Development of Shape-Optimization Tools for the Aerodynamic Design of Turbomachinery Blades

The aim of this work is to develop an automated tool for the optimization of turbomachinery blades founded on an evolutionary strategy. This optimization scheme will serve to deal with supersonic blades cascades for application to Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) turbines. The blade geometry is defined using parameterization techniques based on B-Splines curves, that allow to have a local control of the shape. The location in space of the control points of the B-Spline curve define the design variables of the optimization problem. In the present work, the performance of the blade shape is assessed by means of fully-turbulent flow simulations performed with a CFD package, in which a look-up table method is applied to ensure an accurate thermodynamic treatment. The solver is set along with the optimization tool to determine the optimal shape of the blade. As only blade-to-blade effects are of interest in this study, quasi-3D calculations are performed, and a single-objective evolutionary strategy is applied to the optimization. As a result, a non-intrusive tool, with no need for gradients definition, is developed. The computational cost is reduced by the use of surrogate models. A Gaussian interpolation scheme (Kriging model) is applied for the estimated n-dimensional function, and a surrogate-based local optimization strategy is proved to yield an accurate way for optimization. In particular, the present optimization scheme has been applied to the re-design of a supersonic stator cascade of an axial-flow turbine. In this design exercise very strong shock waves are generated in the rear blade suction side and shock-boundary layer interaction mechanisms occur. A significant efficiency improvement as a consequence of a more uniform flow at the blade outlet section of the stator is achieved. This is also expected to provide beneficial effects on the design of a subsequent downstream rotor. The method provides an improvement to gradient-based methods and an optimized blade geometry is easily achieved using the genetic algorithm.

Aerodynamic Optimization of the Nose Shape of a High-speed Train

La influencia de la aerodinámica en el diseño de los trenes de alta velocidad, unida a la necesidad de resolver nuevos problemas surgidos con el aumento de la velocidad de circulación y la reducción de peso del vehículo, hace evidente el interés de plantear un estudio de optimización que aborde tales puntos. En este contexto, se presenta en esta tesis la optimización aerodinámica del testero de un tren de alta velocidad, llevada a cabo mediante el uso de métodos de optimización avanzados. Entre estos métodos, se ha elegido aquí a los algoritmos genéticos y al método adjunto como las herramientas para llevar a cabo dicha optimización. La base conceptual, las características y la implementación de los mismos se detalla a lo largo de la tesis, permitiendo entender los motivos de su elección, y las consecuencias, en términos de ventajas y desventajas que cada uno de ellos implican. El uso de los algorimos genéticos implica a su vez la necesidad de una parametrización geométrica de los candidatos a óptimo y la generación de un modelo aproximado que complementa al método de optimización. Estos puntos se describen de modo particular en el primer bloque de la tesis, enfocada a la metodología seguida en este estudio. El segundo bloque se centra en la aplicación de los métodos a fin de optimizar el comportamiento aerodinámico del tren en distintos escenarios. Estos escenarios engloban los casos más comunes y también algunos de los más exigentes a los que hace frente un tren de alta velocidad: circulación en campo abierto con viento frontal o viento lateral, y entrada en túnel. Considerando el caso de viento frontal en campo abierto, los dos métodos han sido aplicados, permitiendo una comparación de las diferentes metodologías, así como el coste computacional asociado a cada uno, y la minimización de la resistencia aerodinámica conseguida en esa optimización. La posibilidad de evitar parametrizar la geometría y, por tanto, reducir el coste computacional del proceso de optimización es la característica más significativa de los métodos adjuntos, mientras que en el caso de los algoritmos genéticos se destaca la simplicidad y capacidad de encontrar un óptimo global en un espacio de diseño multi-modal o de resolver problemas multi-objetivo. El caso de viento lateral en campo abierto considera nuevamente los dos métoxi dos de optimización anteriores. La parametrización se ha simplificado en este estudio, lo que notablemente reduce el coste numérico de todo el estudio de optimización, a la vez que aún recoge las características geométricas más relevantes en un tren de alta velocidad. Este análisis ha permitido identificar y cuantificar la influencia de cada uno de los parámetros geométricos incluídos en la parametrización, y se ha observado que el diseño de la arista superior a barlovento es fundamental, siendo su influencia mayor que la longitud del testero o que la sección frontal del mismo. Finalmente, se ha considerado un escenario más a fin de validar estos métodos y su capacidad de encontrar un óptimo global. La entrada de un tren de alta velocidad en un túnel es uno de los casos más exigentes para un tren por el pico de sobrepresión generado, el cual afecta a la confortabilidad del pasajero, así como a la estabilidad del vehículo y al entorno próximo a la salida del túnel. Además de este problema, otro objetivo a minimizar es la resistencia aerodinámica, notablemente superior al caso de campo abierto. Este problema se resuelve usando algoritmos genéticos. Dicho método permite obtener un frente de Pareto donde se incluyen el conjunto de óptimos que minimizan ambos objetivos. ABSTRACT Aerodynamic design of trains influences several aspects of high-speed trains performance in a very significant level. In this situation, considering also that new aerodynamic problems have arisen due to the increase of the cruise speed and lightness of the vehicle, it is evident the necessity of proposing an optimization study concerning the train aerodynamics. Thus, the aerodynamic optimization of the nose shape of a high-speed train is presented in this thesis. This optimization is based on advanced optimization methods. Among these methods, genetic algorithms and the adjoint method have been selected. A theoretical description of their bases, the characteristics and the implementation of each method is detailed in this thesis. This introduction permits understanding the causes of their selection, and the advantages and drawbacks of their application. The genetic algorithms requirethe geometrical parameterization of any optimal candidate and the generation of a metamodel or surrogate model that complete the optimization process. These points are addressed with a special attention in the first block of the thesis, focused on the methodology considered in this study. The second block is referred to the use of these methods with the purpose of optimizing the aerodynamic performance of a high-speed train in several scenarios. These scenarios englobe the most representative operating conditions of high-speed trains, and also some of the most exigent train aerodynamic problems: front wind and cross-wind situations in open air, and the entrance of a high-speed train in a tunnel. The genetic algorithms and the adjoint method have been applied in the minimization of the aerodynamic drag on the train with front wind in open air. The comparison of these methods allows to evaluate the methdology and computational cost of each one, as well as the resulting minimization of the aerodynamic drag. Simplicity and robustness, the straightforward realization of a multi-objective optimization, and the capability of searching a global optimum are the main attributes of genetic algorithm. However, the requirement of geometrically parameterize any optimal candidate is a significant drawback that is avoided with the use of the adjoint method. This independence of the number of design variables leads to a relevant reduction of the pre-processing and computational cost. Considering the cross-wind stability, both methods are used again for the minimization of the side force. In this case, a simplification of the geometric parameterization of the train nose is adopted, what dramatically reduces the computational cost of the optimization process. Nevertheless, some of the most important geometrical characteristics are still described with this simplified parameterization. This analysis identifies and quantifies the influence of each design variable on the side force on the train. It is observed that the A-pillar roundness is the most demanding design parameter, with a more important effect than the nose length or the train cross-section area. Finally, a third scenario is considered for the validation of these methods in the aerodynamic optimization of a high-speed train. The entrance of a train in a tunnel is one of the most exigent train aerodynamic problems. The aerodynamic consequences of high-speed trains running in a tunnel are basically resumed in two correlated phenomena, the generation of pressure waves and an increase in aerodynamic drag. This multi-objective optimization problem is solved with genetic algorithms. The result is a Pareto front where a set of optimal solutions that minimize both objectives.

Aerodynamic study of a blended wing body, comparison with a conventional transport airplane.

Blended-wing-body (BWB) aircraft are being studied with interest and effort to improve economic efficiency and to overcome operational and infrastructure related problems associated to the increasing size of conventional transport airplanes. The objective of the research reported here is to assess the aerodynamic feasibility and operational efficiency of a great size, blended wing body layout, a configuration which has many advantages. To this end, the conceptual aerodynamic design process of an 800 seat BWB has been done completed with a comparison of performance and operational issues with last generation of conventional very large aircraft. The results are greatly encouraging and predict about 20 percent increase in transport productivity efficiency, without the burden of new or aggravated safety or operational problems.

Aerodynamic Optimization of High-Speed Trains Nose using a Genetic Algorithm and Artificial Neural Network

An aerodynamic optimization of the train aerodynamic characteristics in term of front wind action sensitivity is carried out in this paper. In particular, a genetic algorithm (GA) is used to perform a shape optimization study of a high-speed train nose. The nose is parametrically defined via Bézier Curves, including a wider range of geometries in the design space as possible optimal solutions. Using a GA, the main disadvantage to deal with is the large number of evaluations need before finding such optimal. Here it is proposed the use of metamodels to replace Navier-Stokes solver. Among all the posibilities, Rsponse Surface Models and Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) are considered. Best results of prediction and generalization are obtained with ANN and those are applied in GA code. The paper shows the feasibility of using GA in combination with ANN for this problem, and solutions achieved are included.

Aerodynamic optimization of the ICE2 high-speed train nose using a genetic algorithm and metamodels

An aerodynamic optimization of the ICE 2 high-speed train nose in term of front wind action sensitivity is carried out in this paper. The nose is parametrically defined by Be?zier Curves, and a three-dimensional representation of the nose is obtained using thirty one design variables. This implies a more complete parametrization, allowing the representation of a real model. In order to perform this study a genetic algorithm (GA) is used. Using a GA involves a large number of evaluations before finding such optimal. Hence it is proposed the use of metamodels or surrogate models to replace Navier-Stokes solver and speed up the optimization process. Adaptive sampling is considered to optimize surrogate model fitting and minimize computational cost when dealing with a very large number of design parameters. The paper introduces the feasi- bility of using GA in combination with metamodels for real high-speed train geometry optimization.

Multi-objective Aerodynamic Optimization of High-speed Trains in Tunnels

A genetic algorithm (GA) is employed for the multi-objective shape optimization of the nose of a high-speed train. Aerodynamic problems observed at high speeds become still more relevant when traveling along a tunnel. The objective is to minimize both the aerodynamic drag and the amplitude of the pressure gradient of the compression wave when a train enters a tunnel. The main drawback of GA is the large number of evaluations need in the optimization process. Metamodels-based optimization is considered to overcome such problem. As a result, an explicit relationship between pressure gradient and geometrical parameters is obtained.

Aerodynamic Analysis of Cup Anemometers Performance: The Stationary Harmonic Response

The effect of cup anemometer shape parameters, such as the cups’ shape, their size, and their center rotation radius, was experimentally analyzed.This analysis was based on both the calibration constants of the transfer function and the most important harmonic termof the rotor’smovement,which due to the cup anemometer design is the third one.This harmonic analysis represents a new approach to study cup anemometer performances. The results clearly showed a good correlation between the average rotational speed of the anemometer’s rotor and the mentioned third harmonic term of its movement.

Probabilistic approach for longitudinal ventilation system design in fire situations

The main objective of ventilation systems in tunnels is to reach the highest possible safety level both in service and fire situation; being the fire one, the most relevant when designing the system. When designing a longitudinal ventilation system, the methodology to evaluate the capacity of the system is similar both in service and fire situation, with the exception of the chimney effect and the phenomena of thermal transfer which is responsible or the changes in the density of the air. When facing the dimensioning task for longitudinal ventilated tunnels, although similar methodologies are used in different countries, specific hypothesis (aerodynamic, thermal properties, traffic) even if discussed in the literature or current practice, are not usually detailed in the regulations or recommendations. The aim of this paper is to propose a probabilistic approach to the problem which would allow the designer, and the tunnel owner, to understand the uncertainty and sensibility adopted in the results and, eventually, identify possible ways of optimizing the ventilation solution to be adopted.

Aerodynamic loads on bluff bodies under wind gusts

Esta tesis doctoral se ha centrado en el estudio de las cargas aerodinámicas no estacionario en romos cuerpos o no aerodinámicos (bluff bodies). Con este objetivo se han identificado y analizado los siguientes puntos: -Caracterización del flujo medido con diferentes tipos de tubos de Pitot y anemómetro de hilo caliente en condiciones de flujo no estacionario inestable generado por un túnel aerodinamico de ráfagas. -Diseño e integración de los montajes experimentales requeridos para medir las cargas de viento internas y externas que actúan sobre los cuerpos romos en condiciones de flujo de viento con ráfagas. -Implementación de modelos matemáticos semi-empíricos basados en flujo potencial y las teorías fenomenológicas pertinentes para simular los resultados experimentales. -En diversan condiciones de flujo con ráfagas, la identificación y el análisis de la influencia de los parámetros obtenida a partir de los modelos teóricos desarrollados. -Se proponen estimaciones empíricas para averiguar los valores adecuados de los parámetros que influyente, mediante el ajuste de los resultados experimentales y los predichos teóricamente. Los montajes experimentales se has reakizado en un tunel aerodinamico de circuito abierto, provisto de baja velocidad, cámara de ensayes cerrada, un nuevo concepto de mecanismo generador de ráfaga sinusoidal, diseñado y construido en el Instituto de Microgravedad "Ignacio Da Riva" de la Universidad Politécnica de Madrid, (IDR / UPM). La principal característica de este túnel aerodynamico es la capacidad de generar un flujo con un perfil de velocidad uniforme y una fluctuación sinusoidal en el tiempo. Se han realizado pruebas experimentales para estudiar el efecto de los flujos no estacionarios en cuerpos romos situados en el suelo. Se han propuesto dos modelos teóricos para diterminar las cargas de presión externas e internas respectivamente. Con el fin de satisfacer la necesidad de la crea ráfagas de viento sinusoidales para comprobar las predicciones de los modelos teóricos, se han obtenido velocidades de hasta 30 m/s y frecuencias ráfaga de hasta 10 Hz. La sección de la cámara de ensayos es de 0,39 m x 0,54 m, dimensiónes adecuadas para llevar a cabo experimentos con modelos de ensayos. Se muestra que en la gama de parámetros explorados los resultados experimentales están en buen acuerdo con las predicciones de los modelos teóricos. Se han realizado pruebas experimentales para estudiar los efectos del flujo no estacionario, las cuales pueden ayudar a aclarar el fenómeno de las cargas de presión externa sobre los cuerpos romos sometidos a ráfagas de viento: y tambien para determinan las cargas de presión interna, que dependen del tamaño de los orificios de ventilación de la construcción. Por último, se ha analizado la contribución de los términos provenientes del flujo no estacionario, y se han caracterizado o los saltos de presión debido a la pérdida no estacionario de presión a través de los orificios de ventilación. ABSTRACT This Doctoral dissertation has been focused to study the unsteady aerodynamic loads on bluff bodies. To this aim the following points have been identified and analyzed: -Characterization of the flow measured with different types of Pitot tubes and hot wire anemometer at unsteady flow conditions generated by a gust wind tunnel. -Design and integrating of the experimental setups required to measure the internal and external wind loads acting on bluff bodies at gusty wind flow conditions. -Implementation of semi-empirical mathematical models based on potential flow and relevant phenomenological theories to simulate the experimental results.-At various gusty flow conditions, extracting and analyzing the influence of parameters obtained from the developed theoretical models. -Empirical estimations are proposed to find out suitable values of the influencing parameters, by fitting the experimental and theoretically predicted results. The experimental setups are performed in an open circuit, closed test section, low speed wind tunnel, with a new sinusoidal gust generator mechanism concept, designed and built at the Instituto de Microgravedad “Ignacio Da Riva” of the Universidad Politécnica de Madrid, (IDR/UPM). The main characteristic of this wind tunnel is the ability to generate a flow with a uniform velocity profile and a sinusoidal time fluctuation of the speed. Experimental tests have been devoted to study the effect of unsteady flows on bluff bodies lying on the ground. Two theoretical models have been proposed to measure the external and internal pressure loads respectively. In order to meet the need of creating sinusoidal wind gusts to check the theoretical model predictions, the gust wind tunnel maximum flow speed and, gust frequency in the test section have been limited to 30 m/s and 10 Hz, respectively have been obtained. The test section is 0.39 m × 0.54 m, which is suitable to perform experiments with testing models. It is shown that, in the range of parameters explored, the experimental results are in good agreement with the theoretical model predictions. Experimental tests have been performed to study the unsteady flow effects, which can help in clarifying the phenomenon of the external pressure loads on bluff bodies under gusty winds: and also to study internal pressure loads, which depend on the size of the venting holes of the building. Finally, the contribution of the unsteady flow terms in the theoretical model has been analyzed, and the pressure jumps due to the unsteady pressure losses through the venting holes have been characterized.

Genetically aerodynamic optimization of the nose shape of a high-speed train entering a tunnel

The optimization of the nose shape of a high-speed train entering a tunnel has been performed using genetic algorithms(GA).This optimization method requires the parameterization of each optimal candidate as a design vector.The geometrical parameterization of the nose has been defined using three design variables that include the most characteristic geometrical factors affecting the compression wave generated at the entry of the train and the aerodynamic drag of the train.

Aerodynamic shape optimization of the nose of a high-speed train subjected to crosswind conditions

When dealing with the design of a high-speed train, a multiobjective shape optimization problem is formulated, as these vehicles are object of many aerodynamic problems which are known to be in conflict. More mobility involves an increase in both the cruise speed and lightness, and these requirements directly influence the stability and the ride comfort of the passengers when the train is subjected to a side wind. Thus, crosswind stability plays a more relevant role among the aerodynamic objectives to be optimized. An extensive research activity is observed on aerodynamic response in crosswind conditions.

Aerodynamic Optimization of a High-speed Train using Genetic Algorithms

Genetic algorithms (GA) have been used for the minimization of the aerodynamic drag of a train subject to front wind. The significant importance of the external aerodynamic drag on the total resistance a train experiments as the cruise speed is increased highlights the interest of this study. A complete description of the methodology required for this optimization method is introduced here, where the parameterization of the geometry to be optimized and the metamodel used to speed up the optimization process are detailed. A reduction of about a 25% of the initial aerodynamic drag is obtained in this study, what confirms GA as a proper method for this optimization problem. The evolution of the nose shape is consistent with the literature. The advantage of using metamodels is stressed thanks to the information of the whole design space extracted from it. The influence of each design variable on the objective function is analyzed by means of an ANOVA test.

Optimization of the Integrated Guidance and Control for a Dual Aerodynamic Control Missile

Las futuras misiones para misiles aire-aire operando dentro de la atmósfera requieren la interceptación de blancos a mayores velocidades y más maniobrables, incluyendo los esperados vehículos aéreos de combate no tripulados. La intercepción tiene que lograrse desde cualquier ángulo de lanzamiento. Una de las principales discusiones en la tecnología de misiles en la actualidad es cómo satisfacer estos nuevos requisitos incrementando la capacidad de maniobra del misil y en paralelo, a través de mejoras en los métodos de guiado y control modernos. Esta Tesis aborda estos dos objetivos simultáneamente, al proponer un diseño integrando el guiado y el control de vuelo (autopiloto) y aplicarlo a misiles con control aerodinámico simultáneo en canard y cola. Un primer avance de los resultados obtenidos ha sido publicado recientemente en el Journal of Aerospace Engineering, en Abril de 2015, [Ibarrondo y Sanz-Aranguez, 2015]. El valor del diseño integrado obtenido es que permite al misil cumplir con los requisitos operacionales mencionados empleando únicamente control aerodinámico. El diseño propuesto se compara favorablemente con esquemas más tradicionales, consiguiendo menores distancias de paso al blanco y necesitando de menores esfuerzos de control incluso en presencia de ruidos. En esta Tesis se demostrará cómo la introducción del doble mando, donde tanto el canard como las aletas de cola son móviles, puede mejorar las actuaciones de un misil existente. Comparado con un misil con control en cola, el doble control requiere sólo introducir dos servos adicionales para accionar los canards también en guiñada y cabeceo. La sección de cola será responsable de controlar el misil en balanceo mediante deflexiones diferenciales de los controles. En el caso del doble mando, la complicación añadida es que los vórtices desprendidos de los canards se propagan corriente abajo y pueden incidir sobre las superficies de cola, alterando sus características de control. Como un primer aporte, se ha desarrollado un modelo analítico completo para la aerodinámica no lineal de un misil con doble control, incluyendo la caracterización de este efecto de acoplamiento aerodinámico. Hay dos modos de funcionamiento en picado y guiñada para un misil de doble mando: ”desviación” y ”opuesto”. En modo ”desviación”, los controles actúan en la misma dirección, generando un cambio inmediato en la sustentación y produciendo un movimiento de translación en el misil. La respuesta es rápida, pero en el modo ”desviación” los misiles con doble control pueden tener dificultades para alcanzar grandes ángulos de ataque y altas aceleraciones laterales. Cuando los controles actúan en direcciones opuestas, el misil rota y el ángulo de ataque del fuselaje se incrementa para generar mayores aceleraciones en estado estacionario, aunque el tiempo de respuesta es mayor. Con el modelo aerodinámico completo, es posible obtener una parametrización dependiente de los estados de la dinámica de corto periodo del misil. Debido al efecto de acoplamiento entre los controles, la respuesta en bucle abierto no depende linealmente de los controles. El autopiloto se optimiza para obtener la maniobra requerida por la ley de guiado sin exceder ninguno de los límites aerodinámicos o mecánicos del misil. Una segunda contribución de la tesis es el desarrollo de un autopiloto con múltiples entradas de control y que integra la aerodinámica no lineal, controlando los tres canales de picado, guiñada y cabeceo de forma simultánea. Las ganancias del autopiloto dependen de los estados del misil y se calculan a cada paso de integración mediante la resolución de una ecuación de Riccati de orden 21x21. Las ganancias obtenidas son sub-óptimas, debido a que una solución completa de la ecuación de Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman no puede obtenerse de manera práctica, y se asumen ciertas simplificaciones. Se incorpora asimismo un mecanismo que permite acelerar la respuesta en caso necesario. Como parte del autopiloto, se define una estrategia para repartir el esfuerzo de control entre el canard y la cola. Esto se consigue mediante un controlador aumentado situado antes del bucle de optimización, que minimiza el esfuerzo total de control para maniobrar. Esta ley de alimentación directa mantiene al misil cerca de sus condiciones de equilibrio, garantizando una respuesta transitoria adecuada. El controlador no lineal elimina la respuesta de fase no-mínima característica de la cola. En esta Tesis se consideran dos diseños para el guiado y control, el control en Doble-Lazo y el control Integrado. En la aproximación de Doble-Lazo, el autopiloto se sitúa dentro de un bucle interior y se diseña independientemente del guiado, que conforma el bucle más exterior del control. Esta estructura asume que existe separación espectral entre los dos, esto es, que los tiempos de respuesta del autopiloto son mucho mayores que los tiempos característicos del guiado. En el estudio se combina el autopiloto desarrollado con una ley de guiado óptimo. Los resultados obtenidos demuestran que se consiguen aumentos muy importantes en las actuaciones frente a misiles con control canard o control en cola, y que la interceptación, cuando se lanza cerca del curso de colisión, se consigue desde cualquier ángulo alrededor del blanco. Para el misil de doble mando, la estrategia óptima resulta en utilizar el modo de control opuesto en la aproximación al blanco y utilizar el modo de desviación justo antes del impacto. Sin embargo la lógica de doble bucle no consigue el impacto cuando hay desviaciones importantes con respecto al curso de colisión. Una de las razones es que parte de la demanda de guiado se pierde, ya que el misil solo es capaz de modificar su aceleración lateral, y no tiene control sobre su aceleración axial, a no ser que incorpore un motor de empuje regulable. La hipótesis de separación mencionada, y que constituye la base del Doble-Bucle, puede no ser aplicable cuando la dinámica del misil es muy alta en las proximidades del blanco. Si se combinan el guiado y el autopiloto en un único bucle, la información de los estados del misil está disponible para el cálculo de la ley de guiado, y puede calcularse la estrategia optima de guiado considerando las capacidades y la actitud del misil. Una tercera contribución de la Tesis es la resolución de este segundo diseño, la integración no lineal del guiado y del autopiloto (IGA) para el misil de doble control. Aproximaciones anteriores en la literatura han planteado este sistema en ejes cuerpo, resultando en un sistema muy inestable debido al bajo amortiguamiento del misil en cabeceo y guiñada. Las simplificaciones que se tomaron también causan que el misil se deslice alrededor del blanco y no consiga la intercepción. En nuestra aproximación el problema se plantea en ejes inerciales y se recurre a la dinámica de los cuaterniones, eliminado estos inconvenientes. No se limita a la dinámica de corto periodo del misil, porque se construye incluyendo de modo explícito la velocidad dentro del bucle de optimización. La formulación resultante en el IGA es independiente de la maniobra del blanco, que sin embargo se ha de incluir en el cálculo del modelo en Doble-bucle. Un típico inconveniente de los sistemas integrados con controlador proporcional, es el problema de las escalas. Los errores de guiado dominan sobre los errores de posición del misil y saturan el controlador, provocando la pérdida del misil. Este problema se ha tratado aquí con un controlador aumentado previo al bucle de optimización, que define un estado de equilibrio local para el sistema integrado, que pasa a actuar como un regulador. Los criterios de actuaciones para el IGA son los mismos que para el sistema de Doble-Bucle. Sin embargo el problema matemático resultante es muy complejo. El problema óptimo para tiempo finito resulta en una ecuación diferencial de Riccati con condiciones terminales, que no puede resolverse. Mediante un cambio de variable y la introducción de una matriz de transición, este problema se transforma en una ecuación diferencial de Lyapunov que puede resolverse mediante métodos numéricos. La solución resultante solo es aplicable en un entorno cercano del blanco. Cuando la distancia entre misil y blanco es mayor, se desarrolla una solución aproximada basada en la solución de una ecuación algebraica de Riccati para cada paso de integración. Los resultados que se han obtenido demuestran, a través de análisis numéricos en distintos escenarios, que la solución integrada es mejor que el sistema de Doble-Bucle. Las trayectorias resultantes son muy distintas. El IGA preserva el guiado del misil y consigue maximizar el uso de la propulsión, consiguiendo la interceptación del blanco en menores tiempos de vuelo. El sistema es capaz de lograr el impacto donde el Doble-Bucle falla, y además requiere un orden menos de magnitud en la cantidad de cálculos necesarios. El efecto de los ruidos radar, datos discretos y errores del radomo se investigan. El IGA es más robusto, resultando menos afectado por perturbaciones que el Doble- Bucle, especialmente porque el núcleo de optimización en el IGA es independiente de la maniobra del blanco. La estimación de la maniobra del blanco es siempre imprecisa y contaminada por ruido, y degrada la precisión de la solución de Doble-Bucle. Finalmente, como una cuarta contribución, se demuestra que el misil con guiado IGA es capaz de realizar una maniobra de defensa contra un blanco que ataque por su cola, sólo con control aerodinámico. Las trayectorias estudiadas consideran una fase pre-programada de alta velocidad de giro, manteniendo siempre el misil dentro de su envuelta de vuelo. Este procedimiento no necesita recurrir a soluciones técnicamente más complejas como el control vectorial del empuje o control por chorro para ejecutar esta maniobra. En todas las demostraciones matemáticas se utiliza el producto de Kronecker como una herramienta practica para manejar las parametrizaciones dependientes de variables, que resultan en matrices de grandes dimensiones. ABSTRACT Future missions for air to air endo-atmospheric missiles require the interception of targets with higher speeds and more maneuverable, including forthcoming unmanned supersonic combat vehicles. The interception will need to be achieved from any angle and off-boresight launch conditions. One of the most significant discussions in missile technology today is how to satisfy these new operational requirements by increasing missile maneuvering capabilities and in parallel, through the development of more advanced guidance and control methods. This Thesis addresses these two objectives by proposing a novel optimal integrated guidance and autopilot design scheme, applicable to more maneuverable missiles with forward and rearward aerodynamic controls. A first insight of these results have been recently published in the Journal of Aerospace Engineering in April 2015, [Ibarrondo and Sanz-Aránguez, 2015]. The value of this integrated solution is that it allows the missile to comply with the aforementioned requirements only by applying aerodynamic control. The proposed design is compared against more traditional guidance and control approaches with positive results, achieving reduced control efforts and lower miss distances with the integrated logic even in the presence of noises. In this Thesis it will be demonstrated how the dual control missile, where canard and tail fins are both movable, can enhance the capabilities of an existing missile airframe. Compared to a tail missile, dual control only requires two additional servos to actuate the canards in pitch and yaw. The tail section will be responsible to maintain the missile stabilized in roll, like in a classic tail missile. The additional complexity is that the vortices shed from the canard propagate downstream where they interact with the tail surfaces, altering the tail expected control characteristics. These aerodynamic phenomena must be properly described, as a preliminary step, with high enough precision for advanced guidance and control studies. As a first contribution we have developed a full analytical model of the nonlinear aerodynamics of a missile with dual control, including the characterization of this cross-control coupling effect. This development has been produced from a theoretical model validated with reliable practical data obtained from wind tunnel experiments available in the scientific literature, complement with computer fluid dynamics and semi-experimental methods. There are two modes of operating a missile with forward and rear controls, ”divert” and ”opposite” modes. In divert mode, controls are deflected in the same direction, generating an increment in direct lift and missile translation. Response is fast, but in this mode, dual control missiles may have difficulties in achieving large angles of attack and high level of lateral accelerations. When controls are deflected in opposite directions (opposite mode) the missile airframe rotates and the body angle of attack is increased to generate greater accelerations in steady-state, although the response time is larger. With the aero-model, a state dependent parametrization of the dual control missile short term dynamics can be obtained. Due to the cross-coupling effect, the open loop dynamics for the dual control missile is not linearly dependent of the fin positions. The short term missile dynamics are blended with the servo system to obtain an extended autopilot model, where the response is linear with the control fins turning rates, that will be the control variables. The flight control loop is optimized to achieve the maneuver required by the guidance law without exceeding any of the missile aerodynamic or mechanical limitations. The specific aero-limitations and relevant performance indicators for the dual control are set as part of the analysis. A second contribution of this Thesis is the development of a step-tracking multi-input autopilot that integrates non-linear aerodynamics. The designed dual control missile autopilot is a full three dimensional autopilot, where roll, pitch and yaw are integrated, calculating command inputs simultaneously. The autopilot control gains are state dependent, and calculated at each integration step solving a matrix Riccati equation of order 21x21. The resulting gains are sub-optimal as a full solution for the Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equation cannot be resolved in practical terms and some simplifications are taken. Acceleration mechanisms with an λ-shift is incorporated in the design. As part of the autopilot, a strategy is defined for proper allocation of control effort between canard and tail channels. This is achieved with an augmented feed forward controller that minimizes the total control effort of the missile to maneuver. The feedforward law also maintains the missile near trim conditions, obtaining a well manner response of the missile. The nonlinear controller proves to eliminate the non-minimum phase effect of the tail. Two guidance and control designs have been considered in this Thesis: the Two- Loop and the Integrated approaches. In the Two-Loop approach, the autopilot is placed in an inner loop and designed separately from an outer guidance loop. This structure assumes that spectral separation holds, meaning that the autopilot response times are much higher than the guidance command updates. The developed nonlinear autopilot is linked in the study to an optimal guidance law. Simulations are carried on launching close to collision course against supersonic and highly maneuver targets. Results demonstrate a large boost in performance provided by the dual control versus more traditional canard and tail missiles, where interception with the dual control close to collision course is achieved form 365deg all around the target. It is shown that for the dual control missile the optimal flight strategy results in using opposite control in its approach to target and quick corrections with divert just before impact. However the Two-Loop logic fails to achieve target interception when there are large deviations initially from collision course. One of the reasons is that part of the guidance command is not followed, because the missile is not able to control its axial acceleration without a throttleable engine. Also the separation hypothesis may not be applicable for a high dynamic vehicle like a dual control missile approaching a maneuvering target. If the guidance and autopilot are combined into a single loop, the guidance law will have information of the missile states and could calculate the most optimal approach to the target considering the actual capabilities and attitude of the missile. A third contribution of this Thesis is the resolution of the mentioned second design, the non-linear integrated guidance and autopilot (IGA) problem for the dual control missile. Previous approaches in the literature have posed the problem in body axes, resulting in high unstable behavior due to the low damping of the missile, and have also caused the missile to slide around the target and not actually hitting it. The IGA system is posed here in inertial axes and quaternion dynamics, eliminating these inconveniences. It is not restricted to the missile short term dynamic, and we have explicitly included the missile speed as a state variable. The IGA formulation is also independent of the target maneuver model that is explicitly included in the Two-loop optimal guidance law model. A typical problem of the integrated systems with a proportional control law is the problem of scales. The guidance errors are larger than missile state errors during most of the flight and result in high gains, control saturation and loss of control. It has been addressed here with an integrated feedforward controller that defines a local equilibrium state at each flight point and the controller acts as a regulator to minimize the IGA states excursions versus the defined feedforward state. The performance criteria for the IGA are the same as in the Two-Loop case. However the resulting optimization problem is mathematically very complex. The optimal problem in a finite-time horizon results in an irresoluble state dependent differential Riccati equation with terminal conditions. With a change of variable and the introduction of a transition matrix, the equation is transformed into a time differential Lyapunov equation that can be solved with known numerical methods in real time. This solution results range limited, and applicable when the missile is in a close neighborhood of the target. For larger ranges, an approximate solution is used, obtained from solution of an algebraic matrix Riccati equation at each integration step. The results obtained show, by mean of several comparative numerical tests in diverse homing scenarios, than the integrated approach is a better solution that the Two- Loop scheme. Trajectories obtained are very different in the two cases. The IGA fully preserves the guidance command and it is able to maximize the utilization of the missile propulsion system, achieving interception with lower miss distances and in lower flight times. The IGA can achieve interception against off-boresight targets where the Two- Loop was not able to success. As an additional advantage, the IGA also requires one order of magnitude less calculations than the Two-Loop solution. The effects of radar noises, discrete radar data and radome errors are investigated. IGA solution is robust, and less affected by radar than the Two-Loop, especially because the target maneuvers are not part of the IGA core optimization loop. Estimation of target acceleration is always imprecise and noisy and degrade the performance of the two-Loop solution. The IGA trajectories are such that minimize the impact of radome errors in the guidance loop. Finally, as a fourth contribution, it is demonstrated that the missile with IGA guidance is capable of performing a defense against attacks from its rear hemisphere, as a tail attack, only with aerodynamic control. The studied trajectories have a preprogrammed high rate turn maneuver, maintaining the missile within its controllable envelope. This solution does not recur to more complex features in service today, like vector control of the missile thrust or side thrusters. In all the mathematical treatments and demonstrations, the Kronecker product has been introduced as a practical tool to handle the state dependent parametrizations that have resulted in very high order matrix equations.

NURBS-Based Geometry Parameterization for Aerodynamic Shape Optimization

La motivación de esta tesis es el desarrollo de una herramienta de optimización automática para la mejora del rendimiento de formas aerodinámicas enfocado en la industria aeronáutica. Este trabajo cubre varios aspectos esenciales, desde el empleo de Non-Uniform Rational B-Splines (NURBS), al cálculo de gradientes utilizando la metodología del adjunto continuo, el uso de b-splines volumétricas como parámetros de diseño, el tratamiento de la malla en las intersecciones, y no menos importante, la adaptación de los algoritmos de la dinámica de fluidos computacional (CFD) en arquitecturas hardware de alto paralelismo, como las tarjetas gráficas, para acelerar el proceso de optimización. La metodología adjunta ha posibilitado que los métodos de optimización basados en gradientes sean una alternativa prometedora para la mejora de la eficiencia aerodinámica de los aviones. La formulación del adjunto permite calcular los gradientes de una función de coste, como la resistencia aerodinámica o la sustentación, independientemente del número de variables de diseño, a un coste computacional equivalente a una simulación CFD. Sin embargo, existen problemas prácticos que han imposibilitado su aplicación en la industria, que se pueden resumir en: integrabilidad, rendimiento computacional y robustez de la solución adjunta. Este trabajo aborda estas contrariedades y las analiza en casos prácticos. Como resumen, las contribuciones de esta tesis son: • El uso de NURBS como variables de diseño en un bucle de automático de optimización, aplicado a la mejora del rendimiento aerodinámico de alas en régimen transónico. • El desarrollo de algoritmos de inversión de punto, para calcular las coordenadas paramétricas de las coordenadas espaciales, para ligar los vértices de malla a las NURBS. • El uso y validación de la formulación adjunta para el calculo de los gradientes, a partir de las sensibilidades de la solución adjunta, comparado con diferencias finitas. • Se ofrece una estrategia para utilizar la geometría CAD, en forma de parches NURBS, para tratar las intersecciones, como el ala-fuselaje. • No existen muchas alternativas de librerías NURBS viables. En este trabajo se ha desarrollado una librería, DOMINO NURBS, y se ofrece a la comunidad como código libre y abierto. • También se ha implementado un código CFD en tarjeta gráfica, para realizar una valoración de cómo se puede adaptar un código sobre malla no estructurada a arquitecturas paralelas. • Finalmente, se propone una metodología, basada en la función de Green, como una forma eficiente de paralelizar simulaciones numéricas. Esta tesis ha sido apoyada por las actividades realizadas por el Área de Dinámica da Fluidos del Instituto Nacional de Técnica Aeroespacial (INTA), a través de numerosos proyectos de financiación nacional: DOMINO, SIMUMAT, y CORESFMULAERO. También ha estado en consonancia con las actividades realizadas por el departamento de Métodos y Herramientas de Airbus España y con el grupo Investigación y Tecnología Aeronáutica Europeo (GARTEUR), AG/52. ABSTRACT The motivation of this work is the development of an automatic optimization strategy for large scale shape optimization problems that arise in the aeronautics industry to improve the aerodynamic performance; covering several aspects from the use of Non-Uniform Rational B-Splines (NURBS), the calculation of the gradients with the continuous adjoint formulation, the development of volumetric b-splines parameterization, mesh adaptation and intersection handling, to the adaptation of Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) algorithms to take advantage of highly parallel architectures in order to speed up the optimization process. With the development of the adjoint formulation, gradient-based methods for aerodynamic optimization become a promising approach to improve the aerodynamic performance of aircraft designs. The adjoint methodology allows the evaluation the gradients to all design variables of a cost function, such as drag or lift, at the equivalent cost of more or less one CFD simulation. However, some practical problems have been delaying its full implementation to the industry, which can be summarized as: integrability, computer performance, and adjoint robustness. This work tackles some of these issues and analyse them in well-known test cases. As summary, the contributions comprises: • The employment of NURBS as design variables in an automatic optimization loop for the improvement of the aerodynamic performance of aircraft wings in transonic regimen. • The development of point inversion algorithms to calculate the NURBS parametric coordinates from the space coordinates, to link with the computational grid vertex. • The use and validation of the adjoint formulation to calculate the gradients from the surface sensitivities in an automatic optimization loop and evaluate its reliability, compared with finite differences. • This work proposes some algorithms that take advantage of the underlying CAD geometry description, in the form of NURBS patches, to handle intersections and mesh adaptations. • There are not many usable libraries for NURBS available. In this work an open source library DOMINO NURBS has been developed and is offered to the community as free, open source code. • The implementation of a transonic CFD solver from scratch in a graphic card, for an assessment of the implementability of conventional CFD solvers for unstructured grids to highly parallel architectures. • Finally, this research proposes the use of the Green's function as an efficient paralellization scheme of numerical solvers. The presented work has been supported by the activities carried out at the Fluid Dynamics branch of the National Institute for Aerospace Technology (INTA) through national founding research projects: DOMINO, SIMUMAT, and CORESIMULAERO; in line with the activities carried out by the Methods and Tools and Flight Physics department at Airbus and the Group for Aeronautical Research and Technology in Europe (GARTEUR) action group AG/52.

Aerodynamic Modelling for a Morphing Rudder

The appearance of new materials and smaller and more capable actuators enable the morphing controlled deformation of the aerodynamic shape of wing like type of structures. This contribution presents the applied aerodynamics studies of a morphing rudder for a commercial transport aircraft. The conventional rudder aerodynamics is CFD modeled and the results correlated to certification loads report. The morphing rudder CFD model predicts better aerodynamics efficiency in relation to the conventional one. This conclusion is the first step for future commercial aircraft Vertical Tail Plane weight reductions with morphing rudder implementation.