Subjective quality assessment of an adaptive video streaming model

With the recent increased popularity and high usage of HTTP Adaptive Streaming (HAS) techniques, various studies have been carried out in this area which generally focused on the technical enhancement of HAS technology and applications. However, a lack of common HAS standard led to multiple proprietary approaches which have been developed by major Internet companies. In the emerging MPEG-DASH standard the packagings of the video content and HTTP syntax have been standardized; but all the details of the adaptation behavior are left to the client implementation. Nevertheless, to design an adaptation algorithm which optimizes the viewing experience of the enduser, the multimedia service providers need to know about the Quality of Experience (QoE) of different adaptation schemes. Taking this into account, the objective of this experiment was to study the QoE of a HAS-based video broadcast model. The experiment has been carried out through a subjective study of the end user response to various possible clients’ behavior for changing the video quality taking different QoE-influence factors into account. The experimental conclusions have made a good insight into the QoE of different adaptation schemes which can be exploited by HAS clients for designing the adaptation algorithms.

Quality-optimization algorithm based on stochastic dynamic programming for MPEG DASH video streaming

In contrast to traditional push-based protocols, adaptive streaming techniques like Dynamic Adaptive Streaming over HTTP (DASH) fix attention on the client, who dynamically requests different-quality portions of the content to cope with a limited and variable bandwidth but aiming at maximizing the quality perceived by the user. Since DASH adaptation logic at the client is not covered by the standard, we propose a solution based on Stochastic Dynamic Programming (SDP) techniques to find the optimal request policies that guarantee the users' Quality of Experience (QoE). Our algorithm is evaluated in a simulated streaming session and is compared with other adaptation approaches. The results show that our proposal outperforms them in terms of QoE, requesting higher qualities on average.

Quality of experience and HTTP adaptive streaming: a review of subjective studies

HTTP adaptive streaming technology has become widely spread in multimedia services because of its ability to provide adaptation to characteristics of various viewing devices and dynamic network conditions. There are various studies targeting the optimization of adaptation strategy. However, in order to provide an optimal viewing experience to the end-user, it is crucial to get knowledge about the Quality of Experience (QoE) of different adaptation schemes. This paper overviews the state of the art concerning subjective evaluation of adaptive streaming QoE and highlights the challenges and open research questions related to QoE assessment.

Crowdsourcing based subjective quality assessment of adaptive video streaming

In order to cater for user's quality of experience (QoE) requirements, HTTP adaptive streaming (HAS) based solutions of video services have become popular recently. User QoE feedback can be instrumental in improving the capabilities of such services. Perceptual quality experiments that involve humans are considered to be the most valid method of the assessment of QoE. Besides lab-based subjective experiments, crowdsourcing based subjective assessment of video quality is gaining popularity as an alternative method. This paper presents insights into a study that investigates perceptual preferences of various adaptive video streaming scenarios through crowdsourcing based subjective quality assessment.

Subjective quality study of adaptive streaming of monoscopic and stereoscopic video

Nowadays, HTTP adaptive streaming (HAS) has become a reliable distribution technology offering significant advantages in terms of both user perceived Quality of Experience (QoE) and resource utilization for content and network service providers. By trading-off the video quality, HAS is able to adapt to the available bandwidth and display requirements so that it can deliver the video content to a variety of devices over the Internet. However, until now there is not enough knowledge of how the adaptation techniques affect the end user's visual experience. Therefore, this paper presents a comparative analysis of different bitrate adaptation strategies in adaptive streaming of monoscopic and stereoscopic video. This has been done through a subjective experiment of testing the end-user response to the video quality variations, considering the visual comfort issue. The experimental outcomes have made a good insight into the factors that can influence on the QoE of different adaptation strategies.

Effect of content characteristics on quality of experience of adaptive streaming

The growing popularity of adaptive streaming-based video delivery nowadays has raised the interest about the user's perception when experiencing quality adaptation. The impact of the video content characteristics on user's perceptual quality has already become evident. The aim of this study is to investigate the influence of this factor on the quality of experience of adaptive streaming scenarios. Our results show that the perceptual quality of adaptation strategies applied on videos with high spatial and low temporal amount of activity is significantly lower compared to the other content types.

Subjective QoE Analysis of HTTP Adaptive Streaming Applications

Actualmente la optimization de la calidad de experiencia (Quality of Experience- QoE) de HTTP Adaptive Streaming (HAS) de video recibe una atención creciente. Este incremento de interés proviene fundamentalmente de las carencias de las soluciones actuales HAS, que, al no ser QoE-driven, no incluyen la percepción de la calidad de los usuarios finales como una parte integral de la lógica de adaptación. Por lo tanto, la obtención de información de referencia fiable en QoE en HAS presenta retos importantes, ya que las metodologías de evaluación subjetiva de la calidad de vídeo propuestas en las normas actuales no son adecuadas para tratar con la variación temporal de la calidad que es consustancial de HAS. Esta tesis investiga la influencia de la adaptación dinámica en la calidad de la transmisión de vídeo considerando métodos de evaluación subjetiva. Tras un estudio exhaustivo del estado del arte en la evaluación subjetiva de QoE en HAS, se han resaltado los retos asociados y las líneas de investigación abiertas. Como resultado, se han seleccionado dos líneas principales de investigación: el análisis del impacto en la QoE de los parámetros de las técnicas de adaptación y la investigación de las metodologías de prueba subjetiva adecuada para evaluación de QoE en HAS. Se han llevado a cabo un conjunto de experimentos de laboratorio para investigar las cuestiones planteadas mediante la utilización de diferentes metodologáas para pruebas subjetivas. El análisis estadístico muestra que no son robustas todas las suposiciones y reivindicaciones de las referencias analizadas, en particular en lo que respecta al impacto en la QoE de la frecuencia de las variaciones de calidad, de las adaptaciones suaves o abruptas y de las oscilaciones de calidad. Por otra parte, nuestros resultados confirman la influencia de otros parámetros, como la longitud de los segmentos de vídeo y la amplitud de las oscilaciones de calidad. Los resultados también muestran que tomar en consideración las características objetivas de los contenidos puede ser beneficioso para la mejora de la QoE en HAS. Además, todos los resultados han sido validados mediante extensos análisis experimentales que han incluido estudio tanto en otros laboratorios como en crowdsourcing Por último, sobre los aspectos metodológicos de las pruebas subjetivas de QoE, se ha realizado la comparación entre los resultados experimentales obtenidos a partir de un método estandarizado basado en estímulos cortos (ACR) y un método semi continuo (desarrollado para la evaluación de secuencias prolongadas de vídeo). A pesar de algunas diferencias, el resultado de los análisis estadísticos no muestra ningún efecto significativo de la metodología de prueba. Asimismo, aunque se percibe la influencia de la presencia de audio en la evaluación de degradaciones del vídeo, no se han encontrado efectos estadísticamente significativos de dicha presencia. A partir de la ausencia de influencia del método de prueba y de la presencia de audio, se ha realizado un análisis adicional sobre el impacto de realizar comparaciones estadísticas múltiples en niveles estadísticos de importancia que aumentan la probabilidad de los errores de tipo-I (falsos positivos). Nuestros resultados muestran que, para obtener un efectos sólido en el análisis estadístico de los resultados subjetivos, es necesario aumentar el número de sujetos de las pruebas claramente por encima de los tamaños de muestras propuestos por las normas y recomendaciones actuales. ABSTRACT Optimizing the Quality of Experience (QoE) of HTTP adaptive video streaming (HAS) is receiving increasing attention nowadays. The growth of interest is mainly caused by the fact that current HAS solutions are not QoE-driven, i.e. end-user quality perception is not integral part of the adaptation logic. However, obtaining the necessary reliable ground truths on HAS QoE faces substantial challenges, since the subjective video quality assessment methodologies as proposed by current standards are not well-suited for dealing with the time-varying quality properties that are characteristic for HAS. This thesis investigates the influence of dynamic quality adaptation on the QoE of streaming video by means of subjective evaluation approaches. Based on a comprehensive survey of related work on subjective HAS QoE assessment, the related challenges and open research questions are highlighted and discussed. As a result, two main research directions are selected for further investigation: analysis of the QoE impact of different technical adaptation parameters, and investigation of testing methodologies suitable for HAS QoE evaluation. In order to investigate related research issues and questions, a set of laboratory experiments have been conducted using different subjective testing methodologies. Our statistical analysis demonstrates that not all assumptions and claims reported in the literature are robust, particularly as regards the QoE impact of switching frequency, smooth vs. abrupt switching, and quality oscillation. On the other hand, our results confirm the influence of some other parameters such as chunk length and switching amplitude on perceived quality. We also show that taking the objective characteristics of the content into account can be beneficial to improve the adaptation viewing experience. In addition, all aforementioned findings are validated by means of an extensive cross-experimental analysis that involves external laboratory and crowdsourcing studies. Finally, to address the methodological aspects of subjective QoE testing, a comparison between the experimental results obtained from a (short stimuli-based) ACR standardized method and a semi-continuous method (developed for assessment of long video sequences) has been performed. In spite of observation of some differences, the result of statistical analysis does not show any significant effect of testing methodology. Similarly, although the influence of audio presence on evaluation of video-related degradations is perceived, no statistically significant effect of audio presence could be found. Motivating by this finding (no effect of testing method and audio presence), a subsequent analysis has been performed investigating the impact of performing multiple statistical comparisons on statistical levels of significance which increase the likelihood of Type-I errors (false positives). Our results show that in order to obtain a strong effect from the statistical analysis of the subjective results, it is necessary to increase the number of test subjects well beyond the sample sizes proposed by current quality assessment standards and recommendations.

Quality of experience of adaptive video streaming: investigation in service parameters and subjective quality assessment methodology

The usage of HTTP adaptive streaming (HAS) has become widely spread in multimedia services. Because it allows the service providers to improve the network resource utilization and user׳s Quality of Experience (QoE). Using this technology, the video playback interruption is reduced since the network and server status in addition to capability of user device, all are taken into account by HAS client to adapt the quality to the current condition. Adaptation can be done using different strategies. In order to provide optimal QoE, the perceptual impact of adaptation strategies from point of view of the user should be studied. However, the time-varying video quality due to the adaptation which usually takes place in a long interval introduces a new type of impairment making the subjective evaluation of adaptive streaming system challenging. The contribution of this paper is two-fold: first, it investigates the testing methodology to evaluate HAS QoE by comparing the subjective experimental outcomes obtained from ACR standardized method and a semi-continuous method developed to evaluate the long sequences. In addition, influence of using audiovisual stimuli to evaluate the video-related impairment is inquired. Second, impact of some of the adaptation technical factors including the quality switching amplitude and chunk size in combination with high range of commercial content type is investigated. The results of this study provide a good insight toward achieving appropriate testing method to evaluate HAS QoE, in addition to designing switching strategies with optimal visual quality.

Estimating Perceived Video Quality from Objective Parameters in Video over IP Services

In Video over IP services, perceived video quality heavily depends on parameters such as video coding and network Quality of Service. This paper proposes a model for the estimation of perceived video quality in video streaming and broadcasting services that combines the aforementioned parameters with other that depend mainly on the information contents of the video sequences. These fitting parameters are derived from the Spatial and Temporal Information contents of the sequences. This model does not require reference to the original video sequence so it can be used for online, real-time monitoring of perceived video quality in Video over IP services. Furthermore, this paper proposes a measurement workbench designed to acquire both training data for model fitting and test data for model validation. Preliminary results show good correlation between measured and predicted values.

Work in progress - Exploiting videoconferencing possibilities to promote the European convergence process

This paper introduces the experience of using videoconferencing and recording as a mechanism to support courses which need to be promoted or discontinued within the framework of the European convergence process. Our objective is to make these courses accessible as live streaming during the lessons as well as recorded lectures and associated documents available to the students as soon as the lesson has finished. The technology used has been developed in our university and it is all open source. Although this is a technical project the key is the human factor involved. The people managing the virtual sessions are students of the courses being recorded. However, they lack technical knowledge, so we had to train them in audiovisuals and enhance the usability of the videoconferencing tool and platform. The validation process is being carried out in five real scenarios at our university. During the whole period we are evaluating technical and pedagogical issues of this experience for both students and teachers to guide the future development of the service. Depending on the final results, the service of lectures recording will be available as educational resource for all of the teaching staff of our university.

Multi-agent Architecture for Heterogeneous Reasoning under Uncertainty Combining MSBN and Ontologies in Distributed Network Diagnosis

This article proposes a MAS architecture for network diagnosis under uncertainty. Network diagnosis is divided into two inference processes: hypothesis generation and hypothesis confirmation. The first process is distributed among several agents based on a MSBN, while the second one is carried out by agents using semantic reasoning. A diagnosis ontology has been defined in order to combine both inference processes. To drive the deliberation process, dynamic data about the influence of observations are taken during diagnosis process. In order to achieve quick and reliable diagnoses, this influence is used to choose the best action to perform. This approach has been evaluated in a P2P video streaming scenario. Computational and time improvements are highlight as conclusions.

Intelligent context-aware services based on internet of things architectures

La Internet de las Cosas (IoT), como parte de la Futura Internet, se ha convertido en la actualidad en uno de los principales temas de investigación; en parte gracias a la atención que la sociedad está poniendo en el desarrollo de determinado tipo de servicios (telemetría, generación inteligente de energía, telesanidad, etc.) y por las recientes previsiones económicas que sitúan a algunos actores, como los operadores de telecomunicaciones (que se encuentran desesperadamente buscando nuevas oportunidades), al frente empujando algunas tecnologías interrelacionadas como las comunicaciones Máquina a Máquina (M2M). En este contexto, un importante número de actividades de investigación a nivel mundial se están realizando en distintas facetas: comunicaciones de redes de sensores, procesado de información, almacenamiento de grandes cantidades de datos (big--‐data), semántica, arquitecturas de servicio, etc. Todas ellas, de forma independiente, están llegando a un nivel de madurez que permiten vislumbrar la realización de la Internet de las Cosas más que como un sueño, como una realidad tangible. Sin embargo, los servicios anteriormente mencionados no pueden esperar a desarrollarse hasta que las actividades de investigación obtengan soluciones holísticas completas. Es importante proporcionar resultados intermedios que eviten soluciones verticales realizadas para desarrollos particulares. En este trabajo, nos hemos focalizado en la creación de una plataforma de servicios que pretende facilitar, por una parte la integración de redes de sensores y actuadores heterogéneas y geográficamente distribuidas, y por otra lado el desarrollo de servicios horizontales utilizando dichas redes y la información que proporcionan. Este habilitador se utilizará para el desarrollo de servicios y para la experimentación en la Internet de las Cosas. Previo a la definición de la plataforma, se ha realizado un importante estudio focalizando no sólo trabajos y proyectos de investigación, sino también actividades de estandarización. Los resultados se pueden resumir en las siguientes aseveraciones: a) Los modelos de datos definidos por el grupo “Sensor Web Enablement” (SWE™) del “Open Geospatial Consortium (OGC®)” representan hoy en día la solución más completa para describir las redes de sensores y actuadores así como las observaciones. b) Las interfaces OGC, a pesar de las limitaciones que requieren cambios y extensiones, podrían ser utilizadas como las bases para acceder a sensores y datos. c) Las redes de nueva generación (NGN) ofrecen un buen sustrato que facilita la integración de redes de sensores y el desarrollo de servicios. En consecuencia, una nueva plataforma de Servicios, llamada Ubiquitous Sensor Networks (USN), se ha definido en esta Tesis tratando de contribuir a rellenar los huecos previamente mencionados. Los puntos más destacados de la plataforma USN son: a) Desde un punto de vista arquitectónico, sigue una aproximación de dos niveles (Habilitador y Gateway) similar a otros habilitadores que utilizan las NGN (como el OMA Presence). b) Los modelos de datos están basado en los estándares del OGC SWE. iv c) Está integrado en las NGN pero puede ser utilizado sin ellas utilizando infraestructuras IP abiertas. d) Las principales funciones son: Descubrimiento de sensores, Almacenamiento de observaciones, Publicacion--‐subscripcion--‐notificación, ejecución remota homogénea, seguridad, gestión de diccionarios de datos, facilidades de monitorización, utilidades de conversión de protocolos, interacciones síncronas y asíncronas, soporte para el “streaming” y arbitrado básico de recursos. Para demostrar las funcionalidades que la Plataforma USN propuesta pueden ofrecer a los futuros escenarios de la Internet de las Cosas, se presentan resultados experimentales de tres pruebas de concepto (telemetría, “Smart Places” y monitorización medioambiental) reales a pequeña escala y un estudio sobre semántica (sistema de información vehicular). Además, se está utilizando actualmente como Habilitador para desarrollar tanto experimentación como servicios reales en el proyecto Europeo SmartSantander (que aspira a integrar alrededor de 20.000 dispositivos IoT). v Abstract Internet of Things, as part of the Future Internet, has become one of the main research topics nowadays; in part thanks to the pressure the society is putting on the development of a particular kind of services (Smart metering, Smart Grids, eHealth, etc.), and by the recent business forecasts that situate some players, like Telecom Operators (which are desperately seeking for new opportunities), at the forefront pushing for some interrelated technologies like Machine--‐to--‐Machine (M2M) communications. Under this context, an important number of research activities are currently taking place worldwide at different levels: sensor network communications, information processing, big--‐ data storage, semantics, service level architectures, etc. All of them, isolated, are arriving to a level of maturity that envision the achievement of Internet of Things (IoT) more than a dream, a tangible goal. However, the aforementioned services cannot wait to be developed until the holistic research actions bring complete solutions. It is important to come out with intermediate results that avoid vertical solutions tailored for particular deployments. In the present work, we focus on the creation of a Service--‐level platform intended to facilitate, from one side the integration of heterogeneous and geographically disperse Sensors and Actuator Networks (SANs), and from the other the development of horizontal services using them and the information they provide. This enabler will be used for horizontal service development and for IoT experimentation. Prior to the definition of the platform, we have realized an important study targeting not just research works and projects, but also standardization topics. The results can be summarized in the following assertions: a) Open Geospatial Consortium (OGC®) Sensor Web Enablement (SWE™) data models today represent the most complete solution to describe SANs and observations. b) OGC interfaces, despite the limitations that require changes and extensions, could be used as the bases for accessing sensors and data. c) Next Generation Networks (NGN) offer a good substrate that facilitates the integration of SANs and the development of services. Consequently a new Service Layer platform, called Ubiquitous Sensor Networks (USN), has been defined in this Thesis trying to contribute to fill in the previous gaps. The main highlights of the proposed USN Platform are: a) From an architectural point of view, it follows a two--‐layer approach (Enabler and Gateway) similar to other enablers that run on top of NGN (like the OMA Presence). b) Data models and interfaces are based on the OGC SWE standards. c) It is integrated in NGN but it can be used without it over open IP infrastructures. d) Main functions are: Sensor Discovery, Observation Storage, Publish--‐Subscribe--‐Notify, homogeneous remote execution, security, data dictionaries handling, monitoring facilities, authorization support, protocol conversion utilities, synchronous and asynchronous interactions, streaming support and basic resource arbitration. vi In order to demonstrate the functionalities that the proposed USN Platform can offer to future IoT scenarios, some experimental results have been addressed in three real--‐life small--‐scale proofs--‐of concepts (Smart Metering, Smart Places and Environmental monitoring) and a study for semantics (in--‐vehicle information system). Furthermore we also present the current use of the proposed USN Platform as an Enabler to develop experimentation and real services in the SmartSantander EU project (that aims at integrating around 20.000 IoT devices).

High definition video quality assessment metric built upon full reference ratios

Métrica de calidad de video de alta definición construida a partir de ratios de referencia completa. La medida de calidad de video, en inglés Visual Quality Assessment (VQA), es uno de los mayores retos por solucionar en el entorno multimedia. La calidad de vídeo tiene un impacto altísimo en la percepción del usuario final (consumidor) de los servicios sustentados en la provisión de contenidos multimedia y, por tanto, factor clave en la valoración del nuevo paradigma denominado Calidad de la Experiencia, en inglés Quality of Experience (QoE). Los modelos de medida de calidad de vídeo se pueden agrupar en varias ramas según la base técnica que sustenta el sistema de medida, destacando en importancia los que emplean modelos psicovisuales orientados a reproducir las características del sistema visual humano, en inglés Human Visual System, del que toman sus siglas HVS, y los que, por el contrario, optan por una aproximación ingenieril en la que el cálculo de calidad está basado en la extracción de parámetros intrínsecos de la imagen y su comparación. A pesar de los avances recogidos en este campo en los últimos años, la investigación en métricas de calidad de vídeo, tanto en presencia de referencia (los modelos denominados de referencia completa), como en presencia de parte de ella (modelos de referencia reducida) e incluso los que trabajan en ausencia de la misma (denominados sin referencia), tiene un amplio camino de mejora y objetivos por alcanzar. Dentro de ellos, la medida de señales de alta definición, especialmente las utilizadas en las primeras etapas de la cadena de valor que son de muy alta calidad, son de especial interés por su influencia en la calidad final del servicio y no existen modelos fiables de medida en la actualidad. Esta tesis doctoral presenta un modelo de medida de calidad de referencia completa que hemos llamado PARMENIA (PArallel Ratios MEtric from iNtrInsic features Analysis), basado en la ponderación de cuatro ratios de calidad calculados a partir de características intrínsecas de la imagen. Son: El Ratio de Fidelidad, calculado mediante el gradiente morfológico o gradiente de Beucher. El Ratio de Similitud Visual, calculado mediante los puntos visualmente significativos de la imagen a través de filtrados locales de contraste. El Ratio de Nitidez, que procede de la extracción del estadístico de textura de Haralick contraste. El Ratio de Complejidad, obtenido de la definición de homogeneidad del conjunto de estadísticos de textura de Haralick PARMENIA presenta como novedad la utilización de la morfología matemática y estadísticos de Haralick como base de una métrica de medida de calidad, pues esas técnicas han estado tradicionalmente más ligadas a la teledetección y la segmentación de objetos. Además, la aproximación de la métrica como un conjunto ponderado de ratios es igualmente novedosa debido a que se alimenta de modelos de similitud estructural y otros más clásicos, basados en la perceptibilidad del error generado por la degradación de la señal asociada a la compresión. PARMENIA presenta resultados con una altísima correlación con las valoraciones MOS procedentes de las pruebas subjetivas a usuarios que se han realizado para la validación de la misma. El corpus de trabajo seleccionado procede de conjuntos de secuencias validados internacionalmente, de modo que los resultados aportados sean de la máxima calidad y el máximo rigor posible. La metodología de trabajo seguida ha consistido en la generación de un conjunto de secuencias de prueba de distintas calidades a través de la codificación con distintos escalones de cuantificación, la obtención de las valoraciones subjetivas de las mismas a través de pruebas subjetivas de calidad (basadas en la recomendación de la Unión Internacional de Telecomunicaciones BT.500), y la validación mediante el cálculo de la correlación de PARMENIA con estos valores subjetivos, cuantificada a través del coeficiente de correlación de Pearson. Una vez realizada la validación de los ratios y optimizada su influencia en la medida final y su alta correlación con la percepción, se ha realizado una segunda revisión sobre secuencias del hdtv test dataset 1 del Grupo de Expertos de Calidad de Vídeo (VQEG, Video Quality Expert Group) mostrando los resultados obtenidos sus claras ventajas. Abstract Visual Quality Assessment has been so far one of the most intriguing challenges on the media environment. Progressive evolution towards higher resolutions while increasing the quality needed (e.g. high definition and better image quality) aims to redefine models for quality measuring. Given the growing interest in multimedia services delivery, perceptual quality measurement has become a very active area of research. First, in this work, a classification of objective video quality metrics based on their underlying methodologies and approaches for measuring video quality has been introduced to sum up the state of the art. Then, this doctoral thesis describes an enhanced solution for full reference objective quality measurement based on mathematical morphology, texture features and visual similarity information that provides a normalized metric that we have called PARMENIA (PArallel Ratios MEtric from iNtrInsic features Analysis), with a high correlated MOS score. The PARMENIA metric is based on the pooling of different quality ratios that are obtained from three different approaches: Beucher’s gradient, local contrast filtering, and contrast and homogeneity Haralick’s texture features. The metric performance is excellent, and improves the current state of the art by providing a wide dynamic range that make easier to discriminate between very close quality coded sequences, especially for very high bit rates whose quality, currently, is transparent for quality metrics. PARMENIA introduces a degree of novelty against other working metrics: on the one hand, exploits the structural information variation to build the metric’s kernel, but complements the measure with texture information and a ratio of visual meaningful points that is closer to typical error sensitivity based approaches. We would like to point out that PARMENIA approach is the only metric built upon full reference ratios, and using mathematical morphology and texture features (typically used in segmentation) for quality assessment. On the other hand, it gets results with a wide dynamic range that allows measuring the quality of high definition sequences from bit rates of hundreds of Megabits (Mbps) down to typical distribution rates (5-6 Mbps), even streaming rates (1- 2 Mbps). Thus, a direct correlation between PARMENIA and MOS scores are easily constructed. PARMENIA may further enhance the number of available choices in objective quality measurement, especially for very high quality HD materials. All this results come from validation that has been achieved through internationally validated datasets on which subjective tests based on ITU-T BT.500 methodology have been carried out. Pearson correlation coefficient has been calculated to verify the accuracy of PARMENIA and its reliability.

Crecimiento, fabricación y caracterización de heteroestructuras y nanocolumnas ordenadas basadas en nitruros del grupo III para aplicaciones sensoras

Esta memoria está basada en el crecimiento y caracterización de heteroestructuras Al(Ga)N/GaN y nanocolumnas ordenadas de GaN, y su aplicación en sensores químicos. El método de crecimiento ha sido la epitaxia de haces moleculares asistida por plasma (PAMBE). En el caso de las heteroestructuras Al(Ga)N/GaN, se han crecido barreras de distinto espesor y composición, desde AlN de 5 nm, hasta AlGaN de 35 nm. Además de una caracterización morfológica, estructural y eléctrica básica de las capas, también se han fabricado a partir de ellas dispositivos tipo HEMTs. La caracterización eléctrica de dichos dispositivos (carga y movilidad de en el canal bidimensional) indica que las mejores heteroestructuras son aquellas con un espesor de barrera intermedio (alrededor de 20 nm). Sin embargo, un objetivo importante de esta Tesis ha sido verificar las ventajas que podían tener los sensores basados en heteroestructuras AlN/GaN (frente a los típicos basados en AlGaN/GaN), con espesores de barrera muy finos (alrededor de 5 nm), ya que el canal de conducción que se modula por efecto de cambios químicos está más cerca de la superficie en donde ocurren dichos cambios químicos. De esta manera, se han utilizado los dispositivos tipo HEMTs como sensores químicos de pH (ISFETs), y se ha comprobado la mayor sensibilidad (variación de corriente frente a cambios de pH, Ids/pH) en los sensores basados en AlN/GaN frente a los basados en AlGaN/GaN. La mayor sensibilidad es incluso más patente en aplicaciones en las que no se utiliza un electrodo de referencia. Se han fabricado y caracterizado dispositivos ISFET similares utilizando capas compactas de InN. Estos sensores presentan peor estabilidad que los basados en Al(Ga)N/GaN, aunque la sensibilidad superficial al pH era la misma (Vgs/pH), y su sensibilidad en terminos de corriente de canal (Ids/pH) arroja valores intermedios entre los ISFET basados en AlN/GaN y los valores de los basados en AlGaN/GaN. Para continuar con la comparación entre dispositivos basados en Al(Ga)N/GaN, se fabricaron ISFETs con el área sensible más pequeña (35 x 35 m2), de tamaño similar a los dispositivos destinados a las medidas de actividad celular. Sometiendo los dispositivos a pulsos de voltaje en su área sensible, la respuesta de los dispositivos de AlN presentaron menor ruido que los basados en AlGaN. El ruido en la corriente para dispositivos de AlN, donde el encapsulado no ha sido optimizado, fue tan bajo como 8.9 nA (valor rms), y el ruido equivalente en el potencial superficial 38.7 V. Estos valores son más bajos que los encontrados en los dispositivos típicos para la detección de actividad celular (basados en Si), y del orden de los mejores resultados encontrados en la literatura sobre AlGaN/GaN. Desde el punto de vista de la caracterización electro-química de las superficies de GaN e InN, se ha determinado su punto isoeléctrico. Dicho valor no había sido reportado en la literatura hasta el momento. El valor, determinado por medidas de “streaming potential”, es de 4.4 y 4 respectivamente. Este valor es una importante característica a tener en cuenta en sensores, en inmovilización electrostática o en la litografía coloidal. Esta última técnica se discute en esta memoria, y se aplica en el último bloque de investigación de esta Tesis (i.e. crecimiento ordenado). El último apartado de resultados experimentales de esta Tesis analiza el crecimiento selectivo de nanocolumnas ordenadas de GaN por MBE, utilizando mascaras de Ti con nanoagujeros. Se ha estudiado como los distintos parámetros de crecimiento (i.e. flujos de los elementos Ga y N, temperatura de crecimiento y diseño de la máscara) afectan a la selectividad y a la morfología de las nanocolumnas. Se ha conseguido con éxito el crecimiento selectivo sobre pseudosustratos de GaN con distinta orientación cristalina o polaridad; templates de GaN(0001)/zafiro, GaN(0001)/AlN/Si, GaN(000-1)/Si y GaN(11-20)/zafiro. Se ha verificado experimentalmente la alta calidad cristalina de las nanocolumnas ordenadas, y su mayor estabilidad térmica comparada con las capas compactas del mismo material. Las nanocolumnas ordenadas de nitruros del grupo III tienen una clara aplicación en el campo de la optoelectrónica, principalmente para nanoemisores de luz blanca. Sin embargo, en esta Tesis se proponen como alternativa a la utilización de capas compactas o nanocolumnas auto-ensambladas en sensores. Las nanocolumnas auto-ensambladas de GaN, debido a su alta razón superficie/volumen, son muy prometedoras en el campo de los sensores, pero su amplia dispersión en dimensiones (altura y diámetro) supone un problema para el procesado y funcionamiento de dispositivos reales. En ese aspecto, las nanocolumnas ordenadas son más robustas y homogéneas, manteniendo una alta relación superficie/volumen. Como primer experimento en el ámbito de los sensores, se ha estudiado como se ve afectada la emisión de fotoluminiscencia de las NCs ordenadas al estar expuestas al aire o al vacio. Se observa una fuerte caída en la intensidad de la fotoluminiscencia cuando las nanocolumnas están expuestas al aire (probablemente por la foto-adsorción de oxigeno en la superficie), como ya había sido documentado anteriormente en nanocolumnas auto-ensambladas. Este experimento abre el camino para futuros sensores basados en nanocolumnas ordenadas. Abstract This manuscript deals with the growth and characterization of Al(Ga)N/GaN heterostructures and GaN ordered nanocolumns, and their application in chemical sensors. The growth technique has been the plasma-assisted molecular beam epitaxy (PAMBE). In the case of Al(Ga)N/GaN heterostructures, barriers of different thickness and composition, from AlN (5 nm) to AlGaN (35 nm) have been grown. Besides the basic morphological, structural and electrical characterization of the layers, HEMT devices have been fabricated based on these layers. The best electrical characteristics (larger carriers concentration and mobility in the two dimensional electron gas) are those in AlGaN/GaN heterostructures with a medium thickness (around 20 nm). However, one of the goals of this Thesis has been to verify the advantages that sensors based on AlN/GaN (thickness around 7 nm) have compared to standard AlGaN/GaN, because the conduction channel to be modulated by chemical changes is closer to the sensitive area. In this way, HEMT devices have been used as chemical pH sensors (ISFETs), and the higher sensitivity (conductance change related to pH changes, Ids/pH) of AlN/GaN based sensors has been proved. The higher sensibility is even more obvious in application without reference electrode. Similar ISFETs devices have been fabricated based on InN compact layers. These devices show a poor stability, but its surface sensitivity to pH (Vgs/pH) and its sensibility (Ids/pH) yield values between the corresponding ones of AlN/GaN and AlGaN/GaN heterostructures. In order to a further comparison between Al(Ga)N/GaN based devices, ISFETs with smaller sensitive area (35 x 35 m2), similar to the ones used in cellular activity record, were fabricated and characterized. When the devices are subjected to a voltage pulse through the sensitive area, the response of AlN based devices shows lower noise than the ones based on AlGaN. The noise in the current of such a AlN based device, where the encapsulation has not been optimized, is as low as 8.9 nA (rms value), and the equivalent noise to the surface potential is 38.7 V. These values are lower than the found in typical devices used for cellular activity recording (based on Si), and in the range of the best published results on AlGaN/GaN. From the point of view of the electrochemical characterization of GaN and InN surfaces, their isoelectric point has been experimentally determined. Such a value is the first time reported for GaN and InN surfaces. These values are determined by “streaming potential”, being pH 4.4 and 4, respectively. Isoelectric point value is an important characteristic in sensors, electrostatic immobilization or in colloidal lithography. In particular, colloidal lithography has been optimized in this Thesis for GaN surfaces, and applied in the last part of experimental results (i.e. ordered growth). The last block of this Thesis is focused on the selective area growth of GaN nanocolumns by MBE, using Ti masks decorated with nanoholes. The effect of the different growth parameters (Ga and N fluxes, growth temperature and mask design) is studied, in particular their impact in the selectivity and in the morphology of the nanocolumns. Selective area growth has been successful performed on GaN templates with different orientation or polarity; GaN(0001)/sapphire, GaN(0001)/AlN/Si, GaN(000- 1)/Si and GaN(11-20)/sapphire. Ordered nanocolumns exhibit a high crystal quality, and a higher thermal stability (lower thermal decomposition) than the compact layers of the same material. Ordered nanocolumns based on III nitrides have a clear application in optoelectronics, mainly for white light nanoemitters. However, this Thesis proposes them as an alternative to compact layers and self-assembled nanocolumns in sensor applications. Self-assembled GaN nanocolumns are very appealing for sensor applications, due to their large surface/volume ratio. However, their large dispersion in heights and diameters are a problem in terms of processing and operation of real devices. In this aspect, ordered nanocolumns are more robust and homogeneous, keeping the large surface/volume ratio. As first experimental evidence of their sensor capabilities, ordered nanocolumns have been studied regarding their photoluminiscence on air and vacuum ambient. A big drop in the intensity is observed when the nanocolumns are exposed to air (probably because of the oxygen photo-adsortion), as was already reported in the case of self-assembled nanocolumns. This opens the way to future sensors based on ordered III nitrides nanocolumns.

Ontology-based access to sensor data streams

Sensor networks are increasingly becoming one of the main sources of Big Data on the Web. However, the observations that they produce are made available with heterogeneous schemas, vocabularies and data formats, making it difficult to share and reuse these data for other purposes than those for which they were originally set up. In this thesis we address these challenges, considering how we can transform streaming raw data to rich ontology-based information that is accessible through continuous queries for streaming data. Our main contribution is an ontology-based approach for providing data access and query capabilities to streaming data sources, allowing users to express their needs at a conceptual level, independent of implementation and language-specific details. We introduce novel query rewriting and data translation techniques that rely on mapping definitions relating streaming data models to ontological concepts. Specific contributions include: • The syntax and semantics of the SPARQLStream query language for ontologybased data access, and a query rewriting approach for transforming SPARQLStream queries into streaming algebra expressions. • The design of an ontology-based streaming data access engine that can internally reuse an existing data stream engine, complex event processor or sensor middleware, using R2RML mappings for defining relationships between streaming data models and ontology concepts. Concerning the sensor metadata of such streaming data sources, we have investigated how we can use raw measurements to characterize streaming data, producing enriched data descriptions in terms of ontological models. Our specific contributions are: • A representation of sensor data time series that captures gradient information that is useful to characterize types of sensor data. • A method for classifying sensor data time series and determining the type of data, using data mining techniques, and a method for extracting semantic sensor metadata features from the time series.