Restoration of the habitat-forming fucoid alga Hormosira banksii at effluent-affected sites : competitive exclusion by coralline turfs

Fucoid algae often dominate intertidal rocky shores, providing habitat and modifying ecosystem resources for other species, but are susceptible to discharge of sewage effluent. In this study we assessed the potential for competition from coralline turfs to inhibit restoration of the intertidal fucoid macroalga <i>Hormosira banksii</i> at sites associated with an ocean outfall a scenario of improving following water quality in the nearshore coastal environment. The percentage cover and number of individuals of <i>H. banksii </i>were negatively correlated with both the percentage cover and turf height of <i>Corallina officinalis.</i> In contrast, <i>H. banksii</i> was positively associated with rocky substrata and recruited well to rock-surface substrata. Importantly, there appears to be a threshold abundance where the percentage cover of <i>H.</i> <i>banksii </i>rarely reaches above 20% cover amongst coralline turfs with >40% cover. These data support a model of alternative community states: <i>H. banksii </i>dominated canopy on rocky substrata versus <i>C. officinalis </i>turf. In field and laboratory experiments, extensive coralline turfs (up to 4 cm thick) were shown to inhibit recruitment of <i>H. banksii</i>. This study shows competitive exclusion by coralline turfs may limit the successful restoration of habitat provided by <i>H. banksii </i>to shores that have been affected by sustained discharge of secondarily treated sewage effluent. We suggest potential strategies for management authorities to consider when seeking ways of restoring fucoid communities affected by anthropogenic disturbances such as wastewater disposal.