PoolSeq analysis of the selection of the Rhizobium genotypes by the legume host plant

Rhizobium leguminosarum establishes highly specific nitrogen-fixing symbioses. We have applied a Pool-Seq approach to study plant host selection of genotypes. Our results confirm, at the genomic level, previous observations regarding plant selection of specific genotypes

Populations genomics analysis of legume host preference for specific rhizobial genotypes in the Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae symbioses

Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae establishes root nodule symbioses with several legume genera. Although most isolates are equally effective in establishing symbioses with all host genera, previous evidence suggests that hosts select specific rhizobial genotypes among those present in the soil. We have used population genomics to further investigate this observation. P. sativum, L. culinaris, V. sativa, and V. faba plants were used to trap rhizobia from a well-characterized soil, and pooled genomic DNAs from one-hundred isolates from each plant were sequenced. Sequence reads were aligned to the R. leguminosarum bv. viciae 3841 reference genome. High overall conservation of sequences was observed in all subpopulations, although several multigenic regions were absent from the soil population. A large fraction (16-22%) of sequence reads could not be recruited to the reference genome, suggesting that they represent sequences specific to that particular soil population. Although highly conserved, the 16S-23S rRNA gene region presented single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) regarding the reference genome, but no striking differences could be found among plant-selected subpopulations. Plant-specific SNP patterns were, however, clearly observed within the nod gene cluster, supporting the existence of a plant preference for specific rhizobial genotypes. This was also shown after genome-wide analysis of SNP patterns.

Multiple avirulence paralogues in cereal powdery mildew fungi may contribute to parasite fitness and defeat of plant resistance

Powdery mildews, obligate biotrophic fungal parasites on a wide range of important crops, can be controlled by plant resistance (R) genes, but these are rapidly overcome by parasite mutants evading recognition. It is unknown how this rapid evolution occurs without apparent loss of parasite fitness. R proteins recognize avirulence (AVR) molecules from parasites in a gene-for-gene manner and trigger defense responses. We identify AVRa10 and AVRk1 of barley powdery mildew fungus, Blumeria graminis f sp hordei (Bgh), and show that they induce both cell death and naccessibility when transiently expressed in Mla10 and Mlk1 barley (Hordeum vulgare) varieties, respectively. In contrast with other reported fungal AVR genes, AVRa10 and AVRk1 encode proteins that lack secretion signal peptides and enhance infection success on susceptible host plant cells. AVRa10 and AVRk1 belong to a large family with mayor que30 paralogues in the genome of Bgh, and homologous sequences are present in other formae speciales of the fungus infecting other grasses. Our findings imply that the mildew fungus has a repertoire of AVR genes, which may function as effectors and contribute to parasite virulence. Multiple copies of related but distinct AVR effector paralogues might enable populations of Bgh to rapidly overcome host R genes while maintaining virulence.

Effect of Biodiversity Changes in Disease Risk: Exploring Disease Emergence in a Plant-Virus System

The effect of biodiversity on the ability of parasites to infect their host and cause disease (i.e. disease risk) is a major question in pathology, which is central to understand the emergence of infectious diseases, and to develop strategies for their management. Two hypotheses, which can be considered as extremes of a continuum, relate biodiversity to disease risk: One states that biodiversity is positively correlated with disease risk (Amplification Effect), and the second predicts a negative correlation between biodiversity and disease risk (Dilution Effect). Which of them applies better to different host-parasite systems is still a source of debate, due to limited experimental or empirical data. This is especially the case for viral diseases of plants. To address this subject, we have monitored for three years the prevalence of several viruses, and virus-associated symptoms, in populations of wild pepper (chiltepin) under different levels of human management. For each population, we also measured the habitat species diversity, host plant genetic diversity and host plant density. Results indicate that disease and infection risk increased with the level of human management, which was associated with decreased species diversity and host genetic diversity, and with increased host plant density. Importantly, species diversity of the habitat was the primary predictor of disease risk for wild chiltepin populations. This changed in managed populations where host genetic diversity was the primary predictor. Host density was generally a poorer predictor of disease and infection risk. These results support the dilution effect hypothesis, and underline the relevance of different ecological factors in determining disease/infection risk in host plant populations under different levels of anthropic influence. These results are relevant for managing plant diseases and for establishing conservation policies for endangered plant species.

A non-persistently transmitted-virus induces a pull?push strategy inits aphid vector to optimize transmission and spread

Plant viruses are known to modify the behaviour of their insect vectors, both directly and indirectly,generally adapting to each type of virus?vector relationship in a way that enhances transmissionefficiency. Here, we report results of three different studies showing how a virus transmitted in a non-persistent (NP) manner (Cucumber mosaic virus; CMV, Cucumovirus) can induce changes in its host plant,cucumber (Cucumis sativus cv. Marumba) that modifies the behaviour of its aphid vector (Aphis gossypiiGlover; Hemiptera: Aphididae) in a way that enhances virus transmission and spread non-viruliferousaphids changed their alighting, settling and probing behaviour activities over time when exposed toCMV-infected and mock-inoculated cucumber plants. Aphids exhibited no preference to migrate fromCMV-infected to mock-inoculated plants at short time intervals (1, 10 and 30 min after release), butshowed a clear shift in preference to migrate from CMV-infected to mock-inoculated plants 60 min afterrelease. Our free-choice preference assays showed that A. gossypii alates preferred CMV-infected overmock-inoculated plants at an early stage (30 min), but this behaviour was reverted at a later stage andaphids preferred to settle and reproduce on mock-inoculated plants. The electrical penetration graph(EPG) technique revealed a sharp change in aphid probing behaviour over time when exposed to CMV-infected plants. At the beginning (first 15 min) aphid vectors dramatically increased the number of shortsuperficial probes and intracellular punctures when exposed to CMV-infected plants. At a later stage (sec-ond hour of recording) aphids diminished their feeding on CMV-infected plants as indicated by much lesstime spent in phloem salivation and ingestion (E1 and E2). This particular probing behaviour includingan early increase in the number of short superficial probes and intracellular punctures followed by aphloem feeding deterrence is known to enhance the transmission efficiency of viruses transmitted in aNP manner. We conclude that CMV induces specific changes in a plant host that modify the alighting,settling and probing behaviour of its main vector A. gossypii, leading to optimum transmission and spreadof the virus. Our findings should be considered when modelling the spread of viruses transmitted in a NPmanner.

Efecto de la infección por virus persistentes y no persistentes sobre el comportamiento alimenticio, la preferencia, tasa de aterrizaje y asentamiento y la eficacia biológica de Aphis gossypii Glover

En el complejo de plagas que atacan a los principales cultivos hortícolas protegidos, destacan principalmente los Hemípteros, y dentro de estos los pulgones, dada su importancia como vectores de virus que provocan considerables daños y pérdidas económicas. Debido a que la dispersión de la mayoría de los virus de plantas puede ser eficaz con densidades bajas de vectores y su control es muy complicado al no existir métodos curativos para su control, es necesario generar nuevos conocimientos sobre las interacciones virus-vector con el fin de desarrollar nuevas y eficaces estrategias de control. Por ello, el objetivo general de esta Tesis ha sido conocer el efecto de la infección viral (directo-mediado por la presencia del virus en el vector- e indirecto-mediado por las alteraciones físico-químicas que se originan en la planta como consecuencia de la infección viral-) sobre el comportamiento y eficacia biológica del vector Aphis gossypii Glover y sus posibles repercusiones en la epidemiología de virosis de transmisión no persistente (Cucumber mosaic virus, CMV, Cucumovirus) y persistente (Cucurbit aphid-borne yellows virus, CABYV, Polerovirus). El primer objetivo de esta Tesis Doctoral, se centró en el estudio del efecto indirecto del virus de transmisión no persistente CMV sobre el comportamiento alimenticio y la preferencia del pulgón A. gossypii en el cultivo de pepino. Los ensayos de despegue y aterrizaje mostraron que los pulgones que fueron liberados en las plantas de pepino infectadas con CMV tuvieron una mayor propensión en migrar hacia las plantas no infectadas (60, 120 y 180 minutos después de la liberación) que aquellos que fueron sometidos al tratamiento contrario (planta no infectada hacia planta infectada con CMV). El estudio de preferencia y asentamiento mostró que el vector A. gossypii prefiere asentarse en plantas infectadas con CMV en una etapa temprana de evaluación (30 minutos después de la liberación). Sin embargo, este comportamiento se revirtió en una etapa posterior (4 y 48 horas después de la liberación), donde los pulgones se asentaron más en las plantas no infectadas. A través de la técnica de Gráficos de Penetración Eléctrica (EPG) se observó un efecto indirecto del virus CMV, revelado por un cambio brusco en el comportamiento de prueba del pulgón a lo largo del tiempo, cuando éstos fueron expuestos a las plantas infectadas con CMV. Los primeros 15 minutos de registro EPG mostraron que los pulgones hicieron un número mayor de punciones intracelulares (potencial drops - pds) y pruebas en las plantas infectadas con CMV que en las plantas no infectadas. Por otra parte, la duración de la primera prueba fue más corta y la duración total de las pds por insecto fue mucho más larga en las plantas infectadas con CMV. Se observaron diferencias significativas en el tiempo transcurrido desde el final de la última pd hasta el final de la prueba, siendo ese tiempo más corto para los pulgones que estaban alimentándose en plantas infectadas con CMV. En la segunda hora de registro los pulgones rechazaron las plantas infectadas con CMV como fuente de alimento, permaneciendo menos tiempo en las fases de prueba en floema (fase de salivación – E1 y fase de ingestión del floema – E2). El comportamiento alimenticio observado sobre las plantas infectadas con CMV favorece la adquisición y posterior transmisión de los virus de transmisión no persistente, los cuales son adquiridos e inoculados durante la realización de pruebas intracelulares en las primeras pruebas de corta duración. En el segundo objetivo de la Tesis se evaluó el efecto directo e indirecto del virus de transmisión persistente CABYV en el comportamiento alimenticio y preferencia del pulgón A. gossypii en cultivo de pepino, especie susceptible al virus, y algodón, especie inmune al virus. No se observó un efecto directo del virus relevante en el comportamiento alimenticio del vector, ya que los resultados obtenidos a nivel floemático en plantas de pepino no se observaron en plantas de algodón, inmune al virus CABYV. Esto sugiere que los resultados obtenidos en pepino, pueden deberse a un “posible efecto indirecto” originado por la infección de las plantas susceptibles al virus durante la realización del ensayo, lo que indirectamente puede modificar el comportamiento del pulgón durante la fase de evaluación. Sin embargo, el virus CABYV modificó indirectamente el comportamiento alimenticio de su vector a través de cambios en la planta infectada. Los pulgones tardaron menos tiempo en llegar al floema, realizaron un mayor número de pruebas floemáticas y permanecieron durante más tiempo en actividades floemáticas en plantas infectadas con CABYV. El comportamiento observado sobre las plantas infectadas con CABYV favorece la adquisición de virus persistentes, los cuales son adquiridos durante la alimentación sostenida en floema. El estudio de preferencia y asentamiento de A. gossypii mostró que los pulgones virulíferos prefieren asentarse en plantas no infectadas a corto y largo plazo de evaluación (2, 4 y 48 horas después de la liberación). Los ensayos de despegue y aterrizaje mostraron que los pulgones virulíferos que fueron liberados en las plantas de pepino infectadas con CABYV tuvieron una mayor propensión en migrar hacia las plantas no infectadas (3, 6, 24 y 48 horas después de la liberación) que aquellos que fueron sometidos al tratamiento contrario (planta no infectada hacia planta infectada con CABYV). Sin embargo, los pulgones no virulíferos no mostraron preferencia por plantas de pepino no infectadas o infectadas con CABYV en ninguno de los ensayos (preferencia o despegue) o periodos evaluados (corto y largo plazo). Los resultados indican que el virus CABYV es capaz de modificar indirectamente el comportamiento alimenticio de su vector a través de cambios en la planta infectada, favoreciendo su adquisición por su principal vector, A. gossypii. Una vez que los pulgones tienen capacidad de transmitir el virus (virulíferos) se produce un cambio en su comportamiento prefiriendo asentarse sobre plantas no infectadas optimizándose así la dispersión viral. El tercer objetivo de la Tesis, fue evaluar los efectos directos e indirectos del virus CABYV así como los efectos indirectos del virus CMV en la eficacia biológica del vector A. gossypii. Los resultados obtenidos en los ensayos realizados con el virus persistente CABYV indican que el virus parece no modificar directamente ni indirectamente la eficacia biológica del vector en plantas de pepino o algodón, no observándose diferencias estadísticas en ninguno de los parámetros poblacionales evaluados (tiempo de desarrollo, tasa intrínseca de crecimiento, tiempo generacional medio, tasa media de crecimiento relativo y ninfas totales). En cuanto a los ensayos realizados con el virus no persistente, CMV, los resultados muestran un efecto indirecto del virus sobre la biología del vector. Así resultó que tanto la tasa intrínseca de crecimiento natural (rm) como la tasa media de crecimiento relativo (RGR) fueron más altas para pulgones crecidos sobre plantas infectadas con CMV que sobre plantas no infectadas, favoreciendo la reproducción y crecimiento poblacional del vector sobre plantas infectadas con CMV. Los resultados obtenidos en la presente Tesis, ofrecen un ejemplo de como los virus de plantas pueden manipular directa e indirectamente a su vector, maximizando así su dispersión entre las plantas. Esos nuevos conocimientos generados tienen implicaciones importantes en la transmisión, dispersión y en la epidemiología de los virus y deben ser considerados para diseñar o ajustar los modelos de simulación existentes y patrones de dispersión que describen las epidemias de estos virus. ABSTRACT The main objective of this Thesis has been to understand the effect of the viral infection (direct-mediated by the presence of the virus in the vector and indirect mediated by the chemical and physical changes originated in the plant as a consequence of the viral infection) on the behaviour and biological efficacy of the vector Aphis gossypii Glover and its consequences in the epidemiology of two viral diseases, one with non-persistent transmission (Cucumber mosaic virus, CMV, Cucumovirus) and another with persistent transmission (Cucurbit aphid-borne yellows virus, CABYV, Polerovirus). The first objective of this Thesis was the study of the indirect effect of the nonpersistent virus CMV on the feeding behaviour and preference of the aphid A. gossypii in cucumber plants. The results of the alighting and settling behaviour studies showed that aphids exhibited no preference to migrate from CMV-infected to mock-inoculated plants at short time intervals (1, 10 and 30 min after release), but showed a clear shift in preference to migrate from CMV-infected to mock-inoculated plants 60 min after release. Our free-choice preference assays showed that A. gossypii alates preferred CMV-infected over mockinoculated plants at an early stage (30 min), but this behaviour was reverted at a later stage and aphids preferred to settle and reproduce on mock-inoculated plants. The electrical penetration graph (EPG) technique revealed a sharp change in aphid probing behaviour over time when exposed to CMV-infected plants. At the beginning (first 15 min) aphid vectors dramatically increased the number of short superficial probes and intracellular punctures when exposed to CMV-infected plants. At a later stage (second hour of recording) aphids diminished their feeding on CMV-infected plants as indicated by much less time spent in phloem salivation and ingestion (E1 and E2). This particular probing behaviour including an early increase in the number of short superficial probes and intracellular punctures followed by a phloem feeding deterrence is known to enhance the transmission efficiency of viruses transmitted in a NP manner. We conclude that CMV induces specific changes in a plant host that modify the alighting, settling and probing behaviour of its main vector A. gossypii, leading to optimum transmission and spread of the virus. The second objective of this work was to evaluate the effects that the persistently aphid transmitted Cucurbit aphid-borne yellows virus (CABYV) can induce directly and indirectly on the alighting, settling and probing behaviour activities of the cotton aphid A. gossypii. Only minor direct changes on aphid feeding behaviour was observed due to CABYV when viruliferous aphids fed on mock-inoculated plants. However, the feeding behaviour of non-viruliferous aphids was very different on CABYV-infected than on mockinoculated plants. Non-viruliferous aphids spent longer time feeding from the phloem when plants were infected by CABYV than on mock-inoculated plants, suggesting that CABYV indirectly manipulates aphid feeding behaviour through its shared host plant in order to favour viral acquisition. The vector alighting and settling preference was compared between nonviruliferous and viruliferous aphids. Viruliferous aphids showed a clear preference for mockinoculated over CABYV-infected plants at short and long time, while such behaviour was not observed for non-viruliferous aphids. Overall, our results indicate that CABYV induces changes in its host plant that modifies aphid feeding behaviour in a way that virus acquisition from infected plants is enhanced. Once the aphids become viruliferous they prefer to settle on healthy plants, leading to optimize the transmission and spread of the virus. The third objective was to evaluate the direct and indirect effects of CABYV and indirect effects of the CMV on the A. gossypii fitness. Obtained results for the persistent virus CABYV showed that the virus did not modify the vector fitness in cucumber or cotton plants. None of the evaluated variables was statistically significant (development time (d), intrinsic growth rate (rm), mean relative growth rate (RGR) and total number of nymphs). On the other hand, data obtained for the non-persistent virus (CMV) showed an indirect effect of the virus on the vector fitness. Thus, the rm and RGR were higher for aphids grown on CMV-infected plants compared to aphids grown on mock-inoculated plants. Overall, the obtained results are clear examples of how plant viruses could manipulate directly and indirectly vector behaviour to optimize its own dispersion. These results are important for a better understanding of transmission, dispersion and epidemiology of plant viruses transmitted by vectors. This information could be also considered to design or adjust simulation models and dispersion patterns that describe plant virus epidemics.

Does the natural "microcosm" created by Tuber aestivum affect soil microarthropods? A new hypothesis based on Collembola in truffle culture

microarthropods play an important role in fungi dispersion, but little is still known about the interaction between truffle and soil microarthropods. The aim of this study was to investigate the ability of the truffle Tuber aestivum to modify soil biogeochemistry (i.e. create a zone of scarce vegetation around the host plant, called a burn or brûlé) and to highlight the effects of the brûlé on the soil fauna community. We compared soil microarthropod communities found in the soil inside versus outside the T. aestivum brûlé with the chemistry of soil collected inside versus outside the brûlé. The study was carried out in three Mediterranean areas, two in Italy and one in Spain. The results confirmed the ability of T. aestivum to modify soil biogeochemistry in the brûlé: pH was higher and total organic carbon tended to be lower inside the brûlé compared to outside. Soil fauna communities showed some interesting differences. Some groups, such as Symphyla and Pauropoda, adapted well to the soil; some Collembolan families, and biodiversity and soil quality indices were generally higher outside the brûlé. Folsomia sp. showed higher abundance in the soil of the brûlé compared to outside. The results suggest that some Collembola groups may be attracted by the fungal metabolites produced by T. aestivum, while other Collembola and other microarthropods may find an unfavourable environment in the soil of the brûlé. The next steps will be to confirm this hypothesis and to extend the study to other keys groups such as nematodes and earthworms and to link fluctuations of soil communities with the biological phases of truffle growth.

Natural production of Tuber aestivum in central Spain: Pinus spp. versus Quercus spp. brûles

Aim of study: Tuber aestivum is the most widespread edible truffle, with increasing commercial interest. This species can produce carpophores with conifer hosts, in contrast with the inability of Pinus spp. to induce fruiting in other truffle species such as Tuber melanosporum. Therefore the objective is to compare the characteristics and carpophore production of T. aestivum brûlés associated with Pinus spp. versus Quercus spp. Area of study: We studied the natural habitats of T. aestivum in the Alto Tajo Nature Reserve in central Spain. Material and methods: During 5 years, we monitored the production of carpophores and brûlé size of 145 T. aestivum brûlés associated with Pinus nigra subsp. salzmanni and P. sylvestris and Quercus ilex subsp. ballota and Q. faginea hosts. Statistical treatment was performed using the Statistica Program v. 6. Main results: The size of brûlés associated with Pinus was significantly smaller than that of brûlés associated with Quercus. However, carpophore production per brûlé, and especially for brûlés of similar size, was greater when the host plant was a pine. After accounting for brûlé size, the production of brûlés associated with Pinus spp. was 2.23 (95% CI, between 1.35 and 3.69) and 1.61 (95% CI, between 1.02 and 2.54) times greater than the production of brûlés associated with Quercus faginea and Q. ilex subsp. ballota, respectively. Research highlights: The considerable ability of Pinus nigra subsp. salzmanni and P. sylvestris to form effective brûlés and to produce carpophores of Tuber aestivum in natural conditions was clearly demonstrated, and suggest that those species can be of use in the culture of T. aestivum.

Metagenomic Anlaysis of microsymbiont selection by the legume plant host

Rhizobium leguminosarum bv.viciae is able to establish nitrogen-fixing symbioses with legumes of the genera Pisum, Lens, Lathyrus and Vicia. Classic studies using trap plants (Laguerre et al., Young et al.) provided evidence that different plant hosts are able to select different rhizobial genotypes among those available in a given soil. However, these studies were necessarily limited by the paucity of relevant biodiversity markers. We have now reappraised this problem with the help of genomic tools. A well-characterized agricultural soil (INRA Bretennieres) was used as source of rhizobia. Plants of Pisum sativum, Lens culinaris, Vicia sativa and V. faba were used as traps. Isolates from 100 nodules were pooled, and DNA from each pool was sequenced (BGI-Hong Kong; Illumina Hiseq 2000, 500 bp PE libraries, 100 bp reads, 12 Mreads). Reads were quality filtered (FastQC, Trimmomatic), mapped against reference R. leguminosarum genomes (Bowtie2, Samtools), and visualized (IGV). An important fraction of the filtered reads were not recruited by reference genomes, suggesting that plant isolates contain genes that are not present in the reference genomes. For this study, we focused on three conserved genomic regions: 16S-23S rDNA, atpD and nodDABC, and a Single Nucleotide Polymorphism (SNP) analysis was carried out with meta / multigenomes from each plant. Although the level of polymorphism varied (lowest in the rRNA region), polymorphic sites could be identified that define the specific soil population vs. reference genomes. More importantly, a plant-specific SNP distribution was observed. This could be confirmed with many other regions extracted from the reference genomes (data not shown). Our results confirm at the genomic level previous observations regarding plant selection of specific genotypes. We expect that further, ongoing comparative studies on differential meta / multigenomic sequences will identify specific gene components of the plant-selected genotypes

Effect of the Legume Plant Host on Rhizobial Soil Population Dynamics

Rhizobium leguminosarum bv viciae (Rlv) is a soil bacterium able to establish specific root-nodule symbioses with legumes of four different genera: Pisum, Vicia, Lens and Lathyrus. Rlv isolates from nodules of any of these legumes can nodulate any of them; however, it has been shown that plants select specific rhizobial genotypes from those present in the soil (1,2). We have previously shown this at the genomic level by following a population genomics approach. Pool genomic sequences from 100 isolates from each of four plant species: P. sativum, L. culinaris, V. faba and V. sativa, show different, specific profiles at the single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) level for relevant genes. In this work, the extent of Rlv selection from a well-characterized soil population by different legume plant hosts: P. sativum, L. culinaris, V. faba and V. sativa, after a medium-term mesocosm study is described. Direct soil isolates from each of these mesocosm studies have been tested for specific rhizobial genes (glnII and fnrN) and symbiotic genes (nodC and nifH). Different populations were characterized further by Sanger sequencing of both the rpoB phylogenetic marker gene and the symbiotic genes nodC and nifH. The distribution and size of the rhizobial population for each legume host showed changes during the medium-term mesocosm study. Particularly, a non-symbiotic group of rhizobia was enriched by all four hosts, in contrast to the symbiotic rhizobia profile, which was specific for each legume plant host.

The Pangenome of the Plant-Selected Rhizobium leguminosarum bv viciae Sub-popuations

Rhizobium leguminosarum bv viciae (Rlv) is a bacterium able to establish effective symbioses with four different legume genera: Pisum, Lens, Lathyrus and Vicia. Classic studies using trap plants have previously shown that, given a choice, different plants prefer specific genotypes of rhizobia, which are adapted to the host (1, 2). In previous work we have performed a Pool-Seq analysis bases on pooled DNA samples from Rlv nodule isolates obtained from Pisum sativum, Lens culinaris, Vicia fava and V. sativa plants, used as rhizobial traps. This experiment allowed us to test the host preference hypothesis: different plant hosts select specific sub-populations of rhizobia from the available population present in a given soil. We have observed that plant-selected sub-populations are different at the single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) level. We have selected individual isolates from each sub-population (9 fava-bean isolates, 14 pea isolates 9 vetch isolates and 9 lentil isolates) and sequenced their genomes at draft level (ca. 30x, 90 contigs). Genomic analyses have been carried out using J-species and CMG-Biotools. All the isolates had similar genome size (7.5 Mb) and number of genes (7,300). The resulting Average Nucleotide Identity (ANIm) tree showed that Rhizobium leguminosarum bv viciae is a highly diverse group. Each plant-selected subpopulation showed a closed pangenome and core genomes of similar size (11,500 and 4,800 genes, respectively). The addition of all four sub-population results in a larger, closed pangenome of 19,040 genes and a core genome of similar size (4,392 genes). Each sub-population contains a characteristic set of genes but no universal, plant-specific genes were found. The core genome obtained from all four sub-populations is probably a representative core genome for Rhizobium leguminosarum, given that the reference genome (Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae strain 3841) contains most of the core genome. We have also analyzed the symbiotic cluster (nod), and different nod cluster genotypes were found in each sub-population. Supported by MINECO (Consolider-Ingenio 2010, MICROGEN Project, CSD2009-00006).

Molecular cloning and characterization of an amidase from Arabidopsis thaliana capable of converting indole-3-acetamide into the plant growth hormone, indole-3-acetic acid

Acylamidohydrolases from higher plants have not been characterized or cloned so far. AtAMI1 is the first member of this enzyme family from a higher plant and was identified in the genome of Arabidopsis thaliana based on sequence homology with the catalytic-domain sequence of bacterial acylamidohydrolases, particularly those that exhibit indole-3-acetamide amidohydrolase activity. AtAMI1 polypeptide and mRNA are present in leaf tissues, as shown by immunoblotting and RT-PCR, respectively. AtAMI1 was expressed from its cDNA in enzymatically active form and exhibits substrate specificity for indole-3-acetamide, but also some activity against l-asparagine. The recombinant enzyme was characterized further. The results show that higher plants have acylamidohydrolases with properties similar to the enzymes of certain plant-associated bacteria such as Agrobacterium-, Pseudomonas- and Rhodococcus-species, in which these enzymes serve to synthesize the plant growth hormone, indole-3-acetic acid, utilized by the bacteria to colonize their host plants. As indole-3-acetamide is a native metabolite in Arabidopsis thaliana, it can no longer be ruled out that one pathway for the biosynthesis of indole-3-acetic acid involves indole-3-acetamide-hydrolysis by AtAMI1.

A bacterial cysteine protease effector protein interferes with photosynthesis to suppress plant innate immune responses

The bacterial pathogen Pseudomonas syringae pv tomato DC3000 suppresses plant innate immunity with effector proteins injected by a type III secretion system (T3SS). The cysteine protease effector HopN1, which reduces the ability of DC3000 to elicit programmed cell death in non-host tobacco, was found to also suppress the production of defence-associated reactive oxygen species (ROS) and callose when delivered by Pseudomonas fluorescens heterologously expressing a P. syringae T3SS. Purified His 6 -tagged HopN1 was used to identify tomato PsbQ, a member of the oxygen evolving complex of photosystem II (PSII), as an interacting protein. HopN1 localized to chloroplasts and both degraded PsbQ and inhibited PSII activity in chloroplast preparations, whereas a HopN1 D299A non-catalytic mutant lost these abilities. Gene silencing of NtPsbQ in tobacco compromised ROS production and programmed cell death.

Mejora de la eficacia de Penicillium oxalicum como agente de biocontrol en enfermedades de plantas hortícolas

Actualmente, la reducción de materias activas (UE) y la implantación de la nueva Directiva comunitaria 2009/128/ que establece el marco de actuación para conseguir un uso sostenible de los plaguicidas químicos y la preferencia de uso de métodos biológicos, físicos y otros no químicos, obliga a buscar métodos de control menos perjudiciales para el medio ambiente. El control biológico (CB) de enfermedades vegetales empleando agentes de control biológico (ACB) se percibe como una alternativa más segura y con menor impacto ambiental, bien solos o bien como parte de una estrategia de control integrado. El aislado 212 de Penicillium oxalicum (PO212) (ATCC 201888) fue aislado originalmente de la micoflora del suelo en España y ha demostrado ser un eficaz ACB frente a la marchitez vascular del tomate. Una vez identificado y caracterizado el ACB se inició el periodo de desarrollo del mismo poniendo a punto un método de producción en masa de sus conidias. Tras lo cual se inició el proceso de formulación del ACB deshidratando las conidias para su preservación durante un período de tiempo mayor mediante lecho fluido. Finalmente, se han desarrollado algunos formulados que contienen de forma individual diferentes aditivos que han alargado su viabilidad, estabilidad y facilitado su manejo y aplicación. Sin embargo, es necesario seguir trabajando en la mejora de su eficacia de biocontrol. El primer objetivo de esta Tesis se ha centrado en el estudio de la interacción ACB-patógeno-huésped que permita la actuación de P.oxalicum en diferentes patosistemas. Uno de los primeros puntos que se abordan dentro de este objetivo es el desarrollo de nuevas FORMULACIONES del ACB que incrementen su eficacia frente a la marchitez vascular del tomate. Las conidias formuladas de PO212 se obtuvieron por la adición conjunta de distintos aditivos (mojantes, adherentes o estabilizantes) en dos momentos diferentes del proceso de producción/secado: i) antes del proceso de producción (en la bolsa de fermentación) en el momento de la inoculación de las bolsas de fermentación con conidias de PO212 o ii) antes del secado en el momento de la resuspensión de las conidias tras su centrifugación. De las 22 nuevas formulaciones desarrolladas y evaluadas en plantas de tomate en ensayos en invernadero, seis de ellas (FOR22, FOR25, FOR32, FOR35, FOR36 y FOR37) mejoran significativamente (P=0,05) el control de la marchitez vascular del tomate con respecto al obtenido con las conidias secas de P.oxalicum sin aditivos (CSPO) o con el fungicida Bavistin. Los formulados que mejoran la eficacia de las conidias secas sin aditivos son aquellos que contienen como humectantes alginato sódico en fermentación, seguido de aquellos que contienen glicerol como estabilizante en fermentación, y metil celulosa y leche desnatada como adherentes antes del secado. Además, el control de la marchitez vascular del tomate por parte de los formulados de P. oxalicum está relacionado con la fecha de inicio de la enfermedad. Otra forma de continuar mejorando la eficacia de biocontrol es mejorar la materia activa mediante la SELECCIÓN DE NUEVAS CEPAS de P. oxalicum, las cuales podrían tener diferentes niveles de eficacia. De entre las 28 nuevas cepas de P. oxalicum ensayadas en cámara de cultivo, sólo el aislado PO15 muestra el mismo nivel de eficacia que PO212 (62-67% de control) frente a la marchitez vascular del tomate en casos de alta presión de enfermedad. Mientras que, en casos de baja presión de enfermedad todas las cepas de P. oxalicum y sus mezclas demuestran ser eficaces. Finalmente, se estudia ampliar el rango de actuación de este ACB a OTROS HUÉSPEDES Y OTROS PATÓGENOS Y DIFERENTES GRADOS DE VIRULENCIA. En ensayos de eficacia de P. oxalicum frente a aislados de diferente agresividad de Verticillium spp. y Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lycopersici en plantas de tomate en cámaras de cultivo, se demuestra que la eficacia de PO212 está negativamente correlacionada con el nivel de enfermedad causada por F. oxysporum f. sp. lycopersici pero que no hay ningún efecto diferencial en la reducción de la incidencia ni de la gravedad según la virulencia de los aislados. Sin embargo, en los ensayos realizados con V. dahliae, PO212 causa una mayor reducción de la enfermedad en las plantas inoculadas con aislados de virulencia media. La eficacia de PO212 también era mayor frente a aislados de virulencia media alta de F. oxysporum f. sp. melonis y F. oxysporum f. sp. niveum, en plantas de melón y sandía, respectivamente. En ambos huéspedes se demuestra que la dosis óptima de aplicación del ACB es de 107 conidias de PO212 g-1 de suelo de semillero, aplicada 7 días antes del trasplante. Además, entre 2 y 4 nuevas aplicaciones de PO212 a la raíces de las plantas mediante un riego al terreno de asiento mejoran la eficacia de biocontrol. La eficacia de PO212 no se limita a hongos patógenos vasculares como los citados anteriormente, sino también a otros patógenos como: Phytophthora cactorum, Globodera pallida y G. rostochiensis. PO212 reduce significativamente los síntomas (50%) causados por P. cactorum en plantas de vivero de fresa, tras la aplicación del ACB por inmersión de las raíces antes de su trasplante al suelo de viveros comerciales. Por otra parte, la exposición de los quistes de Globodera pallida y G. rostochiensis (nematodos del quiste de la patata) a las conidias de P. oxalicum, en ensayos in vitro o en microcosmos de suelo, reduce significativamente la capacidad de eclosión de los huevos. Para G. pallida esta reducción es mayor cuando se emplean exudados de raíz de patata del cv. 'Monalisa', que exudados de raíz del cv. 'Desirée'. No hay una reducción significativa en la tasa de eclosión con exudados de raíz de tomate del cv. 'San Pedro'. Para G. rostochiensis la reducción en la tasa de eclosión de los huevos se obtiene con exudados de la raíz de patata del cv. 'Desirée'. El tratamiento con P. oxalicum reduce también significativamente el número de quistes de G. pallida en macetas. Con el fin de optimizar la aplicación práctica de P. oxalicum cepa 212 como tratamiento biológico del suelo, es esencial entender cómo el entorno físico influye en la capacidad de colonización, crecimiento y supervivencia del mismo, así como el posible riesgo que puede suponer su aplicación sobre el resto de los microorganismos del ecosistema. Por ello en este segundo objetivo de esta tesis se estudia la interacción del ACB con el medio ambiente en el cual se aplica. Dentro de este objetivo se evalúa la INFLUENCIA DE LA TEMPERATURA, DISPONIBILIDAD DE AGUA Y PROPIEDADES FÍSICO-QUÍMICAS DE LOS SUELOS (POROSIDAD, TEXTURA, DENSIDAD...) SOBRE LA SUPERVIVENCIA Y EL CRECIMIENTO DE PO212 en condiciones controladas elaborando modelos que permitan predecir el impacto de cada factor ambiental en la supervivencia y crecimiento de P. oxalicum y conocer su capacidad para crecer y sobrevivir en diferentes ambientes. En las muestras de suelo se cuantifica: i) la supervivencia de Penicillium spp. usando el recuento del número de unidades formadoras de colonias en un medio de cultivo semi-selectivo y ii) el crecimiento (biomasa) de PO212 mediante PCR en tiempo real. En los resultados obtenidos se demuestra que P. oxalicum crece y sobrevive mejor en condiciones de sequía independientemente de la temperatura y del tipo de suelo. Si comparamos tipos de suelo P. oxalicum crece y sobrevive en mayor medida en suelos areno-arcillosos con un bajo contenido en materia orgánica, un mayor pH y una menor disponibilidad de fósforo y nitrógeno. La supervivencia y el crecimiento de P. oxalicum se correlaciona de forma negativa con la disponibilidad de agua y de forma positiva con el contenido de materia orgánica. Sólo la supervivencia se correlaciona también positivamente con el pH. Por otro lado se realizan ensayos en suelos de huertos comerciales con diferentes propiedades físico-químicas y diferentes condiciones ambientales para ESTUDIAR EL ESTABLECIMIENTO, SUPERVIVENCIA Y DISPERSIÓN VERTICAL Y MOVILIDAD HORIZONTAL DE PO212. P. oxalicum 212 puede persistir y sobrevivir en esos suelos al menos un año después de su liberación pero a niveles similares a los de otras especies de Penicillium indígenas presentes en los mismos suelos naturales. Además, P. oxalicum 212 muestra una dispersión vertical y movilidad horizontal muy limitada en los diferentes tipos de suelo evaluados. La introducción de P. oxalicum en un ambiente natural no sólo implica su actuación sobre el microorganismo diana, el patógeno, si no también sobre otros microorganismos indígenas. Para EVALUAR EL EFECTO DE LA APLICACIÓN DE P. oxalicum SOBRE LAS POBLACIONES FÚNGICAS INDIGENAS PRESENTES EN EL SUELO de dos huertos comerciales, se analizan mediante electroforesis en gradiente desnaturalizante de poliacrilamida (DGGE) muestras de dichos suelos a dos profundidades (5 y 10 cm) y a cuatro fechas desde la aplicación de P. oxalicum 212 (0, 75, 180 y 365 días). El análisis de la DGGE muestra que las diferencias entre las poblaciones fúngicas se deben significativamente a la fecha de muestreo y son independientes del tratamiento aplicado y de la profundidad a la que se tomen las muestras. Luego, la aplicación del ACB no afecta a la población fúngica de los dos suelos analizados. El análisis de las secuencias de la DGGE confirma los resultados anteriores y permiten identificar la presencia del ACB en los suelos. La presencia de P. oxalicum en el suelo se encuentra especialmente relacionada con factores ambientales como la humedad. Por tanto, podemos concluir que Penicillium oxalicum cepa 212 puede considerarse un óptimo Agente de Control Biológico (ACB), puesto que es ecológicamente competitivo, eficaz para combatir un amplio espectro de enfermedades y no supone un riesgo para el resto de microorganismos fúngicos no diana presentes en el lugar de aplicación. ABSTRACT Currently, reduction of active (EU) and the implementation of the new EU Directive 2009/128 which establishing the framework for action to achieve the sustainable use of chemical pesticides and preference of use of biological, physical and other non-chemical methods, forces to look for control methods less harmful to the environment. Biological control (CB) of plant diseases using biological control agents (BCA) is perceived as a safer alternative and with less environmental impact, either alone or as part of an integrated control strategy. The isolate 212 of Penicillium oxalicum (PO212) (ATCC 201888) was originally isolated from the soil mycoflora in Spain. P. oxalicum is a promising biological control agent for Fusarium wilt and other tomato diseases. Once identified and characterized the BCA, was developed a mass production method of conidia by solid-state fermentation. After determined the process of obtaining a formulated product of the BCA by drying of product by fluid-bed drying, it enables the preservation of the inoculum over a long period of time. Finally, some formulations of dried P. oxalicum conidia have been developed which contain one different additive that have improved their viability, stability and facilitated its handling and application. However, further work is needed to improve biocontrol efficacy. The first objective of this thesis has focused on the study of the interaction BCA- pathogen-host, to allow P.oxalicum to work in different pathosystems. The first point to be addressed in this objective is the development of new FORMULATIONS of BCA which increase their effectiveness against vascular wilt of tomato. PO212 conidial formulations were obtained by the joint addition of various additives (wetting agents, adhesives or stabilizers) at two different points of the production-drying process: i) to substrate in the fermentation bags before the production process, and (ii) to conidial paste obtained after production but before drying. Of the 22 new formulations developed and evaluated in tomato plants in greenhouse tests, six of them (FOR22 , FOR25 , FOR32 , FOR35 , FOR36 and FOR3) improved significantly (P = 0.05) the biocontrol efficacy against tomato wilt with respect to that obtained with dried P.oxalicum conidia without additives (CSPO) or the fungicide Bavistin. The formulations that improve the efficiency of dried conidia without additives are those containing as humectants sodium alginate in the fermentation bags, followed by those containing glycerol as a stabilizer in the fermentation bags, and methylcellulose and skimmed milk as adherents before drying. Moreover, control of vascular wilt of tomatoes by PO212 conidial formulations is related to the date of disease onset. Another way to further improve the effectiveness of biocontrol is to improve the active substance by SELECTION OF NEW STRAINS of P. oxalicum, which may have different levels of effectiveness. Of the 28 new strains of P. oxalicum tested in a culture chamber, only PO15 isolate shows the same effectiveness that PO212 (62-67 % of control) against tomato vascular wilt in cases of high disease pressure. Whereas in cases of low disease pressure all strains of P. oxalicum and its mixtures effective. Finally, we study extend the range of action of this BCA TO OTHER GUESTS AND OTHER PATHOGENS AND DIFFERENT DEGREES OF VIRULENCE. In efficacy trials of P. oxalicum against isolates of different aggressiveness of Verticillium spp. and Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lycopersici in tomato plants in growth chambers, shows that the efficiency of PO212 is negatively correlated with the level of disease caused by F. oxysporum f. sp. lycopersici. There is not differential effect in reducing the incidence or severity depending on the virulence of isolates. However, PO212 cause a greater reduction of disease in plants inoculated with virulent isolates media of V. dahlia. PO212 efficacy was also higher against isolates of high and average virulence of F. oxysporum f. sp. melonis and F. oxysporum f. sp. niveum in melon and watermelon plants, respectively. In both hosts the optimum dose of the BCA application is 107 conidia PO212 g-1 soil, applied on seedlings 7 days before transplantation into the field. Moreover, the reapplication of PO212 (2-4 times) to the roots by irrigation into the field improve efficiency of biocontrol. The efficacy of PO212 is not limited to vascular pathogens as those mentioned above, but also other pathogens such as Oomycetes (Phytophthora cactorum) and nematodes (Globodera pallida and G. rostochiensis). PO212 significantly reduces symptoms (50 %) caused by P. cactorum in strawberry nursery plants after application of BCA by dipping the roots before transplanting to soil in commercial nurseries. Moreover, the exposure of G. pallida and G. rostochiensis cysts to the conidia of P. oxalicum, in in vitro assays or in soil microcosms significantly reduces hatchability of eggs. The reduction in the rate of G. pallida juveniles hatching was greatest when root diffusates from the `Monalisa´ potato cultivar were used, followed by root diffusates from the `Désirée´ potato cultivar. However, no significant reduction in the rate of G. pallida juveniles hatching was found when root diffusates from the ‘San Pedro” tomato cultivar were used. For G. rostochiensis reduction in the juveniles hatching is obtained from the root diffusates 'Desirée' potato cultivar. Treatment with P. oxalicum also significantly reduces the number of cysts of G. pallida in pots. In order to optimize the practical application of P. oxalicum strain 212 as a biological soil treatment, it is essential to understand how the physical environment influences the BCA colonization, survival and growth, and the possible risk that can cause its application on other microorganisms in the ecosystem of performance. Therefore, the second objective of this thesis is the interaction of the BCA with the environment in which it is applied. Within this objective is evaluated the INFLUENCE OF TEMPERATURE, WATER AVAILABILITY AND PHYSICAL-CHEMICAL PROPERTIES OF SOILS (POROSITY, TEXTURE, DENSITY...) ON SURVIVAL AND GROWTH OF PO212 under controlled conditions to develop models for predicting the environmental impact of each factor on survival and growth of P. oxalicum and to know their ability to grow and survive in different environments. Two parameters are evaluated in the soil samples: i) the survival of Penicillium spp. by counting the number of colony forming units in semi-selective medium and ii) growth (biomass) of PO212 by real-time PCR. P. oxalicum grows and survives better in drought conditions regardless of temperature and soil type. P. oxalicum grows and survives more in sandy loam soils with low organic matter content, higher pH and lower availability of phosphorus and nitrogen. Survival and growth of P. oxalicum negatively correlates with the availability of water and positively with the organic content. Only survival also correlated positively with pH. Moreover, trials are carried out into commercial orchards soils with different physic-chemical properties and different environmental conditions TO STUDY THE ESTABLISHMENT, SURVIVAL, VERTICAL DISPERSION AND HORIZONTAL SPREAD OF PO212. P. oxalicum 212 can persist and survive at very low levels in soil one year after its release. The size of the PO212 population after its release into the tested natural soils is similar to that of indigenous Penicillium spp. Furthermore, the vertical dispersion and horizontal spread of PO212 is limited in different soil types. The introduction of P. oxalicum in a natural environment not only involves their action on the target organism, the pathogen, but also on other indigenous microorganisms. TO ASSESS THE EFFECT OF P. oxalicum APPLICATION ON SOIL INDIGENOUS FUNGAL COMMUNITIES in two commercial orchards, soil samples are analyzed by Denaturing Gradient Gel Electrophoresis polyacrylamide (DGGE). Samples are taken from soil at two depths (5 and 10 cm) and four dates from the application of P. oxalicum 212 (0, 75, 180 and 365 days). DGGE analysis shows that differences are observed between sampling dates and are independent of the treatment of P. oxalicum applied and the depth. BCA application does not affect the fungal population of the two soil analyzed. Sequence analysis of the DGGE bands confirms previous findings and to identify the presence of BCA on soils. The presence of P. oxalicum in soil is especially related to environmental factors such as humidity. Therefore, we conclude that the 212 of strain Penicillium oxalicum can be considered an optimum BCA, since it is environmentally competitive and effective against a broad spectrum of diseases and does not have any negative effect on soil non-target fungi communities.

New insights into the regulation of NADPH oxidase dependent reactive oxygen species signaling during the plant immune response

Las NADPH oxidasas de plantas, denominadas “respiratory burst oxidase homologues” (RBOHs), producen especies reactivas del oxígeno (ROS) que median un amplio rango de funciones. En la célula vegetal, el ajuste preciso de la producción de ROS aporta la especificidad de señal para generar una respuesta apropiada ante las amenazas ambientales. RbohD y RbohF, dos de los diez genes Rboh de Arabidopsis, son pleiotrópicos y median diversos procesos fisiológicos en respuesta a patógenos. El control espacio-temporal de la expresión de los genes RbohD y RbohF podría ser un aspecto crítico para determinar la multiplicidad de funciones de estas oxidasas. Por ello, generamos líneas transgénicas de Arabidopsis con fusiones de los promoters de RbohD y RbohF a los genes delatores de la B-glucuronidasa y la luciferasa. Estas líneas fueron empleadas para revelar el patrón de expresión diferencial de RbohD y RbohF durante la respuesta inmune de Arabidopsis a la bacteria patógena Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000, el hongo necrótrofo Plectosphaerella cucumerina y en respuesta a señales relacionadas con la respuesta inmune. Nuestros experimentos revelan un patrón de expresión diferencial de los promotores de RbohD y RbohF durante el desarrollo de la planta y en la respuesta inmune de Arabidopsis. Además hemos puesto de manifiesto que existe una correlación entre el nivel de actividad de los promotores de RbohD y RbohF con la acumulación de ROS y el nivel de muerte celular en respuesta a patógenos. La expression de RbohD y RbohF también es modulada de manera diferencial en respuesta a patrones moleculares asociados a patógenos (PAMPs) y por ácido abscísico (ABA). Cabe destacar que, mediante una estrategia de intercambio de promotores, hemos revelado que la región promotora de RbohD, es necesaria para dirigir la producción de ROS en respuesta a P. cucumerina. Adicionalmente, la activación del promotor de RbohD en respuesta al aislado de P. cucumerina no adaptado a Arabidopsis 2127, nos llevó a realizar ensayos de susceptibilidad con el doble mutante rbohD rbohF que han revelado un papel desconocido de estas oxidasas en resistencia no-huesped. La interacción entre la señalización dependiente de las RBOHs y otros componentes de la respuesta inmune de plantas podría explicar también las distintas funciones que median estas oxidasas en relación con la respuesta inmune. Entre la gran cantidad de señales coordinadas con la actividad de las RBOHs, existen evidencias genéticas y farmacológicas que indican que las proteínas G heterotriméricas están implicadas en algunas de las rutas de señalización mediadas por ROS derivadas de los RBOHs en respuesta a señales ambientales. Por ello hemos estudiado la relación entre estas RBOH-NADPH oxidasas y AGB1, la subunidad β de las proteínas G heterotriméricas en la respuesta inmune de Arabidopsis. Análisis de epistasis indican que las proteínas G heterotriméricas están implicadas en distintas rutas de señalización en defensa mediadas por las RBOHs. Nuestros resultados ilustran la relación compleja entre la señalización mediada por las RBOHs y las proteínas G heterotriméricas, que varía en función de la interacción planta-patógeno analizada. Además, hemos explorado la posible asociación entre AGB1 con RBOHD y RBOHF en eventos tempranos de la respuesta immune. Cabe señalar que experimentos de coímmunoprecipitación apuntan a una posible asociación entre AGB1 y la kinasa citoplasmática reguladora de RBOHD, BIK1. Esto indica un posible mecanismo de control de la función de esta NADPH oxidase por AGB1. En conjunto, estos datos aportan nuevas perspectivas sobre cómo, a través del control transcripcional o mediante la interacción con las proteínas G heterotriméricas, las NADPH oxidases de plantas median la producción de ROS y la señalización por ROS en la respuesta inmune. Nuestro trabajo ejemplifica cómo la regulación diferencial de dos miembros de una familia multigénica, les permite realizar distintas funciones fisiológicas especializadas usando un mismo mecanismo enzimático. ABSTRACT The plant NADPH oxidases, termed respiratory burst oxidase homologues (RBOHs), produce reactive oxygen species (ROS) which mediate a wide range of functions. Fine tuning this ROS production provides the signaling specificity to the plant cell to produce the appropriate response to environmental threats. RbohD and RbohF, two of the ten Rboh genes present in Arabidopsis, are pleiotropic and mediate diverse physiological processes in response to pathogens. One aspect that may prove critical to determine the multiplicity of functions of RbohD and RbohF is the spatio-temporal control of their gene expression. Thus, we generated Arabidopsis transgenic lines with RbohD- and RbohF-promoter fusions to the β-glucuronidase and the luciferase reporter genes. These transgenics were employed to reveal RbohD and RbohF promoter activity during Arabidopsis immune response to the pathogenic bacterium Pseudomonas syringae pv tomato DC3000, the necrotrophic fungus Plectosphaerella cucumerina and in response to immunity-related cues. Our experiments revealed a differential expression pattern of RbohD and RbohF throughout plant development and during Arabidopsis immune response. Moreover, we observed a correlation between the level of RbohD and RbohF promoter activity, the accumulation of ROS and the amount of cell death in response to pathogens. RbohD and RbohF gene expression was also differentially modulated by pathogen associated molecular patterns and abscisic acid. Interestingly, a promoter-swap strategy revealed the requirement for the promoter region of RbohD to drive the production of ROS in response to P. cucumerina. Additionally, since the RbohD promoter was activated during Arabidopsis interaction with a non-adapted P. cucumerina isolate 2127, we performed susceptibility tests to this fungal isolate that uncovered a new role of these oxidases on non-host resistance. The interplay between RBOH-dependent signaling with other components of the plant immune response might also explain the different immunity-related functions mediated by these oxidases. Among the plethora of signals coordinated with RBOH activity, pharmacological and genetic evidence indicates that heterotrimeric G proteins are involved in some of the signaling pathways mediated by RBOH–derived ROS in response to environmental cues. Therefore, we analysed the interplay between these RBOH-NADPH oxidases and AGB1, the Arabidopsis β-subunit of heterotrimeric G proteins during Arabidopsis immune response. We carried out epistasis studies that allowed us to test the implication of AGB1 in different RBOH-mediated defense signaling pathways. Our results illustrate the complex relationship between RBOH and heterotrimeric G proteins signaling, that varies depending on the type of plant-pathogen interaction. Furthermore, we tested the potential association between AGB1 with RBOHD and RBOHF during early immunity. Interestingly, our co-immunoprecipitation experiments point towards an association of AGB1 and the RBOHD regulatory kinase BIK1, thus providing a putative mechanism in the control of the NADPH oxidase function by AGB1. Taken all together, these studies provide further insights into the role that transcriptional control or the interaction with heterotrimeric G-proteins have on RBOH-NADPH oxidase-dependent ROS production and signaling in immunity. Our work exemplifies how, through a differential regulation, two members of a multigenic family achieve specialized physiological functions using a common enzymatic mechanism.