Brownian dynamics simulations of protein folding: Access to milliseconds time scale and beyond

Protein folding occurs on a time scale ranging from milliseconds to minutes for a majority of proteins. Computer simulation of protein folding, from a random configuration to the native structure, is nontrivial owing to the large disparity between the simulation and folding time scales. As an effort to overcome this limitation, simple models with idealized protein subdomains, e.g., the diffusion–collision model of Karplus and Weaver, have gained some popularity. We present here new results for the folding of a four-helix bundle within the framework of the diffusion–collision model. Even with such simplifying assumptions, a direct application of standard Brownian dynamics methods would consume 10,000 processor-years on current supercomputers. We circumvent this difficulty by invoking a special Brownian dynamics simulation. The method features the calculation of the mean passage time of an event from the flux overpopulation method and the sampling of events that lead to productive collisions even if their probability is extremely small (because of large free-energy barriers that separate them from the higher probability events). Using these developments, we demonstrate that a coarse-grained model of the four-helix bundle can be simulated in several days on current supercomputers. Furthermore, such simulations yield folding times that are in the range of time scales observed in experiments.

Definition of amide protection factors for early kinetic intermediates in protein folding

Hydrogen–deuterium exchange experiments have been used previously to investigate the structures of well defined states of a given protein. These include the native state, the unfolded state, and any intermediates that can be stably populated at equilibrium. More recently, the hydrogen–deuterium exchange technique has been applied in kinetic labeling experiments to probe the structures of transiently formed intermediates on the kinetic folding pathway of a given protein. From these equilibrium and nonequilibrium studies, protection factors are usually obtained. These protection factors are defined as the ratio of the rate of exchange of a given backbone amide when it is in a fully solvent-exposed state (usually obtained from model peptides) to the rate of exchange of that amide in some state of the protein or in some intermediate on the folding pathway of the protein. This definition is straightforward for the case of equilibrium studies; however, it is less clear-cut for the case of transient kinetic intermediates. To clarify the concept for the case of burst-phase intermediates, we have introduced and mathematically defined two different types of protection factors: one is Pstruc, which is more related to the structure of the intermediate, and the other is Papp, which is more related to the stability of the intermediate. Kinetic hydrogen–deuterium exchange data from disulfide-intact ribonuclease A and from cytochrome c are discussed to explain the use and implications of these two definitions.

Antibody catalysis of peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerization in the folding of RNase T1

An antibody generated to an α-keto amide containing hapten 1 catalyzes the cis-trans isomerization of peptidyl-prolyl amide bonds in peptides and in the protein RNase T1. The antibody-catalyzed peptide isomerization reaction showed saturation kinetics for the cis-substrate, Suc-Ala-Ala-Pro-Phe-pNA, with a kcat/Km value of 883 s−1⋅M−1; the reaction was inhibited by the hapten analog 13 (Ki = 3.0 ± 0.4 μM). Refolding of denatured RNase T1 to its native conformation also was catalyzed by the antibody, with the antibody-catalyzed folding reaction inhibitable both by the hapten 1 and hapten analog 13. These results demonstrate that antibodies can catalyze conformational changes in protein structure, a transformation involved in many cellular processes.

GroEL-GroES-mediated protein folding requires an intact central cavity

The chaperonin GroEL is an oligomeric double ring structure that, together with the cochaperonin GroES, assists protein folding. Biochemical analyses indicate that folding occurs in a cis ternary complex in which substrate is sequestered within the GroEL central cavity underneath GroES. Recently, however, studies of GroEL “minichaperones” containing only the apical substrate binding subdomain have questioned the functional importance of substrate encapsulation within GroEL-GroES complexes. Minichaperones were reported to assist folding despite the fact that they are monomeric and therefore cannot form a central cavity. Here we compare directly the folding activity of minichaperones with that of the full GroEL-GroES system. In agreement with earlier studies, minichaperones assist folding of some proteins. However, this effect is observed only under conditions where substantial spontaneous folding is also observed and is indistinguishable from that resulting from addition of the nonchaperone protein α-casein. By contrast, the full GroE system efficiently promotes folding of several substrates under conditions where essentially no spontaneous folding is observed. These data argue that the full GroEL folding activity requires the intact GroEL-GroES complex, and in light of previous studies, underscore the importance of substrate encapsulation for providing a folding environment distinct from the bulk solution.

An optimal Mg2+ concentration for kinetic folding of the Tetrahymena ribozyme

Divalent metal ions, such as Mg2+, are generally required for tertiary structure formation in RNA. Although the role of Mg2+ binding in RNA-folding equilibria has been studied extensively, little is known about the role of Mg2+ in RNA-folding kinetics. In this paper, we explore the effect of Mg2+ on the rate-limiting step in the kinetic folding pathway of the Tetrahymena ribozyme. Analysis of these data reveals the presence of a Mg2+-stabilized kinetic trap that slows folding at higher Mg2+ concentrations. Thus, the Tetrahymena ribozyme folds with an optimal rate at 2 mM Mg2+, just above the concentration required for stable structure formation. These results suggest that thermodynamic and kinetic folding of RNA are cooptimized at a Mg2+ concentration that is sufficient to stabilize the folded form but low enough to avoid kinetic traps and misfolding.

Folding protein models with a simple hydrophobic energy function: The fundamental importance of monomer inside/outside segregation

The present study explores a “hydrophobic” energy function for folding simulations of the protein lattice model. The contribution of each monomer to conformational energy is the product of its “hydrophobicity” and the number of contacts it makes, i.e., E(h⃗, c⃗) = −Σi=1N cihi = −(h⃗.c⃗) is the negative scalar product between two vectors in N-dimensional cartesian space: h⃗ = (h1, … , hN), which represents monomer hydrophobicities and is sequence-dependent; and c⃗ = (c1, … , cN), which represents the number of contacts made by each monomer and is conformation-dependent. A simple theoretical analysis shows that restrictions are imposed concomitantly on both sequences and native structures if the stability criterion for protein-like behavior is to be satisfied. Given a conformation with vector c⃗, the best sequence is a vector h⃗ on the direction upon which the projection of c⃗ − c̄⃗ is maximal, where c̄⃗ is the diagonal vector with components equal to c̄, the average number of contacts per monomer in the unfolded state. Best native conformations are suggested to be not maximally compact, as assumed in many studies, but the ones with largest variance of contacts among its monomers, i.e., with monomers tending to occupy completely buried or completely exposed positions. This inside/outside segregation is reflected on an apolar/polar distribution on the corresponding sequence. Monte Carlo simulations in two dimensions corroborate this general scheme. Sequences targeted to conformations with large contact variances folded cooperatively with thermodynamics of a two-state transition. Sequences targeted to maximally compact conformations, which have lower contact variance, were either found to have degenerate ground state or to fold with much lower cooperativity.

Ultrafast signals in protein folding and the polypeptide contracted state

To test the significance of ultrafast protein folding signals (≪1 msec), we studied cytochrome c (Cyt c) and two Cyt c fragments with major C-terminal segments deleted. The fragments remain unfolded under all conditions and so could be used to define the unfolded baselines for protein fluorescence and circular dichroism (CD) as a function of denaturant concentration. When diluted from high to low denaturant in kinetic folding experiments, the fragments readjust to their new baseline values in a “burst phase” within the mixing dead time. The fragment burst phase reflects a contraction of the polypeptide from a more extended unfolded condition at high denaturant to a more contracted unfolded condition in the poorer, low denaturant solvent. Holo Cyt c exhibits fluorescence and CD burst phase signals that are essentially identical to the fragment signals over the whole range of final denaturant concentrations, evidently reflecting the same solvent-dependent, relatively nonspecific contraction and not the formation of a specific folding intermediate. The significance of fast folding signals in Cyt c and other proteins is discussed in relation to the hypothesis of an initial rate-limiting search-nucleation-collapse step in protein folding [Sosnick, T. R., Mayne, L. & Englander, S. W. (1996) Proteins Struct. Funct. Genet. 24, 413–426].

Linking topography of its potential surface with the dynamics of folding of a protein model

The “3-color, 46-bead” model of a folding polypeptide is the vehicle for adapting to proteins a mode of analysis used heretofore for atomic clusters, to relate the topography of the potential surface to the dynamics that lead to formation of selected structures. The analysis is based on sequences of stationary points—successive minima, joined by saddles—that rise monotonically in energy from basin bottoms. Like structure-seeking clusters, the potential surface of the model studied here is staircase-like, rather than sawtooth-like, with highly collective motions required for passage from one minimum to the next. The surface has several deep basins whose minima correspond to very similar structures, but which are separated by high energy barriers.

RNA folding kinetics regulates translation of phage MS2 maturation gene

The gene for the maturation protein of the single-stranded RNA coliphage MS2 is preceded by an untranslated leader of 130 nt, which folds into a cloverleaf, i.e., three stem–loop structures enclosed by a long distance interaction (LDI). This LDI prevents translation because its 3′ moiety contains the Shine–Dalgarno sequence of the maturation gene. Previously, several observations suggested that folding of the cloverleaf is kinetically delayed, providing a time window for ribosomes to access the RNA. Here we present direct evidence for this model. In vitro experiments show that ribosome binding to the maturation gene is faster than refolding of the denatured cloverleaf. This folding delay appears related to special properties of the leader sequence. We have replaced the three stem–loop structures by a single five nt loop. This change does not affect the equilibrium structure of the LDI. Nevertheless, in this construct, the folding delay has virtually disappeared, suggesting that now the RNA folds faster than ribosomes can bind. Perturbation of the cloverleaf by an insertion makes the maturation start permanently accessible. A pseudorevertant that evolved from an infectious clone carrying the insertion had overcome this defect. It showed a wild-type folding delay before closing down the maturation gene. This experiment reveals the biological significance of retarded cloverleaf formation.

Exploring the folding free energy surface of a three-helix bundle protein

The multidimensional free energy surface for a small fast folding helical protein is explored based on first-principle calculations. The model represents the 46-residue segment from fragment B of staphylococcal protein A. The relationship between collapse and tertiary structure formation, and the order of collapse and secondary structure formation, are investigated. We find that the initial collapse process gives rise to a transition state with about 30% of the native tertiary structure and 50–70% of the native helix content. We also observe two distinct distributions of native helix in this collapsed state (Rg ≈ 12 Å), one with about 20% of the native helical hydrogen bonds, the other with near 70%. The former corresponds to a local minimum. The barrier from this metastable state to the native state is about 2 kBT. In the latter case, folding is essentially a downhill process involving topological assembly. In addition, the order of formation of secondary structure among the three helices is examined. We observe cooperative formation of the secondary structure in helix I and helix II. Secondary structure in helix III starts to form following the formation of certain secondary structure in both helix I and helix II. Comparisons of our results with those from theory and experiment are made.

Structure and function in rhodopsin: Packing of the helices in the transmembrane domain and folding to a tertiary structure in the intradiscal domain are coupled*

A previous study of the retinitis pigmentosa mutation L125R and two designed mutations at this site, L125A and L125F, showed that these mutations cause partial or total misfolding of the opsins expressed in COS cells from the corresponding mutant opsin genes. We now report on expression and characterization of the opsins from the following retinitis pigmentosa mutants in the transmembrane domain of rhodopsin that correspond to six of the seven helices: G51A and G51V (helix A), G89D (helix B), A164V (helix D), H211P (helix E), P267L and P267R (helix F), and T297R (helix G). All the mutations caused partial misfolding of the opsins as observed by the UV/visible absorption characteristics and by separation of the expressed opsins into fractions that bound 11-cis-retinal to form the corresponding mutant rhodopsins and those that did not bind 11-cis-retinal. Further, all the mutant rhodopsins prepared from the above mutants, except for G51A, showed strikingly abnormal bleaching behavior with abnormal metarhodopsin II photointermediates. The results show that retinitis pigmentosa mutations in every one of the transmembrane helices can cause misfolding of the opsin. Therefore, on the basis of these and previous results, we conclude that defects in the packing of the transmembrane helices resulting from these mutations are relayed to the intradiscal domain, where they cause misfolding of the opsin by inducing the formation of a disulfide bond other than the native Cys-110—Cys-187 disulfide bond. Thus, there is coupling between packing of the helices in the transmembrane domain and folding to a tertiary structure in the intradiscal domain.

Protein folding kinetics exhibit an Arrhenius temperature dependence when corrected for the temperature dependence of protein stability

The anomalous temperature dependence of protein folding has received considerable attention. Here we show that the temperature dependence of the folding of protein L becomes extremely simple when the effects of temperature on protein stability are corrected for; the logarithm of the folding rate is a linear function of 1/T on constant stability contours in the temperature–denaturant plane. This convincingly demonstrates that the anomalous temperature dependence of folding derives from the temperature dependence of the interactions that stabilize proteins, rather than from the super Arrhenius temperature dependence predicted for the configurational diffusion constant on a rough energy landscape. However, because of the limited temperature range accessible to experiment, the results do not rule out models with higher order temperature dependences. The significance of the slope of the stability-corrected Arrhenius plots is discussed.

Characteristic temperatures of folding of a small peptide

We perform a generalized-ensemble simulation of a small peptide taking the interactions among all atoms into account. From this simulation we obtain thermodynamic quantities over a wide range of temperatures. In particular, we show that the folding of a small peptide is a multistage process associated with two characteristic temperatures, the collapse temperature Tθ and the folding temperature Tƒ. Our results give supporting evidence for the energy landscape picture and funnel concept. These ideas were previously developed in the context of studies of simplified protein models, and here are checked in an all-atom Monte Carlo simulation.

Evolution of the folding ability of proteins through functional selection

An evolutionary process is simulated with a simple spin-glass-like model of proteins to examine the origin of folding ability. At each generation, sequences are randomly mutated and subjected to a simulation of the folding process based on the model. According to the frequency of local configurations at the active sites, sequences are selected and passed to the next generation. After a few hundred generations, a sequence capable of folding globally into a native conformation emerges. Moreover, the selected sequence has a distinct energy minimum and an anisotropic funnel on the energy surface, which are the imperative features for fast folding of proteins. The proposed model reveals that the functional selection on the local configurations leads a sequence to fold globally into a conformation at a faster rate.

Folding in vivo of a newly translated yeast cytosolic enzyme is mediated by the SSA class of cytosolic yeast Hsp70 proteins

The nature of chaperone action in the eukaryotic cytosol that assists newly translated cytosolic proteins to reach the native state has remained poorly defined. Actin, tubulin, and Gα transducin are assisted by the cytosolic chaperonin, CCT, but many other proteins, for example, ornithine transcarbamoylase (OTC), a cytosolic homotrimeric enzyme of yeast, do not require CCT action. Here, we observe that yeast cytosolic OTC is assisted to its native state by the SSA class of yeast cytosolic Hsp70 proteins. In vitro, refolding of OTC diluted from denaturant was assisted by crude yeast cytosol and ATP and found to be directed by SSA1/2. In vivo, when OTC was induced in a temperature-sensitive SSA-deficient strain, it exhibited reduced specific activity, and nonnative subunits were detected in the soluble fraction. These findings indicate that, in vivo, the Hsp70 system assists in folding at least some newly translated cytosolic enzymes, most likely functioning in a posttranslational manner.