Classification of mononuclear zinc metal sites in protein structures

Our study of the extended metal environment, particularly of the second shell, focuses in this paper on zinc sites. Key findings include: (i) The second shell of mononuclear zinc centers is generally more polar than hydrophobic and prominently features charged residues engaged in an abundance of hydrogen bonding with histidine ligands. Histidine–acidic or histidine–tyrosine clusters commonly overlap the environment of zinc ions. (ii) Histidine tautomeric metal bonding patterns in ligating zinc ions are mixed. For example, carboxypeptidase A, thermolysin, and sonic hedgehog possess the same ligand group (two histidines, one unibidentate acidic ligand, and a bound water), but their histidine tautomeric geometries markedly differ such that the carboxypeptidase A makes only Nδ1 contacts, thermolysin makes only Nɛ2 contacts, and sonic hedgehog uses one of each. Thus the presence of a similar ligand cohort does not necessarily imply the same topology or function at the active site. (iii) Two close histidine ligands HXmH, m ≤ 5, rarely both coordinate a single metal ion in the Nδ1 tautomeric conformation, presumably to avoid steric conflicts. Mononuclear zinc sites can be classified into six types depending on the ligand composition and geometry. Implications of the results are discussed in terms of divergent and convergent evolution.