Planning across differences: collaborative planning processes for the California Central Valley's future

This dissertation examines the intersections between difference, participation, and planning processes. Rooted in scholarly conversations about deliberative democracy, collaborative planning, and nonprofit organizations in civil society, this research considers how planning practitioners can better plan across difference. Through case study research, this dissertation examines a collaborative planning process conducted by a nonprofit organization. Unlike more conventional participatory planning processes, the organization utilized scenario planning. Exercising their position in civil society, participation in the process was not open to all community members and the organization carefully selected a diverse set of participants. Findings from this research project indicate that this process, by moving away from a strict definition of rational discourse, focusing on multiple futures as opposed to a single, utopian future, and deliberately bringing together a broad cross-section of community members allowed for participants to speak freely and learn from one another’s perspectives and experiences. Experiences of process participants also demonstrate the degree to which cultural backgrounds shape participation in and expectations of planning processes. While there remains no clear answer in how to represent and respond to cultural differences in planning processes, the experiences of the organization, program staff, and community participants help scholars and practitioners move closer to planning across differences.

Wastewater treatment by novel hybrid biological – ion exchange processes

This study presents two novel methods for treating important environmental contaminants from two different wastewater streams. One process utilizes the kinetic advantages and reliability of ion exchanging clinoptilolite in combination with biological treatment to remove ammonium from municipal sewage. A second process, HAMBgR (Hybrid Adsorption Membrane Biological Reactor), combines both ion exchange resin and bacteria into a single reactor to treat perchlorate contaminated waters. Combining physicochemical adsorptive treatment with biological treatment can provide synergistic benefits to the overall removal processes. Ion exchange removal solves some of the common operational reliability limitations of biological treatment, like slow response to environmental changes and leaching. Biological activity can in turn help reduce the economic and environmental challenges of ion exchange processes, like regenerant cost and brine disposal. The second section of this study presents continuous flow column experiments, used to demonstrate the ability of clinoptilolite to remove wastewater ammonium, as well as the effectiveness of salt regeneration using highly concentrated sea salt solutions. The working capacity of clinoptilolite more than doubled over the first few loading cycles, while regeneration recovered more than 98% of ammonium. Using the regenerant brine for subsequent halotolerant algae growth allowed for its repeated use, which could lead to cost savings and production of valuable algal biomass. The algae were able to uptake all ammonium in solution, and the brine was able to be used again with no loss in regeneration efficiency. This process has significant advantages over conventional biological nitrification; shorter retention times, wider range of operational conditions, and higher quality effluent free of nitrate. Also, since the clinoptilolite is continually regenerated and the regenerant is rejuvenated by algae, overall input costs are expected to be low. The third section of this study introduces the HAMBgR process for the elimination of perchlorate and presents batch isotherm experiments and pilot reactor tests. Results showed that a variety of ion-exchange resins can be effectively and repeatedly regenerated biologically, and maintain an acceptable working capacity. The presence of an adsorbent in the HAMBgR process improved bioreactor performance during operational fluctuations by providing a physicochemical backup to the biological process. Pilot reactor tests showed that the HAMBgR process reduced effluent perchlorate spikes by up to 97% in comparison to a conventional membrane bio-reactor (MBR) that was subject to sudden changes in influent conditions. Also, the HAMBgR process stimulated biological activity and lead to higher biomass concentrations during increased contaminant loading conditions. Conventional MBR systems can be converted into HAMBgR’s at a low cost, easily justifiable by the realized benefits. The concepts employed in the HAMBgR process can be adapted to treat other target contaminants, not just perchlorate.

Single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer study of SNARE-mediated membrane fusion

This is a comprehensive study of protein-mediated membrane fusion through single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (smFRET). Membrane fusion is one of the important cellular processes by which two initially distinct lipid bilayers merge their hydrophobic cores, resulting in one interconnected structure. For example, exocytosis, fertilization of an egg by a sperm and communication between neurons are a few among many processes that rely on some form of fusion. Proteins called soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptor (SNARE) play a central role in fusion processes which is also regulated by many accessory proteins, such as synaptotagmin, complexin and Munc18. By a new lipid mixing method at the single-vesicle level, we are able to accurately detect different stages of SNARE-mediated membrane fusion including docking, hemi and full fusion via FRET value of single donor/acceptor vesicle pair. Through this single-vesicle lipid mixing assay, we discovered the vesicle aggregation induced by C2AB/Ca2+, the dual function of complexin, and the fusion promotion role of Munc18/SNARE-core binding mode. While this new method provides the information regarding the extent of the ensemble lipid mixing, the fusion pore opening between two vesicular cavities and the interaction between proteins cannot be detected. In order to overcome these limitations, we then developed a single-vesicle content mixing method to reveal the key factor of pore expansion by detecting the FRET change of dual-labeled DNA probes encapsulated in vesicles. Through our single-vesicle content mixing assay, we found the fusion pore expansion role of yeast SNAREs as well as neuronal SNAREs plus synaptotagmin 1.