HF PEG-OB, 190.4±6.4g; P=NS). Similarly, blood glucose, as indicated by HbA1c (HF saline, 6.30±0.15; HF PEG-OB, 6.13±0.36%; P=NS) and insulin tolerance (HF saline, 105.2±52.5; HF PEG-OB, 90.3±45.4mmol/L.min; P=NS), were unaltered by PEG-OB. Despite the apparent lack of metabolic effects, chronic PEG-OB treatment markedly attenuated development of HF-induced hypertension (HF saline, 146.5±4.9mmHg; HF PEG-OB, 123.0±9.7mmHg; P<0.01), assessed by tail-cuff plethysmography. Furthermore, organ bath pharmacology in isolated aortic rings, indicated that HF diet-induced endothelial dysfunction was completely prevented by PEG-OB (acetylcholine, EC50: SD saline, 335±113; HF saline, 758±164; HF PEG-OB, 277±85nmol/L; P<0.05). However, contraction to phenylephrine and relaxation to the NO donor, sodium nitroprusside, were unaltered between groups. Conclusions: PEG-OB exerts beneficial effects on hypertension and endothelial function in diabetes independently of metabolic actions suggesting that obestatin signalling may represent a novel therapeutic target to reduce the risk of associated cardiovascular complications.

John Thompson: Seeing through China

In 1848, Karl Marx predicted that a flow of cheap commodities would be the heavy artillery which would batter down all Chinese walls and open up the country to the west (Marx, 1978, p. 477). The Scottish photographer John Thomson (1837-1921) was both chronicler of and participant in the early moments of this process. Thomson was a commercial photographer who first arrived in the Far East in 1862. He earned the moniker of 'China' in a decade-long stay during which he photographed what he considered to be the key aspects of its culture and landscape. In this body of work, Illustrations of China and its People (first published in 1874) is perhaps the most comprehensive. It explores, through two hundred photographs and accompanying texts, a series of phenomena from the macro-scale of landscape, infrastructure and industry to the smaller scales of streetscapes, domestic spaces, individual portraits, and other details of everyday life. Despite his own description of the volumes as encyclopedic, Illustrations is geographically quite limited. Thomson's explorations into the hinterland proceed up the country’s principal rivers from those coastal ports which had already been wrested into western hands during the Opium Wars (of the 1840s) and subsequently opened up to trade. This is perhaps one of the reasons why Illustrations has been described as an explicitly colonial text, a guide-book for the prospective settler whose content offered the strategic knowledge of land, culture and natural resources necessary if the territorial advantages of the coastal periphery were to extended to the interior (Jeffrey, 1981, p. 64). It can also be argued, however, that Thomson’s volume offered justification for a potential colonial presence. Faced with a civilization whose history was as sophisticated as the west, it depicts a culture that is static and moribund, its addiction to traditional values an impediment to progress. While this is perhaps most explicit in the texts of Illustrations of China, it can also be seen in the images whose uniform chemical rendering also serves to make an essentially diverse culture seem homogenous. Yet it is these images that distinguish Illustrations from previous attempts to collate China’s culture and landscape. Here, the mechanical precision of his camera captures a reality that often subverts the colonial narrative, confounding stereotypes as Thomson’s mass-produced images allow another China to emerge.

Neolithic and Bronze age migration to Ireland and establishment of the insular Atlantic genome

The Neolithic and Bronze Age transitions were profound cultural shifts catalyzed in parts of Europe by migrations, first of early farmers from the Near East and then Bronze Age herders from the Pontic Steppe. However, a decades-long, unresolved controversy is whether population change or cultural adoption occurred at the Atlantic edge, within the British Isles. We address this issue by using the first whole genome data from prehistoric Irish individuals. A Neolithic woman (3343–3020 cal BC) from a megalithic burial (10.3× coverage) possessed a genome of predominantly Near Eastern origin. She had some hunter–gatherer ancestry but belonged to a population of large effective size, suggesting a substantial influx of early farmers to the island. Three Bronze Age individuals from Rathlin Island (2026–1534 cal BC), including one high coverage (10.5×) genome, showed substantial Steppe genetic heritage indicating that the European population upheavals of the third millennium manifested all of the way from southern Siberia to the western ocean. This turnover invites the possibility of accompanying introduction of Indo-European, perhaps early Celtic, language. Irish Bronze Age haplotypic similarity is strongest within modern Irish, Scottish, and Welsh populations, and several important genetic variants that today show maximal or very high frequencies in Ireland appear at this horizon. These include those coding for lactase persistence, blue eye color, Y chromosome R1b haplotypes, and the hemochromatosis C282Y allele; to our knowledge, the first detection of a known Mendelian disease variant in prehistory. These findings together suggest the establishment of central attributes of the Irish genome 4,000 y ago.

Doxorubicin induces the cleavage of Poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase, a marker of programmed cell death (apoptosis) in mouse cardiomyocytes

Cancer is one of the leading causes of death in the world. Despite this, a growing number of people are surviving the disease due to medical advancements and the development of numerous new therapies. Doxorubicin, a chemotherapeutic agent, is a widely-used and successful first-line anti-tumour treatment. However, the established toxic and deleterious effects of the drug on the cardiovascular system confer increased risk of congestive heart failure, thereby necessitating the use of reduced doxorubicin doses. In order to investigate how these events are initiated, mouse cardiomyocytes (HL-1) were treated in vitro with varying concentrations of doxorubicin (0.5-4.0 µmol/L). Following treatment (24h), a marked level of cell death was observed in comparison to untreated cardiomyocytes; the level of death appeared to correlate with the concentration of the drug used. Western blotting revealed the cleavage of full length Poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP) into 89 and 24kDa fragments, a process which is instrumental in triggering programmed cell death/apoptosis. Importantly, results suggested that this event may be independent of caspase 3 cleavage and thus activation. A number of previous studies have reported a functional role for both Mitofusin-2 (Mfn2) and NADPH oxidase 2 (Nox2) in the cardiotoxic response. Given that PARP cleavage is a validated indicator of cellular apoptosis, these results clearly indicate that this marker could be used in future studies when determining if depletion of the above proteins would cause a reduction in or eradicate the pro-apoptotic action of this agent on cardiomyocytes. Such investigations may lead to significant developments in ensuring that doxorubicin can achieve its full therapeutic anti-tumour potential without causing the subsequent deleterious effects on the cardiovascular system.

INFLUENCE OF NOX4 NADPH OXIDASE ON GENERATION AND ANGIOGENIC FUNCTION OF INDUCED PLURIPOTENT STEM CELL-DERIVED ENDOTHELIAL CELLS

Human induced pluripotent stem (iPS) cell-derived endothelial cells (ECs) hold clear potential for therapeutic angiogenesis as a novel strategy for ischaemic disease. Recently, we have developed a novel method for direct reprogramming of partial iPS (PiPS) cells, which unlike iPS cells, are generated before pluripotency so do not form tumours, and may be differentiated into ECs with characteristic morphology and pro-angiogenic actions. Our previous work showed that PiPS-derived ECs are capable of forming vascular-like tubes both in vitro and in vivo and promoting re-endothelialisation of ischemic tissue, with greater effectiveness versus mature ECs.

Interestingly, our preliminary data demonstrate that Nox NADPH oxidases, which are reported to influence stem cell function, are progressively induced during PiPs/PiPS-EC differentiation and in response to hypoxia, with Nox4 demonstrating highest expression. As this isoform is an established regulator of angiogenesis, we hypothesize that Nox4 plays a key role in modulating PiPS-EC generation and angiogenic function.

The aim of this project is therefore to investigate: (1) the specific role of Nox4 in direct reprogramming of PiPS cells and differentiation to PiPS-ECs; (2) whether genetic manipulation of Nox4 influences in vitro function of PiPs-ECs and their ability to promote in vivo angiogenesis. This will be achieved by employing established in vitro functional assays and an experimental model of hindlimb ischaemia with assessment of relevant end-points. Identification of a key role for Nox4 in regulating PiPS-EC generation/function may inform selective targeting of this isoform to enhance the efficiency of PiPS-EC differentiation and their capacity to treat ischemic disease.

INVESTIGATING THE ROLE OF NOX NADPH OXIDASE SIGNALLING IN CELL MIGRATION AND ANGIOGENESIS OF ENDOTHELIAL COLONY-FORMING CELLS

Introduction. Endothelial colony-forming cells (ECFCs) hold great cytotherapeutic potential for ischaemic disease. Emerging evidence supports a key role for NADPH oxidases in underlying angiogenic processes of these and other endothelial cells. Aims. To study the influence of Nox NADPH oxidases on the pro-angiogenic function of ECFCs. Methods. Human ECFCs isolated from umbilical cord blood were treated with pro-oxidant PMA and assessed in vitro, both under basal conditions and after siRNA knockdown of Nox4, a key endothelial NADPH oxidase isoform, alongside primary mature human aortic endothelial cells (HAoECs) for comparison, using an established scratch-wound assay as the functional end-point. Results. PMA (500nM for 8h) increased cell migration (control 18.6±2.8, PMA 32.7±6.6% wound closure; n=6, P<0.05) in a superoxide-dependent manner, as indicated by attenuation of this effect in the presence of PEG-SOD. Although HAoEC migration in response to PMA also tended to increase, this did not reach statistical significance. Notably, cell migration at 16h was reduced by Nox4 knockdown in ECFCs (control siRNA 53.4±3.5, Nox4 siRNA 35.1±4.9% closure; n=3, P<0.05), but not in HAoECs, whilst the pro-migratory effect of PMA in ECFCs was potentiated after Nox4 knockdown (control siRNA 53.4±3.5, +PMA 61.5±3.2% closure; n=3, P=NS; Nox4 siRNA 35.1±4.9, +PMA 53.0±4.9% closure; n=3, P<0.05). Conclusion. ECFC migration is enhanced by low concentrations of superoxide, to a greater extent compared to mature endothelial cells, and appears to be at least partly dependent upon NADPH oxidase, including a specific role for Nox4. Although, the precise contribution of endothelial Nox NADPH oxidases isoforms remains to be determined, it is clear that these findings may have significant implications for potential ECFC-based therapies for ischaemic disease, which is associated with an oxidative microenvironment.

EFFECTS OF ENVIRONMENTAL ANTIOXIDANTS ON PRO-ANGIOGENIC ROS SIGNALLING IN ENDOTHELIAL COLONY FORMING CELLS IN VITRO

Introduction. Endothelial colony-forming cells (ECFCs) hold great cytotherapeutic potential for ischaemic disease. Whilst increasing evidence supports a key role for reactive oxygen species (ROS), specifically those derived from Nox NADPH oxidases, in the underlying angiogenic processes of these and other endothelial cells, such studies investigating the role of redox signalling may be hampered by the standard inclusion of antioxidant agents in endothelial cell media, such as phenol red. Aims. To study the effects of antioxidants present in culture media on pro-angiogenic function of ECFCs in vitro. Methods. Human ECFCs isolated from umbilical cord blood were maintained in media with and without antioxidant components (EGM2 and phenol red-free DMEM, respectively) prior to treatment with pro-oxidant PMA and assessment of their in vitro migratory capacity using a scratch-wound assay to measure pro-angiogenic activity. Results. Our previous work in our group indicated that PMA (500nM) increased ECFC migration in a both a superoxide and NADPH oxidase-dependent manner (control 18.6±2.8, PMA 32.7±6.6% wound closure; n=6, P<0.05), as indicated by attenuation with PEG-SOD and VAS2870. However, inconsistencies in the data generated under varying experimental conditions led us to hypothesise that antioxidant agents in the standard ECFC media may be influencing these effects. Indeed, a direct comparison of cell migration between ECFCs incubated in EGM2 DMEM demonstrated a clear trend towards higher migration in the latter (EGM2 9.0±4.5, DMEM 22.7±6.4%; n=3, P=NS). Similar to our previous EGM2 studies, cell migration was potentiated by PMA (control 11.6±1.6, PMA 25.1±2.8%; n=3, P<0.05), but at a lower dose (100nM), which is consistent with a reduction in media antioxidants. Notably, this response was attenuated by VAS2870 (PMA 37.6±7.3, PMA+VAS2870 10.3±2.9%; n=6, P<0.05), underlining a likely role for Nox NADPH oxidases. Conclusion. Taken together, these data indicate that ECFC migration is sensitive to different endothelial cell growth media, which appears to be dependent upon their antioxidant content. Although further experiments, such as quantification of cellular superoxide generation by dihydroethidium fluorescence may be required to confirm a specific role for antioxidants, such blunting of ROS signalling in vitro is clearly an important consideration which may significantly impact upon data interpretation.

Validating the use of intrinsic markers in body feathers to identify inter‑individual differences in non‑breeding areas of northern fulmars

Many wildlife studies use chemical analyses to explore spatio-temporal variation in diet, migratory patterns and contaminant exposure. Intrinsic markers are particularly valuable for studying non-breeding marine predators, when direct methods of investigation are rarely feasible. However, any inferences regarding foraging ecology are dependent upon the time scale over which tissues such as feathers are formed. In this study, we validate the use of body feathers for studying non-breeding foraging patterns in a pelagic seabird, the northern fulmar. Analysis of carcasses of successfully breeding adult fulmars indicated that body feathers moulted between September and March, whereas analyses of carcasses and activity patterns suggested that wing feather and tail feather moult occurred during more restricted periods (September to October and September to January, respectively). By randomly sampling relevant body feathers, average values for individual birds were shown to be consistent. We also integrated chemical analyses of body feather with geolocation tracking data to demonstrate that analyses of δ13C and δ15N values successfully assigned 88 % of birds to one of two broad wintering regions used by breeding adult fulmars from a Scottish study colony. These data provide strong support for the use of body feathers as a tool for exploring non-breeding foraging patterns and diet in wide-ranging, pelagic seabirds.

Alpha-2 agonists for sedation of mechanically ventilated adults in intensive care units: a systematic review

BACKGROUND: Care of critically ill patients in intensive care units (ICUs) often requires potentially invasive or uncomfortable procedures, such as mechanical ventilation (MV). Sedation can alleviate pain and discomfort, provide protection from stressful or harmful events, prevent anxiety and promote sleep. Various sedative agents are available for use in ICUs. In the UK, the most commonly used sedatives are propofol (Diprivan(®), AstraZeneca), benzodiazepines [e.g. midazolam (Hypnovel(®), Roche) and lorazepam (Ativan(®), Pfizer)] and alpha-2 adrenergic receptor agonists [e.g. dexmedetomidine (Dexdor(®), Orion Corporation) and clonidine (Catapres(®), Boehringer Ingelheim)]. Sedative agents vary in onset/duration of effects and in their side effects. The pattern of sedation of alpha-2 agonists is quite different from that of other sedatives in that patients can be aroused readily and their cognitive performance on psychometric tests is usually preserved. Moreover, respiratory depression is less frequent after alpha-2 agonists than after other sedative agents.

OBJECTIVES: To conduct a systematic review to evaluate the comparative effects of alpha-2 agonists (dexmedetomidine and clonidine) and propofol or benzodiazepines (midazolam and lorazepam) in mechanically ventilated adults admitted to ICUs.

DATA SOURCES: We searched major electronic databases (e.g. MEDLINE without revisions, MEDLINE In-Process & Other Non-Indexed Citations, EMBASE and Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials) from 1999 to 2014.

METHODS: Evidence was considered from randomised controlled trials (RCTs) comparing dexmedetomidine with clonidine or dexmedetomidine or clonidine with propofol or benzodiazepines such as midazolam, lorazepam and diazepam (Diazemuls(®), Actavis UK Limited). Primary outcomes included mortality, duration of MV, length of ICU stay and adverse events. One reviewer extracted data and assessed the risk of bias of included trials. A second reviewer cross-checked all the data extracted. Random-effects meta-analyses were used for data synthesis.

RESULTS: Eighteen RCTs (2489 adult patients) were included. One trial at unclear risk of bias compared dexmedetomidine with clonidine and found that target sedation was achieved in a higher number of patients treated with dexmedetomidine with lesser need for additional sedation. The remaining 17 trials compared dexmedetomidine with propofol or benzodiazepines (midazolam or lorazepam). Trials varied considerably with regard to clinical population, type of comparators, dose of sedative agents, outcome measures and length of follow-up. Overall, risk of bias was generally high or unclear. In particular, few trials blinded outcome assessors. Compared with propofol or benzodiazepines (midazolam or lorazepam), dexmedetomidine had no significant effects on mortality [risk ratio (RR) 1.03, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.85 to 1.24, I (2) = 0%; p = 0.78]. Length of ICU stay (mean difference -1.26 days, 95% CI -1.96 to -0.55 days, I (2) = 31%; p = 0.0004) and time to extubation (mean difference -1.85 days, 95% CI -2.61 to -1.09 days, I (2) = 0%; p < 0.00001) were significantly shorter among patients who received dexmedetomidine. No difference in time to target sedation range was observed between sedative interventions (I (2) = 0%; p = 0.14). Dexmedetomidine was associated with a higher risk of bradycardia (RR 1.88, 95% CI 1.28 to 2.77, I (2) = 46%; p = 0.001).

LIMITATIONS: Trials varied considerably with regard to participants, type of comparators, dose of sedative agents, outcome measures and length of follow-up. Overall, risk of bias was generally high or unclear. In particular, few trials blinded assessors.

CONCLUSIONS: Evidence on the use of clonidine in ICUs is very limited. Dexmedetomidine may be effective in reducing ICU length of stay and time to extubation in critically ill ICU patients. Risk of bradycardia but not of overall mortality is higher among patients treated with dexmedetomidine. Well-designed RCTs are needed to assess the use of clonidine in ICUs and identify subgroups of patients that are more likely to benefit from the use of dexmedetomidine.

STUDY REGISTRATION: This study is registered as PROSPERO CRD42014014101.

FUNDING: The National Institute for Health Research Health Technology Assessment programme. The Health Services Research Unit is core funded by the Chief Scientist Office of the Scottish Government Health and Social Care Directorates.