A fatigue damage model for seismic response of RC structures

Numerous damage models have been developed in order to analyze seismic behavior. Among the different possibilities existing in the literature, it is very clear that models developed along the lines of continuum damage mechanics are more consistent with the definition of damage as a phenomenon with mechanical consequences because they include explicitly the coupling between damage and mechanical behavior. On the other hand, for seismic processes, phenomena such as low cycle fatigue may have a pronounced effect on the overall behavior of the frames and, therefore, its consideration turns out to be very important. However, most of existing models evaluate the damage only as a function of the maximum amplitude of cyclic deformation without considering the number of cycles. In this paper, a generalization of the simplified model proposed by Cipollina et al. [Cipollina A, López-Hinojosa A, Flórez-López J. Comput Struct 1995;54:1113–26] is made in order to include the low cycle fatigue. Such a model employs in its formulation irreversible thermodynamics and internal state variable theory.

Modelization of low cycle fatigue damage in frames

Damage models based on the Continuum Damage Mechanics (CDM) include explicitly the coupling between damage and mechanical behavior and, therefore, are consistent with the definition of damage as a phenomenon with mechanical consequences. However, this kind of models is characterized by their complexity. Using the concept of lumped models, possible simplifications of the coupled models have been proposed in the literature to adapt them to the study of beams and frames. On the other hand, in most of these coupled models damage is associated only with the damage energy release rate which is shown to be the elastic strain energy. According to this, damage is a function of the maximum amplitude of cyclic deformation but does not depend on the number of cycles. Therefore, low cycle effects are not taking into account. From the simplified model proposed by Flórez-López, it is the purpose of this paper to present a formulation that allows to take into account the degradation produced not only by the peak values but also by the cumulative effects such as the low cycle fatigue. For it, the classical damage dissipative potential based on the concept of damage energy release rate is modified using a fatigue function in order to include cumulative effects. The fatigue function is determined through parameters such as the cumulative rotation and the total rotation and the number of cycles to failure. Those parameters can be measured or identified physically through the haracteristics of the RC. So the main advantage of the proposed model is the possibility of simulating the low cycle fatigue behavior without introducing parameters with no suitable physical meaning. The good performance of the proposed model is shown through a comparison between numerical and test results under cycling loading.

A simplified model for evaluation of fatigue damage in frames

Many studies have been developed to analyze the structural seismic behavior through the damage index concept. The evaluation of this index has been employed to quantify the safety of new and existing structures and, also, to establish a framework for seismic retrofitting decision making of structures. Most proposed models are based in a posterthquake evaluation in such a way they uncouple the structural response from the damage evaluation. In this paper, a generalization of the model by Flórez-López (1995) is proposed. The formulation employs irreversible thermodynamics and internal state variable theory applied to the study of beams and frames and it allows and explicit coupling between the degradation and the structural mechanical behavior. A damage index es defined in order to model elastoplasticity coupled with damage and fatigue damage.

Fatigue damage modelling of steel structures

In the present work a constitutive model is developed which permits the simulation of the low cycle fatigue behaviour in steel framed structures. In the elaboration of this model, the concepts of the mechanics of continuum medium are applied on lumped dissipative models. In this type of formulation an explicit coupling between the damage and the structural mechanical behaviour is employed, allowing the possibility of considering as a whole different coupled phenomena. A damage index is defined in order to model elastoplasticity coupled with damage and fatigue damage.

Non contact inspection of the fatigue damage state of carbon fiber reinforced polymer by optical surface roughness measurements

This work presents the evaluation of a new non-contact technique to assess the fatigue damage state of CFRP structures by measuring surface roughness parameters. Surface roughness and stiffness degradation have been measured in CFRP coupons cycled with constant amplitude loads, and a Pearson?s correlation of 0.79 was obtained between both variables. Results suggest that changes on the surface roughness measured in strategic zones of components made of the evaluated CFRP, could be indicative of the level of damage due to fatigue loads. This methodology could be useful for other FRP due to similarities in the fatigue damage process.

Optical sensing of the fatigue damage state of CFRP under realistic aeronautical load sequences

We present an optical sensing methodology to estimate the fatigue damage state of structures made of carbon fiber reinforced polymer (CFRP), by measuring variations on the surface roughness. Variable amplitude loads (VAL), which represent realistic loads during aeronautical missions of fighter aircraft (FALSTAFF) have been applied to coupons until failure. Stiffness degradation and surface roughness variations have been measured during the life of the coupons obtaining a Pearson correlation of 0.75 between both variables. The data were compared with a previous study for Constant Amplitude Load (CAL) obtaining similar results. Conclusions suggest that the surface roughness measured in strategic zones is a useful technique for structural health monitoring of CFRP structures, and that it is independent of the type of load applied. Surface roughness can be measured in the field by optical techniques such as speckle, confocal perfilometers and interferometry, among others.

Comportamiento a fatiga por cortante de elementos lineales de hormigón armado sin cercos

Las estructuras de hormigón son susceptibles de sufrir los efectos asociados a las acciones de fatiga cuando estas se ven sometidas a un elevado número de cargas repetidas. Muchas de estas estructuras no requieren armadura transversal para cumplir los condicionantes de dimensionamiento estático como por ejemplo las losas superiores de tableros de puentes, los muros de contención, las losas de transición de puentes, las torres eólicas o las estructuras marítimas. La mayor parte de los códigos de diseño vigentes no incluyen una comprobación específica del nivel de seguridad a cortante de estas estructuras para acciones de fatiga, y aquellas que lo hacen prefieren utilizar expresiones de tipo empírico basadas en curvas S-N que relacionan el número de ciclos resistentes con el valor de la carga aplicada. A pesar de que el empleo de curvas S-N es de gran utilidad desde un punto de vista práctico, estas curvas no permiten comprender el proceso de rotura por cortante para cargas repetidas. El objetivo principal de esta Tesis es el de estudiar el comportamiento a cortante de elementos de hormigón armado sin cercos sometidos a fatiga. Además, el análisis es ampliado al estudio del comportamiento transversal de los voladizos de las losas superiores de tableros de puentes de hormigón que de forma habitual son diseñados sin armadura de cortante. De forma habitual estos elementos se diseñan atendiendo a criterios de dimensionamiento estáticos sin tener en cuenta la resistencia a cortante cuando se ven sometidos a cargas cíclicas. A pesar de que las cargas de fatiga son inferiores a aquellas que producen el fallo estático, es importante tener en cuenta el comportamiento de estos elementos ante cargas repetidas. Los trabajos experimentales existentes en vigas de hormigón armado sin cercos evidenciaron diferencias significativas entre los modos de fallo ante cargas estáticas y cíclicas. Estos trabajos llegaron a la conclusión de que estos elementos diseñados para tener un fallo dúctil por flexión pueden llegar a desarrollar un tipo de fallo frágil por cortante cuando se ven sometidos a cargas repetidas. El proceso de rotura por cortante en elementos de hormigón armado sin cercos sometidos a fatiga es un proceso complejo que debe ser estudiado en profundidad debido al carácter frágil de este tipo de fallo. Los trabajos experimentales permitieron comprobar que el origen de este fallo tiene lugar tras la formación de una fisura de cortante a partir de una fisura de flexión formada durante los primeros ciclos en el vano de cortante. Tras la formación de esta fisura, esta se va propagando hacia la cabeza de compresión hasta que finalmente se produce el fallo como consecuencia de la destrucción de la cabeza de compresión cuando la altura alcanzada por esta es insuficiente para resistir la fuerza de compresión aplicada en esta zona. Por otra parte, la propagación de esta fisura diagonal puede desarrollarse por completo en el instante en el que esta se forma derivando en un tipo de fallo por cortante más frágil que el anterior. El proceso de fatiga es estudiado en esta Tesis mediante un modelo mecánico. Por una parte, se propone un modelo predictivo para determinar el número de ciclos acumulados hasta que se forma la fisura diagonal en función del estado tensional que se tiene en la punta de una fisura crítica de flexión formada en los primeros ciclos. Por otra parte, la resistencia a fatiga tras la formación de la fisura diagonal se analiza teniendo en cuenta el daño por fatiga acumulado en la cabeza de compresión y las variables que afectan a la propagación de esta fisura de cortante. Para la evaluación de la resistencia a fatiga tras la formación de la fisura crítica de cortante en este tipo de elementos, se plantea un modelo teórico basado en conceptos de Mecánica de la Fractura adaptados al hormigón. Este modelo puede ser aplicado a vigas de hormigón armado sin cercos de canto constante o variable siguiendo diferentes procedimientos. Una campaña experimental ha sido llevada a cabo con el objetivo de estudiar el comportamiento a cortante de vigas de hormigón armado sin cercos de canto variable sometidas a cargas estáticas y de fatiga. Se han desarrollado un total de diez ensayos estáticos y de fatiga para diferentes niveles de carga y esbelteces de cortante, teniendo lugar diferentes modos de fallo. Estos elementos fueron diseñados para reproducir, a escala real y de forma simplificada, los voladizos laterales de las losas superiores de tableros de puentes de carretera de hormigón. Los resultados experimentales demostraron que el tipo de fallo desarrollado depende de varios parámetros como por ejemplo el nivel de carga máxima, el nivel de oscilación de tensiones en la armadura longitudinal, la esbeltez de cortante o la calidad del hormigón utilizado entre otros. Para valores similares de esbeltez de cortante, los ensayos de fatiga realizados permitieron comprobar que la rotura por cortante de estos elementos está asociada a niveles de carga máxima elevados, mientras que el fallo por fatiga de la armadura longitudinal tiene mayor probabilidad de ocurrir en elementos sometidos a elevados niveles de oscilación de tensiones en esta armadura. Además, estos ensayos han sido analizados a través del modelo propuesto para tratar de comprender el comportamiento resistente de estos elementos sometidos a cargas de fatiga. Concrete structures are able to suffer fatigue when they are subjected to high number of cyclic loads. Many of these need not shear reinforcement to satisfy static design requirements, such as bridge deck slabs, retaining walls, bridge approach slabs, wind towers or maritime structures among others. Many codes of practice do not include a verification of the shear fatigue safety. Moreover, those which include it still prefer empirical S-N-based approaches that provide the number of cycles as a function of applied forces. S-N models are practical but they do not provide information to understand the shear fatigue process. The main objective of this Thesis is to study shear behaviour of reinforced concrete elements without stirrups subjected to fatigue loads. In addition, the analysis is extended in order to study the transverse behaviour of cantilever slabs of concrete bridges that traditionally are designed without shear reinforcement. These elements usually are designed on the basis of static strength and it is unusual that codes consider fatigue strength of concrete in shear. Accordingly, it is important to take into account the fatigue behaviour of structural members subjected to cyclic loads although these loads are lower than those which produce the static failure. Existing experimental works show important differences between the static and cyclic failure modes of reinforced concrete beams without stirrups. These works concluded that beams without transverse reinforcement, designed to have a ductile failure mode in flexure, can submit a brittle shear failure mode when they are subjected to repeated loads. Shear fatigue failure of reinforced concrete beams without stirrups is a rather complex process from the mechanical viewpoint. Since it leads to a brittle failure mode it should be better understood. Experimental evidence indicates that a diagonal crack first develops from the inclination of flexural cracks in the shear span. Thereafter, the diagonal crack propagates into the compression zone. Failure normally takes place by the destruction of the compression zone when its depth is too small to resist the applied force. The propagation of the diagonal crack can also be instantaneous, leading to sudden diagonal cracking fatigue failure rather than shear-compression failure. Fatigue process is studied in this Thesis on a mechanical basis. On the one hand, a predictive model is derived to obtain the number of cycles up to diagonal cracking, as a function of the stress state at the tip of a critical flexural crack. On the other hand, the residual fatigue strength after diagonal cracking is analyzed taking into account the fatigue damage accumulated by the compression zone and the variables affecting the propagation of the diagonal crack. In order to assess the residual fatigue strength after diagonal cracking of such elements, a theoretical model is proposed based on concepts from fracture mechanics adapted to concrete. This model can be successfully applied for straight or haunched reinforced concrete beams without stirrups following different procedures. In order to achieve a more advanced knowledge in this subject, an experimental campaign has been carried out with the aim of study the shear behaviour of reinforced concrete haunched beams without stirrups subjected to static and fatigue loads. A total of ten static and fatigue tests have been performed with distinct load levels and shear span-to-depth ratios, presenting different failures modes. These elements were designed to reproduce in a simplified form the cantilever slab of concrete bridges at real scale. Experimental results showed that the type of failure depends on several parameters as for example the maximum load level, the stress oscillation level on the longitudinal reinforcement, the shear span-to-depth ratio or the quality of the concrete used among others. For a similar value of the shear span-to-depth ratio, tests evidenced that shear fatigue failure is related to high maximum load levels, while steel fatigue failure is easier to occur in elements subjected to high stress oscillation level on the reinforcement bars. Besides, these tests have been analyzed through the proposed model in order to clarify the structural behaviour of such elements subjected to fatigue loads.

Fatiga en CFRP: Caracterización y Método Óptico para la Estimación del Daño

El desarrollo de nuevas estructuras aeroespaciales optimizadas, utilizan materiales compuestos, para los componentes críticos y subsistemas, principalmente polímeros reforzados con fibra de carbono (CFRP). Un conocimiento profundo del estado de daño por fatiga de estructuras de CFRP avanzado, es esencial para predecir la vida residual y optimizar los intervalos de inspección estructural, reparaciones y/o sustitución de componentes. Las técnicas actuales se basan principalmente en la medición de cargas estructurales a lo largo de la vida útil de la estructura mediante galgas extensométricas eléctricas. Con esos datos, se estima la vida a fatiga utilizando modelos de acumulación de daño. En la presente tesis, se evalúa la metodología convencional para la estimación de la vida a fatiga de un CFRP aeronáutico. Esta metodología está basada en la regla de acumulación de daño lineal de Palmgren-Miner, y es aplicada para determinar la vida a fatiga de estructuras sometidas a cargas de amplitud variable. Se ha realizado una campaña de ensayos con cargas de amplitud constante para caracterizar un CFRP aeronáutico a fatiga, obteniendo las curvas clásicas S-N, en diferentes relaciones de esfuerzo. Se determinaron los diagramas de vida constante, (CLD), también conocidos como diagramas de Goodman, utilizando redes neuronales artificiales debido a la ausencia de modelos coherentes para materiales compuestos. Se ha caracterizado la degradación de la rigidez debido al daño por fatiga. Se ha ensayado un segundo grupo de probetas con secuencias estandarizadas de cargas de amplitud variable, para obtener la vida a fatiga y la degradación de rigidez en condiciones realistas. Las cargas aplicadas son representativas de misiones de aviones de combate (Falstaff), y de aviones de transporte (Twist). La vida a fatiga de las probetas cicladas con cargas de amplitud variable, se comparó con el índice de daño teórico calculado en base a la regla de acumulación de daño lineal convencional. Los resultados obtenidos muestran predicciones no conservativas. Esta tesis también presenta el estudio y desarrollo, de una nueva técnica de no contacto para evaluar el estado de daño por fatiga de estructuras de CFRP por medio de cambios de los parámetros de rugosidad. La rugosidad superficial se puede medir fácilmente en campo con métodos sin contacto, mediante técnicas ópticas tales como speckle y perfilómetros ópticos. En el presente estudio, se han medido parámetros de rugosidad superficial, y el factor de irregularidad de la superficie, a lo largo de la vida de las probetas cicladas con cargas de amplitud constante y variable, Se ha obtenido una buena tendencia de ajuste al correlacionar la magnitud de la rugosidad y el factor de irregularidad de la superficie con la degradación de la rigidez de las probetas fatigadas. Estos resultados sugieren que los cambios en la rugosidad superficial medida en zonas estratégicas de componentes y estructuras hechas de CFRP, podrían ser indicativas del nivel de daño interno debido a cargas de fatiga. Los resultados también sugieren que el método es independiente del tipo de carga de fatiga que ha causado el daño. Esto último hace que esta técnica de medición sea aplicable como inspección para una amplia gama de estructuras de materiales compuestos, desde tanques presurizados con cargas de amplitud constante, estructuras aeronáuticas como alas y colas de aeronaves cicladas con cargas de amplitud variable, hasta aplicaciones industriales como automoción, entre otros. ABSTRACT New optimized aerospace structures use composite materials, mainly carbon fiber reinforced polymer composite (CFRP), for critical components and subsystems. A strong knowledge of the fatigue state of highly advanced (CFRP) structures is essential to predict the residual life and optimize intervals of structural inspection, repairs, and/or replacements. Current techniques are based mostly on measurement of structural loads throughout the service life by electric strain gauge sensors. These sensors are affected by extreme environmental conditions and by fatigue loads in such a way that the sensors and their systems require exhaustive maintenance throughout system life. In the present thesis, the conventional methodology based on linear damage accumulation rules, applied to determine the fatigue life of structures subjected to variable amplitude loads was evaluated for an aeronautical CFRP. A test program with constant amplitude loads has been performed to obtain the classical S-N curves at different stress ratios. Constant life diagrams, CLDs, where determined by means of Artificial Neural Networks due to the absence of consistent models for composites. The stiffness degradation due to fatigue damage has been characterized for coupons under cyclic tensile loads. A second group of coupons have been tested until failure with a standardized sequence of variable amplitude loads, representative of missions for combat aircraft (Falstaff), and representative of commercial flights (Twist), to obtain the fatigue life and the stiffness degradation under realistic conditions. The fatigue life of the coupons cycled with variable amplitude loads were compared to the theoretical damage index calculated based on the conventional linear damage accumulation rule. The obtained results show non-conservative predictions. This thesis also presents the evaluation of a new non-contact technique to evaluate the fatigue damage state of CFRP structures by means of measuring roughness parameters to evaluate changes in the surface topography. Surface roughness can be measured easily on field with non-contact methods by optical techniques such as speckle and optical perfilometers. In the present study, surface roughness parameters, and the surface irregularity factor, have been measured along the life of the coupons cycled with constant and variable amplitude loads of different magnitude. A good agreement has been obtained when correlating the magnitude of the roughness and the surface irregularity factor with the stiffness degradation. These results suggest that the changes on the surface roughness measured in strategic zones of components and structures made of CFRP, could be indicative of the level of internal damage due to fatigue loads. The results also suggest that the method is independent of the type of fatigue load that have caused the damage. It makes this measurement technique applicable for a wide range of inspections of composite materials structures, from pressurized tanks with constant amplitude loads, to variable amplitude loaded aeronautical structures like wings and empennages, up to automotive and other industrial applications.

Discussion of "Simplified Model of Low Cycle Fatigue for RC Frames"

To model strength degradation due to low cycle fatigue, at least three different approaches can be considered. One possibility is based on the formulation of a new free energy function and damage energy release rate, as was proposed by Ju(1989). The second approach uses the notion of bounding surface introduced in cyclic plasticity by Dafalias and Popov (1975). From this concept, some models have been proposed to quantify damage in concrete or RC (Suaris et al. 1990). The model proposed by the author to include fatigue effects is based essentially in Marigo (1985) and can be included in this approach.

Damage tolerance of cold drawn ferritic-austenitic stainless steels wires for prestressed concrete

Damage tolerance of high strength cold-drawn ferritic–austenitic stainless steel wires is assessed by means of tensile fracture tests of cracked wires. The fatigue crack is transversally propagated from the wire surface. The damage tolerance curve of the wires results from the empirical failure load when given as a function of crack depth. As a consequence of cold drawing, the wire microstructure is orientated along its longitudinal axis and anisotropic fracture behaviour is found at macrostructural level at the tensile failure of the cracked specimens. An in situ optical technique known as video image correlation VIC-2D is used to get an insight into this failure mechanism by tensile testing transversally fatigue cracked plane specimens extracted from the cold-drawn wires. Finally, the experimentally obtained damage tolerance curve of the cold-drawn ferritic–austenitic stainless steel wires is compared with that of an elementary plastic collapse model and existing data of two types of high strength eutectoid steel currently used as prestressing steel for concrete.

A damage model for seismic retrofitting of structures

Numerous damage models have been developed in order to analyse the seismic behavior. Among the different possibilities existing in the literature, it is very clear that models developed along the lines of Continuum Damage Mechanics are more consistent with the definition of damage like a phenomenon with mechanical consequences as they include explicitly the coupling between damage and mechanical behavior. On the other hand, for seismic processes, phenomena such as low cycle fatigue may have a pronounced effect on the overall behavior of the frames and, therefore, its consideration turns out to be very important. However, many of existing models evaluate the damage only as a function of the maximum amplitude of cyclic deformation without considering the number of cycles. In this paper, a generalization of the simplified model proposed by Flórez is made in order to include the low cycle fatigue. Such model employs in its formulation irreversible thermodynamics and internal state variable theory.