Robust control of underactuated wheeled mobile manipulators using GPI disturbance observers

This article describes the design of a linear observer–linear controller-based robust output feedback scheme for output reference trajectory tracking tasks in the case of nonlinear, multivariable, nonholonomic underactuated mobile manipulators. The proposed linear feedback scheme is based on the use of a classical linear feedback controller and suitably extended, high-gain, linear Generalized Proportional Integral (GPI) observers, thus aiding the linear feedback controllers to provide an accurate simultaneous estimation of each flat output associated phase variables and of the exogenous and perturbation inputs. This information is used in the proposed feedback controller in (a) approximate, yet close, cancelations, as lumped unstructured time-varying terms, of the influence of the highly coupled nonlinearities, and (b) the devising of proper linear output feedback control laws based on the approximate estimates of the string of phase variables associated with the flat outputs simultaneously provided by the disturbance observers. Simulations reveal the effectiveness of the proposed approach.

Performance indices for robotic manipulators: a review of the state of the art

The performance indices are important tools for motion planning and design of robot manipulators. In this paper we present a collection of some of the performance indices that have generated interest in the robotics community. These indices are four different types: kinetostatic performance indices, dynamic performance indices, indices of joint limits, and finally global performance indices. In addition, we review the strategies that have been proposed to solve the problems that occur when the units of the Jacobian matrix elements are not homogeneous. At the end of this paper, we propose a set of global performance indices that can be useful in the design of robot manipulators.

Development of Robotized Laser Welding Applications for Joining Thin Sheets

Laser Welding (LW) is more often used in manufacturing due to its advantages, such as accurate control, good repeatability, less heat input, opportunities for joining of special materials, high speed, capability to join small dimension parts etc. LW is dedicated to robotized manufacturing, and the fabrication cells are using various level of flexibility, from specialized robots to very flexible setups. This paper features several LW applications using two industrially-scaled manufacturing cells at UPM Laser Centre (CLUPM) of Polytechnical University of Madrid (Universidad Politécnica de Madrid). The one dedicated to Remote Laser Welding (RLW) of thin sheets for automotive and other sectors uses a CO2 laser of 3500 W. The second has a high flexibility, is based on a 6-axis ABB robot and a Nd:YAG laser of 3300 W, and is meant for various laser processing methods, including welding. After a short description of each cell, several LW applications experimented at CLUPM and recently implemented in industry are briefly presented: RLW of automotive coated sheets, LW of high strength automotive sheets, LW vs. laser hybrid welding (LHW) of Double Phase steel thin sheets, and LHW of thin sheets of stainless steel and carbon steel (dissimilar joints). The main technological issues overcame and the critical process parameters are pointed out. Conclusions about achievements and trends are provided.

Control of a Teleoperation System by State Convergence with Variable Time Delay

In this paper, we propose a novel control scheme for bilateral teleoperation of n degree-of-freedom (DOF) nonlinear robotic systems with time-varying communication delay. We consider that the human operator contains a constant force on the local manipulator. The local and remote manipulators are coupled using state convergence control scheme. By choosing a Lyapunov-Krasovskii functional, we show that the local-remote teleoperation system is asymptotically stable. It is also shown that, in the case of reliable communication protocols, the proposed scheme guarantees that the remote manipulator tracks the delayed trajectory of the local manipulator. The time delay of communication channel is assumed to be unknown and randomly time varying, but the upper bounds of the delay interval and the derivative of the delay are assumed to be known.

Proprioceptive force estimation and control for teleoperation in radioactive environments

A medida que se incrementa la energía de los aceleradores de partículas o iones pesados como el CERN o GSI, de los reactores de fusión como JET o ITER, u otros experimentos científicos, se va haciendo cada vez más imprescindible el uso de técnicas de manipulación remota para la interacción con el entorno sujeto a la radiación. Hasta ahora la tasa de dosis radioactiva en el CERN podía tomar valores cercanos a algunos mSv para tiempos de enfriamiento de horas, que permitían la intervención humana para tareas de mantenimiento. Durante los primeros ensayos con plasma en JET, se alcanzaban valores cercanos a los 200 μSv después de un tiempo de enfriamiento de 4 meses y ya se hacía extensivo el uso de técnicas de manipulación remota. Hay una clara tendencia al incremento de los niveles de radioactividad en el futuro en este tipo de instalaciones. Un claro ejemplo es ITER, donde se esperan valores de 450 Sv/h en el centro del toroide a los 11 días de enfriamiento o los nuevos niveles energéticos del CERN que harán necesario una apuesta por niveles de mantenimiento remotos. En estas circunstancias se enmarca esta tesis, que estudia un sistema de control bilateral basado en fuerza-posición, tratando de evitar el uso de sensores de fuerza/par, cuyo contenido electrónico los hace especialmente sensitivos en estos ambientes. El contenido de este trabajo se centra en la teleoperación de robots industriales, que debido a su reconocida solvencia y facilidad para ser adaptados a estos entornos, unido al bajo coste y alta disponibilidad, les convierte en una alternativa interesante para tareas de manipulación remota frente a costosas soluciones a medida. En primer lugar se considera el problema cinemático de teleoperación maestro-esclavo de cinemática disimilar y se desarrolla un método general para la solución del problema en el que se incluye el uso de fuerzas asistivas para guiar al operador. A continuación se explican con detalle los experimentos realizados con un robot ABB y que muestran las dificultades encontradas y recomendaciones para solventarlas. Se concluye el estudio cinemático con un método para el encaje de espacios de trabajo entre maestro y esclavo disimilares. Posteriormente se mira hacia la dinámica, estudiándose el modelado de robots con vistas a obtener un método que permita estimar las fuerzas externas que actúan sobre los mismos. Durante la caracterización del modelo dinámico, se realizan varios ensayos para tratar de encontrar un compromiso entre complejidad de cálculo y error de estimación. También se dan las claves para modelar y caracterizar robots con estructura en forma de paralelogramo y se presenta la arquitectura de control deseada. Una vez obtenido el modelo completo del esclavo, se investigan diferentes alternativas que permitan una estimación de fuerzas externas en tiempo real, minimizando las derivadas de la posición para minimizar el ruido. Se comienza utilizando observadores clásicos del estado para ir evolucionando hasta llegar al desarrollo de un observador de tipo Luenberger-Sliding cuya implementación es relativamente sencilla y sus resultados contundentes. También se analiza el uso del observador propuesto durante un control bilateral simulado en el que se compara la realimentación de fuerzas obtenida con las técnicas clásicas basadas en error de posición frente a un control basado en fuerza-posición donde la fuerza es estimada y no medida. Se comprueba como la solución propuesta da resultados comparables con las arquitecturas clásicas y sin embargo introduce una alternativa para la teleoperación de robots industriales cuya teleoperación en entornos radioactivos sería imposible de otra manera. Finalmente se analizan los problemas derivados de la aplicación práctica de la teleoperación en los escenarios mencionados anteriormente. Debido a las condiciones prohibitivas para todo equipo electrónico, los sistemas de control se deben colocar a gran distancia de los manipuladores, dando lugar a longitudes de cable de centenares de metros. En estas condiciones se crean sobretensiones en controladores basados en PWM que pueden ser destructivas para el sistema formado por control, cableado y actuador, y por tanto, han de ser eliminadas. En este trabajo se propone una solución basada en un filtro LC comercial y se prueba de forma extensiva que su inclusión no produce efectos negativos sobre el control del actuador. ABSTRACT As the energy on the particle accelerators or heavy ion accelerators such as CERN or GSI, fusion reactors such as JET or ITER, or other scientific experiments is increased, it is becoming increasingly necessary to use remote handling techniques to interact with the remote and radioactive environment. So far, the dose rate at CERN could present values near several mSv for cooling times on the range of hours, which allowed human intervention for maintenance tasks. At JET, they measured values close to 200 μSv after a cooling time of 4 months and since then, the remote handling techniques became usual. There is a clear tendency to increase the radiation levels in the future. A clear example is ITER, where values of 450 Sv/h are expected in the centre of the torus after 11 days of cooling. Also, the new energetic levels of CERN are expected to lead to a more advanced remote handling means. In these circumstances this thesis is framed, studying a bilateral control system based on force-position, trying to avoid the use of force/torque sensors, whose electronic content makes them very sensitive in these environments. The contents of this work are focused on teleoperating industrial robots, which due its well-known reliability, easiness to be adapted to these environments, cost-effectiveness and high availability, are considered as an interesting alternative to expensive custom-made solutions for remote handling tasks. Firstly, the kinematic problem of teloperating master and slave with dissimilar kinematics is analysed and a new general approach for solving this issue is presented. The solution includes using assistive forces in order to guide the human operator. Coming up next, I explain with detail the experiments accomplished with an ABB robot that show the difficulties encountered and the proposed solutions. This section is concluded with a method to match the master’s and slave’s workspaces when they present dissimilar kinematics. Later on, the research studies the dynamics, with special focus on robot modelling with the purpose of obtaining a method that allows to estimate external forces acting on them. During the characterisation of the model’s parameters, a set of tests are performed in order to get to a compromise between computational complexity and estimation error. Key points for modelling and characterising robots with a parallelogram structure are also given, and the desired control architecture is presented. Once a complete model of the slave is obtained, different alternatives for external force estimation are review to be able to predict forces in real time, minimizing the position differentiation to minimize the estimation noise. The research starts by implementing classic state observers and then it evolves towards the use of Luenberger- Sliding observers whose implementation is relatively easy and the results are convincing. I also analyse the use of proposed observer during a simulated bilateral control on which the force feedback obtained with the classic techniques based on the position error is compared versus a control architecture based on force-position, where the force is estimated instead of measured. I t is checked how the proposed solution gives results comparable with the classical techniques and however introduces an alternative method for teleoperating industrial robots whose teleoperation in radioactive environments would have been impossible in a different way. Finally, the problems originated by the practical application of teleoperation in the before mentioned scenarios are analysed. Due the prohibitive conditions for every electronic equipment, the control systems should be placed far from the manipulators. This provokes that the power cables that fed the slaves devices can present lengths of hundreds of meters. In these circumstances, overvoltage waves are developed when implementing drives based on PWM technique. The occurrence of overvoltage is very dangerous for the system composed by drive, wiring and actuator, and has to be eliminated. During this work, a solution based on commercial LC filters is proposed and it is extensively proved that its inclusion does not introduce adverse effects into the actuator’s control.

Contribución al análisis cinemático y dinámico de manipuladores paralelos

El documento presentado contiene una aproximación a algunos de los diversos problemas actuales existentes en el campo de la robótica paralela. Primeramente se hace una propuesta para el cálculo de los parámetros estructurales de los robots paralelos, mediante el desarrollo de una metodología que combina las herramientas del estudio de mecanismos con el álgebra lineal; en una segunda sección se propone la solución del problema geométrico directo a partir de la definición de ecuaciones de restricción y su respectiva solución usando métodos numéricos, así como la solución para el problema geométrico inverso; en la tercera parte se aborda el problema dinámico tanto directo como inverso y su solución a partir de una metodología basada en el método de Kane o de trabajos virtuales. Para las propuestas metodológicas expuestas se han desarrollado ejemplos de aplicación tanto teóricos como prácticos (simulaciones y pruebas físicas), donde se demuestra su alcance y desempeño, mediante su utilización en múltiples configuraciones para manipuladores paralelos, entre los que se destacan la plataforma Stewart Gough, y el 3-RRR. Todo con el objetivo de extender su aplicación en futuros trabajos de investigación en el área. ABSTRACT The document presented below provides an approach to some of the many current problems existing in the field of parallel robotics. First is maked a proposal for calculating the structural parameters of the parallel robots, through developing a methodology that combines tools to study mechanisms with the linear algebra; a second section contains a direct geometrical problem solution from the definition of constraint equations and their respective solution using numerical methods, as well as the solution to the inverse geometric problem; in the third part, both, direct and inverse dynamic problem and its solution based on methodology Kane or the method of virtual work are propossed. For each of the exposed methodological proposals they were developed examples of both theoretical and practical application (simulations and physical tests), where its scope and performance is demonstrated by its use in multiple configurations for parallel manipulators, among which stand out the platform Stewart Gough, and 3-RRR. All with the goal of extending its application in future research in the area.

Advanced Control Strategies for a 6 DoF Hydraulic Parallel Robot Based on the Dynamic Model

Nowadays robots have made their way into real applications that were prohibitive and unthinkable thirty years ago. This is mainly due to the increase in power computations and the evolution in the theoretical field of robotics and control. Even though there is plenty of information in the current literature on this topics, it is not easy to find clear concepts of how to proceed in order to design and implement a controller for a robot. In general, the design of a controller requires of a complete understanding and knowledge of the system to be controlled. Therefore, for advanced control techniques the systems must be first identified. Once again this particular objective is cumbersome and is never straight forward requiring of great expertise and some criteria must be adopted. On the other hand, the particular problem of designing a controller is even more complex when dealing with Parallel Manipulators (PM), since their closed-loop structures give rise to a highly nonlinear system. Under this basis the current work is developed, which intends to resume and gather all the concepts and experiences involve for the control of an Hydraulic Parallel Manipulator. The main objective of this thesis is to provide a guide remarking all the steps involve in the designing of advanced control technique for PMs. The analysis of the PM under study is minced up to the core of the mechanism: the hydraulic actuators. The actuators are modeled and experimental identified. Additionally, some consideration regarding traditional PID controllers are presented and an adaptive controller is finally implemented. From a macro perspective the kinematic and dynamic model of the PM are presented. Based on the model of the system and extending the adaptive controller of the actuator, a control strategy for the PM is developed and its performance is analyzed with simulation.

Desarrollo de tecnologías de telemanipulación con alto grado de escalado orientadas a la interacción hombre-robot en entornos nucleares

Esta tesis se centra en desarrollo de tecnologías para la interacción hombre-robot en entornos nucleares de fusión. La problemática principal del sector de fusión nuclear radica en las condiciones ambientales tan extremas que hay en el interior del reactor, y la necesidad de que los equipos cumplan requisitos muy restrictivos para poder aguantar esos niveles de radiación, magnetismo, ultravacío, temperatura... Como no es viable la ejecución de tareas directamente por parte de humanos, habrá que utilizar dispositivos de manipulación remota para llevar a cabo los procesos de operación y mantenimiento. En las instalaciones de ITER es obligatorio tener un entorno controlado de extrema seguridad, que necesita de estándares validados. La definición y uso de protocolos es indispensable para regir su buen funcionamiento. Si nos centramos en la telemanipulación con algo grado de escalado, surge la necesidad de definir protocolos para sistemas abiertos que permitan la interacción entre equipos y dispositivos de diversa índole. En este contexto se plantea la definición del Protocolo de Teleoperación que permita la interconexión entre dispositivos maestros y esclavos de distinta tipología, pudiéndose comunicar bilateralmente entre sí y utilizar distintos algoritmos de control según la tarea a desempeñar. Este protocolo y su interconectividad se han puesto a prueba en la Plataforma Abierta de Teleoperación (P.A.T.) que se ha desarrollado e integrado en la ETSII UPM como una herramienta que permita probar, validar y realizar experimentos de telerrobótica. Actualmente, este Protocolo de Teleoperación se ha propuesto a través de AENOR al grupo ISO de Telerobotics como una solución válida al problema existente y se encuentra bajo revisión. Con el diseño de dicho protocolo se ha conseguido enlazar maestro y esclavo, sin embargo con los niveles de radiación tan altos que hay en ITER la electrónica del controlador no puede entrar dentro del tokamak. Por ello se propone que a través de una mínima electrónica convenientemente protegida se puedan multiplexar las señales de control que van a través del cableado umbilical desde el controlador hasta la base del robot. En este ejercicio teórico se demuestra la utilidad y viabilidad de utilizar este tipo de solución para reducir el volumen y peso del cableado umbilical en cifras aproximadas de un 90%, para ello hay que desarrollar una electrónica específica y con certificación RadHard para soportar los enormes niveles de radiación de ITER. Para este manipulador de tipo genérico y con ayuda de la Plataforma Abierta de Teleoperación, se ha desarrollado un algoritmo que mediante un sensor de fuerza/par y una IMU colocados en la muñeca del robot, y convenientemente protegidos ante la radiación, permiten calcular las fuerzas e inercias que produce la carga, esto es necesario para poder transmitirle al operador unas fuerzas escaladas, y que pueda sentir la carga que manipula, y no otras fuerzas que puedan influir en el esclavo remoto, como ocurre con otras técnicas de estimación de fuerzas. Como el blindaje de los sensores no debe ser grande ni pesado, habrá que destinar este tipo de tecnología a las tareas de mantenimiento de las paradas programadas de ITER, que es cuando los niveles de radiación están en sus valores mínimos. Por otro lado para que el operador sienta lo más fielmente posible la fuerza de carga se ha desarrollado una electrónica que mediante el control en corriente de los motores permita realizar un control en fuerza a partir de la caracterización de los motores del maestro. Además para aumentar la percepción del operador se han realizado unos experimentos que demuestran que al aplicar estímulos multimodales (visuales, auditivos y hápticos) aumenta su inmersión y el rendimiento en la consecución de la tarea puesto que influyen directamente en su capacidad de respuesta. Finalmente, y en referencia a la realimentación visual del operador, en ITER se trabaja con cámaras situadas en localizaciones estratégicas, si bien el humano cuando manipula objetos hace uso de su visión binocular cambiando constantemente el punto de vista adecuándose a las necesidades visuales de cada momento durante el desarrollo de la tarea. Por ello, se ha realizado una reconstrucción tridimensional del espacio de la tarea a partir de una cámara-sensor RGB-D, lo cual nos permite obtener un punto de vista binocular virtual móvil a partir de una cámara situada en un punto fijo que se puede proyectar en un dispositivo de visualización 3D para que el operador pueda variar el punto de vista estereoscópico según sus preferencias. La correcta integración de estas tecnologías para la interacción hombre-robot en la P.A.T. ha permitido validar mediante pruebas y experimentos para verificar su utilidad en la aplicación práctica de la telemanipulación con alto grado de escalado en entornos nucleares de fusión. Abstract This thesis focuses on developing technologies for human-robot interaction in nuclear fusion environments. The main problem of nuclear fusion sector resides in such extreme environmental conditions existing in the hot-cell, leading to very restrictive requirements for equipment in order to deal with these high levels of radiation, magnetism, ultravacuum, temperature... Since it is not feasible to carry out tasks directly by humans, we must use remote handling devices for accomplishing operation and maintenance processes. In ITER facilities it is mandatory to have a controlled environment of extreme safety and security with validated standards. The definition and use of protocols is essential to govern its operation. Focusing on Remote Handling with some degree of escalation, protocols must be defined for open systems to allow interaction among different kind of equipment and several multifunctional devices. In this context, a Teleoperation Protocol definition enables interconnection between master and slave devices from different typologies, being able to communicate bilaterally one each other and using different control algorithms depending on the task to perform. This protocol and its interconnectivity have been tested in the Teleoperation Open Platform (T.O.P.) that has been developed and integrated in the ETSII UPM as a tool to test, validate and conduct experiments in Telerobotics. Currently, this protocol has been proposed for Teleoperation through AENOR to the ISO Telerobotics group as a valid solution to the existing problem, and it is under review. Master and slave connection has been achieved with this protocol design, however with such high radiation levels in ITER, the controller electronics cannot enter inside the tokamak. Therefore it is proposed a multiplexed electronic board, that through suitable and RadHard protection processes, to transmit control signals through an umbilical cable from the controller to the robot base. In this theoretical exercise the utility and feasibility of using this type of solution reduce the volume and weight of the umbilical wiring approximate 90% less, although it is necessary to develop specific electronic hardware and validate in RadHard qualifications in order to handle huge levels of ITER radiation. Using generic manipulators does not allow to implement regular sensors for force feedback in ITER conditions. In this line of research, an algorithm to calculate the forces and inertia produced by the load has been developed using a force/torque sensor and IMU, both conveniently protected against radiation and placed on the robot wrist. Scaled forces should be transmitted to the operator, feeling load forces but not other undesirable forces in slave system as those resulting from other force estimation techniques. Since shielding of the sensors should not be large and heavy, it will be necessary to allocate this type of technology for programmed maintenance periods of ITER, when radiation levels are at their lowest levels. Moreover, the operator perception needs to feel load forces as accurate as possible, so some current control electronics were developed to perform a force control of master joint motors going through a correct motor characterization. In addition to increase the perception of the operator, some experiments were conducted to demonstrate applying multimodal stimuli (visual, auditory and haptic) increases immersion and performance in achieving the task since it is directly correlated with response time. Finally, referring to the visual feedback to the operator in ITER, it is usual to work with 2D cameras in strategic locations, while humans use binocular vision in direct object manipulation, constantly changing the point of view adapting it to the visual needs for performing manipulation during task procedures. In this line a three-dimensional reconstruction of non-structured scenarios has been developed using RGB-D sensor instead of cameras in the remote environment. Thus a mobile virtual binocular point of view could be generated from a camera at a fixed point, projecting stereoscopic images in 3D display device according to operator preferences. The successful integration of these technologies for human-robot interaction in the T.O.P., and validating them through tests and experiments, verify its usefulness in practical application of high scaling remote handling at nuclear fusion environments.