Transcript of record. Supreme court of the United States. October term, 1908. No. 396. William R. Willcox et al., constituting the Public service commission of the state of New York for the first district, appellants, vs. Consolidated gas company of New York. no. 397. The city of New York, appellant, vs. Consolidated gas company of New York. No. 398. William S. Jackson, as attorney general of the state of New York, appellant, vs. Consolidated gas company of New York. Appeals from the Circuit court of the United States for the Southern district of New York. Filed May 16, 1908. (21,176, 21,177, 21,178)

Proceedings in the Circuit court in the cause of the Consolidated Gas Company "against William S. Jackson, as attorney general, et al.," originally instituted against "Julius M. Mayer, as attorney general, et al."