Narrative Deliberation? On Storytelling as a Necessary Component of Public Deliberation

This paper deals with the place of narrative, that is, storytelling, in public deliberation. A distinction is made between weak and strong conceptions of narrative. According to the weak one, storytelling is but one rhetorical device among others with which social actors produce and convey meaning. In contrast, the strong conception holds that narrative is necessary to communicate, and argue, about topics such as the human experience of time, collective identities and the moral and ethical validity of values. The upshot of this idea is that storytelling should be a necessary component of any ideal of public deliberation. Contrary to recent work by deliberative theorists, who tend to adopt the weak conception of narrative, the author argues for embracing the strong one. The main contention of this article is that stories not only have a legitimate place in deliberation, but are even necessary to formulate certain arguments in the fi rst place; for instance, arguments drawing on historical experience. This claim, namely that narrative is constitutive of certain arguments, in the sense that, without it, said reasons cannot be articulated, is illustrated by deliberative theory’s own narrative underpinnings. Finally, certain possible objections against the strong conception of narrative are dispelled.

Rightful Resistance in the Colombian conflict. A theoretical reflection based on a Peace Community

This article considers the opportunities of civilians to peacefully resist violent conflicts or civil wars. The argument developed here is based on a field-based research on the peace community San José de Apartadó in Colombia. The analytical and theoretical framework, which delimits the use of the term ‘resistance’ in this article, builds on the conceptual considerations of Hollander and Einwohner (2004) and on the theoretical concept of ‘rightful resistance’ developed by O’Brien (1996). Beginning with a conflict-analytical classification of the case study, we will describe the long-term socio-historical processes and the organizational experiences of the civilian population, which favoured the emergence of this resistance initiative. The analytical approach to the dimensions and aims of the resistance of this peace community leads to the differentiation of O`Brian’s concept of ‘rightful resistance’.

El Evento ‘Museo’: Aportes sobre el campo teórico de la Museología (1955-2015)

Desde hace mucho tiempo hemos defendido la idea de que Museo no es solo una institución, sino que debe ser entendido también como un proceso, fenómeno, flujo o acontecimiento. En el escenario contemporáneo del conocimiento, es fundamental que se pueda percibir al Museo más allá de su forma institucionalizada: solamente así será posible comprender con alguna precisión y profundidad sus nuevas formas de presentación y las relaciones que se establecen entre este fenómeno y las nuevas representaciones sociales. Este artículo presenta algunas reflexiones sobre el tema a partir del análisis de autores del campo museal, haciendo especial énfasis en los argumentos de base teórico-filosófica, o de base comunicacional, a partir de los cuales la Museología se ha estructurado como campo disciplinario.